Don’t Use ChatGPT! Use This Instead

The video script discusses the limitations of Chat GPT for writing tasks, despite its popularity and the legal challenges faced by Open AI. The speaker, an experienced writer, criticizes the quality of writing produced by Chat GPT, describing it as overly flowery and melodramatic. They provide an example of a prompt given to Chat GPT and critique the resulting text. The video suggests alternatives to Chat GPT, highlighting Claude 3 for its responsiveness and ability to match writing styles, Gemini for brainstorming, and Novel Crafter for its tailored approach to fiction writing. The speaker also mentions the use of Dolly 3 for image generation and recommends other tools like Mid Journey, Leonard, and Idiogram as superior options. The summary emphasizes the need for better tools for creative writing and ideation, and provides insights into the strengths and weaknesses of various AI writing tools.

Takeaways

• 🚫 Don't use Chat GPT for writing, as it's not very good at it despite being well-known.
• 👍 Chat GPT is good at following directions and summarization, but has issues with writing quality.
• 📚 Skilled writers can easily identify text written by GPT due to its overly flowery and melodramatic style.
• 💡 Other AI tools like Claude and Gemini are better for creative ideation and brainstorming.
• 🖼️ Dolly 3 in Chat GPT is good for image generation, but has been surpassed by other tools like Mid Journey, Leonard, and Idiogram.
• 🚀 For edgier content, consider open source models like Mr. Large on Open Router, which offer less censorship.
• 🎉 Claude 3 is recommended for natural and human-sounding prose, and is highly responsive to style prompts.
• 📈 Gemini is good for brainstorming but not as effective for writing compared to Claude 3.
• 📚 Novel Crafter is a tool designed for fiction writers that can integrate various AI models for a tailored writing experience.
• 📝 Novel Crafter allows writers to input character details and scene beats to generate prose that matches the writer's style.
• ⚙️ Open Router is a platform where you can experiment with different open source models on a pay-as-you-go basis.

Q & A

Why does the author suggest not using Chat GPT for writing?

The author suggests not using Chat GPT for writing because it is not very good at it, even when provided with specific style prompts. The output tends to be overly flowery, melodramatic, and not up to the standards of skilled writers.

What are some redeemable qualities of Chat GPT mentioned in the transcript?

Chat GPT is good at following directions, summarization, and performing simple tasks. It has been instrumental in the creation of the channel and might improve in the future with new models from Open AI.

What is the issue with the writing style produced by Chat GPT?

The writing style produced by Chat GPT is often described as overly flowery, purple, and melodramatic. It uses too many adjectives and tends to be over the top, which is not typical of most novels or professional writing.

How does the author evaluate the effectiveness of AI writing tools?

The author evaluates AI writing tools based on their ability to follow style prompts, produce high-quality writing, and assist in creative ideation. They also consider the tool's responsiveness to user prompts and its ability to match the user's writing style.

What alternative tools are suggested for creative ideation?

The author suggests using tools like Claude and Gemini for creative ideation, as they are better at providing ideas and helping users get unstuck compared to Chat GPT.

How does the author compare Dolly 3 to other image-generating tools?

While Dolly 3 was impressive when first released, the author notes that it has been surpassed by other image-generating tools like Mid Journey, Leonard, and Idiogram, which offer better quality or provide free daily generations.

What are the advantages of using open source models for writing?

Open source models, such as Mr. Large, offer a comparable quality to Chat GPT but with less censorship, allowing for more edgy and graphic content. They are also cost-effective, with the possibility of paying only a few cents for a significant amount of writing.

How does Claude 3 differ from Chat GPT in terms of writing style?

Claude 3 produces writing that is less flowery and over the top compared to Chat GPT. It is more responsive to style prompts and can better match the user's writing style, making it a preferred choice for natural-sounding prose.

What is the primary function of Novel Crafter?

Novel Crafter is a tool designed to tailor the writing experience for fiction writers by allowing them to input detailed information about characters and scenes, which then helps the AI generate more consistent and stylistically matched prose.

How does the author describe the process of using Novel Crafter?

The author describes the process as involving inputting character details and scene beats into Novel Crafter, then selecting an AI model like Claude 3 to generate prose. The tool uses previous writing samples to match the user's style, resulting in higher quality output.

What are the author's final recommendations for writers looking for AI writing assistance?

The author recommends exploring alternatives to Chat GPT, such as Claude 3 for natural-sounding prose, open source models for less censorship, and Novel Crafter for a tailored writing experience, especially for fiction writers.

Outlines

00:00

📚 Limitations of Chat GPT for Writing

The speaker begins by expressing their appreciation for Chat GPT and its role in starting their channel. However, they argue that Chat GPT is not adept at writing, despite being a well-known AI writing tool. The speaker points out that even with detailed style prompts, Chat GPT's output remains overly flowery and melodramatic, which skilled writers can easily identify as AI-generated. They also mention that Chat GPT struggles with creative ideation, suggesting that other tools like Claude and Gemini are superior for this purpose.

05:00

🎨 Alternatives to Chat GPT for Creative Writing

The speaker discusses the limitations of Chat GPT for creative tasks and introduces alternatives. They mention that while Chat GPT can generate images with Dolly 3, there are better image-generating tools available. The speaker recommends trying open-source models through platforms like Open Router, highlighting Mr. Large as a reliable option with less censorship. They also praise Claude 3 for its natural and human-like prose and its responsiveness to style prompts, making it their preferred choice for writing tasks.

10:01

🚀 Tools for Tailored Writing Experiences

The speaker introduces Novel Crafter as a tool that can integrate various AI models to enhance the writing experience, particularly for fiction writers. They explain that Novel Crafter allows users to input detailed character information and scene beats, which the AI then uses to generate prose that matches the writer's style and the characters' unique traits. The speaker also compares Novel Crafter's capabilities with other models like Claude and Gemini, noting that while Gemini is good for brainstorming, it falls short in comparison to Claude 3 for writing tasks.

Keywords

Chat GPT

Chat GPT refers to a specific AI model developed by Open AI, known for its ability to generate human-like text based on given prompts. In the video, it is criticized for not being very good at writing tasks, despite being well-known and the subject of legal disputes.

AI Writing Tools

AI writing tools are software applications that utilize artificial intelligence to assist in the writing process, which can include tasks like content generation, summarization, and style adaptation. The video discusses the limitations of Chat GPT as an AI writing tool and suggests alternatives.

Summarization

Summarization is the process of condensing longer pieces of text into shorter, more manageable versions while retaining the key points. It is mentioned that Chat GPT is good at summarization, which is one of its redeemable qualities.

Style Prompt

A style prompt is a set of instructions given to an AI to guide the tone, voice, or specific elements that should be included in the generated text. The video argues that even with solid style prompts, Chat GPT's output often remains overly flowery and not much improved.

Urban Fantasy Novel

An urban fantasy novel is a genre of fiction that features magical or supernatural elements set against a contemporary, urban backdrop. The video uses the example of writing an opening scene for an urban fantasy novel to illustrate the shortcomings of Chat GPT.

Creative Ideation

Creative ideation involves the generation of new ideas or concepts, often required in the early stages of writing. The video suggests that other tools like Claude and Gemini are superior to Chat GPT for assisting with creative ideation.

Dolly 3

Dolly 3 is an AI-driven image generation tool that can be integrated with Chat GPT to create visual content. While initially impressive, the video states that other image-generating services like Mid Journey, Leonard, and Idiogram have surpassed Dolly 3.

Open Router

Open Router is a platform where users can access and experiment with various open-source AI models on a pay-as-you-go basis. It is highlighted as a place to explore alternatives to Chat GPT, particularly for those seeking less censorship in their writing.

Claude 3

Claude 3 is an AI model that is part of the Claude family, known for producing more natural and human-sounding prose compared to Chat GPT. The video praises Claude 3 for its responsiveness to style prompts and its ability to match writing styles effectively.

Gemini

Gemini is another AI model mentioned in the video, which, while good for brainstorming, does not perform as well as Claude 3 in terms of writing quality. It is part of the Gemini family of models and offers a different approach to AI writing assistance.

Novel Crafter

Novel Crafter is a tool designed to assist fiction writers by integrating various AI models and providing a platform to input character details and scene beats. It is lauded for its ability to tailor the writing experience and generate prose that matches the writer's style and the unique characteristics of the characters.

Highlights

The author recommends not using Chat GPT for writing due to its limitations.

Chat GPT is praised for its ability to follow directions and perform simple tasks.

Despite its popularity, Chat GPT's writing quality is criticized as being overly dramatic and not suitable for professional writing.

The author has 14 books to their name and identifies AI-written text easily.

An example of Chat GPT's writing is provided, illustrating its melodramatic style.

Chat GPT is said to struggle with creative ideation and providing unique ideas.

Other tools like Claude and Gemini are suggested as better for creative ideation.

Dolly 3's image generation capabilities are noted, but other tools like Mid Journey are considered superior.

The author suggests that there's no strong reason to use Chat GPT over other alternatives.

Open source models on platforms like Open Router are recommended for less censorship.

MRAL Large is highlighted as a reliable open source model with less censorship.

Claude 3 is praised for its natural sounding prose and responsiveness to style prompts.

Gemini and Gemini Advance are mentioned, with a note that they are good for brainstorming but not as effective for writing as Claude 3.

Novel Crafter is introduced as a tool that can integrate various AI models to enhance writing for fiction and non-fiction.

Novel Crafter is particularly good at utilizing character information to create distinctive dialogue.

The author provides a demonstration of Novel Crafter's capabilities using the Claude 3 model.

A video on 'Novel Crafter 101' is promised for those interested in learning more about the tool.