GPS 2 JUTA VS GPS 5 JUTA | HUAWEI WATCH FIT 4 VS GARMIN INSTINCT E

Summary

In this video, Rizal Fauzi compares the GPS performance and workout data features of the Huawei WatchFit 4 and Garmin Instinct E. Despite Huawei being significantly cheaper, both smartwatches show similarly fast GPS lock times, with minor differences in accuracy and stability across various terrains. Huawei impresses with visually appealing workout data, while Garmin offers more detailed metrics and tracking options. Rizal demonstrates GPS tracking, route stability, and heart rate comparisons, concluding that Huawei provides solid performance for its price, but Garmin maintains a slight edge in overall GPS reliability and data depth.

Takeaways

• 😀 Both Huawei WatchFit 4 and Garmin Instinct E provide fast GPS lock times, with differences often under a second.
• 😀 Huawei WatchFit 4 uses a sunflower antenna technology that helps it compete with Garmin in GPS accuracy despite a lower price.
• 😀 Garmin Instinct E is significantly more expensive (around Rp5 million) compared to Huawei WatchFit 4 (under Rp2 million).
• 😀 In GPS tracking, both devices are generally accurate, with minimal differences in total distance (1–20 meters).
• 😀 Huawei WatchFit 4 offers visually appealing workout data with charts and graphs, making it more engaging for casual users.
• 😀 Garmin provides more detailed and comprehensive data, including metrics like intensity minutes, body metrics, battery, and hydration, but with less visual appeal.
• 😀 On tight or obstructed paths, both devices occasionally show GPS drift, though Garmin tends to be slightly more stable overall.
• 😀 Heart rate tracking between the two devices is similar, with minor differences in average BPM readings (Huawei 136 bpm, Garmin 138 bpm).
• 😀 Garmin allows users to log gear used during workouts, which is a feature absent in Huawei WatchFit 4.
• 😀 Overall, Huawei WatchFit 4 offers strong GPS performance and heart rate monitoring for its price, while Garmin excels in stability, data depth, and professional-level tracking features.

Q & A

What was the main objective of Rizal Fauzi's video?

The main objective was to compare the GPS performance and data tracking features of the Huawei WatchFit 4 with the Garmin Instinct E, highlighting differences in speed, stability, and data presentation.

How do the GPS lock speeds of Huawei WatchFit 4 and Garmin Instinct E compare?

Both devices have very fast GPS lock speeds, with only minimal differences of less than one second. The lock speed can alternate between the two devices, showing they are nearly equal in performance.

What is the price difference between the two smartwatches?

The Huawei WatchFit 4 costs under IDR 2 million, while the Garmin Instinct E is priced around IDR 5 to 5.5 million, making Garmin significantly more expensive.

How does the visual presentation of workout data differ between Huawei and Garmin?

Huawei WatchFit 4 presents workout data in a visually appealing way with charts and colorful displays, while Garmin focuses more on detailed statistics and numerical data without emphasizing visual design.

Which device offers more comprehensive data tracking?

Garmin provides more detailed and comprehensive data, including metrics like intensity minutes, body metrics, battery, nutrition, hydration, and gear tracking, which are not fully available on Huawei.

How did the GPS tracking accuracy compare between the two devices?

Both devices performed similarly in GPS tracking with minimal distance discrepancies (10–20 meters). Garmin showed slightly more stability in certain segments, while Huawei occasionally recorded minor errors, especially in tight or obstructed paths.

Were there any noticeable differences in heart rate monitoring?

Heart rate monitoring between the devices was very similar, with average readings being close (Garmin 138 bpm, Huawei 136 bpm). Some minor variations or 'hit and miss' moments were observed, but overall both devices performed well.

Which smartwatch is better for users who prioritize visual appeal in workout data?

Huawei WatchFit 4 is better suited for users who prefer visually appealing data presentations with colorful charts and easy-to-read displays.

Which smartwatch is better for users who prioritize detailed metrics and analysis?

Garmin Instinct E is better for users who want in-depth data, advanced metrics, and comprehensive tracking for sports and fitness purposes.

Based on Rizal Fauzi’s testing, is the Huawei WatchFit 4 a good alternative to Garmin despite the price difference?

Yes, the Huawei WatchFit 4 provides reliable GPS performance and heart rate monitoring at a much lower price, making it a viable alternative for users who do not require all the advanced features of Garmin.