Scientific Evidence Why Handwriting Analysis is NOT a Pseudoscience
Summary
TLDRLeah addresses criticisms of handwriting analysis, presenting scientific studies that link handwriting changes to psychiatric and neurological disorders like depression, OCD, and bipolar disorder. She discusses how handwriting can reflect mental states and even predict manic episodes or detect motor side effects of medications. Leah argues that graphology is often dismissed due to a lack of studies, which is a missed opportunity for early detection and screening of serious conditions. She advocates for more research to explore the potential benefits of handwriting analysis in mental health assessments.
Takeaways
- 🚫 Leah addresses common criticisms of her videos on handwriting analysis, such as accusations of over-analysis and pseudoscience.
- 📚 Leah introduces herself and her content, which includes videos on handwriting analysis and other topics of interest.
- 🔍 She aims to examine scientific research and journals to validate the legitimacy of handwriting analysis.
- 📝 The script mentions an article linking handwriting changes to psychiatric symptoms, suggesting a connection between mental health and handwriting.
- 🧠 Handwriting analysis, or graphology, is discussed as a tool for understanding emotional states and assessing psychiatric conditions.
- 💊 A case study is cited where a girl's handwriting changed due to depression, and improved after treatment with antidepressants.
- 🔍 Leah discusses further research suggesting handwriting can be used to screen for mental illnesses and predict manic episodes in bipolar disorder.
- 📉 Another study shows a correlation between handwriting pressure and anxiety levels.
- 🛡 A study proposes handwriting analysis as a method for detecting the effects of antipsychotics and the presence of sexual abuse in children.
- 🔮 Leah concludes that handwriting analysis has potential for early detection and screening of various mental and neurological conditions.
- 📈 She expresses disappointment in the lack of studies on handwriting analysis due to its discredited status, advocating for more research to unlock its full potential.
Q & A
What is the main topic of Leah's videos?
-Leah's videos primarily focus on handwriting and handwriting analysis, specifically its relationship to human psychology and its potential use in psychiatric assessments.
Why does Leah feel the need to address criticism in her video?
-Leah addresses criticism because her videos often receive comments dismissing her work as over-analysis, pseudoscience, or similar to astrology, which she aims to counter with scientific evidence.
What is the term used to describe the study and analysis of handwriting in relation to human psychology?
-The term used is 'graphology', which is the study and analysis of handwriting, especially in relation to human psychology.
How can changes in handwriting be an indicator of psychiatric disorders according to the article Leah mentioned?
-According to the article, changes in handwriting can be a symptom of psychiatric disorders such as depression, OCD, and schizophrenia, as these conditions can affect the presentation of handwriting.
What was the case of the girl with depression as described in the article?
-The girl had nice handwriting before her depression, but her handwriting changed significantly in terms of width, height, organization, and overall presentation. Despite efforts, she could not revert to her original handwriting, but it improved after being prescribed antidepressants.
What potential use does the article suggest for handwriting analysis in psychiatric assessment?
-The article suggests that handwriting analysis could be used as a tool to understand the emotional state of a person and could be implicated during psychiatric assessments for more accurate results.
What findings did the study on handwriting changes in patients with BD (Bipolar Disorder) reveal?
-The study found a specific pattern of handwriting changes in participants when going through a manic episode, suggesting that handwriting features could be used to screen patients and predict when a patient might switch into a manic episode.
How can handwriting analysis be used to detect the motor side effects of antipsychotics according to the study mentioned?
-The study suggests that handwriting can be used to detect the motor side effects of antipsychotics in the early period, indicating that changes in handwriting may serve as an early indicator of such side effects.
What was the conclusion of the study on the relationship between stress, anxiety, and handwriting?
-The study concluded that handwriting pressure does correlate with anxiety levels, indicating that changes in the pressure applied while writing can be an indicator of stress or anxiety.
How does the study on handwriting and children's traumatic sexual experiences relate to personality traits and irrational beliefs?
-The study concluded that most children's positive or negative personality traits and irrational beliefs are displayed in their handwriting, and the presence and frequency of sexual abuse can be indicated through handwriting analysis.
What is Leah's conclusion about the credibility and potential of handwriting analysis based on the studies she reviewed?
-Leah concludes that handwriting analysis is discredited due to a lack of studies, but the studies she reviewed show encouraging findings that it can be used for early detection and screening of various mental and neurological conditions. She believes more research could lead to significant benefits.
Outlines
📝 Addressing Criticisms of Handwriting Analysis
Leah, the speaker, addresses common criticisms of her handwriting analysis videos, such as accusations of over-analyzing or pseudoscience. She introduces herself as a non-academic who posts videos on handwriting and its analysis, and expresses her desire for more subscribers and a play button. Leah plans to counter these criticisms by referencing scientific research and journals to support the legitimacy of handwriting analysis.
🔍 Scientific Evidence for Handwriting Analysis
The speaker presents various studies that link handwriting changes to psychiatric symptoms and neurological disorders. She discusses an article that views handwriting change as a psychiatric symptom, mentioning specific cases like a girl with depression whose handwriting changed significantly and improved with treatment. Leah also highlights research suggesting handwriting analysis can be a tool for psychiatric assessment and a method to detect motor side effects of antipsychotics, emphasizing the need for further research in this field.
📉 Handwriting Changes in Manic and Depressive Episodes
Leah cites a study that identifies handwriting changes during manic episodes in patients with bipolar disorder (BD). The study found specific patterns in handwriting that corresponded to these episodes, suggesting that handwriting analysis could be used for patient follow-up and to predict manic episodes. The speaker also notes that handwriting features could be used to screen patients and detect the side effects of medication.
🔎 Handwriting Analysis for Detecting Psychological Conditions
The speaker reviews studies that explore the relationship between handwriting and psychological conditions such as stress, anxiety, and even traumatic experiences in children. One study found a correlation between handwriting pressure and anxiety levels, while another confirmed that handwriting can indicate the presence and frequency of sexual abuse in children. Leah concludes that handwriting analysis, despite being discredited, shows promising results as an early detection and screening tool for various mental health conditions.
🚀 The Potential of Handwriting Analysis
In conclusion, Leah emphasizes the potential of handwriting analysis as demonstrated by the studies she has reviewed. She laments the lack of studies in the field due to its discredited status, which she views as a missed opportunity for early detection and intervention in serious mental health conditions. Leah calls for more research to unlock the full potential of handwriting analysis and its applications in various psychological and neurological assessments.
Mindmap
Keywords
💡Handwriting Analysis
💡Pseudoscience
💡Neurological Disorders
💡Psychiatric Disorders
💡Depression
💡OCD
💡Schizophrenia
💡Manic Episode
💡Handwriting Pressure
💡Sexual Abuse
💡Early Detection
💡Screening
Highlights
Handwriting analysis, or graphology, is often criticized as pseudoscience but has potential in understanding human psychology.
Leah, the speaker, addresses common criticisms of her work in handwriting analysis.
Handwriting changes can be a symptom of psychiatric disorders, such as depression, OCD, and schizophrenia.
A case study found a girl's handwriting changed significantly due to depression, which improved with treatment.
Graphology should be made more specific and sensitive to provide accurate results in psychiatric assessments.
Handwriting changes can be used to follow up patients with bipolar disorder (BD) and detect manic episodes.
Handwriting features can be used to screen patients for discharge and predict manic episodes in BD patients.
Handwriting analysis can also detect motor side effects of antipsychotics in the early period.
A study found a protocol for assessing severe major depressive disorder using handwriting analysis with positive results.
Handwriting pressure correlates with anxiety levels, as concluded in a specific study.
Handwriting can indicate the presence and frequency of sexual abuse in children's experiences.
The lack of studies on handwriting analysis is due to its discredited status, creating a negative cycle.
Studies show encouraging findings that graphology can be used for early detection and screening of mental illnesses.
Increased understanding and research in handwriting analysis could lead to faster help for many people.
Handwriting analysis has the potential to detect serious conditions and open up possibilities for its application.
Leah calls for more research and understanding of handwriting analysis to unlock its full potential.
The video concludes by emphasizing the importance and potential benefits of handwriting analysis.
Transcripts
so whenever my videos get viewed by a
large amount of people that are
unfamiliar with my comments I usually
get a lot of comments that are like oh
you're over analyzing it oh this is dumb
this is fake this is a pseudoscience
this is like stationary astrology so
today I felt like addressing it so hello
my name is Leah I post videos about
handwriting and handwriting analysis and
whatever I want if you'd like to
subscribe please do I want my play
button this year but that's not why
we're here I don't consider myself a
very like academic person but we're
gonna be looking at different scientific
research and journals and studies to
demonstrate that no it isn't just
handwriting okay in this article
handwriting change is a psychiatric
symptom they say graphology is the study
and Analysis of handwriting especially
in relationship to human psychology many
neurological disorders affect
handwriting many psychiatric disorders
like depression OCD schizophrenia are
also linked with handwriting a unique
presentation of major depressive
disorder manifesting as Chief complain
of handwriting change was observed in a
girl who had nice handwriting before
depression in spite of constant efforts
she was not able to revert back to her
original handwriting her new
handwritings were different from old one
in form of width and height of letters
organization and overall presentation
she was prescribed antidepressants
depressive symptoms were relieved and
her handwriting started gradually
improving considerably though previous
level had not been achieved analysis of
handwriting as a tool to understand the
emotional state of a person can be
implicated during psychiatric assessment
the written off science of graphology
needs to be made specific and sensitive
so that it could provide more accurate
results further research in this area is
wanted is warranted so that's just one
here's another article the uses of
handwriting changes for the follow-up
patients with BD so in their results
they found a specific pattern of changes
in the handwriting of their participants
when going through a manic episode and
then they write the specific differences
what changes in the handwriting in their
conclusion they write writing is
understood as a psycho neuro motor
process affected by several factors when
one of these processes are processes are
affected serious changes can occur in
handwriting handwriting features can be
used to screen patients for discharge
and can be helpful for predicting when a
patient with BD might switch into a
manic episode also we suggest that
handwriting can be used to detect the
motor side effects of antipsychotics in
the early period Then in this other
study handwriting analysis protocol for
assessing severe major depressive
disorder it was a really confusing
abstract but in their agreement they
they write psychiatric trick assessment
and the ratings given by the judges we
found satisf Factory results they say
the substantial improvements obtained in
comparison blah blah blah are
encouraging and support further attempts
so basically they said
um handwriting used as protocol for
assessing depression they found positive
results and they want to keep studying
it then here's another study
relationship between stress anxiety and
handwriting this study focused
specifically on handwriting pressure in
relationship to anxiety and they
concluded that handwriting pressure does
in fact correlate to anxiety and then in
this in this other study can handwriting
help in the detection of children's
traumatic sexual experiences in their
conclusion they say the study concluded
that the hypothesis was proved it
confirms that most children do have
positive slash negative personality
traits and irrational beliefs displayed
in their handwriting the presence and
frequency of sexual abuse was clearly
indicated in the same so many so so so
my conclusion so I just read you a bunch
of physically I just took a bunch of
studies and kind of Skips to the end of
the book and found the conclusion and
told you guys the conclusion handwriting
analysis is discredited constantly
because there aren't enough studies on
it and there aren't enough studies on it
because it is discredited constantly
which in my opinion is a real shame all
these studies are showing like really
encouraging findings that graphology can
be used as like an early detection in
screening for different mental illnesses
and and different neurological
conditions different psychological
conditions if we knew more about it and
we had more studies like being done then
a lot of people could get help a lot
faster and if handwriting analysis can
help detect these very serious
conditions then think about all the
possibilities for how it could be
helpful next thank you subscribe
تصفح المزيد من مقاطع الفيديو ذات الصلة
What your Margins say about YOU
The Riddler's terrifying handwriting -- BATMAN HANDWRITING ANALYSIS
Everything I know about handwriting analysis in under 14 minutes. BEGINNER AND ADVANCED GRAPHOLOGY!!
How to Spot a Liar by their Handwriting
what books should I read? (graphology books I recommend)
DID Handwriting Analysis (Dissociative Identity Disorder/OSDD writing)
5.0 / 5 (0 votes)