Let's talk about Witcher 4..

Summary

The video discusses the mixed reactions to the reveal of The Witcher 4, with fans divided over the game's focus on Ciri rather than Geralt. Some fans are skeptical about a female protagonist, while others defend the game's creative choices. The video compares the first trailer of Witcher 3 to the new Witcher 4 trailer, highlighting the evolution in graphics and character designs. It also touches on lore discrepancies and the potential reasons for Ciri’s role as the main character. Overall, the speaker remains cautiously optimistic, awaiting more gameplay details before forming a final opinion.

Takeaways

• 😀 The Witcher 4 trailer has sparked a range of reactions, from excitement to disappointment, especially regarding the shift from Geralt to Ciri as the main protagonist.
• 😀 Some fans feel the inclusion of Ciri as the lead character is part of a forced cultural agenda, while others believe it's a natural progression in the story.
• 😀 The visuals of the Witcher 3's first trailer were impressive for their time, and there's a clear evolution in the graphics between Witcher 3 and Witcher 4, especially with Unreal Engine 5.
• 😀 While Geralt's appearance in the trailer is not identical to his in-game model, the differences are subtle, and the character still retains recognizable features.
• 😀 The Witcher 4 trailer introduces Ciri as an older, more experienced character. Some fans have mixed opinions on her appearance, with debates around her attractiveness and age.
• 😀 The opinion that everyone is entitled to their personal taste in characters and games is emphasized. People shouldn't feel pressured to justify their preferences.
• 😀 The lore of The Witcher world is complex, with questions about how Ciri could become a Witcher, as traditionally women couldn't undergo the Witcher trials.
• 😀 The game developers have revealed that Ciri is indeed the protagonist of Witcher 4, which was anticipated by many fans, even though it caused some dissatisfaction among others.
• 😀 Despite the differing opinions, the trailer presents a darker, more grim atmosphere with moments of hope and choice, maintaining the tone of the Witcher universe.
• 😀 The script includes a breakdown of key moments from the Witcher 4 cinematic trailer, such as the ritual sacrifice, Ciri's use of a chain weapon, and her connection to the monster in the woods.
• 😀 The developers' decision to create a new, distinct story in Witcher 4 is seen by some as diverging from original lore, but there is an acknowledgment that the game could still be great based on gameplay and narrative execution.

Q & A

Why is there controversy around the choice of Siri as the protagonist in The Witcher 4?

The controversy stems from fans’ attachment to Geralt as the protagonist, with some expressing disappointment over the shift to Siri. Some also argue that the choice may be influenced by cultural or identity politics, with criticisms that it represents a forced narrative of gender representation.

What comparisons are made between the Witcher 4 trailer and The Witcher 3 trailer?

The Witcher 4 trailer features updated graphics, but similar to Witcher 3, there is an emphasis on a dark, grim world filled with monsters. The key difference highlighted is that in Witcher 3, Geralt saves the girl, whereas in Witcher 4, Siri fails to save Mei, leading to a different tone and ending.

How does the user feel about Siri's appearance in the Witcher 4 trailer?

The user thinks Siri's appearance is generally fine but notes that there are certain angles where she looks odd. They acknowledge that beauty is subjective and suggest that some might find her less attractive, but others would find her fine.

Why does the user believe some people dislike Siri's design in the trailer?

The user speculates that some negative reactions may come from personal taste, with some people finding her features unconventional or not adhering to traditional beauty standards. However, the user emphasizes that such opinions are valid and should not be dismissed.

What is the user's understanding of the lore surrounding female Witchers?

The user is confused by the lore regarding female Witchers, as they believed the Witcher trials were only for men. However, the developers have revealed that while there are other Witcher schools, traditionally, females were not part of the Witcher mutations, and Siri’s abilities may be an exception due to her Elder Blood heritage.

How does the user feel about the developers potentially abandoning the Witcher lore?

The user mentions that Witcher 3 already deviated significantly from the original book series, and they are not overly concerned about the developers making further changes in Witcher 4, as long as the game remains good.

What is the user's stance on the potential inclusion of identity politics in The Witcher 4?

The user dismisses concerns about identity politics in gaming, stating that fans should not be pressured into liking a game based on its political or cultural elements. They believe that personal tastes are valid and that games should be judged on their merit, not on external agendas.

What specific scene in the Witcher 4 trailer did the user find particularly impactful?

The user highlights the scene where Siri uses her abilities in the woods, where she seems to lure the monster while simultaneously facing emotional and physical challenges. This moment is seen as a significant display of her powers and the game's darker tone.

What is the user’s opinion on the narrative direction of The Witcher 4?

The user is cautiously optimistic about The Witcher 4’s narrative, expressing curiosity about the direction of the story with Siri as the protagonist. They feel the game has potential, but they want to see more before making a final judgment.

What are the user's thoughts on the game's potential to replicate the success of previous Witcher titles?

The user acknowledges that CD Projekt Red has earned goodwill from previous titles like Witcher 3 and Cyberpunk 2077, particularly with the well-received Phantom Liberty expansion. They are hopeful that The Witcher 4 could build on that success, but they remain cautious about the unknowns of the new game.