Nespresso Vertuo vs Original - Which is Best?

Summary

In this video, James from Mostly Helpful compares two Nespresso coffee machines: the original Nespresso Cities and the newer Nespresso Virtuo Next. He evaluates them based on convenience, coffee quality, and cost. Both machines are user-friendly, but the Virtuo Next offers the advantage of reusing capsules. The coffee quality varies due to different brewing methods, with the original system using pressure and the Virtuo Next using a centrifugal system, resulting in a foamy head. Cost-wise, the original system is more economical, and it offers more flexibility with third-party capsule options. James concludes that the original system better suits his preferences.

Takeaways

• 😀 The video compares two Nespresso machines: the original Nespresso Cities machine and the newer Nespresso Virtuo Next.
• 🔍 The comparison is based on three criteria: convenience, coffee quality, and cost.
• 🤔 The Nespresso Cities machine uses original capsules and is easy to use with one-handed operation and a simple button system.
• ☕ The Nespresso Virtuo Next uses barcoded capsules and adjusts the coffee volume based on the capsule type, but may require a stronger hand for operation.
• 💧 Both machines have similar-sized water tanks, but the Virtuo Next may require more frequent refills due to its larger capsule sizes.
• 🍽 The coffee from the Cities machine has a standard crema created by pressure, while the Virtuo Next creates a foamy head through aeration.
• 📈 The original capsule system offers more variety and can be purchased from various retailers, unlike the Virtuo capsules which are exclusive to Nespresso.
• 💰 The cost of the machines is similar, but the Virtuo capsules are generally more expensive than the original capsules.
• 🌍 There is a slight environmental concern with the larger and less compact Virtuo capsules compared to the smaller original ones.
• 🛒 The video suggests that for those who prefer not to have a foamy coffee, the original system might be more suitable due to the control over crema and cost-effectiveness.
• 👍 The video encourages viewers to try both systems if possible to determine personal preference and to subscribe for more content like this.

Q & A

What are the two Nespresso machines discussed in the video?

The two Nespresso machines discussed are the Nespresso Cities machine and the Nespresso Virtuo Next coffee machine.

What are the three criteria used to compare the Nespresso machines?

The three criteria used to compare the machines are convenience, coffee quality, and cost.

How does the Nespresso Cities machine operate in terms of convenience?

The Nespresso Cities machine is very easy to use, simple, and compact, allowing for one-handed operation and featuring an espresso and a double espresso button.

What is unique about the Nespresso Virtuo Next machine's operation?

The Nespresso Virtuo Next machine operates with a single button and uses a barcode on the capsule to determine the volume of water it flows into the capsule.

What is the benefit of the Nespresso Virtuo Next machine mentioned in the script?

One benefit of the Nespresso Virtuo Next machine is that it allows the user to vent through a used capsule if it's not ejected after brewing.

How do the water tanks of the two machines compare in size?

The water tanks of both machines are very similar in size, but the Nespresso Cities machine, which uses a single size of capsule, requires less frequent refills compared to the Virtuo Next machine.

What are the differences in the coffee brewing process between the two machines?

The Nespresso Cities machine uses a pressure system to create a standard crema, while the Nespresso Virtuo Next machine uses a centrifugal system, creating a crema through aeration.

How does the availability of capsules affect the convenience of each machine?

The Nespresso Cities machine is more convenient in terms of capsule availability as it can use capsules from various retailers like Starbucks, Costa, and others, while the Virtuo Next machine requires capsules from Nespresso or specific retailers.

What is the difference in cost between the two types of capsules?

The Virtuo Next capsules are generally more expensive than the original Nespresso capsules, with a small but noticeable difference in cost per capsule.

What is the reviewer's personal preference regarding the coffee crema?

The reviewer prefers the standard crema from the Nespresso Cities machine over the foamy head created by the Virtuo Next machine, as it doesn't feel or taste as appealing.

What is the reviewer's conclusion about the cost implications of using the Virtuo Next machine?

The reviewer concludes that there is a cost implication when using the Virtuo Next machine due to the more expensive capsules, and for their personal coffee preference, they find it difficult to justify the extra cost.

Outlines

00:00

😀 Introduction and Comparison of Nespresso Machines

In the first paragraph, the host introduces two Nespresso coffee machines: the Nespresso Cities and the Nespresso Virtuo Next. The video aims to compare these machines based on convenience, coffee quality, and cost. The host demonstrates the ease of use of the Satis machine, highlighting its one-handed operation and compact size. The Virtuo Next is shown to be slightly more complex due to its single button operation and reliance on barcodes for determining coffee volume. A unique feature of the Virtuo Next is its ability to vent through a used capsule without ejecting it first, which is not possible with the Cities machine. The water tanks of both machines are noted to be similar in size.

05:01

😕 Exploring Coffee Quality and Capsule Variety

In the second paragraph, the focus shifts to the coffee quality produced by the machines. The host discusses the difference in crema between the pressure-based system of the Cities machine and the aeration-based system of the Virtuo Next. The latter creates a foamy coffee head that diminishes over time, leaving a residue that the host finds unappealing. The variety of capsules is also discussed, with the original system offering more choices and the ability to purchase compatible capsules from various retailers, unlike the Virtuo system which requires capsules from Nespresso. The host expresses disappointment with the foamy head of the Virtuo system and the lack of control over it, as it is determined by the capsule's barcode.

10:02

💰 Cost Analysis and Personal Preference

The third paragraph delves into the cost implications of the two systems. The host compares the prices of the machines and the capsules, noting a slightly higher cost for the Virtuo system's capsules. The environmental impact of the larger, more material-intensive capsules of the Virtuo system is briefly mentioned. The host concludes that while the machines themselves have a negligible cost difference, the Virtuo system will likely result in higher overall costs due to more expensive capsules. The host also shares a personal preference for the original system due to the undesirable foamy head of the Virtuo system and the cost savings of the original capsules. The video ends with a call for viewer feedback on their experiences with the machines and a prompt to like and subscribe for more content.

Keywords

💡Nespresso

Nespresso is a brand of coffee machines and coffee capsules owned by Nestlé. In the video, the presenter discusses two Nespresso machines, highlighting the differences in their capsule systems. Nespresso is central to the video's theme as it is the brand of both machines being compared.

💡Virtuo Next

Virtuo Next is a model of Nespresso coffee machine that uses barcoded capsules to determine the volume of water dispensed. The video compares this machine with the Nespresso Cities machine, focusing on convenience, coffee quality, and cost. The Virtuo Next is a key element in the comparison as it represents the newer technology of Nespresso machines.

💡Original Capsules

Original capsules refer to the standard Nespresso coffee capsules that do not use barcodes and are compatible with a variety of Nespresso machines. The video discusses the original capsules in contrast to the newer barcoded capsules, emphasizing the broader availability and compatibility of the original capsules.

💡Convenience

Convenience in the context of the video pertains to the ease of use, one-handed operation, and the ability to purchase capsules outside of Nespresso's ecosystem. The presenter evaluates both machines on these criteria, with the original capsule system being more convenient due to its wider availability.

💡Coffee Quality

Coffee quality is a significant aspect of the video, where the presenter compares the taste and crema produced by the two machines. The original system uses pressure to create crema, while the Virtuo Next uses a centrifugal system, leading to different coffee experiences.

💡Cost

Cost is evaluated in terms of both the initial price of the machines and the ongoing expense of the capsules. The video details the price difference between the two machines and the cost per cup of coffee, with the Virtuo Next system's capsules being more expensive.

💡Barcoded Capsules

Barcoded capsules are a feature of the Virtuo Next system, where each capsule has a barcode that the machine reads to determine the volume of water to dispense. This technology is highlighted as a distinguishing factor between the two Nespresso systems discussed in the video.

💡Centrifugal System

The centrifugal system, also referred to as 'central fusion' by Nespresso, is the method used in the Virtuo Next machine where the capsule spins at high speeds to aerate the coffee. This is contrasted with the pressure system of the original capsules, resulting in a different coffee texture and crema.

💡Crema

Crema is the foamy layer on top of espresso, which is influenced by the brewing method. The video compares the crema produced by the pressure system of the original capsules to the aeration-based crema of the Virtuo Next, noting differences in appearance and texture.

💡Environmental Concern

Environmental concern is briefly mentioned in the video in relation to the size and material of the capsules. The original capsules are smaller and more compact, potentially having a lower environmental impact compared to the larger barcoded capsules.

💡Compatibility

Compatibility refers to the ability to use capsules from different retailers with the original Nespresso system, which is not possible with the Virtuo Next system. This aspect is discussed in terms of convenience and flexibility for the user.

Highlights

Introduction to comparing Nespresso Virtuo and Nespresso Cities coffee machines.

Comparison based on three criteria: convenience, coffee quality, and cost.

Demonstration of making coffee with the Satis machine for ease of use comparison.

Comparison of water tank sizes and refill frequency between the two machines.

Explanation of the pressure system in the Nespresso Cities machine versus the centrifugal system in the Virtuo machine.

Observation of crema differences due to brewing methods in both machines.

Discussion on the ability to adjust coffee volume with the Virtuo machine's barcode system.

Comparison of coffee choices available in the original and virtual capsule systems.

Mention of the broader availability of original capsules from various retailers due to expired patents.

Cost comparison between the two machines and their respective capsules.

Personal preference for coffee without the foamy head produced by the Virtuo machine's larger capsules.

Recommendation to test the foamy coffee head in-store or with a friend's machine before committing to a purchase.

Final thoughts on the cost implications of choosing the Virtuo system over the original system.

Environmental consideration regarding the size and material of the capsules.

Conclusion on the preference for the Nespresso Cities machine over the Virtuo for the presenter's coffee needs.

Call to action for viewers to share their experiences and preferences regarding the two Nespresso systems.

Transcripts

this is my nespresso cities coffee

machine and this is my new nespresso

virtual machine and in today's video i'm

going to talk about both the machines

and the different capsule systems to

help you make a decision about which

one's right for you let's get to it

[Music]

hi i'm james and welcome to mostly

helpful this is the second and final

part of a video series where i've been

looking at my new nespresso virtuo next

coffee machine and in today's video i'm

going to be comparing that to this

nespresso cities machine which uses the

original capsules in order to make that

comparison we're going to be looking at

three criteria one convenience two the

coffee and three the cost

so starting with convenience then the

first thing i want to do right now is

actually make a coffee so let's talk

about these machines this is my satis

machine i've owned this for a year and i

find this very easy to use it's very

simple you can do everything one-handed

like this

and

as you can see it's very easy and

compact it takes up a similar footprint

to this machine over here and in terms

of ease of use it's very simple you've

got a espresso button on here and a

double espresso button here the virtual

machine is a little different you can

operate it one-handed but you need to be

reasonably um kind of strong in the hand

and it's only got one single button up

here

because it determines the amount of

volume it flows into the capsule

because of this barcode that's on the

capsule itself but in terms of ease of

use they're both very simple they're

both one or two button machines there is

nothing complicated here and there's not

a great deal to decide between the two

of them there is one benefit of the

virtual machine that i've noticed and

that is if you brew a coffee in one of

these machines and you forget to eject a

capsule like that you can then come

along press the button again and you can

vent through a used capsule it doesn't

stop you doing that this machine does

once you've vended through a capsule if

you don't eject it which is doing that

process it will not let you activate the

system again until you've ejected that

capsule

so

that is certainly one of the the

benefits that i spotted of this machine

in terms of water quantity at the back

they're actually

they have very very similar size tanks i

did a little experiment earlier and

filled up one tank from the other and

the water levels are very very similar

but this machine because it can take

these larger capsules

you're likely to be filling up that tank

more regularly than this machine which

takes a single size of capsule so let's

talk about the coffee and while we do

that i'm going to just make a coffee i'm

going to use the skewer here for this

one

let's power on that machine

this machine interestingly powers on as

soon as you lift that lid although it's

just powered off but as soon as you do

that it powers itself on you don't need

to press anything

and then this is a

double espresso skewering so i should be

getting similar vend quantities from

both

it's worth noting that this machine uses

a pressure system and this machine uses

a

centrifugal system i think nespresso has

called it central fusion

so the capsule actually spins inside at

some crazy rate 1000 rpm or something

like that and what that creates is a

very different effect on the coffee so

in this machine you get a standard crema

let's

then this one now

so what you have here is a crema that's

created by pressure and the pressure of

the water flowing through that capsule

in this machine it creates a crema

through aeration of the coffee and

there's a really excellent video by

james hoffman that talks all about how

the virtual system works uh he's done a

much better job of it than i will do

but let's vend this one and i'll

demonstrate how different it is

and there we go that one's finished and

as you can see they look very similar

this one's a little bit shorter and the

reason for that is that the virtual

system

determines how much water to vent

through by virtue of the type of capsule

you've got this is a single espresso or

peru that will give 40 mil

that one we've just put in there is a

double espresso that gives 80 mils i'm

assuming that's 80 ml i haven't checked

and then you get the larger capsules

that give you a greater size that's a

mug size at 230.

these machines

this button if i remember correctly is

programmed to 40 mil and this one is

programmed to 110 but you can there's a

bit of variation you can program that

down if you wanted an 80mm double

espresso so you've got some uh

capability to adjust your coffee whereas

in these machines

you get it how the pod kind of wants you

to get it

when taking espresso or double espresso

i do find that there isn't a great deal

of difference between the two systems

the difference i've really noticed is

with these big capsules

it creates a very large foamy coffee

head it isn't crema in the true sense of

the word because it's

it

you'll see

i'll insert some video here that shows

what happens after five minutes it kind

of

loses it it's kind of aeration i suppose

and then gradually over time it

diminishes but it doesn't diminish

cleanly in the way that a pressure-based

crema does so what you end up with is

sort of

coffee

i hesitate to use the word scum that

come that flows down the inside of the

mug which i find personally a little bit

unappealing

but i know that a lot of people value

how their coffee looks and you can see

that the the

head if that's the right word on this is

diminishing much more rapidly than this

one is here

and that i think is the difference with

these machines

from a coffee point of view as well

though you've also you've got a good

good amount of choice in the virtual

capsule system but you've got much more

choice currently in the original capsule

system and that's not surprising it's

been around a lot longer virtual systems

actually been on the market since 2014

but i think nespresso have been really

pushing it

in the last 18 months to two years and

certainly all the deals in the nosferatu

shop on machines are on this kind of

machine the virtual machine you almost

don't see deals on the original machines

anymore

the other

benefit of these machines now is that

you can get coffee from other retailers

because the patents ended on this style

of capsule you can go to starbucks you

can go to costa you can go to cafe nero

there are any number of people that will

sell you capsules compatible with this

machine so if you run out of coffee and

you haven't had your regular order for

an espresso if you're doing mail order

or you haven't been to the espresso shop

you can go to your local supermarket and

get capsules of coffee for this machine

but what you can't do is you can't go

and get virtual capsules for that

machine unless you go to an espresso

shop

anyway time to try this coffee and then

we will talk about the cost

so talking about cost with respect to

the machines

currently if you go on espressos uk

website today this machine the virtual

next is 149 and this machine that it is

is 159

so very little in price in terms of the

machines in terms of the coffee

i think it's fair to say that if you go

for a virtual machine no matter what

capsule you're going to buy you're

always going to be paying more for the

equivalent capsule and to give you some

idea this is a peru espresso capsule

it's a 40 mil capsule and that is 57

pence or 5 pounds 70 for 10 and this is

a equally an espresso capsule but for

this machine and that is 51 pence or 5

pound 10. so a small difference but

over time depending on how much coffee

you have

a difference that you will notice the

gap gets wider when you start talking

about these bigger capsules that gives

you a mug of coffee 230ml kind of this

sort of size really

that is 66p or 6.60 for 10. that is the

same coffee both of these are columbia

from the master origins range

that obviously gives you

a smaller coffee but it's 47 pence

now there's an interesting point here

and this mug will tell you why we're

talking about it which is that

previously what i used to do is i

use this machine vendor coffee into a

mug and then fill that back up with hot

water from a kettle and that is how i

like my coffee i know some of you will

find that horrendous that i'm drinking

my coffee that way but that is how i

like it

an espresso with hot water up to the top

no sugar no milk nice and simple

i really hoped with this virtuo machine

that we would get to a position where i

could just move to these capsules

and then wouldn't have the boiling the

cattle process but there's partly the

cost reason there's 19p between those

and i'm absolutely confident it doesn't

cost 19p to boil a kettle for a small

amount of water for a coffee

but secondly the foam that you get on

one of these is there's just too much of

it for me i don't like it i like it like

this where you get a very light layer

and in fact i went into my local

nespresso store shortly after buying

that machine and said is there any way i

can stop the machine creating that much

foam with these larger capsules and was

told nope it's it's all done on the

barcode there's no control in the

machine so if you

you like that foam

that's great but if like me you don't

want that foam you don't find it

appealing then these capsules give you

something that you don't want so in

terms of cost for me and what i want i

i feel reluctant paying extra for those

because it doesn't give me what i want

and then all i'm really comparing is a

40 mil capsule in a virtuo system to a

40 mil capsule in a

original system and as i've shown in

that one there's a there's a six pence

difference

so

every coffee is going to cost me 6p and

i have three a day so it's going to be

20 a day i mean it's not an enormous

amount of money but it's a pound a week

50 pounds a year

so there is a definitely a cost

implication of going for this

so with all those three criteria looked

at let's summarize in terms of the

machines and the convenience of the

systems i think that they there is

there is much to like about both of them

if you think of convenience being that

you can access capsules outside of the

nespresso world from your supermarket

then this system is more convenient

because you can go to your supermarket

and buy

costa capsules or sainsbury's capsules

whatever whereas with this system you

have to go and order direct from

nespresso will go to an espresso store

in terms of the coffee they've both got

lots of choice a bit more choice on this

one but i think

anybody would be able to find something

i like across either of these systems

the only thing from my point of view to

watch out for is see if you can if

you're unsure about whether you like

that foamy head see if they will give

you a demonstration in store or see if

you know somebody who's got one already

who can give you a coffee of that style

in order that you can test it it's been

really disappointing from my point of

view i thought it would be beautiful

velvety and like a cappuccino without

the frothing of the milk castle

but it isn't like that at all it looks

lovely but it doesn't feel or tastes

lovely

and then i think in terms of cost

there's a there's a the machines are

negligible in terms of cost cost

difference i think though if you go for

a virtual machine you'll see a little

bit more cost over life

simply because the capsules are more

expensive there is a tiny bit of an

environmental concern as well that i

haven't really touched on but just

physically these are bigger

there's clearly more material in them

these are much more compact there

they take up a lot less room but what

that means for me is that this machine

is going up for sale i've used it i've

enjoyed experimenting with it but i

don't think it materially improves on

what i have here and and that for me is

the important thing does this

fundamentally do something better than

this machine for me and for me it

doesn't do let me know what you think

about these systems have you experienced

a virtuo do you prefer the original let

me know

if you've liked this video do

hit that like if you like this kind of

content then please do consider

subscribing it really helps the channel

and i look forward to coming to you in a

new video very soon thanks and goodbye