Breaking News: George RR Martin Breaks His Silence On House of the Dragon Season 2 & Winds of Winter

Summary

Fans of 'A Song of Ice and Fire' and 'Game of Thrones' express disappointment over HBO's 'House of the Dragon' season 2, feeling it didn't meet expectations. Author George R. R. Martin is reportedly unsatisfied, hinting at a blog post detailing his concerns. The video speculates on potential issues, such as budget constraints and creative liberties, and discusses Martin's struggle between focusing on his novels or HBO's adaptations. The sponsor, displate, offers a discount on metal posters, providing a creative backdrop for fans' passion projects.

Takeaways

• 🔥 Fans of 'A Song of Ice and Fire' and 'Game of Thrones' are divided over the quality of HBO's 'House of the Dragon', with many considering the latest season underwhelming.
• 🐉 The finale of 'House of the Dragon' was satisfactory for some, but the series did not meet the high expectations set by HBO's previous drama series.
• 💸 There is a belief that the second season of 'House of the Dragon' could have had a better ending if the showrunners had been allocated more resources.
• 🎥 The production of key episodes like the Battle of the Gullet and the fall of King's Landing was hindered by budget constraints.
• 📉 HBO's reluctance to finance a full season of 'House of the Dragon' could lead to a repeat of the issues faced in the second season.
• 💬 Author George R. R. Martin has expressed dissatisfaction with the second season of 'House of the Dragon', hinting at a more detailed critique to come.
• 🖥️ The video features a sponsored segment for 'Displate', a company offering metal posters and装饰品 for walls.
• 📚 George R. R. Martin is struggling with the decision between focusing on his novels or the TV adaptations, which could impact the legacy of 'A Song of Ice and Fire'.
• 🤔 There is speculation about the extent of Martin's involvement in the show's development and whether his input could have improved the second season.
• 👀 The video creator anticipates Martin's forthcoming blog post, which may provide insight into the specific issues he has with 'House of the Dragon'.

Q & A

What is the general fan consensus on the second season of 'House of the Dragon'?

Many fans consider the second season of 'House of the Dragon' to be underwhelming, falling below the high standards expected from an HBO drama series.

What major events were fans expecting to see in the second season finale of 'House of the Dragon'?

Fans were expecting to see the Battle of the Gullet and the fall of King's Landing in the second season finale of 'House of the Dragon'.

What issues did the 'House of the Dragon' showrunners face during the second season?

The showrunners faced budget constraints which led to the inability to film the Battle of the Gullet and the fall of King's Landing, and it seems they might face similar issues in the upcoming season.

What has been the reaction of the author George R. R. Martin to the second season of 'House of the Dragon'?

George R. R. Martin has expressed dissatisfaction with the second season of 'House of the Dragon', indicating that he will share his thoughts in a blog post.

What is the current status of George R. R. Martin's involvement in the 'House of the Dragon' series?

George R. R. Martin is not actively involved in the writer's room for 'House of the Dragon', but he has been in communication with the showrunners and has given feedback on scripts and outlines.

What is the main dilemma George R. R. Martin is facing regarding his work on 'A Song of Ice and Fire' and the TV adaptations?

George R. R. Martin is wrestling with the idea of whether to focus on finishing the 'A Song of Ice and Fire' novels or to continue working with HBO on the TV adaptations.

What is the current sentiment of George R. R. Martin regarding the legacy he wants to leave behind?

George R. R. Martin is stressed about his legacy and is considering his impact on both his novels and the TV adaptations, expressing a desire for a lasting legacy similar to that of J.R.R. Tolkien.

What is the speculated reason for George R. R. Martin's lack of focus on finishing 'A Song of Ice and Fire'?

It is speculated that George R. R. Martin's involvement in multiple HBO projects and his desire to see his ideas come to life on screen are distracting him from focusing solely on completing the novels.

What is the fan expectation from George R. R. Martin's upcoming blog post about 'House of the Dragon'?

Fans are expecting George R. R. Martin to address specific issues with the second season of 'House of the Dragon', including his thoughts on character developments and storyline changes from the source material.

What is the current offer from 'Displate' mentioned in the script?

Displate is offering a discount on their metal posters, with 22% off on the first two displates or 30% off on three or more, as part of their sponsorship of the video.

Outlines

00:00

🔥 'House of the Dragon' Season 2 Critiques and Future Concerns

The first paragraph discusses the mixed reactions from 'A Song of Ice and Fire' and 'Game of Thrones' fans to HBO's 'House of the Dragon' season 2. It mentions that while the finale was satisfactory to some extent, the season did not meet the high expectations set by HBO dramas. The script suggests that a lack of resources could be a reason for the perceived shortcomings and that the showrunners' vision for the season finale, including the 'Battle of the Gallet' and the 'Fall of King's Landing,' was not fully realized due to budget constraints. The paragraph also hints at potential issues for the upcoming season, with the showrunner indicating that HBO may not be willing to finance a full season, which could impact the adaptation of significant events from 'Fire and Blood.' The author, George R. R. Martin, is also noted to be dissatisfied with the season, as he expressed at a recent convention and on his blog, potentially leading to a call for increased budget or an additional season to do justice to the source material.

05:02

📚 George R. R. Martin's Involvement and Dilemma with 'House of the Dragon'

The second paragraph delves into George R. R. Martin's involvement with 'House of the Dragon' and his personal dilemma. It is suggested that Martin's lack of constant presence in the writer's room might have affected the show's fidelity to the source material. While he was actively involved in the initial stages, his busy schedule and focus on other projects have limited his ongoing contribution. The paragraph also touches on Martin's struggle between ensuring a faithful adaptation of his work and concentrating on completing the 'A Song of Ice and Fire' book series. His recent statements at a convention and on his blog indicate a level of dissatisfaction with the show's direction and a contemplation of his legacy, hinting at the stress he feels about the unfinished novels and his desire for a lasting impact akin to J.R.R. Tolkien's.

10:02

🤔 Speculations on George R. R. Martin's Opinions on 'House of the Dragon' Season 2

The third paragraph speculates on George R. R. Martin's opinions about the second season of 'House of the Dragon,' particularly in light of his cryptic statements. It raises questions about his views on specific narrative choices and character developments in the season, such as the handling of Rhaenyra's visions, the readiness to surrender the city, and romantic subplots. The paragraph also discusses Martin's past silence on the ending of the original 'Game of Thrones' series, suggesting his dissatisfaction might extend to 'House of the Dragon.' The author expresses a desire for Martin to provide a detailed critique to help improve the show in the future, hoping for transparency in his feedback despite his ongoing relationship with HBO.

Keywords

💡House of the Dragon

House of the Dragon is a prequel television series to Game of Thrones, based on George R. R. Martin's A Song of Ice and Fire novels. The series is set approximately 200 years before the events of Game of Thrones and chronicles the history of House Targaryen. In the script, the show's second season is discussed, with fans expressing dissatisfaction with the season's finale and the showrunners' perceived lack of resources to deliver a satisfying conclusion.

💡A Song of Ice and Fire

A Song of Ice and Fire is a series of epic fantasy novels by American novelist and screenwriter George R. R. Martin. The series is known for its complex characters, political intrigue, and dramatic plot twists. The script discusses the fans' expectations from the television adaptations, such as House of the Dragon, and how they compare to the original source material.

💡Game of Thrones

Game of Thrones is an American fantasy drama television series created by David Benioff and D. B. Weiss for HBO, based on the A Song of Ice and Fire novels by George R. R. Martin. The script mentions the show as a point of comparison for House of the Dragon, highlighting the high standards set by the original series and the fans' disappointment with the prequel's second season.

💡Showrunners

In television, showrunners are the individuals who oversee all aspects of a TV series' production, including writing, directing, and editing. The script discusses the fans' belief that House of the Dragon's second season could have been better if the showrunners had been given more resources, implying that budget constraints may have affected the show's quality.

💡Battle of the Gallet

The Battle of the Gallet is a significant event in George R. R. Martin's Fire & Blood, a book set in the world of A Song of Ice and Fire. The script mentions that fans were expecting to see this battle in the second season of House of the Dragon, but it was not included, possibly due to budget or resource limitations.

💡HBO

HBO (Home Box Office) is an American premium television network owned by Warner Bros. Discovery. It is known for producing high-quality original programming, including Game of Thrones and House of the Dragon. The script discusses HBO's role in financing the series and the fans' concerns that the network may not be providing adequate funding for a faithful adaptation of the source material.

💡George R. R. Martin

George R. R. Martin is an American novelist and screenwriter, best known for his series A Song of Ice and Fire, which serves as the basis for the television series Game of Thrones and House of the Dragon. The script highlights Martin's dissatisfaction with the second season of House of the Dragon and his struggle to balance his work on the TV adaptations with completing his book series.

💡Fire and Blood

Fire & Blood is a historical fiction novel by George R. R. Martin, set in the world of A Song of Ice and Fire, focusing on the history of House Targaryen. The script refers to the book as a source of material that the showrunners of House of the Dragon were expected to adapt, with fans expressing concerns about the show's fidelity to the events and details presented in the book.

💡Winds of Winter

The Winds of Winter is the anticipated sixth novel in George R. R. Martin's A Song of Ice and Fire series. The script mentions Martin's struggle to complete the book amidst his involvement with the television adaptations, suggesting that his focus is divided between his literary and screenwriting responsibilities.

💡Legacy

In the context of the script, 'legacy' refers to the lasting impact or the body of work that an individual leaves behind, often after their death. The discussion about George R. R. Martin's legacy centers on his desire to complete his book series and the potential consequences for his reputation if he does not finish A Song of Ice and Fire, as fans and critics await the conclusion to the story.

Highlights

Fans are divided over the quality of HBO's 'House of the Dragon' season finale.

The showrunners believe the second season could have had a better ending with more resources.

The anticipated 'Battle of the Gallet' and the fall of King's Landing were not filmed due to budget constraints.

HBO may not finance a full season of 'House of the Dragon', indicating potential issues for future seasons.

Author George R. R. Martin expressed dissatisfaction with the second season of 'House of the Dragon'.

Martin is considering whether to focus on his novels or the TV adaptations, highlighting his dilemma.

The author is concerned about his legacy and the impact of the TV shows on his original work.

Martin's involvement in the writer's room is limited, affecting the adaptation's fidelity to the source material.

The show's creators have to balance Martin's input with their own creative freedom.

Martin is still working on 'The Winds of Winter' but is struggling to focus due to his involvement with HBO.

The author's health and age are factors in his ability to complete the 'A Song of Ice and Fire' series.

Martin has yet to comment on specific issues with 'House of the Dragon', leaving fans to speculate.

The video discusses the potential impact of HBO's budget decisions on the quality of 'House of the Dragon'.

The author's silence on the ending of 'Game of Thrones' suggests dissatisfaction with the show's direction.

The video concludes by urging HBO to address the issues raised by fans and the author for the upcoming season.

Transcripts

as you all know A Song of Ice and Fire

and Game of Thrones fans are divided

once again after HBO delivered what many

fans are considering an underwhelming

season of House of the Dragon although I

was mostly satisfied with House of the

dragon's finale the show obviously fell

below the high standards we expect to

see from a major drama series at HBO

every fan now knows House of the Dragon

second season would have had a much

better ending if only the showrunners

were given enough resources to deliver a

satisfying season finale now we all have

to wait until next season before we're

finally able to see the battle of the

gallet as you all know we should have

already seen the battle of the gallet as

well as the fall of Kings Landing at the

end of the second season House of the

Dragon showrunners were not able to film

those episodes because they were not

given enough money as of right now it

looks like House of the Dragon might

face some of the same issues they did

during the second season now the

showrunner has already said HBO no

longer wants to finance a full season

it's no secret they're going to need

either a bigger budget or an extra

season if they want to Faithfully adapt

all the major battles and Fire and Blood

we're going to need someone to step in

and fix this issue before it's too late

hopefully the executives will listen to

all the recent backlash regarding the

season finale I do believe if all of us

are loud enough they might actually wake

up and listen Game of Thrones and A Song

of Ice and Fire fans are not the only

ones who feel this way Author George R

Martin wasn't satisfied with House of

the Dragon second season either he's

actually said as much during a recent

convention in New Mexico as well as his

not a Blog website earlier this morning

this now makes the second time this this

week he said he will reveal his honest

thoughts about House of the Dragon now

before I get into everything that was

said I have to let all my Game of

Thrones fans know about this amazing new

offer I'd like to thank the sponsor of

today's video display now what do you

see when you look at your walls if

they're nothing but a bland empty space

this can end right now with display your

walls can become your own Multiverse a

gallery of passion creativity and

personality displayed offers metal

posters that look stunning and stay

stunning they're made from extra durable

steel and are designed to treat your

eyes with highly detailed vibrantly

colorful prints for decades to come it

only takes seconds to hang or swap their

posters with their magnet mounting

system so that your walls can evolve and

change with you it is toolfree safe for

your walls and super quick each display

comes with a magnet kit so that

everything you need is Right In The Box

there's no drilling holes and no

frustration as you all know every story

has its own twist and turns and this one

has no plot holes actually no holes at

all dis plates catalog has over 2

million artworks available you can

choose from new original art or

officially licensed designs there's

everything from high resolution photos

to abstract art and from official movie

posters to Pixel Perfect Game designs

it's everything you need to make your

walls reflect how you truly want to

express yourself on a Sleek piece of

metal and with this Plate's fast

delivery your new metal poster should

arrive in 45 business days that's just

enough time to plan how you want to

arrange them now displate is launching a

new product line called display Textra

and it's pushing the boundaries of what

metal posters can be display Textra

posters have TX stle textures and 3D

Contours and you can get them with

either a matte or gloss finish now if

you'd like to transform your walls and

try displayed for yourself go to the

discount Link in my description or go to

displate.com Thrones to get 22% off your

first two displates or 30% off three or

more you don't want to miss out on this

amazing offer once again I have to thank

displate for sponsoring today's video I

think most of us were already under the

assumption that George R Martin wasn't

happy with House of the Dragon second

season earlier this week he shared some

of his thoughts about House of the

Dragon during a small convention in New

Mexico unfortunately there is no audio

or video from the event all we have is a

description of what he said now

according to a fan who was there George

R Martin said House of the Dragon season

1 was great the second season however

was um I'm going to have to write a blog

about that later he said he was starting

to wonder if he was a fool for caring

about whether or not the show was good

or faithful to his Source material he

said lots of writers usually just sell

the TV rights and never think about it

again and are most likely happier than

he is meanwhile he hasn't been able to

forget about his shows he wants to see

them succeed he said he found himself in

a dilemma on one hand he does want to

fight for a faithful adaptation of his

story while on the other hand he

wrestles with the idea of giving up on

the show so he can focus on A Song of

Ice and Fire now although we don't know

exactly what was said at at the

convention he did confirm some of this

during his newest not a blog entry now

earlier this morning he said I do not

look forward to the other blogs I need

to write about everything that's gone

wrong with House of the Dragon but I

need to do that too and I will not today

though now maybe this is only me but it

sounds like he has a lot of issues with

the second season I think if it was

something minor he most likely would

have said it already what I really want

to know is will most of the blame fall

on the writers or HBO's lack of funding

what does he actually think affected the

season the most and could some of these

mistakes have been avoided if he was

there working with the writers every day

honestly I think his lack of focus is

making the shows and his novels suffer

he doesn't really help out that much

with House of the dragon and that's why

the show isn't a direct adaptation of

Fire and Blood as we all know he's not

always there in the writer's room to

make sure they're always following the

guideline now that's not to say he

doesn't help out at all he obviously

helped them a lot in the beginning when

they were getting the show off the

ground in fact Ryan Condell said as much

during one of his interviews at deadline

he did say George actually helped us a

lot in the very beginning back when we

had a small writer room before the show

was officially green lit generally it's

George and I in communication I sent him

everything I sent him outlines I sent

him scripts I sent him Cuts I sent him

text messages and I'll even ask him

things like why did you do this and what

does this mean he said he's very active

and reads a lot and gives a lot of

feedback other times he just sort of

defers and says go with the gods but as

as we all know he's a very busy guy it's

really hard for him to engage with us at

the pace that we would need him to to

weigh in on every single little decision

the show is moving fast but he always

knows what's going on that's the thing I

always wanted from the very beginning I

might not always do exactly the thing he

wants me to do but we will always talk

about it we're always going to have the

discussion and I've honored that so as

you can see George R Martin does not

live in the writer room with him as

they're making the outline for each

season they're only able to discuss

things with him mostly via email and

messages but that's not enough because

he doesn't help them with everything

obviously they are hired writers after

all he should not have to hold their

hands for everything you want the

screenwriter to feel he's free to make

it his own um and too many screenwriters

do make it their own even if they're

adapting Dickens or tolane or um

Shakespeare or whoever you want they

they decide to make it their own but

they never make it better because

usually the people who are making it

their own are simply not as good as the

people who wrote it in the first place

now with that being said the show does

suffer because he's not always there on

the other hand the Winds of winner also

suffers because he's not able to solely

focus on his writing when he's helping

HBO develop all these different shows

he's always working with HBO on some new

show even if he's not there with them in

the writer's room one day he might have

to decide if he wants to finish these

shows or if he wants to finish A Song of

Ice and Fire as of right now he's sort

of half-assing the show and his novel

because he doesn't actually f focus on

either one he basically said this

himself and that's why he's been

wrestling with the idea of Shifting his

Focus the website winter has coming

actually wrote an interesting article

about this very subject as I said before

some of the fans who were at the New

Mexico convention shared what they saw

and heard we might not have the audio or

video but we do have secondhand

information from the fans who were there

one of the fans who was there States

George said he was still working on the

Winds of Winter and that he was really

stressed out about it and thinking about

his legacy a lot he was very open and

honest about how the recent years have

been stressful and he is easily

distracted he is not finished with the

Winds of Winter but he is working on it

every day as always he is thinking a lot

about his legacy and whether to focus on

writing or the TV shows he said he

visited Jr artan's grave and he felt

emotional after seeing what all the fans

Left Behind he said he wants a legacy

like that he also went on to say his

novels are like his children but also

how the Game of Thrones shows are very

rewarding because you can see your ideas

come to life

it honestly makes me feel kind of sad to

know this is what's on his mind as we

all know he is roughly 75 years old and

although we all hate to say it he's not

in the best of shape unfortunately we

all know he's not going to be around

forever and he's reminded of this every

time one of his friends die even if I

never made another video I would still

love to see him finish his writing it's

no secret his legacy will suffer if he

doesn't finish A Song of Ice and Fire

and that's the last thing I want to see

happen I just don't think he's going to

be able to finish it himself the only

way I see him actually finishing A Song

of Ice and Fire is if he's able to

release the Winds of Winter within the

next three or four years as long as he's

still working on all these different

shows he's never going to be able to

focus on ending his story I am also

anxious to see what he has to say about

House of the Dragon like he said he

wants to go into everything that was

wrong with the second season we already

know he had some issues with the very

first episode after he shared his

thoughts on his website when he released

that na blog he had only seen the first

two episodes at that time although he

was vague he said the only thing about

the show that is drawing criticism is

the ending of the blood and chees

storyline he said he did like the ending

he thought it was a gut punch especially

for all the fans who have never read

Fire and Blood however all the fans who

did read Fire and Blood well there's a

lot to be said about that but this is

not the place for me to say it the

issues are too complicated somewhere

down the line I will do a separate blog

about all the issues raised by Blood and

cheese and mord the missing there's a

lot to say now that he has seen the

whole season I can only assume he had

more issues with the show as it went on

every fan wants to know how he feels

about Nettles is he upset over the fact

that Damon had were wood Visions does he

hate the fact that Allison is ready to

surrender the city was he a fan of the

make out session with rira and masara

it's really hard to say what he thinks

went wrong with the second season I do

hope he directly addresses all the

issues whether it be with the writers or

HBO I'm just not sure how much he will

say given the fact that he still has

working relationships with everyone

after all h HBO still hands him millions

of dollars to adapt his stories if he

does actually have an issue with the

company as a whole will he bite the hand

that feeds him I don't think he will

considering he has almost always been

vague before he still hasn't said much

about Dan and Dave or how they ended the

original series now maybe this isn't

fair to say but I have to assume he

hated the ending of Game of Thrones

given the fact that he wanted them to

make upwards of a dozen Seasons how you

doing why is it

ending uh I don't know ask David and Dan

when they come through

um we could have gone to 11 12 13

Seasons but uh they I guess they wanted

a life uh you wanted it to keep going

well it it you know if you've read my

novels you you know there was enough

material for for more seasons they made

certain Cuts I think his silence Alone

says a lot we usually know whenever he

loves the show or certain episodes

because he'll often share those thoughts

on his website when he is silent however

it leads me to believe he's not happy

but he doesn't want to say that because

of his relationship with HBO now I

actually like most of House of the

Dragon second season most of the issues

I have are with the final episode and I

know they can solve those if HBO gives

them a bigger budget for now I want to

wait until he gives his full breakdown

of the Season before I assume he's

either mad at House of the Dragons

writers or HBO's Executives as of right

now we can only speculate on what that

might be I just hope he's not vague with

his thoughts the only way they can fix

things before seon season 3 is if they

know exactly what is wrong I hope he

doesn't hold back because they're more

likely to listen to him before they

listen to any of us let me know what all

of you think down below what are some of

the issues you think he will address I

also want to thank displate again for

sponsoring the video Don't Forget Their

discount link is down below in my

description I definitely want to give

them another shout out because they've

certainly been a big help now that HBO

is copyright claiming all of my videos

once again I want to thank all of you

for watching another video there's a lot

more heading your way he I hope all of

you have a great day I will see you

again very soon bye