Why You're So Lonely | Camus' The Stranger

Unsolicited advice
12 Jun 202425:46

Summary

TLDRThis video explores the theme of isolation in Albert Camus' novel 'The Stranger', analyzing the protagonist Meursault's indifference and its impact on his relationships and society's judgment. It discusses how Meursault's alienation is a reflection of the universe's indifference, leading to his eventual acceptance of the absurd. The video also delves into how Camus uses Meursault's story to challenge our understanding of morality, social norms, and the search for meaning in a seemingly meaningless world.

Takeaways

  • 😔 The protagonist Meursault in 'The Stranger' experiences profound alienation and indifference, which sets him apart from society and leads to his doom.
  • 📚 The novel explores the feeling of isolation and the search for companionship, highlighting the struggle to connect with others despite efforts.
  • 🌐 Meursault's indifference is a reflection of his belief in the lack of objective value in the world, which distances him from societal norms and relationships.
  • 🔍 The text dissects how Meursault's actions, such as his response to his mother's death and his relationship with Marie, demonstrate his emotional detachment.
  • 👥 The societal judgment and condemnation Meursault faces during his trial are more focused on his character and indifference rather than the act of killing itself.
  • 🌀 The novel delves into the human fear of the unknown and the chaos it can cause, as seen in the reactions to Meursault's incomprehensible behavior.
  • 🔄 Meursault's alienation is a two-way street; while he is alien to others, they are also alien to him, creating a mutual state of confusion and hostility.
  • 🔄 The script suggests that we all have elements of the absurd in our lives, where the search for meaning can lead to feelings of isolation.
  • 🔑 The final chapter reveals Meursault's acceptance of the universe's indifference, finding peace and happiness in his own philosophy of absurdism.
  • 🌟 'The Stranger' is celebrated as a rich philosophical novel that intertwines existential alienation with the search for meaning and personal identity.

Q & A

  • What is the main theme explored in 'The Stranger' by Albert Camus?

    -The main theme explored in 'The Stranger' is the concept of existential isolation and the absurdity of the human condition, where the protagonist, Meursault, experiences alienation and indifference in a universe that is indifferent to human concerns.

  • How does Meursault's indifference to his mother's death set the tone for his character in 'The Stranger'?

    -Meursault's indifference to his mother's death is a pivotal moment that sets the tone for his character, highlighting his detachment from societal norms and expectations, and foreshadowing his ultimate alienation from others throughout the novel.

  • What role does the sun play in Meursault's actions in 'The Stranger'?

    -In 'The Stranger', the sun plays a significant role in Meursault's actions, particularly during the murder scene, where its blinding light and heat contribute to his confusion and subsequent violent reaction, symbolizing the absurdity and randomness of life.

  • How does the trial in 'The Stranger' reflect the society's judgment of Meursault?

    -The trial in 'The Stranger' reflects society's judgment of Meursault by focusing less on the murder itself and more on his character and perceived moral failings, such as his lack of emotion over his mother's death, highlighting his alienation from societal norms.

  • What does Meursault's relationship with Marie reveal about his indifference?

    -Meursault's relationship with Marie reveals his indifference in that he enjoys her company and is attracted to her but does not attach any deeper meaning to their relationship, such as love, which he considers meaningless.

  • How does Camus use the character of Raymond to explore themes of morality and indifference in 'The Stranger'?

    -Camus uses the character of Raymond to explore themes of morality and indifference by contrasting Meursault's nonchalance towards Raymond's violent tendencies with societal expectations of moral judgment, thereby questioning the nature of right and wrong.

  • What is the significance of the magistrate's reaction to Meursault's lack of belief in God in 'The Stranger'?

    -The magistrate's reaction to Meursault's lack of belief in God is significant as it underscores the protagonist's alienation from religious and moral norms, reflecting the broader theme of the absurd and the incompatibility of Meursault's worldview with the society he lives in.

  • How does Meursault's outlook on life pose a threat to society in the eyes of others in 'The Stranger'?

    -Meursault's outlook on life is seen as a threat to society because his indifference to conventional values and morality challenges the established order, making him an enigmatic and potentially destabilizing figure in the eyes of others.

  • What does the title 'The Stranger' signify in the context of the novel?

    -The title 'The Stranger' signifies the protagonist's status as an outsider and his existential isolation, both from society and from any sense of inherent meaning or purpose in life.

  • How does Camus explore the concept of the absurd in 'The Stranger'?

    -Camus explores the concept of the absurd in 'The Stranger' through Meursault's experiences and reactions to the world around him, which highlight the lack of inherent meaning in life and the human struggle to find purpose in an indifferent universe.

  • What is the turning point for Meursault's understanding of his place in the world in 'The Stranger'?

    -The turning point for Meursault's understanding of his place in the world comes at the end of the novel when he reconciles with the universe's indifference, finding solace and happiness in his own absurd existence, thus no longer feeling like a stranger.

Outlines

00:00

🌌 Alienation and Indifference

The paragraph introduces the theme of existential alienation and indifference through the lens of Albert Camus' 'The Stranger'. It discusses the protagonist's inability to connect with others and his indifference to societal norms and values. The protagonist's disconnection is highlighted by his lack of emotional response to his mother's death and his casual approach to relationships and violence, reflecting a broader commentary on the human condition and the search for meaning in an absurd world.

05:01

🧐 The Outsider's Perspective

This section delves into the protagonist's status as an outsider, someone who does not conform to societal expectations or values. His indifference is not a result of rebellion but a genuine lack of concern for societal norms. This detachment leads to a sense of alienation, which many can relate to in moments of existential crisis. The paragraph also touches on the absurdity of life, where despite longing for meaning, we often find the universe indifferent to our desires.

10:01

🔍 Confusion and Condemnation

The narrative continues with the protagonist's trial, where the focus is not on the act of killing but on his unusual disposition that sets him apart from others. The prosecutor and society at large are threatened by his indifference, viewing it as a challenge to their moral norms. The paragraph explores how society reacts to those who do not conform, often with fear and hostility, and how this reaction is a reflection of humanity's discomfort with the unknown.

15:01

🤔 The Search for Understanding

Here, the text examines the protagonist's interactions with authority figures who struggle to comprehend his lack of religious belief and moral values. His indifference is met with confusion and anger, leading to his condemnation as an 'Antichrist'. The paragraph illustrates the human fear of the unknown and the tendency to judge and condemn what we cannot understand, highlighting the absurdity of seeking reasons and values in a universe that may not have any.

20:01

🌱 Embracing the Absurd

In the final chapter, the protagonist experiences a philosophical epiphany. Rather than rejecting his indifference, he comes to terms with it, finding peace in the universe's indifference towards him. He realizes that his outlook mirrors the universe's, and this realization brings him a sense of belonging and happiness. The paragraph discusses how one can find comfort in accepting the absurdity of life and the meaninglessness of the universe.

25:02

📚 Literature's Exploration of Isolation

The final paragraph reflects on 'The Stranger' as a profound examination of isolation, not just on a personal or societal level, but at the core of our philosophical understanding. It suggests that Camus' work offers insights into dealing with feelings of loneliness and alienation by embracing absurdism, which can provide comfort in accepting the universe's indifference.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡Alienation

Alienation refers to a feeling of isolation or estrangement from others or from one's society. In the video, it is discussed as a common human experience where individuals feel fundamentally disconnected from others despite attempts to connect. The protagonist of 'The Stranger' embodies this concept, feeling indifferent to societal norms and values, which leads to his alienation.

💡Indifference

Indifference is the quality of not being interested or concerned about something. The protagonist, Meursault, exhibits indifference towards various aspects of life, including his mother's death and societal expectations. His indifference is a central theme of the video, illustrating his disconnection from others and his ultimate acceptance of the universe's indifference.

💡Absurdism

Absurdism is a philosophical notion that emphasizes the conflict between the human tendency to seek inherent meaning in life and the indifference of the universe. The video discusses how 'The Stranger' explores absurdism through Meursault's experiences, highlighting the absurdity of human existence when faced with a meaningless universe.

💡Isolation

Isolation is the state of being separated from others or society. The video script uses isolation to describe the protagonist's experience of being an outsider, both in his personal life and in the broader context of the universe. It is a key element in understanding his journey towards finding peace with his alienation.

💡Meaninglessness

Meaninglessness is the concept that life or events have no inherent meaning or purpose. The video discusses how Meursault's indifference stems from his realization of the universe's meaninglessness. This realization is central to the theme of absurdism and his personal journey.

💡Mourning

Mourning is the process of expressing grief or sorrow. In the video, Meursault's lack of mourning for his mother's death is used to illustrate his indifference and detachment from societal norms, which is a significant aspect of his character and his alienation.

💡Trial

A trial is a formal examination of evidence to determine guilt or innocence. In the context of the video, Meursault's trial is not just a legal process but also a metaphorical examination of his character and philosophy. The trial highlights society's judgment and misunderstanding of his indifference.

💡Confusion

Confusion is a state of uncertainty or lack of understanding. The video describes how Meursault's behavior confuses those around him, leading to judgment and condemnation. It also reflects the broader human fear of the unknown and the struggle to comprehend the absurd.

💡Philosophical Outlook

A philosophical outlook refers to an individual's general perspective on life, existence, and values. The video discusses how Meursault's philosophical outlook, characterized by indifference and the recognition of life's meaninglessness, sets him apart and leads to his alienation.

💡Existential Isolation

Existential isolation refers to the experience of being fundamentally alone or disconnected in the universe. The video ties this concept to absurdism and Meursault's journey, suggesting that coming to terms with existential isolation is a way to find peace with the absurd.

💡The Absurd

The Absurd, as discussed in the video, is the experience of the conflict between human desires for meaning and the universe's indifference. It is a central theme in 'The Stranger' and is used to explore the human condition and the search for understanding in a seemingly meaningless world.

Highlights

The protagonist's indifference to societal norms and values sets him apart and leads to his doom.

Meursault's alienation is reflected in his language and matter-of-fact monologues.

Meursault's lack of emotional investment is evident in his relationship with Marie.

Meursault's ambivalence extends to his interactions with the violent character Raymond.

Meursault's inability to feel remorse is indicative of his broader indifference to morality.

Meursault's existential crisis is a reflection of the absurdist view of life.

The novel explores the feeling of alienation and the search for companionship.

Meursault's trial becomes a platform to judge his character rather than his crime.

The prosecutor's focus on Meursault's indifference highlights societal discomfort with non-conformity.

Meursault's lack of remorse and his actions are used to paint him as a moral monster.

The novel challenges the reader to confront their own fear of meaninglessness.

Meursault's alienation is a catalyst for philosophical contemplation on the nature of existence.

The theme of confusion and chaos is central to understanding Meursault's character.

Meursault's confrontation with the prison chaplain marks a turning point in his understanding of the absurd.

Meursault's final acceptance of the universe's indifference leads to a sense of peace.

The novel concludes with Meursault finding happiness in the absurdity of life.

Camus uses Meursault's story to explore the philosophical problem of existential isolation.

The Stranger is presented as an insightful examination of what it means to be alone.

Transcripts

play00:00

mother died today or maybe yesterday I

play00:03

can't be sure have you ever got the

play00:05

sense that you are fundamentally

play00:06

alienated from other people that despite

play00:09

all your attempts to connect you cannot

play00:11

find someone you have a real

play00:12

companionship with no matter what you do

play00:15

and no matter how hard you try there is

play00:17

always some barrier that separates you

play00:19

from other people you seem to be

play00:21

different but not in a way that Sparks

play00:23

Joy or Pride but instead one that just

play00:26

makes you feel terrifyingly alone I

play00:29

would wager that many of us have

play00:30

experienced this isolation in smaller or

play00:33

greater Doses and nowhere is this

play00:35

feeling articulated better than an Alber

play00:38

Chu's Landmark novel The Stranger I've

play00:41

referenced it before on this channel in

play00:42

the context of absurdism but today I

play00:44

want to tackle it from a different angle

play00:46

I want to look at what the protagonist's

play00:48

experience of being an outsider can tell

play00:51

us about our own lives and how we might

play00:54

slowly learn to make peace with this

play00:56

creeping feeling of being totally alone

play00:58

in the universe get ready to learn how

play01:01

philosophy can make you isolated how

play01:03

those that don't understand you can

play01:04

become cruel and heartless and so much

play01:07

more bear in mind that this is such a

play01:10

notoriously Rich text that I will only

play01:12

be able to cover a fraction of its true

play01:14

depth here and you can check out my

play01:16

other video on absurdism if you want

play01:18

some greater historical context but

play01:20

without further Ado let's look at the

play01:21

foundational property of our protagonist

play01:24

the one that both sets him aparts from

play01:26

everybody else and eventually spells his

play01:29

Doom one indifference and difference the

play01:33

first half of the stranger follows our

play01:35

hero moo as he goes about his daily life

play01:38

in French Algeria the book opens with

play01:40

him burying his recently deceased mother

play01:42

before pivoting to a series of vignettes

play01:45

where he interacts with Marie his

play01:46

mistress Raymond a violent criminal and

play01:49

salamano a very old man with an

play01:51

incredibly sick dog and the

play01:53

extraordinary thing about Mero the thing

play01:55

that alienates him from the rest of

play01:57

society even at this early stage is his

play02:00

total indifference to everything that

play02:02

other people care about this manifests

play02:04

in every faucet of his life but perhaps

play02:07

the most prominent way it is displayed

play02:08

is not in anything moo outright says or

play02:11

does in the novel but instead in the way

play02:13

kamu uses language throughout the text

play02:16

mos in a monologue is remarkably matter

play02:18

of fact he will describe seemingly

play02:20

pointless details like the heat of the

play02:22

sun alongside what most people would

play02:24

consider far more important matters like

play02:26

outright threats to his life moo sees

play02:29

the entire world as if it is through a

play02:31

gray filter nothing is ever that great

play02:34

or that bad it is all in different

play02:36

shades of indifference in other words

play02:38

everything matters roughly the same

play02:40

amount to him which is to say not at all

play02:42

for instance in his romantic

play02:44

relationship with Marie he finds great

play02:46

enjoyment in her company and is clearly

play02:48

incredibly attracted to her in all

play02:50

respects he seems emotionally invested

play02:52

in their budding relationship but when

play02:54

she outright asks him if he loves her he

play02:56

replies that it doesn't mean anything

play02:58

either way but he doesn't think so the

play03:00

particular way kamu puts this is vital

play03:03

it is not just that moo does not love

play03:05

Marie it is that he does not value love

play03:07

itself but this is also not the spiteful

play03:09

Rebellion against love that we see in

play03:11

some other stories moo is not kicking

play03:14

his feet against romance nor is he lying

play03:16

to project some pseudo stoic image it is

play03:19

as simple and honest as he says he just

play03:21

doesn't think it matters this phenomenon

play03:24

which almost everyone else seems to hold

play03:26

in high esteem strikes moo as pointless

play03:29

combined with Moo's remark that his

play03:31

mother's passing has not really changed

play03:33

anything this provides a valuable

play03:35

insight into his character when it comes

play03:37

to personal relationships a pillar of

play03:39

what most people think makes their lives

play03:41

meaningful he is deeply indifferent and

play03:44

his ambivalence does not stop there we

play03:47

have already mentioned raymont the

play03:48

unsavory character moo becomes friends

play03:50

with near the beginning of the novel

play03:52

raymont tells moo to write a note in

play03:54

order to lure one of his old girlfriends

play03:56

back to his flat for the express purpose

play03:58

of berting humiliating and possibly

play04:01

beating her surprisingly for the

play04:03

supposed hero of our story moo agrees

play04:06

but it is not with conspiratorial Glee

play04:08

but again with calm indifference he

play04:10

condemns a woman to violence with a

play04:11

shrug of his shoulders he does not mind

play04:14

where the Raymond attacks this woman or

play04:16

not the whole moral matter strikes him

play04:18

as a triviality the fact that Raymond is

play04:20

violent and cruel does not concern him

play04:22

he certainly doesn't see it as a

play04:23

positive but he doesn't see it as a

play04:25

negative either this gels rather well

play04:27

with something Maro says later in the

play04:29

novel about being unable to feel remorse

play04:31

again it is not that he is deliberately

play04:33

immoral or malicious he's certainly not

play04:35

outright cruel but morality is just

play04:37

another thing he doesn't particularly

play04:39

value to him it is as strange as some

play04:41

people would view my habit of collecting

play04:43

hardback books or one of my good friends

play04:45

obsession with Lego this is the first

play04:47

Brick in the Wall between himself and

play04:50

others moo may not call himself a

play04:52

philosopher but he has seen the lack of

play04:54

objective value in the world and this

play04:56

has seeped deep into his psyche he thus

play04:58

holds the world and everyone else in it

play05:00

at a distance in effect he has very

play05:02

little in common with almost everyone

play05:04

around him they are still in mesed in

play05:06

their social roles their sets of values

play05:08

and their ideas of right and wrong he

play05:11

just can't bring himself to care about

play05:13

any of this this does not make him

play05:15

particularly sad or particularly happy

play05:17

but it does cut him off from relating to

play05:19

and forging bonds with other people and

play05:21

it sets him apart from the whole rest of

play05:23

his Society it is what makes him a

play05:25

stranger to everyone and while we might

play05:28

not fully relate to so's position of

play05:30

valuing basically nothing many of us

play05:32

will be familiar with this sudden

play05:34

feeling of alienation of seeing yourself

play05:37

in the third person or the world

play05:38

suddenly striking us as completely

play05:40

mundane we might be sitting in a coffee

play05:42

shop or at work or chatting with friends

play05:44

when in an instant we become painfully

play05:47

aware of the sheer pointlessness of it

play05:49

all our life ceases to feel like a

play05:51

hero's journey and instead becomes a

play05:53

hamster wheel at that moment it feels

play05:55

like we're observing ourselves from afar

play05:57

and whatever we're doing starts to feel

play05:59

bizarre why am I doing this we ask and

play06:02

we cannot find a satisfactory answer the

play06:04

people around us transform from warm

play06:06

familiar faces we can relate to to

play06:09

unconvincing masks placed at top

play06:11

mysterious unknown thoughts we become

play06:13

acutely aware of the brevity of Our

play06:15

Lives the meaninglessness of our daily

play06:17

existence and our ultimate Solitude in a

play06:19

universe that does not care about us and

play06:22

could not even if it tried and we look

play06:24

around at everyone else wondering if

play06:27

they are thinking the same thing in Kam

play06:29

terminology we have caught a glimpse of

play06:32

the Absurd the fact that despite our

play06:34

longing there is no meaning out in the

play06:36

universe for many of us the sighting

play06:38

will be brief and we will eventually

play06:39

fall back into the unconscious habits of

play06:42

our everyday lives but what makes Mero

play06:44

so remarkable is that he does not do

play06:46

this having come to realize that

play06:48

everything is pointless he nonetheless

play06:50

continues to live but this personal

play06:52

philosophy marks him out as different

play06:54

and isolated and alone and if there is

play06:57

one thing that people don't take kindly

play06:59

to it is this sort of difference if you

play07:02

want to help me make more videos like

play07:03

this then please consider subscribing to

play07:05

my Channel or my patreon the links are

play07:07

in the description two judgment and

play07:11

condemnation the second half of cmu's

play07:13

novel is dominated by Moo's trial

play07:16

essentially Raymond developed a rivalry

play07:18

with another man the brother of the

play07:20

woman that he was so cruel to at the

play07:21

beginning of the book Raymond and Mero

play07:24

go on a beach Excursion and while they

play07:25

are out they encounter this man and some

play07:28

friends and they become involved in a

play07:30

physical altercation that wounds raymont

play07:32

then when he is strolling along the

play07:34

beach later that day moo bumps into

play07:36

Raymond's rival again who draws a knife

play07:38

dazzling moo with the reflection of the

play07:40

Sun in the confusion moo shoots the man

play07:43

dead and fires four more shots into his

play07:46

body for good measure unsurprisingly moo

play07:48

is put on trial for this but very little

play07:50

focus is given to the events of the

play07:52

crime the prosecutor seems unconcerned

play07:54

with whether Moo's victim actually meant

play07:56

him harm and whether this was a killing

play07:58

in self-defense or an aggress crime

play08:00

instead he focuses on Moo's General

play08:03

disposition the things that set him

play08:04

apart from other people this begins with

play08:07

an examination of how moo felt about his

play08:09

mother's passing the prosecutor

play08:11

questions why he was so unbothered by

play08:13

her death he points to his nonchalance

play08:15

at his mother's funeral how he offered

play08:17

someone a cigarette and accepted coffee

play08:19

how he did not cry and didn't want to

play08:21

look upon his mother's body essentially

play08:24

the prosecutor reveals just how

play08:25

unusually Mero behaved and how out of

play08:28

Step this was with the proper way of

play08:30

doing things the assembled crowd seee in

play08:33

their hatred for Mero because they are

play08:35

convinced he is a callous and uncaring

play08:37

son and in a sense they're right he

play08:40

flies in the face of their moral Norms

play08:42

he is strange to them this Hammer home

play08:45

Moo's sense of alienation and he even

play08:48

describes wanting to cry for the first

play08:50

time in years this points to the fact

play08:52

that moo despite all of his General

play08:54

indifference still yearns to be

play08:56

understood by other people put a pin in

play08:58

that because it will become an important

play09:00

point after this his relationship with

play09:02

Marie is called into question how could

play09:04

this man so soon after his mother's

play09:06

death begin an affair with this young

play09:08

lady where was his sense of decorum

play09:10

where was his mourning for that matter

play09:12

what was he doing striking up a

play09:14

friendship with raymont how could he

play09:15

justify writing a letter that would

play09:17

deliver a young woman to a beating why

play09:19

did he get involved in Raymond's

play09:21

disputes with these other men former so

play09:24

the answer to these questions is obvious

play09:26

it is because he did not mind either way

play09:27

and so went along with whatever struck

play09:29

him as easiest or most interesting in

play09:31

the moment his General non-committal

play09:33

attitude to life made him very easily

play09:36

swayed by external circumstances and as

play09:38

we said in the last section his

play09:40

indifference allowed him to remain

play09:42

Untouched by his mother's death enjoy

play09:44

his time with Marie without becoming at

play09:46

all attached and Aid Raymond in his

play09:48

dastardly schemes all while staying in

play09:50

the same calm Bland mental state while

play09:53

other people perceive him as a kind of

play09:55

malicious monster able to kill without a

play09:58

second thought and eating the world he

play10:00

ultimately just lives an existence so

play10:03

alien to the people of French alers that

play10:05

What mattered to them simply struck him

play10:08

as pointless they may condemn him and

play10:10

they may kill him but are they justified

play10:12

in judging him by standards that strike

play10:14

him as completely absurd moo doesn't

play10:17

even seem to understand why they're

play10:19

interested in his behavior at all at the

play10:21

end of the trial the prosecutor

play10:23

describes Moo's philosophical Outlook as

play10:25

an abyss threatening to swallow up

play10:28

society and I I think this is a really

play10:30

important point the jurors and the

play10:32

assembled public are less concerned with

play10:34

what moo has done and more threatened by

play10:37

his Outlook this is not entirely

play10:39

irrational of them we all might have

play10:41

good reason to fear someone who does not

play10:43

care about their fellow man or morality

play10:45

but at the same time I think there is

play10:47

something deeper going on moo by his

play10:50

very existence is posing them a question

play10:52

they simply don't want to confront what

play10:54

if we truly do live in a world devoid of

play10:57

meaning waiting to devour us at the

play10:59

point of death what if indifference is

play11:02

the sole sensible position and we only

play11:04

continue to care about anything because

play11:06

of our inability to look facts in the

play11:08

face once again moo is alienated by his

play11:11

philosophy because of what it

play11:13

unwittingly forces on other people and

play11:16

as Jean Paul satra points out in his

play11:17

famous essay on the stranger the reader

play11:20

is not exempt from this analysis

play11:22

although many will relate to Moo's sense

play11:24

of alienation from the world and perhaps

play11:26

even sympathize with his devaluation of

play11:28

social norms not not many people are

play11:30

going to find his complete apathy

play11:32

towards the fact that he has killed a

play11:33

man particularly Charming nor his

play11:36

willingness to Aid Raymond in his plot

play11:38

to violently harm a young woman in

play11:40

presenting us with someone so at odds

play11:42

with our own worldview kamu is asking us

play11:45

a question as well can we truly cope

play11:47

with an absurd man someone who does not

play11:49

discriminate between different

play11:51

experiences and who thinks that any life

play11:53

is as good as any other who is able to

play11:55

look at the emptiness of existence

play11:57

without flinching and lives their life

play11:58

accordingly or do we just see a dire

play12:01

threat to our way of life in some ways

play12:04

the reaction of the crowd and the reader

play12:06

to Moo is the same reaction many of us

play12:08

have towards this concept of

play12:10

meaninglessness many of us find the idea

play12:12

that nothing matters repugnant and since

play12:14

moo is this concept personified we find

play12:17

him slightly disgusting as well but kamu

play12:20

forces us to ask why this is and he

play12:23

questions whether our judgment truly

play12:25

comes from a place of philosophical and

play12:27

moral concern and consistency or whether

play12:30

it simply stems from our own fear and

play12:33

maybe some of us can relate to Moo's

play12:35

plight maybe we have Properties or hold

play12:38

certain positions that are out of step

play12:39

with the moral system we happen to live

play12:41

in perhaps we are an atheist in a deeply

play12:43

religious community or a maligned

play12:45

religious sect if so we may be used to

play12:48

the idea that we are a threat to the

play12:50

moral order and should be dispensed with

play12:52

forth withth I've said this before but

play12:53

one of the great strengths of kamu

play12:55

writings is that he is able to show us

play12:57

people who are truly Beyond good and

play12:59

evil and challenge us to react to them

play13:01

in an honest and authentic fashion how

play13:03

do we respond when the Absurd is thrust

play13:06

in our face and how should we respond

play13:08

but the hatred Mero receives at the

play13:10

hands of his jury is partly due to a

play13:12

near Universal human phenomenon and one

play13:15

we might have good reason to be scared

play13:17

of three confusion and Chaos perhaps one

play13:22

of the deepest human fears is the fear

play13:24

of the unknown even our Terror at the

play13:26

concept of death is partly because we

play13:28

don't know know what happens to us

play13:30

afterwards hence why the notion of an

play13:31

afterlife can bring some people great

play13:34

peace in their final days humanity is

play13:36

adept at conquering those aspects of the

play13:39

world we cannot yet make sense of this

play13:41

is something religion science philosophy

play13:43

art and more all have in common they are

play13:46

often trying to make something we

play13:47

currently find incomprehensible that bit

play13:50

more understandable either by crafting

play13:52

empirical theories or mathematical

play13:53

models or by communicating a message in

play13:56

a particular way and kamu novel

play13:58

illustrates just how disturbing it can

play14:00

be when we are confronted with something

play14:02

we just cannot get our heads around as I

play14:04

said before throughout all the

play14:06

interrogations and trials the people

play14:08

examining Mero show very little interest

play14:10

in his actual crime they seem untroubled

play14:12

by the mere fact that he has killed a

play14:13

man and possibly done so In Cold Blood

play14:15

instead they are constantly searching

play14:17

for a way to make sense of him to slot

play14:19

him neatly into their worldview they

play14:21

cannot understand his Outlook and the

play14:23

Mystery of this is what terrifies them

play14:26

most of all first there is the

play14:27

magistrate who talks to when he has

play14:29

brought him for questioning he is

play14:31

fascinated by the fact moo does not

play14:33

believe in God but even more so that he

play14:35

treats the whole proposition with total

play14:37

indifference the magistrate just cannot

play14:40

understand why someone could not be at

play14:42

all concerned with the matters of the

play14:43

Divine talking about it in the same tone

play14:45

of voice as you might wonder what you

play14:47

were going to have for breakfast even an

play14:49

atheist might recognize that the

play14:51

question of God's existence is an

play14:52

important one but moo is different he is

play14:55

just unbothered this incomprehensibility

play14:58

is further when moo is asked why he left

play15:01

a gap between his first shot and his

play15:03

later shots this is a perfectly sensible

play15:05

question to ask it may hints that moo

play15:07

truly did want the man dead whether or

play15:09

not he was initially acting in

play15:11

self-defense you can imagine the kind of

play15:13

answers the magistrate might expect moo

play15:15

might have claimed that the man was

play15:17

getting up to attack him or that he

play15:18

wasn't sure that he had been neutralized

play15:20

as a threat but moo just seems genuinely

play15:23

perplexed by the question answering only

play15:25

that he doesn't know the shots are an

play15:27

insoluble mystery even to the man who

play15:29

was wielding the gun the Magistrate's

play15:31

confusion at muro's Behavior causes him

play15:34

to treat Mero with a mixture of anger

play15:36

and disgust he says he has never known

play15:38

someone to be so unaffected by the image

play15:40

of Christ's suffering or to be so eerily

play15:42

calm about this whole event he might be

play15:45

able to deal with criminals both

play15:46

rebellious and repentant but this

play15:48

bizarre attachment was too foreign too

play15:51

alien to him he eventually decides to

play15:53

call moo mure Antichrist A fitting name

play15:56

that denotes the Magistrate's opinion of

play15:58

him a Monster not quite of this world

play16:00

yet deceptively in human form this theme

play16:03

of confusion leading to condemnation and

play16:06

judgment becomes even more pointed

play16:08

during Moo's trial where his silence and

play16:10

indifference make him appear strange to

play16:12

the jury and the craft again no one

play16:14

seems interested in the fact that moo

play16:16

has actually killed a man they do not

play16:18

dwell on the suffering of the victim or

play16:20

how it has affected his family they

play16:22

essentially do not care about the crime

play16:24

at all but only the unique questions moo

play16:27

poses they want to make sense of of him

play16:29

to find out what makes him tick they

play16:31

want to conquer this little slice of the

play16:33

unknown that terrifies them so much of

play16:36

course the largely indifferent Moo Can

play16:38

Only explain his actions in ways that

play16:40

are totally unsatisfactory in response

play16:43

to the question of why he shot his

play16:44

victim he says it was because of the Sun

play16:47

and he is being perfectly honest here

play16:49

the sun blinded him making him confused

play16:51

and he only ever moved towards the man

play16:53

because he felt the sun's heat on his

play16:55

back and was trying to escape it maso's

play16:57

movements were not ated by a reasoned

play17:00

will but rather by these vague

play17:02

animalistic impulses but of course the

play17:04

jury only laughs off this answer they

play17:06

want to know what reasons and values LED

play17:09

Mero to committing this crime and he

play17:11

simply has no answer a large part of why

play17:13

the prosecutor deems Mero this grave

play17:15

philosophical threat to society and why

play17:18

he eventually asks for the death penalty

play17:20

is because of this intense confusion

play17:22

everybody feels towards him he is an

play17:24

unknown element something so strange he

play17:27

is difficult to look at they do not know

play17:29

what he will do next or what he values

play17:31

or what motivates his actions they

play17:33

cannot change him and they cannot make

play17:35

sense of him so they consign him to the

play17:37

Flames sentencing him to the guillotine

play17:40

and this confusion is shared by Maro

play17:42

just like the jury cannot make sense of

play17:44

his indifference he can't understand why

play17:46

they behave in certain ways he does not

play17:48

get why he should have been more upset

play17:51

by his mother's death nor why his

play17:52

behavior with Marie is deemed

play17:54

inappropriate their morals are as

play17:56

strange to him as his lack of morals are

play17:58

to to us this shared bewilderment opens

play18:01

an unbridgeable Chasm between Mero and

play18:04

the rest of mankind and it eventually

play18:06

breaks out into hostility hence he is

play18:09

sentenced to death first it is worth

play18:11

noting that maro's strangeness is just

play18:13

an extreme form of the way we are all

play18:16

somewhat alien to one another sure we

play18:18

may in fact share values experiences and

play18:20

memories with others but there is always

play18:22

the barrier of people's skulls

play18:24

preventing us from fully knowing what's

play18:26

going on in their mind the paranoia the

play18:29

have about muro's psychology is a

play18:31

heightened version of an unease we can

play18:32

all feel when we recognize how much of

play18:35

other people's minds are forever bar off

play18:37

to us our best friend could secretly

play18:39

hate us our partner could be cheating on

play18:41

us and anyone at any moment could embark

play18:43

on a course of action that we would find

play18:45

totally confusing and incomprehensible

play18:48

all because of this unbridgeable gap

play18:50

between our Consciousness and the

play18:51

consciousness of everyone around us we

play18:53

are all strangers just not to the same

play18:56

extent moo refuses to make himself even

play18:59

a little bit understandable to others

play19:01

and it throws people into a violent

play19:03

frenzy they hate him far more than he

play19:05

ever hated the man he killed it is a

play19:07

stark reminder of how vicious humans can

play19:09

be when they encounter the unknown and

play19:11

since we are all to a certain extent

play19:13

unknown to one another this leaves a

play19:15

bitter taste in our mouths how would

play19:17

people react we might think if they knew

play19:20

what I was really like the desperate

play19:22

search for a theory to explain Moo's

play19:25

Behavior also serves as an analogy for

play19:27

how we encounter the absurd we want the

play19:29

universe to be understandable like a

play19:32

rational human agent we want it to have

play19:34

Concepts like good and evil and to be

play19:37

interested in us in some way but it does

play19:40

not and is not and many of us find this

play19:42

idea unbearable we might be able to cope

play19:45

with a universe that hated us but one

play19:47

that does not know we exist and cannot

play19:49

understand us is so terrifyingly Bland

play19:52

that it can throw us into a crisis in

play19:54

classic fashion kamu manages to comment

play19:56

both on our interpersonal alienation and

play19:58

our existential isolation in a single

play20:01

literary Master stroke it is no wonder

play20:03

that this has gone down as one of the

play20:05

richest philosophical novels in history

play20:07

but finally I want to explore how moo

play20:10

learns to deal with this alienation how

play20:12

he transforms the world from something

play20:14

he is simply indifferent to into his

play20:16

dear friend without abandoning his

play20:19

philosophical principle that nothing

play20:21

really matters four the comfort of the

play20:24

Absurd for many people the idea that the

play20:27

universe is indifferent to us can seem

play20:29

distressing masso's attitude of total

play20:32

apathy towards the world can come across

play20:34

as incredibly Bleak and sometimes the

play20:36

line between absurdism and nihilism

play20:38

seems very thin but in the final chapter

play20:41

of the book where moo is awaiting his

play20:43

execution we see him undergo a

play20:45

philosophical breakthrough in a lot of

play20:47

other stories not written by kamu this

play20:49

would be where maso learns the error of

play20:51

his ways rejecting his prior

play20:53

indifference and deciding that morality

play20:55

love and family are truly worth

play20:57

something but but of course this book is

play21:00

written by kamu and so moo does remain

play21:03

indifferent and alienated but at the

play21:05

same time manages to make peace with

play21:07

this fact his Revelation is sparked by a

play21:10

conversation with the prison chaplain

play21:11

just like everybody else he finds Moo's

play21:14

Outlook strange and absurd the chaplain

play21:16

refuses to accept that moo is different

play21:19

and that he truly does not see the value

play21:21

in the prospect of higher meaning or an

play21:23

afterlife or anything else for that

play21:25

matter eventually Mero becomes enraged

play21:28

by the priest's refusal to even try to

play21:30

see his point of view and throws him out

play21:33

of the cell there is no one who seems to

play21:35

understand moo no matter how hard he

play21:37

tries to get his point across it is

play21:39

simply beyond their limits to see him as

play21:42

anything other than a weird anomaly a

play21:44

human defect a philosophical Abomination

play21:47

he shouts at the priest that he means

play21:49

exactly what he says that nothing

play21:51

matters and he does not see why he

play21:53

should care about any of it moo seems

play21:55

relieved by this outburst and when he

play21:57

settles back into to bed he realizes

play21:59

that there is something similar to him

play22:02

and that is the universe itself his

play22:04

Outlook is simply a reflection of the

play22:06

world's indifference and as long as this

play22:08

Remains the case he is not truly alone

play22:11

he may be a stranger to everyone else

play22:13

but to the cosmos he is perhaps the most

play22:15

sensible person on the planet in that

play22:17

moment he no longer feels like he is

play22:19

kicking against hostile and vengeful

play22:21

crowds but instead sees them for what

play22:23

they are future corpses shouting at

play22:26

nothing amounting to nothing signifying

play22:29

nothing in his own words I opened myself

play22:32

to the gentle indifference of the world

play22:34

finding it so much like myself so like a

play22:37

brother really I felt I had been happy

play22:39

and that I was happy again as is often

play22:42

the case with kamu this passage

play22:44

communicates two thoughts simultaneously

play22:46

the first is that moo has now fully

play22:48

accepted the meaninglessness of the

play22:50

universe he is no longer troubled by the

play22:52

Absurd in the slightest and has moved

play22:54

past it finding happiness in

play22:55

indifference rather than just

play22:57

indifference but for the first time in

play22:59

the novel he has also ceased to be a

play23:01

stranger for the rest of the book Maro

play23:04

is constantly in contrast with people

play23:06

that are fundamentally opposed to his

play23:08

worldview Marie wants him to notice the

play23:10

value in her love Raymond wants him to

play23:12

be alive to his anger and the courts

play23:14

want him to recognize that he should

play23:16

have mourned his mother everywhere he

play23:18

has turned marau has found opposition

play23:20

and condemnation he has been made

play23:22

strange but it is in these final moments

play23:25

awaiting his execution that he finally

play23:28

discovered was a friend he may be alien

play23:30

to everyone else but he is at peace with

play23:33

himself and with the world as it appears

play23:35

to him just as absurdism is coming to

play23:38

terms with the universe's

play23:39

meaninglessness rather than attempting

play23:41

to inject meaning into it m so

play23:43

transcends the need to have others

play23:45

accept him or even understand him he has

play23:48

embraced his position as an outsider and

play23:50

has found satisfaction in it at the

play23:52

philosophical level he is able to live

play23:54

with meaninglessness and at the everyday

play23:56

level he has made sense of his position

play23:58

as isolated alone and resented the only

play24:01

thing he wishes is for there to be a

play24:03

large crowd of braying hating people at

play24:06

his execution and this is emblematic of

play24:09

a theme that will only become more

play24:10

prominent in kamu later works like the

play24:13

rebel and the fall the problem of

play24:15

existential meaning and how to move past

play24:17

the Absurd is inexorably tied up with

play24:19

our own everyday problems of Cruelty

play24:21

violence political struggle isolation

play24:24

social unrest and morality it is all

play24:26

considered part of one enormous thorny

play24:29

problem in the stranger Camu ties

play24:31

together the issues of being alone

play24:34

isolated and judged and the problem of

play24:36

an indifferent universe and paints a

play24:38

form of absurdism as the answer both to

play24:41

the larger philosophical concern but

play24:43

also to the very real and concrete issue

play24:45

of when we feel unbearably alone

play24:48

paradoxically just as we can imagine

play24:50

Copus happy in his pointless task the

play24:52

universe itself becomes Moo's companion

play24:55

its indifference becomes not crushing

play24:57

but comforting and we move through the

play24:59

problem of our incomprehensible

play25:01

isolation rather than running from it or

play25:04

rejecting it and this for me is what

play25:06

makes the stranger one of the most

play25:08

exciting and insightful examinations of

play25:11

what it means to be alone in all

play25:13

literature it paints isolation not just

play25:16

as a problem of the person or of society

play25:19

or of psychology but one that cuts at

play25:21

the deepest level of our fundamental

play25:23

philosophy and I hope this video has

play25:25

encouraged you to give it a read but if

play25:27

you want more more on the way kamu

play25:29

meshes absurdism with more everyday

play25:31

problems then click here to see how he

play25:33

approaches the topic of guilt and shame

play25:36

from the standpoint of the Absurd it's

play25:38

also perhaps one of the most terrifying

play25:40

books I've ever read so there's that and

play25:42

stick around for more on thinking to

play25:44

improve your life

Rate This

5.0 / 5 (0 votes)

Ähnliche Tags
ExistentialismAbsurdismCamusIsolationAlienationPhilosophyLiteratureMeaninglessnessThe StrangerIndifference
Benötigen Sie eine Zusammenfassung auf Englisch?