Europa levanta muros y pacta con autócratas para frenar la migración
Summary
TLDRThe Mediterranean Sea, a lethal border, witnesses thousands of deaths annually as people attempt the perilous journey from North Africa to Europe. The EU struggles to manage migration, leading to severe consequences. Barriers are being erected, raising questions about their compatibility with human rights. Lampedusa, an Italian island, is a focal point for these deadly migration routes. Critics argue that the EU isn't doing enough to protect refugees, with allegations of illegal pushbacks by Greek coastguards. NGOs like Open Arms and Sea-Watch face legal challenges for rescuing migrants. The EU is now focusing on externalizing migration control, offering Tunisia up to €1 billion to curb departures, sparking debates about human rights and the effectiveness of such measures.
Takeaways
- 🌍 The Mediterranean Sea is a dangerous crossing point for migrants, with thousands dying each year trying to reach Europe from North Africa.
- 🏛️ The European Union is struggling to control migration, leading to serious consequences and raising questions about the compatibility of border measures with Human Rights.
- 🏝️ Lampedusa, an Italian island, is a critical destination for migrants due to its proximity to Africa and has witnessed numerous overcrowded boat arrivals.
- 🚑 Since 2014, nearly 30,000 people have died or gone missing attempting to cross the Mediterranean.
- 🛂 Many migrants flee from war and political persecution, seeking asylum, but others escape poverty, which is not a legal basis for asylum in the EU.
- 🚨 Critics argue that the EU is not doing enough to protect refugees and migrants, with allegations of illegal pushbacks by Greek coastguards.
- 🚢 NGOs like Open Arms and Sea-Watch face legal challenges for rescuing migrants at sea and bringing them to European soil.
- 💵 Human trafficking and irregular migration to Europe is a lucrative business, with traffickers charging thousands of euros per person.
- 🇮🇹 In 2023, over 150,000 people arrived in Italy by sea, many through Lampedusa, a small island with only 6,000 residents, causing infrastructure strain and local discontent.
- 🛑 Right-wing politicians like Italy's Georgia Meloni have gained support with anti-immigration stances, using situations like Lampedusa's crisis to further their agendas.
- 🏗️ The EU has increased border walls and is considering externalizing asylum processing to countries outside its borders, raising concerns about human rights and EU values.
Q & A
What is the Mediterranean Sea's role in the context of the script?
-The Mediterranean Sea serves as a perilous migratory route where thousands of people attempt to cross from North Africa to Europe, leading to numerous deaths.
Why does the European Union struggle to control migration as mentioned in the script?
-The European Union faces challenges in controlling migration due to the complex nature of the issue, which includes humanitarian concerns, legal obligations, and political pressures.
What measures is Europe taking to address the migration crisis according to the script?
-Europe is erecting walls and barriers compatible with Human Rights, as claimed, to contain the crisis. Additionally, they are involved in rescue operations and facing legal challenges from NGOs involved in migrant rescues.
Why do people risk their lives to cross the Mediterranean to Europe?
-People risk their lives due to factors such as fleeing from wars, political persecution, or seeking better economic opportunities, despite not always having a legal basis for asylum in the European Union.
What is the significance of Lampedusa in the migration context?
-Lampedusa is an Italian island closer to Africa than the rest of Europe, making it a primary destination for the deadliest migration routes, with a high number of deaths and disappearances recorded since 2014.
How does the script describe the role of the Italian coast guard and other EU member states' coast guards?
-The script acknowledges that the EU and its member states' coast guards have saved many people in danger but also highlights criticism that they do not do enough to protect refugees and migrants.
What are the challenges faced by NGOs like Open Arms and Sea-Watch as mentioned in the script?
-These NGOs face legal issues with Italian justice for bringing migrants to European soil, despite operating under international treaties that commit the EU to protect refugees.
What is the impact of irregular immigration on Europe according to the script?
-Irregular immigration is a lucrative business for traffickers, who charge thousands of euros per person and put migrants' lives at risk with unseaworthy vessels.
How does the script portray the stance of Italy's Prime Minister, Georgia Meloni, on immigration?
-The script presents Georgia Meloni as an ultra-right leader who was elected largely due to her anti-immigration stance, using the chaos in Lampedusa to reinforce her message.
What is the EU's strategy to manage migration from countries like Tunisia and Turkey?
-The EU is focusing on externalizing migration control by offering financial packages to countries like Tunisia and Turkey to manage their borders and prevent migrants from reaching Europe.
What are the criticisms against the EU's approach to migration as depicted in the script?
-Critics argue that the EU's approach, including the construction of barriers and externalizing migration control, betrays its own values and does not effectively address the root causes of migration.
Outlines
🌊 Mediterranean Migration Crisis
The paragraph discusses the perilous Mediterranean Sea border, which has become the deadliest in the world, with thousands of people attempting to cross from North Africa to Europe each year, resulting in many deaths. The European Union's struggle to control migration is highlighted, with the Mediterranean becoming a graveyard for those seeking a better life. The paragraph raises questions about the effectiveness of border walls and barriers in managing the crisis while respecting human rights. It introduces the Italian island of Lampedusa, a paradoxical paradise for tourists and a deadly crossing point for migrants, and mentions the high number of deaths and disappearances since 2014. The reasons behind the dangerous journey, such as fleeing from war, political persecution, and poverty, are also explored, along with the legal complexities of seeking asylum in the EU.
🛑 Fortress Europe and Its Critics
This section delves into the European Union's efforts to control migration, including the rescue operations by EU coast guards and the criticism they face for not doing enough to protect refugees. It mentions the role of NGOs like Open Arms and Sea-Watch in maritime rescues and their legal battles with Italian authorities. The paragraph also discusses the political stance of figures like Georgia Meloni, who advocate for stricter immigration policies, and the increase in border walls within the EU. Critics argue that strengthening borders is not an effective solution to irregular migration, and the paragraph provides examples of Hungary's efforts to build a wall and the subsequent finding of alternative routes by migrants. The EU's strategy shift towards preventing departures from Tunisian shores is also mentioned, along with the controversial deal offering financial aid to Tunisia in exchange for stricter migration control.
🏛️ EU's Controversial Migration Policies
The final paragraph examines the European Union's controversial agreements with authoritarian leaders to stem the flow of migrants. It discusses the case of Tunisia, where with EU support, the country has increased its naval forces to intercept migrants, leading to thousands being detained under miserable conditions. The paragraph also touches on the EU's partnerships with other leaders, such as Turkey's Recep Tayyip Erdogan, who has used migrants as leverage for financial gain. The narrative criticizes the EU for compromising its values in its migration policies and agreements. It concludes by suggesting that long-term solutions to the migration crisis involve addressing the root causes of emigration in origin countries and better integrating migrants into European labor markets, which require political will and a holistic approach to migration policy.
Mindmap
Keywords
💡Mediterranean Sea
💡European Union (EU)
💡Migrant Crisis
💡Human Rights
💡Asylum
💡Smugglers
💡Frontex
💡Lampedusa
💡Populism
💡Migration Policy
💡Human Trafficking
Highlights
The Mediterranean Sea is a lethal border where thousands die each year trying to cross from North Africa to Europe.
The European Union struggles to control migration, leading to severe consequences.
Barriers and walls are being raised by Europe in a way that must be compatible with Human Rights.
Lampedusa, an Italian island, is a paradise for tourists but also a scene of overcrowded boats arriving from Africa.
Since 2014, nearly 30,000 people have died or disappeared trying to cross the Mediterranean.
Many migrants flee from wars and persecution but not all qualify for asylum in the European Union.
Others escape poverty, which is not a legal basis for asylum in the EU, leading many to risk their lives.
Judith Collenberg, an Austrian researcher, discusses the EU's asylum and migration policies.
Critics argue that the EU is not doing enough to protect refugees and migrants.
NGOs like Open Arms and Sea-Watch face legal challenges for rescuing migrants at sea.
In 2023, one million people applied for asylum in EU countries, but many have slim chances of success.
Human traffickers profit from irregular immigration to Europe, charging thousands per person.
In 2023, over 150,000 people arrived in Italy by sea, many through Lampedusa, a small island with only 6,000 inhabitants.
The influx of migrants to Lampedusa in September 2023 nearly collapsed the island's infrastructure.
Georgia Meloni, leader of the Italian far-right and Prime Minister, is known for her anti-immigration stance.
Meloni and other populist politicians base their agendas on anti-immigration policies.
The EU has increased border walls to prevent migrants from entering, with plans to build even more.
Experts argue that strengthening borders is not an effective method to prevent irregular migration.
Hungary built a wall along its border with Serbia to stop migrants, but they found other routes to the EU.
The EU is betting on a strategy to prevent illegal departures, mainly from Tunisia, a major point of embarkation for migrants.
The EU offered Tunisia up to 1 billion euros in investments to stop migration from its shores.
Human rights concerns arise as the EU collaborates with authoritarian leaders to control migration.
Critics say the EU's externalization of asylum policies and questionable agreements betray its values.
Experts propose that Europe should integrate migrants better into their labor markets to address the migration crisis.
Transcripts
es tranquilo pero también es la frontera
más letal del
mundo Este es el mar
Mediterráneo miles de personas mueren
aquí cada año intentando cruzar desde el
norte de África a
Europa mientras la Unión Europea
reivindica la gente se ahoga en las
costas europeas
[Música]
la Unión Europea no consigue controlar
la migración y los resultados tienen
graves consecuencias Qué se puede hacer
para contener una crisis como esta son
las vallas y barreras que Europa está
levantando compatibles con los Derechos
Humanos que dice defender Y quién se
beneficia de todo esto lo mostramos aquí
en dw geopolítica
[Risas]
Esta es la isla italiana de lampedusa
con playas paradisíacas para los
turistas pero también escenario de
imágenes como estas embarcaciones
abarrotadas que llegan de
[Música]
África lampedusa está más cerca del
continente africano que el resto de
Europa por lo que es el principal
destino de las rutas migratorias más
mortíferas del
[Música]
mundo desde 2014 casi 30,000 personas
han muerto o desaparecido intentando
cruzar el
Mediterráneo Por qué entonces hay tanta
gente intentando hacer esa
travesía muchos huyen de guerras y de
persecución política tienen derecho a
solicitar asilo pero primero tienen que
pisar suelo
europeo otros huyen de la pobreza sin
embargo esto no constituye una base
legal para solicitar asilo en la Unión
Europea en principio ninguno de estos
grupos suele tener posibilidades de
obtener un
entr Europa y eso Muchos optan arriesgar
sus vidas en tierra y en
[Música]
altamar sensible and serious man to and
TR to
prent of Die notou
Ella es la investigadora austríaca judit
collenberg experta en política de asilo
migración de la Unión Europea la Unión
Europea y los guardacostas de sus
estados miembros han salvado a muchas
personas en peligro pero los críticos
dicen que la Unión Europea no hace lo
suficiente para proteger a los
refugiados in migrantes incluso hay
denuncias de que guardacostas griegos
han expulsado ilegalmente a
embarcaciones de de aguas de la Unión
Europea otros actores involucrados son
las ong que rescatan a personas en
altamar como la española Open Arms o La
alemana seawatch estas afrontan
problemas con la justicia italiana por
llevar migrantes a suelo europeo y todo
esto Pese a que el bloque ha firmado
tratados internacionales que lo
compromete a proteger a los refugiados
solo en 2023 un millón de personas
solicitó asilo en países de la Unión
Europea pero muchos no tienen
posibilidades de conseguirlo y la
mayoría de los países del bloque
sostiene que llega demasiada
gente para los traficantes la
inmigración irregular hacia Europa es un
gran
negocio pueden cobrar miles de euros por
persona y asinan a migrantes en
embarcaciones precarias no aptas para
navegar en aguas abiertas
en 2023 solo a Italia llegaron más de
150,000 personas por
mar y estos son los cinco principales
países de
procedencia y como hemos visto muchos de
ellos entraron a Italia a través de
lampedusa
pero fíjense en lo pequeña que es esta
Isla tiene solo 6000
habitantes en septiembre de 2023 en solo
una semana lampedusa recibió una cifra
de migrantes dos veces superior a ese
número eso llevó la infraestructura de
La Isla al borde del
colapso y generó descontento entre los
residentes de lampedusa que viven
situaciones similares una y otra
vez lusa
[Aplausos]
diasta
sonos Esta es Georgia meloni la líder de
la ultraderecha Italiana y elegida
primera ministra en gran parte por su
postura anti
inmigración el caos de lampedusa es el
caldo de cultivo perfecto para su
mensaje en ogni caso se entrate
illegalmente Italia tratu ratri dat
mandato alla difesa di realizzare n
breve
ilon seici de
crisando unaer como muchos os políticos
populistas de la Unión Europea segú la
investigadora judit cenber
[Música]
meloni y varios más basan su agenda
política en eso
con incluso países de la Unión Europea
que acogieron a muchos refugiados se
están sumando a esta
petición en 2014 había pocos kilómetros
de vallas en las fronteras de la Unión
Europea Ahora hay seis veces más con el
objetivo de impedir entrar a los
migrantes y se proyecta construir aún
más
la mayoría de los expertos afirma que
reforzar las fronteras no es un método
efectivo para evitar la migración
[Música]
irregular hemos visto aquí
Canes muchos de los que huyeron de la
guerra en Siria utilizaban la ruta a
través de Turquía para llegar a la Unión
Europea pero en 2014 Hungría intentó
impedir el paso de personas por su
[Música]
territorio el Primer Ministro húngaro es
conocido por su retórica populista de
derecha
[Música]
Hungría comenzó a constru estaa a largo
de su frontera con Serbia en
[Música]
2015 pero los migrantes encontraron
otras vías para llegar a la Unión
Europea
[Música]
esto nos lleva de nuevo a lampedusa
ahora mismo uno de los principales
destinos para los
migrantes una valla obviamente no
funciona en aguas abiertas así que por
el momento la Unión Europea Apuesta por
otra
estrategia la si fermano le parten
illegali la mayoría de las embarcaciones
que llegan a lampedusa sale de Tunes a
unos 200 km
un país que Georgia meloni y la
presidenta de la comisión europea ursula
Von Der l visitaron en junio de
2023 y el equipo Europa quiere que Tunes
detenga la migración desde sus costas a
cambio ofrecieron al país africano un
paquete de hasta 1000 millones de euros
en inversiones incluidos unos 100
millones para seguridad fronteriza
[Música]
aast interest Breaking the cic Bus mod
of and
traff it is horrible to see how they
deliberately risk human lives for profit
so We Will work Together on an anti
smuggling operational partnership and We
Will Support tunisia with Border
management the objective is to have a
holistic approach to migration policy
roed in the respect for human
pero son precisamente los Derechos
Humanos los que hacen polémico este
acuerdo porque La Unión Europea hizo el
pacto con este hombre el presidente
tunesino no solo emplea la mano dura
contra la oposición sino que también
contra los
[Música]
migrantes principal grupo de derechos
humanos de tunz que supervisa la
situación de migrantes y
refugiados dice que con la ayuda del
bloque europeo Tunes reforzó sus fuerzas
de control naval y ha detenido a 800000
migrantes que se dirigían a Europa
[Música]
cientos de personas que querían hacer la
travesí fueron supuestamente enviadas A
las afueras de laad de y siguen vivendo
ahí en condiciones Miserables
[Música]
el bloque también se asoció con otros
líderes autoritarios para impedir la
llegada de
migrantes y además de recibir miles de
millones de euros estos líderes salieron
ganando de otra
[Música]
manera un ejemplo es Turquía un país con
el que el bloque ha cerrado su acuerdo
migratorio
importante desde 2016 Turquía ha
recibido hasta 9,000 millones de
euros básicamente para impedir la
entrada de migrantes y
refugiados y miren lo que pasó en 2020
Turquía reabrió su frontera con Grecia
para dejar que muchos migrantes se
dirigieran hacia la Unión Europea la
policía fronteriza griega empleó la
fuerza para frenar a las
multitudes se reportaron dos muertos y
miles de heridos
el presidente Turco reip tayb erdogan
había utilizado a los migrantes como
moneda de cambio para presionar a la
Unión Europea y obtener más
fondos la Unión Europea planea ahora
externalizar aún más la aplicación de la
ley con un nuevo pacto
migratorio por ejemplo con centros para
solicitantes de asilo en sus fronteras
exteriores los críticos dicen que ese
pacto es una traición a los valores de
la Unión Europea
y como vimos el bloque ya ha
comprometido sus propios valores con
políticas y acuerdos dudosos mientras
populistas traficantes de personas y
autócratas se
benefician y los expertos coinciden en
que ninguna de las medidas detendrá a
los migrantes que intentan llegar a
Europa huyendo de la miseria y Las
Guerras Incluso si eso significa poner
en riesgo sus vidas y qué alternativas
hay además de políticas para enfrentar
los problemas que causan la emigración
en los países de origen muchos expertos
Proponen que los países europeos hagan
esfuerzos para integrar mejor a los
migrantes en sus mercados laborales que
están necesitados de mano de obra son
opciones para solucionar la crisis
migratoria Eso sí de más a largo plazo y
para lo que es necesaria una buena
voluntad política
[Música]
Weitere ähnliche Videos ansehen
Why Anti-Migrant Pushback Laws are On the Rise in Europe
IOM:2023 could be the deadliest year for migrants crossing the Mediterranean
Understanding migration in Africa
What's behind the UK's deportation deal with Rwanda? | DW News
New Changes To All UK Visas: UK Immigration Fees, Dependent, Family, Work & Study Visas All Affected
Mediterranean migration routes
5.0 / 5 (0 votes)