Is Twilight the WORST Thing Ever?

Summary

The Nostalgia Critic delves into the controversial Twilight saga, questioning its status as the worst in entertainment history. He critiques the unrealistic portrayal of vampires, plot inconsistencies, and shallow characters, particularly focusing on the protagonist Bella's lack of depth and agency. Despite acknowledging its flaws, the Critic argues that society's reaction to Twilight is more noteworthy than the franchise itself, suggesting that it will be viewed with nostalgia and amusement in the future, much like other once-controversial media.

Takeaways

• 🎬 The video discusses the controversial 'Twilight' franchise, questioning whether it deserves the negative reputation it has garnered over the years.
• 🧛 The script critiques the portrayal of vampires in 'Twilight', particularly the unrealistic sparkle and the inconsistencies in the lore.
• 🕳 The critique points out numerous plot holes and illogical story elements within the 'Twilight' universe.
• 👎 The special effects of the movies are described as terrible, with a comparison to 'Garbage Pail Kids' to emphasize the poor quality.
• 👚 The video argues that the 'Twilight' series is often labeled as female-oriented smut, but it actually has minimal explicit content.
• 🛌 The script humorously notes the lack of chemistry and emotional depth between the main characters, and the flatness of their personalities.
• 🤔 It questions the ethics and intelligence of the characters, particularly Edward and Jacob, and their relationships with Bella.
• 👶 The controversial aspect of Jacob imprinting on a newborn is mentioned, with the script suggesting it's a poorly understood and potentially problematic plot device.
• 👰 The main character, Bella, is criticized for being a 'blank slate' and a poor role model for young women, being overly dependent and passive.
• 🌐 The video suggests that the hatred towards 'Twilight' may be more about societal reactions and what the popularity of the series says about us as a culture.
• 🔮 Finally, the script proposes that 'Twilight' will likely be viewed in the future as a product of its time, similar to how we now view past controversial media with a sense of nostalgia and humor.

Q & A

What is the main topic of the Nostalgia Critic's discussion in the script?

The main topic is whether the Twilight franchise, including both the books and movies, is deserving of the title 'the worst thing ever' in terms of cinematic and literary quality.

What are some of the criticisms the Nostalgia Critic points out about the Twilight series?

The criticisms include the unrealistic portrayal of vampires, plot holes, poor character development, and the controversial portrayal of relationships and ethics.

Why does the Nostalgia Critic mention 'Garbage Pail Kids' in the script?

The Nostalgia Critic uses 'Garbage Pail Kids' as a comparison to highlight the perceived low quality of the Twilight effects and story elements.

What is the Nostalgia Critic's opinion on the portrayal of the female lead, Bella, in Twilight?

The Nostalgia Critic believes Bella is a problematic character due to her lack of independence, emotional depth, and ethical issues, making her a poor role model.

How does the Nostalgia Critic view the character of Edward in the Twilight series?

The Nostalgia Critic sees Edward as a character with no personality development despite his age, and criticizes his relationship with Bella for its lack of chemistry and his overbearing nature.

What is the controversy surrounding the character Jacob in the Twilight series?

The controversy is Jacob's 'imprinting' on a newborn baby, which is seen as ethically questionable and indicative of poor character judgment.

Why does the Nostalgia Critic argue that Twilight is not the worst thing ever?

The Nostalgia Critic argues that society has a history of evolving beyond initially controversial or disliked media, suggesting that Twilight will be seen as just another example of this in the future.

What historical examples does the Nostalgia Critic use to illustrate society's adaptability to controversial media?

The Nostalgia Critic cites examples such as The Simpsons, Andrew Dice Clay, and Madonna, all of which were once considered shocking or detrimental but are now seen in a different light.

What is the Nostalgia Critic's final stance on the impact of Twilight on society?

The Nostalgia Critic believes that while Twilight has its flaws and is deserving of criticism, it is not the worst thing ever and that society will likely move on and adapt its views over time.

How does the Nostalgia Critic describe the role of Bella in the Twilight series?

The Nostalgia Critic describes Bella as a 'blank slate' character, serving as a vessel for female readers to project themselves into a fantasy world of love and excitement.

What does the Nostalgia Critic suggest about the future perception of Twilight?

The Nostalgia Critic suggests that people will likely look back on Twilight and laugh at its absurdity, similar to how they view other once-controversial media today.