Ancient Rome Expert Answers Roman Empire Questions From Twitter | Tech Support | WIRED

WIRED
28 Nov 202320:26

Summary

TLDRIn this informative video, Professor Lauren Ginsberg debunks myths and answers internet queries about Ancient Rome. She discusses the ceremonial use of togas, the practicality of Roman clothing, and the innovative use of urine for cleaning. She clarifies misconceptions about 'vomitorium' as exit pathways, reveals snacking habits in the Colosseum, and delves into the durability of Roman concrete. The professor also touches on gladiators' battles with lions, the Romans' advanced surgical tools, and the vibrant colors of their statues and buildings. She addresses the social aspects of Roman life, including public toilets, children's toys, and the rights of women, concluding with the complexities of defining Roman emperors and the pantheon of gods they worshipped.

Takeaways

  • 👘 The average Roman did not wear a toga daily; it was a ceremonial garment due to its complexity and length.
  • 🧼 Romans washed clothes in urine which breaks down into ammonia, a common ingredient in modern cleaners, for its cleaning properties.
  • 🏟️ The term 'vomitorium' in ancient Rome referred to large stairways for quick evacuation of large venues, not places for vomiting after overeating.
  • 🍇 Romans snacked on nuts, fruits, and grilled meat during events at the Colosseum, as discovered from residues found in the sewers.
  • 🏛 Ancient Roman concrete has superior qualities, including rapid hardening and self-healing properties, due to the use of quick lime and lime clasts.
  • 🦁 Gladiators fought lions in the Colosseum, but many survived and retired, indicating fights were often choreographed rather than deadly.
  • ⚕️ Romans invented and used surgical tools that are strikingly similar to those used today, demonstrating their advanced medical practices.
  • 🍷 Roman bars, or 'tabernae', were social hubs where people could get food and drink, much like modern neighborhood bars.
  • 🎨 Greek and Roman statues were originally painted with vibrant colors, contrary to the pristine white marble appearance often associated with them.
  • 🛏️ Roman sexual behavior was diverse and open, with access to contraception and a wide range of sexual expressions.
  • 🤴 There is no definitive 'best' Roman emperor, as the concept of a fair ruler in the context of an autocratic empire is subjective and complex.

Q & A

  • Why did Romans wear togas and when were they typically worn?

    -Romans wore togas as a ceremonial gown, and it was not common for the average Roman to wear a toga in everyday life due to its length and complexity. The toga was recognized as a symbol of status and was worn during formal and religious occasions.

  • What was the basic Roman garment worn by people of any status?

    -The basic Roman garment was the tunic or tunica, which was essentially a long T-shirt worn by individuals of any status, male or female.

  • Did Romans really wash their clothes in urine and why was it effective?

    -Yes, Romans washed their clothes in urine because it breaks down into ammonia over time, which is a caustic substance that cleans effectively. The process involved soaking clothes in concentrated urine and then washing them with clean water in multiple vats.

  • What is the true meaning of 'vomitorium' in Ancient Rome and how is it misunderstood today?

    -The term 'vomitorium' comes from the Latin word 'vomit' meaning 'to send forth' and referred to large stairways designed to quickly disperse crowds from stadiums and theaters. It is often mistakenly believed to be a place for Romans to vomit after overeating.

  • What snacks did the Romans consume in the Colosseum based on recent archaeological findings?

    -Archaeological excavations in the Colosseum's drainage system revealed that Romans snacked on nuts, fruits like figs, peaches, and grapes, and also grilled meat on portable grills or braziers during events.

  • Why does ancient Roman concrete outperform modern concrete and what is the secret behind it?

    -Ancient Roman concrete contains lime clasts that are believed to be a result of using quick lime, which superheats the chemical process of concrete hardening and allows it to be self-healing to some extent. This contributes to its durability and resistance to stress.

  • Did gladiators in Ancient Rome really fight lions and how often did they die in these encounters?

    -Yes, gladiators fought lions in the Colosseum, but the frequency of their deaths was not as high as one might think. Many gladiators had successful careers, winning multiple competitions, and deaths were often prearranged.

  • What surgical tools did the Romans invent that are still in use today?

    -Romans did not invent but perfected surgical tools such as scalpels, tweezers, and forceps, which are still used in modern medicine with similar designs and materials.

  • Did Ancient Romans have bars and what were they like?

    -Ancient Romans had bars called tavernas where people could get drinks and food. Excavations in Pompeii revealed that these bars were social hubs in neighborhoods, similar to modern neighborhood bars.

  • Were Greek and Roman statues actually painted as suggested by recent findings?

    -Yes, Greek and Roman statues were painted with vibrant colors and patterns. The Romans were skilled painters and would have found plain white marble statues and buildings to be boring.

  • What misconceptions exist about the sexual behavior in Ancient Rome and how did Romans view sex?

    -Romans had a diverse and open sexual culture with sex happening both inside and outside of marriage for pleasure and procreation. They had access to contraception and had a spectrum of sexual behaviors and interests, contrary to the misconception of Ancient Rome being a 'sexual free for all'.

  • How did the Romans produce their coins and what materials were used?

    -Roman coins were produced through a hand stamping process using molds for the coin's design and metal discs for the base material. The images on both sides of the coin were imprinted by striking the mold with a hammer.

  • What were the leisure activities of Ancient Romans and did they have holidays?

    -Ancient Romans enjoyed leisure time at the coast, especially in the Bay of Naples, and had seaside villas for extended spa-like vacations. Additionally, they celebrated over 100 public holidays featuring various entertainment spectacles like gladiatorial matches and theatrical performances.

  • What can be inferred about the daily life of an average Roman citizen?

    -The daily life of an average Roman involved work in various trades such as shoemaking or sewing, living in rented spaces above their shops, and dealing with common issues like poor maintenance and noisy neighbors.

  • What is the significance of the hemp plant in Ancient Rome and did they use it for recreational purposes?

    -Hemp, known as cannabis in Latin, was valued by Romans for its utility in making ropes and other products. There is no evidence that Romans smoked it or recognized its psychoactive properties for recreational use.

  • Why is there a discrepancy in the number of Roman emperors recorded by historians?

    -The difficulty in counting Roman emperors arises from the empire's size, the presence of multiple claimants backed by armies, usurpers, and the lack of clear rules for declaring an emperor. Sometimes, the only evidence of a claimant's reign is a single coin.

  • How did Romans view their pantheon of gods and what was unique about their religious beliefs?

    -Romans believed in a vast array of gods and divine beings associated with various natural phenomena and aspects of life. They saw the divine in many places and sought to connect with it through religious practices, unlike the specific count of gods in other cultures.

  • What is the historical validity of the story of Romulus and Remus, the founders of Rome?

    -Romulus and Remus are legendary figures with a story that includes being nursed by a she-wolf, overthrowing an evil king, and founding Rome. However, even Romans were skeptical about the factual basis of this story, viewing it more as a myth similar to other cultural legends.

Outlines

00:00

👩‍🏫 Professor Lauren Ginsberg on Ancient Roman Life

Professor Lauren Ginsberg introduces herself as a professor of Ancient Rome and the host of 'Ancient Rome Support'. She addresses various misconceptions about Roman life, such as the common use of togas, which were actually ceremonial garments, and the everyday attire of Romans, which was the tunica or tunic. She also discusses the practice of washing clothes in urine due to its ammonia content, the true meaning of 'vomitorium' as large stairways for quick evacuation from stadiums, and the types of snacks consumed in the Colosseum. Additionally, she explains the misconceptions about Roman concrete's durability and the myth of gladiators always fighting to the death.

05:00

🗡 Gladiators and the Roman Way of Life

The script delves into the reality of gladiatorial combat, explaining that while gladiators did fight lions, many survived numerous battles and could retire to train others. It also touches on the invention of surgical tools by the Romans, the prevalence of bars called 'tabernae' in Ancient Rome, and the vibrant colors of Roman statues and buildings. The discussion continues with the sexual mores of Romans, their access to contraception, and the variety of sexual behaviors. It also addresses the question of the 'best' Roman emperor, highlighting the autocratic nature of the empire and the difficulty in objectively determining a 'good' ruler.

10:01

🚽 Roman Hygiene and Public Facilities

This section focuses on the advanced water technologies of Ancient Rome, including aqueducts, sewer systems, and public bathing facilities. It discusses the regular use of baths by Romans across social classes and the existence of public toilets. However, it also points out the limitations of Roman hygiene practices, such as the use of communal sponges, which could spread diseases like dysentery. The paragraph also explores the types of toys Roman children played with, the average lifespan of a Roman peasant, and the evidence of a purpose-built brothel in Pompeii.

15:02

🧶 Roman Fashion and Currency Production

The script describes how Romans adapted to winter weather by layering their clothing, utilizing wool for warmth, and wearing thick socks and leather shoes. It also explains the process of Roman coin production, which involved hand-stamping metal discs with molds to create images on both sides of the coin. Additionally, it covers the leisure activities of Romans, such as visiting the coast for extended holidays and participating in public festivals that featured various entertainments.

20:02

🏛 Daily Life and Mythology in Ancient Rome

This part of the script discusses the daily life of average Romans, who worked in various trades and often lived in rented spaces above their workplaces. It also touches on the topic of civil wars within the Roman Empire and the challenges in defining and counting them. The script addresses the question of the number of Roman emperors, the diversity of gods worshipped in Roman religion, and the legendary story of Romulus and Remus, the founders of Rome, which is considered more of a myth than a historical fact.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡Toga

A toga is a type of ancient Roman garment that was long and complex to wear, typically associated with ceremonial occasions. In the video, it is mentioned that the average Roman did not wear a toga on a daily basis due to its impracticality for regular activities, and it was more of a symbol of status and formality.

💡Tunica

The tunica, or tunic, was the basic Roman garment worn by individuals of any status, male or female. It is described as essentially a long T-shirt, indicating its simplicity and ubiquity in everyday Roman life. The script mentions it as the common attire that was worn by people who are depicted in contrast to those wearing togas.

💡Fullonica

A fullonica was an ancient Roman laundromat where clothes were washed using urine, which breaks down into ammonia, an effective cleaning agent. The script explains the process of Roman laundry, emphasizing the use of concentrated urine as part of the cleaning process before rinsing with clean water.

💡Vomitorium

In the video, vomitorium is clarified as a term often misunderstood. It actually refers to large stairways in ancient Roman structures like stadiums and amphitheaters, designed to quickly disperse crowds. The script dispels the myth that it was a place for Romans to vomit after overeating, instead highlighting its architectural purpose.

💡Concrete

Roman concrete is highlighted in the script for its durability and advanced properties compared to modern concrete. It is noted that Roman concrete could harden quickly, even underwater, and had self-healing properties. The script mentions recent research by MIT scientists that suggests the presence of lime clasts in Roman concrete, which contribute to these characteristics.

💡Gladiator

Gladiators are depicted in the script as fighters in ancient Roman arenas, known for combats against animals like lions. The video explains that while gladiatorial fights could be deadly, many gladiators survived numerous fights and could retire, indicating that outcomes were sometimes prearranged.

💡Surgical Tools

The script mentions that the Romans invented and used surgical tools that are still recognizable today, such as scalpels, tweezers, and forceps. These tools were made of similar types of metal as those used in modern medicine, showcasing the Romans' contribution to medical practices.

💡Taberna

A taberna was a type of bar in ancient Rome where people could get drinks and food. The script describes these establishments as social hubs in working-class neighborhoods, similar to neighborhood bars today, and as places where food like stews was served.

💡Painted Statues

Contrary to the common perception of white marble statues, the script reveals that Greek and Roman statues were actually painted with vibrant colors. This reflects the Romans' appreciation for vibrancy and their skill in painting, which was applied to both statues and buildings.

💡Sexual Behavior

The script discusses the diverse sexual behaviors in ancient Rome, emphasizing that Romans had a healthy sex life that included sex for both procreation and pleasure. It mentions that Romans had access to contraception and that sexual acts and desires were openly represented in art and literature.

💡Aqueducts

Roman aqueducts are mentioned as part of the advanced water technology in ancient Rome, which brought clean water across vast distances. The script highlights the Romans' sophisticated systems for water management, including aqueducts and sewers, which contributed to public hygiene and the functioning of public baths.

Highlights

Romans wore togas as ceremonial gowns, not for everyday wear due to their complexity.

The basic Roman garment was the tunica, similar to a long T-shirt, worn by all social statuses.

Romans washed clothes in urine, which breaks down into ammonia, an effective cleaning agent.

Vomitorium in Ancient Rome were large stairways for crowd dispersal, not places for vomiting after feasts.

Excavations in the Colosseum revealed nuts, fruits, and portable grills as popular snacks.

Ancient Roman concrete contains lime clasts that contribute to its self-healing properties.

Gladiators fought lions, but many survived and retired, contrary to the common belief of high mortality.

Roman surgical tools were advanced and similar to those used today in medical procedures.

Ancient Roman bars, or tavernas, were social hubs similar to modern neighborhood bars.

Greek and Roman statues were painted with vibrant colors, contrary to the common perception of plain marble.

Romans had a diverse sexual culture with various sexual behaviors and interests.

Roman emperors were autocrats, and their effectiveness and goodness are subjective and context-dependent.

Romans had advanced water technologies including aqueducts, sewer systems, and public bathing facilities.

Roman children played with articulated dolls, dice games, walking toys, and building blocks.

The average lifespan of a Roman was lower due to high infant and child mortality, but many lived into their mid-50s.

Archaeologists can identify brothels through the presence of tiny stalls and explicit graffiti.

Roman women had significant rights including property ownership and the ability to run businesses.

Determining the number of Roman civil wars is complex due to varying definitions and historical contexts.

Romans wore woolen socks, thick leather shoes, and cloaks for warmth during winter.

Roman coins were made by hand using a stamping process with molds for each side of the coin.

Romans engaged in leisure activities such as visiting the coast and participating in public holidays and festivals.

Daily life in Ancient Rome involved work, rent payment, and dealing with landlords similar to modern times.

Romans used hemp for its practical uses like making ropes, but there's no evidence of recreational use.

The number of Roman emperors is disputed due to various claimants and usurpers throughout history.

Ancient Romans worshipped a vast number of gods, seeing divinity in many aspects of life.

Romulus and Remus are legendary figures with a story that even Romans were skeptical about.

Transcripts

play00:00

- I'm Lauren Ginsberg, professor of Ancient Rome,

play00:02

and I'm here to answer your questions from the internet.

play00:04

This is Ancient Rome Support.

play00:06

[upbeat music]

play00:11

@Abe_Eagle, why did Romans wear togas?

play00:14

The average Roman did not go out of their house

play00:16

hanging out in a toga because togas were extremely long,

play00:20

extremely complicated gowns to put together.

play00:23

So even extremely elite Roman citizens recognize the toga

play00:26

as a ceremonial gown.

play00:27

I like this image because we have all these people

play00:29

who are wearing things that are decidedly not togas.

play00:32

What they're wearing is the basic Roman garment

play00:35

that any one of any status,

play00:36

male or female would wear,

play00:37

which is what's called the tunic or the tunica.

play00:40

And this is essentially a long T-shirt.

play00:43

@C450hs, did the Romans really wash their clothes in urine?

play00:48

Yes, and essentially, so do we.

play00:50

So if you look at any of your household cleaners,

play00:53

you will see that one of the highest ingredients

play00:55

generally is ammonia.

play00:57

It's very caustic, so it's not always very good

play00:59

for your things, but it cleans extremely effectively

play01:01

and so the Romans were able to recognize

play01:03

that urine when stored for quite some time,

play01:06

tends to break down into ammonia.

play01:09

So when you would bring your clothes to a fullonica,

play01:12

so this is a laundromat essentially in the ancient world.

play01:14

First thing was it would go into a vat

play01:16

in which highly concentrated urine would be poured

play01:19

and you would let it sit there.

play01:20

Then the clothes would be washed with clean flowing water

play01:23

in three to four separate vats,

play01:25

until the end, it was basically perfectly clean

play01:28

and it could be line dried.

play01:29

FinnHuckster, did the Romans really have vomitorium?

play01:32

Yes, but not in the way that you mean.

play01:35

It is true that if you look at some urban plans in Rome,

play01:38

stadium buildings, amphitheaters, theaters,

play01:41

places where tens of thousands of people would come,

play01:43

you'll often find the word vomitorium that's written there

play01:46

and somehow a myth has been created

play01:48

that this is where decadent Romans would go

play01:50

after they ate too much food

play01:52

and they would purge themselves.

play01:53

This is not what those words mean.

play01:55

It comes from the Latin word vomo,

play01:57

vomere, which basically means to send forth

play02:00

and so yes, on the one hand send forth your food,

play02:03

but on the other, it can mean to send forth people.

play02:05

So what these were were actually large, large stairways

play02:08

to get lots of people out of a stadium very quickly.

play02:11

So we actually still use the exact same technology

play02:14

that Romans called vomitorium.

play02:15

We just don't call them vomitorium

play02:17

and I for one, think maybe we should.

play02:19

@NotlandLEW, man, they didn't even have popcorn

play02:22

back in Ancient Rome, true story.

play02:24

What did they snack on in the Colosseum?

play02:26

This made headlines last summer

play02:27

because they've actually started to do excavations

play02:30

in the drainage system of the Colosseum and in the sewers,

play02:33

'cause if you think about it,

play02:34

if you go to a rock concert today,

play02:36

you can see everything sticky on the floor.

play02:38

People throw their food all over the place.

play02:39

Where does that go?

play02:40

In Ancient Rome, it would go down into the drains

play02:42

and it would go down into the sewers

play02:44

and that means that things that can survive

play02:45

for those millennia, we can be able to tell

play02:47

that those were the kind of foods that were snacked on.

play02:49

All sorts of varieties of nuts

play02:51

and residues of nuts have been found in these sewers.

play02:53

Fruits, for example, figs and peaches

play02:55

and other fruits, grapes that were easy to carry.

play02:58

Also, what they discovered was that people seemed to bring

play03:01

or at least have access to small portable grills,

play03:05

sort of like tailgating grills, little braziers

play03:07

where they could grill meat at the time

play03:09

as you watched people fight to the death and animals die.

play03:12

@Juadog, why does concrete from ancient Rome stand up better

play03:16

than modern concrete?

play03:17

If we look at this dome in the pantheon of Rome,

play03:20

it looks pretty spectacular today.

play03:22

If we consider that this dome is made of concrete

play03:25

and we think of a bridge

play03:27

that might have been built into your city in the 1970s,

play03:29

these two things do not look the same.

play03:31

So just this past summer, a team of civil engineers from MIT

play03:34

set out to figure out what this was,

play03:36

and they think that they have an answer.

play03:38

If you look at Roman concrete,

play03:39

you can see in the matrix these chunks of white material.

play03:43

So this group of MIT scientists figured out

play03:46

that these white chunks called lime class were deliberate

play03:49

and were also proof

play03:51

that the Romans used something called quick lime,

play03:54

as opposed to lime that had been premixed with water,

play03:57

which had always been the assumption

play03:59

and the quick lime superheats the chemical process

play04:02

as it makes concrete

play04:03

and so one of the things we've always known

play04:05

about Roman concrete is that it can harden really quickly,

play04:08

including underwater.

play04:09

Also, the other property that they were able to recreate

play04:12

in the lab was that Roman concrete can be self-healing

play04:15

to a certain amount.

play04:16

So if you put modern concrete

play04:17

and roman concrete in a stress environment

play04:19

so that the concrete cracks,

play04:21

Roman concrete can actually heal that cracks

play04:24

and the key that they think they found

play04:26

is that these lime clasts, these calcifisised white chunks,

play04:30

would be able to immediately distribute material

play04:33

to those cracks and help with the self-healing properties.

play04:35

It is much more expensive to make concrete this way,

play04:37

so I'm not actually sure that we're about to have

play04:39

a Roman concrete revolution,

play04:41

but it is pretty cool that these scientists

play04:42

think they've recreated what the secret

play04:44

of Roman concrete is.

play04:45

@Dylansfault, did those gladiators really fight lions?

play04:49

How often did they die?

play04:50

Absolutely, gladiators really fought lions.

play04:53

It's not even like they would just be released

play04:55

from a gate and everyone could tell.

play04:56

An architectural investigation has shown the technology

play05:00

through which lions below the surface of the floor

play05:02

of the Colosseum would able to be launched into the air

play05:05

to suddenly appear.

play05:07

But the question about how often did they die,

play05:09

we have tombstones that show gladiators who have won

play05:12

50 different competitions in their life.

play05:14

Evidence of gladiators who retire from being a gladiator

play05:17

and train other gladiators

play05:19

and so it wouldn't really make sense if every time

play05:21

they went into the arena there was a 50/50 shot

play05:23

that they weren't going to walk out.

play05:25

Instead, what we see mostly when it's human versus human,

play05:28

gladiator versus gladiator is a heavily stage managed,

play05:32

choreographed fight that's designed

play05:33

to be extremely exciting for the audience.

play05:35

That doesn't mean that they weren't sometimes killed.

play05:38

We do also have evidence that gladiators could be killed,

play05:40

but that would've been agreed upon in advance

play05:43

by whoever was running the games

play05:45

and whoever had nominal control over the gladiator's life.

play05:47

We have Getgators.

play05:49

What did the Romans invent that we still use today?

play05:53

One thing we wanna poke at is this word invention,

play05:55

because the Romans sort of took things that existed,

play05:57

concrete is a good example and perfected it.

play06:00

But the example I think of immediately

play06:02

is actually surgical tools, scalpels, tweezers, forceps.

play06:06

But the actual basic tools, if you looked on say the set

play06:09

of "Grey's Anatomy" or some medical show

play06:11

would look extremely similar

play06:12

to what the Romans were using in the past

play06:14

and they would be made out of similar types of metal.

play06:16

From ThisIsNiko, did they have bars in Ancient Rome

play06:19

or did wine just flow freely down the streets?

play06:21

Unfortunately, no, but they did have bars

play06:24

and they had bars all over the place.

play06:26

So these were often called taverna

play06:28

and these would be bars where you could get drink,

play06:30

but you could also get food

play06:32

and this is a great example.

play06:33

So this comes from some recent excavations in Pompeii,

play06:36

in an area that were just open to the public.

play06:38

And what you can see here is a big counter.

play06:40

So you can imagine someone behind here

play06:42

actually serving alcohol, but those big jars

play06:44

that you see would also have food.

play06:46

So stews, rich, hot items that people would either get

play06:50

to have as their primary meal of the day in the bar,

play06:53

or that they would then take home

play06:55

where they could heat it up simply.

play06:56

So these bars show up so often

play06:59

in these working class neighborhoods of Pompeii

play07:01

and the analogy I like to use is they show up as often

play07:04

as a Dunkin Donuts does in the city of Boston.

play07:06

And the graffiti that we found on them

play07:08

shows that they're really a social hub of the neighborhood.

play07:10

It's likely that you would just go to the pub on the corner

play07:12

much the way we think of neighborhood bars today.

play07:14

From Atepsflame, come on, I suppose next

play07:17

you're gonna tell me that all those Greek

play07:19

and Roman statues were actually gaudily painted?

play07:21

Yes, I'm here to tell you that all of those Greek

play07:24

and Roman statues were painted,

play07:25

but I object to the term gaudily.

play07:27

When people think about what it was like

play07:28

to walk around the streets of Ancient Rome,

play07:30

they think about these things that are here.

play07:32

Bright white marble, marble buildings, marble statues.

play07:36

The Romans would've found

play07:37

all of this white marble extremely boring.

play07:40

They loved vibrancy and they were also world-class painters.

play07:44

There was a fantastic exhibit last summer

play07:46

at the Metropolitan Museum of Art

play07:48

that actually featured a number of recreated statues

play07:51

in which scientists had very carefully taken tiny bits

play07:54

of pigment on statues, so you could see that say a statue

play07:58

of someone like Nero here,

play08:00

each layer of clothing would be painted with shades,

play08:02

with texture, with patterns

play08:04

and the same thing is true with Roman buildings.

play08:06

Rome was a wash of color.

play08:08

Nevadaknight67, was Ancient Rome really

play08:11

a sexual free for all?

play08:13

So here's the thing, Romans had a very healthy sex life.

play08:16

Romans had sex inside

play08:17

and outside the institution of marriage.

play08:20

Romans had sex for procreation, yes, but also for pleasure.

play08:23

Romans had access to contraception.

play08:25

Romans, especially Roman women,

play08:27

would rise up when they thought that those rights

play08:30

were being curtailed.

play08:31

Romans have pictures and works of art

play08:34

and literary texts that talk about sexual desire,

play08:38

that talk about sex acts,

play08:40

that talk about their favorite positions.

play08:41

Short, it's women on top

play08:43

is the thing that they seem to like a lot.

play08:44

Men have sex with women, men have sex with men,

play08:46

women have sex with women, women have sex with men,

play08:49

and so much like today, it was really a spectrum

play08:52

of sexual behavior, sexual performance,

play08:55

sexual interest.

play08:56

From thekinocorner, which Roman emperor

play08:58

was objectively the best?

play09:00

The Roman Empire was an autocracy,

play09:02

which means that all Roman emperors were autocrats.

play09:04

And it means, I don't actually think any of them

play09:06

were very good people.

play09:07

I think in general that form of government

play09:09

doesn't lead to people doing good things.

play09:11

So I'm gonna take a couple of examples

play09:13

of good and bad emperors.

play09:14

We have a friend Nero here

play09:16

who everyone probably agrees,

play09:17

the worst of the worst emperors.

play09:19

And then we have everyone's favorite emperor

play09:21

on the internet, Marcus Aurelius.

play09:23

He wrote this nice book of stoic philosophy,

play09:25

and so people think he's extremely chill

play09:28

and thus under his empire,

play09:29

things must have gone particularly well.

play09:31

But let's ask this question objectively,

play09:33

the best for whom and was he objectively the best

play09:36

for the substantial population of the Roman Empire

play09:39

at that time, who were enslaved?

play09:41

We always have an idea of what we mean as best for whom

play09:44

and I just don't happen to think that the Roman Empire

play09:46

produced anyone that we would consider

play09:47

to be a fair ruler today.

play09:49

@RoyallyAri, how often do you think about the Roman Empire?

play09:53

Well, this is a little bit of an unfair question

play09:54

because I have to say the answer is more than daily

play09:57

because it is a professional obligation.

play09:59

I probably think about the Roman Empire

play10:01

more than your average person.

play10:02

@NzeoraHQ, how effective were public toilets

play10:06

and bathrooms at keeping people clean

play10:09

and how is hygiene in Ancient Rome?

play10:11

Romans had extremely advanced technologies of water.

play10:14

For example, they had extensive systems of aqueducts

play10:17

that were able to bring clean water

play10:18

across vast expanses of land.

play10:21

They had a sewer system,

play10:23

as of I believe the Fourth Century BC, that's bananas.

play10:27

They had public bathing facilities.

play10:29

So it was very regular if you were a Roman,

play10:31

no matter your status, to actually go and use these baths

play10:34

on a daily basis to clean yourselves.

play10:36

And yes, they also had public toilets.

play10:38

This would not be the only place

play10:40

that people would go to the bathroom.

play10:41

But you can see in this that we would have stalls.

play10:43

They would probably not lead to a lot of privacy

play10:45

and you can see that running along down the side of them

play10:48

would be places for channels of water.

play10:51

So what were the Romans not good at in terms of hygiene

play10:53

with this water technology?

play10:55

Well, they didn't understand things like dysentery,

play10:57

about communicable diseases that way.

play10:59

And so if you're having say, reusable toilet paper,

play11:03

which in the Roman world would be a sea sponge

play11:05

and it's being cleaned in vinegar,

play11:07

which can do some things.

play11:08

That's not gonna stop things like dysentery

play11:10

from being passed along.

play11:11

@NzeoraHQ, what kind of toys did Roman children play with?

play11:15

We have so much wonderful information about the value

play11:19

that was put on playing as a social emotional strategy

play11:22

for raising Roman children.

play11:23

One of my favorite is actually this doll.

play11:26

This particular one is made out of ivory

play11:28

and what's so impressive about it is you can see

play11:30

that the limbs are articulated.

play11:32

So you can see that you can sit this doll down,

play11:34

you can have her stand up

play11:36

and this doll actually also has the famous hairstyle

play11:39

of the Roman empress at the time, Julia Domna.

play11:42

So she's also a high fashion doll.

play11:44

We know that dice games were very common.

play11:47

Walking toys that would clearly teach little toddlers

play11:49

how to walk and a lot of the building blocks

play11:51

that teach children how to play with each other

play11:53

were considered particularly important,

play11:55

and with this doll could also be considered

play11:57

extremely beloved objects that someone would keep

play11:59

well past their girlhood.

play12:01

From @El_Gringo_Loko,

play12:02

what was the average lifespan of a Roman peasant?

play12:05

This is a really great question

play12:07

because you're gonna find on the internet

play12:08

when you look this up,

play12:09

this idea that the Roman average lifespan was 35 years

play12:13

and then people often think as a result that if you made it

play12:15

to 35, you were grandparent age

play12:17

and that's just not true. 'cause we have to think about

play12:19

what an average means.

play12:20

Infant mortality in Rome was astronomically high.

play12:24

Most children died within the first year of birth.

play12:27

So that was just infant mortality.

play12:28

Child mortality, about 50% of children died by age 10

play12:33

and you can see already why that's lowering

play12:35

and lowering that average.

play12:36

So if you made it to age 10, as a lower class Roman citizen,

play12:39

whether you were living in the country,

play12:41

you had a decently high chance of making it

play12:43

into your mid 50s and we know plenty of people

play12:45

lived beyond that.

play12:47

Our next question is from Krista Callen.

play12:49

How does an archeologist look at an ancient column

play12:51

and conclude this was a Roman brothel?

play12:53

They could not do that.

play12:54

We do know that there's a very famous purpose-built brothel

play12:57

in Pompeii, and the building is entirely full

play12:59

of tiny stalls and in each of the stalls

play13:03

is only a bed shaped platform.

play13:05

Above the stalls are extremely graphic sex acts

play13:09

and then there is graffiti.

play13:10

And my favorite that has survived is over one stall

play13:13

and I have to imagine this was from the sex worker

play13:15

that wrote, "Thrust slowly."

play13:17

Putting all of those things together, it's pretty easy

play13:20

to see that this was a place where sex work

play13:21

was on the agenda.

play13:23

Numahonetweetu, what rights did Roman women gain

play13:26

in Imperial Rome?

play13:27

Roman women couldn't vote, and that's a big one.

play13:29

But Roman women could be citizens.

play13:31

Roman women could own property in their own name.

play13:34

They could inherit property in their own name.

play13:36

Roman women could be business owners

play13:38

and some of whom were using their own business sense

play13:40

to advance their children, especially their sons

play13:42

in their political ambition.

play13:44

Roman women could hire a lawyer to defend themselves

play13:47

or to bring a suit in court.

play13:48

Roman women lived with a greater degree of freedom

play13:50

across social classes than we're used to seeing

play13:53

in the ancient world.

play13:54

@EngCreamCakes, how many civil wars did Rome have,

play13:58

including the Byzantine era?

play14:00

That is a very hard question to answer

play14:02

for very good reasons.

play14:03

One is that the Romans thought that civil war

play14:06

was something inside them

play14:07

that you had to fight against every day or it would erupt.

play14:11

Romans had documented civil wars,

play14:13

and they're the ones that actually came up with this term

play14:14

where two Roman armies would fight each other,

play14:18

headed by two Romans.

play14:19

But what's the difference between that

play14:21

and an uprising of enslaved people who are part of

play14:24

the Roman population like Spartacus?

play14:26

Is that a civil war?

play14:27

What's the difference between the whole system

play14:30

of Roman provinces rising up against Roman rule?

play14:33

They're part of Rome and they're rising up

play14:35

and they're fighting, but they're fighting

play14:36

more with guerilla War tactics.

play14:38

Do we call that a civil war?

play14:39

You can see it becomes very hard to parse

play14:42

when one part of Rome is fighting the other.

play14:44

But it happens all the time.

play14:47

@BloodOorange, what the fuck did Ancient Romans wear

play14:50

during the winter?

play14:51

I know, right, 'cause all the images we see

play14:53

are in these sort of lightweight linen shirts

play14:56

and like sandals.

play14:57

That's our image of Rome and it snowed in Rome.

play15:00

Well, the key to Roman happiness,

play15:01

and this would be layers in the same way that it is today

play15:04

and Romans actually had access, even then, to material

play15:08

that we know is the best to keep you warm

play15:09

and that is wool.

play15:10

So the average Roman would wear socks.

play15:13

Yes, Romans really pioneered the idea of socks and sandals.

play15:16

They would wear extra thick socks,

play15:18

but they also didn't just wear sandals.

play15:19

They had thick leather shoes

play15:21

and the more layers of leather,

play15:22

the better those shoes would be in winter conditions.

play15:24

And then cloaks, tons and tons of beautiful wool cloaks

play15:28

on top.

play15:29

@RobertSmith29th, I was wondering

play15:31

how the Romans produced their Roman coins

play15:33

and how they put the emperor onto the coins.

play15:35

The way the Romans made coins was a by hand process.

play15:39

So what you would do is you would have a base

play15:41

and you would put in this base a mold

play15:43

that had one side of the coin.

play15:45

And in that mold you would put a metal disc

play15:47

and I would put it face down.

play15:48

So you can imagine it's almost like a clam with two molds

play15:51

and the metal disc goes in here,

play15:52

then I take a hammer and I whack it.

play15:54

And that's called stamping.

play15:55

And that would put the images on both sides of the coin.

play15:58

From @theistinthought, did Ancient Romans go on hikes

play16:01

or go to the beach for relaxation?

play16:03

Yes, there was a heavy leisure time activity in Rome

play16:06

where people would go to the coast,

play16:08

especially the Bay of Naples, and have seaside villas

play16:11

and go to these really fancy baths,

play16:13

sort of like a spa vacation,

play16:15

but it could last months.

play16:16

The extreme elite of Rome

play16:18

that would have access to these seaside villas.

play16:20

So the average Roman person probably didn't have a lot

play16:23

of time to be able to do that.

play16:25

So what did they do to relax?

play16:26

Rome had a lot of holidays around a festival calendar

play16:29

and these festivals would feature gladiatorial matches.

play16:32

They would feature chariot racing.

play16:34

They would feature theatrical spectacles,

play16:37

including the ancient equivalent of musicals.

play16:39

And we have evidence that people,

play16:40

even from rural communities, would come in

play16:42

for these festivals, especially the big ones.

play16:44

That's because they were state holidays.

play16:46

In the empire, there were over 100 days of public holidays.

play16:49

@jus_Tamon, so like in Ancient Rome,

play16:52

what was living there like?

play16:54

People worked and then went home and did they pay rent?

play16:56

The average Marcus, I should say instead of the average Joe,

play16:59

he could be a shoemaker,

play17:00

could be someone who sews clothing, could be a launderer.

play17:03

Any of the activities that you need done

play17:05

in your general city life would be the same thing

play17:07

that they would need done in Ancient Rome.

play17:08

Sometimes home was right above you.

play17:10

If they were quite wealthy, they might own the space

play17:12

that their shop is in.

play17:13

But often they would be renting out both of those spaces

play17:15

from a landlord

play17:16

and you bet the Romans complained about their landlords.

play17:19

Shoddy upgrades, vermin that weren't being taken care of.

play17:23

A neighbor who parties too hard

play17:24

and wakes the baby.

play17:25

@Tweekfan25, did they have weed in ancient Rome?

play17:29

Yes, but not in the way that you were asking.

play17:31

Romans really loved hemp as a plant

play17:34

and they loved how easy it was to make ropes with it.

play17:37

We find hemp products all over the place

play17:39

and hemp, the word for it in Latin is cannabis.

play17:42

So you can see the connection,

play17:43

but there's no sense that the Romans, first of all,

play17:45

smoked it.

play17:46

Smoking was not a particularly good thing in Roman culture.

play17:48

But there's also not great evidence

play17:51

that they recognized

play17:52

its sort of mind altering possibilities.

play17:54

@Kevin_Feeney, it will always be faintly extraordinary to me

play17:57

that Roman historians cannot agree on the answer

play17:59

to the superficially simple question

play18:01

of how many Roman emperors were there.

play18:03

So when Augustus is the first emperor,

play18:05

he declares a successor, Tiberius.

play18:08

Tiberius becomes the next emperor

play18:10

and miraculously we have two.

play18:11

So why is it so hard to keep counting?

play18:13

Eventually Rome becomes big

play18:15

and eventually other people decide they could be emperor

play18:18

and what does it take to become emperor?

play18:19

For a lot of Romans, the answer is an army

play18:21

that they're paying can declare them emperor

play18:24

and they can besiege Rome until they are declared emperor.

play18:26

Flash forward to later in the Roman Empire

play18:29

when we have divided centers.

play18:30

Is the center of Rome the city of Rome anymore, no.

play18:33

There is a center in Constantinople.

play18:35

Sometimes it's Milan, sometimes it's Ravenna.

play18:37

We're getting them multiple emperors

play18:39

or people who could be perceived as emperors

play18:41

at the same time.

play18:42

But we also get usurpers.

play18:44

Guys with armies that come in, think, "I could do this."

play18:47

And who gets to declare the emperor at that point?

play18:49

There aren't rules for this one way or another.

play18:51

It can become really hard for us to tell who is emperor

play18:53

and sometimes all we have is a single coin as evidence.

play18:56

Just one coin that one guy who claims to be emperor minted.

play19:00

Was he emperor, we have no idea.

play19:02

@TerraEncounters, how many Gods did Ancient Romans worship?

play19:05

It's not really fair to ask how many gods they worshiped.

play19:08

It's more fair to ask what Gods didn't they worship.

play19:11

Romans saw divine in lots of things.

play19:13

Springs had a divine being.

play19:15

Caves had a divine being.

play19:17

They had a festival to ward off mildew

play19:19

and it was called the Robigalia and it was in April

play19:22

and that showed that they also thought that mildew

play19:24

had a divine spirit in it,

play19:25

that they could essentially bribe

play19:27

to not destroy their crops.

play19:29

So the Romans had a really heavy investment

play19:31

in seeing the divine in as many places as possible

play19:33

and finding a way to connect with that religiously.

play19:35

@ShakeShur, I need someone to tell me if Romulus

play19:38

and Remus were real, like immediately.

play19:40

Romulus and Remus are the legendary founders of Rome.

play19:43

They were twins who had been expelled from their patrimony

play19:45

by an evil king, and they were supposed to be drowned

play19:48

in a river and the legend goes that a she wolf found them

play19:51

and nursed them and prevented them from dying.

play19:54

And then when they grew up, they were able to overthrow

play19:56

the evil king and they were able to found

play19:57

their own civilization.

play19:59

But even the Romans are pretty skeptical about this story.

play20:02

You can see a lot of the historians later saying,

play20:04

really, a she wolf, are we sure it wasn't a sex worker

play20:07

that we just called a she wolf?

play20:09

This was a pretty legendary story,

play20:10

sort of like George Washington and the cherry tree,

play20:13

and they didn't put much factual faith behind it.

play20:15

All right, that's all the time we have

play20:16

for questions for today.

play20:17

I hope you learn something weird

play20:19

and interesting about Romans and we'll see you next time.

Rate This

5.0 / 5 (0 votes)

الوسوم ذات الصلة
Ancient RomeRoman HistoryCultural MythsDaily LifeInnovationsSocial CustomsHistorical FactsToga FashionUrinary CleaningRoman Architecture
هل تحتاج إلى تلخيص باللغة الإنجليزية؟