MARCELO BRIGADEIRO É SINCERO SOBRE TREINO DE MMA NOS E.U.A

Só Papos MMA

16 May 202407:52

Summary

TLDRThe video script discusses the cultural differences between Brazilian and American coaching methods in sports, particularly in combat sports like MMA. It emphasizes the importance of a dedicated trainer or 'formador' in an athlete's development, contrasting the nurturing approach of Brazilian coaches with the more business-like, results-driven methods of American coaches. It also highlights the significance of the coach-athlete relationship, suggesting that a strong bond is crucial for an athlete's success and perseverance. The script critiques the idea that moving to the U.S. for training is always beneficial, arguing that it may not be suitable for every athlete, especially those in the early stages of their careers.

Takeaways

🏋️‍♂️ The importance of having a dedicated coach for athlete development is highlighted, emphasizing the difference between a coach, a trainer, and an athlete developer.
🌐 The script discusses the common belief that athletes need to train with foreign coaches, particularly in the United States, to improve and gain recognition.
🤼‍♂️ It addresses the criticism faced by athletes like José Aldo for not seeking foreign training and the idea that staying in Brazil could limit their growth.
🤔 The speaker reflects on the notion that going to the United States for training might be overrated and not necessarily the best for an athlete's formation.
🦈 The metaphor of an athlete being thrown into a 'shark tank' is used to describe the competitive and potentially overwhelming environment of training in the U.S.
💼 The business aspect of sports training in the U.S. is mentioned, suggesting that there is a focus on profit and less on personal connections or friendships.
👥 The script contrasts the professional approach of American coaches with the more personal and flexible approach often found with Brazilian coaches.
🤝 The value of the relationship between an athlete and their coach is underscored, stating that the coach who shapes the athlete will earn their respect and loyalty.
🗣️ It is suggested that communication and understanding between the athlete and the coach are crucial, especially during competition.
👨‍🏫 The speaker mentions that Tim Ruberg, an American wrestling coach living in Brazil, has a different approach to coaching, which is more professional and structured.
💰 The script touches on the financial aspect of coaching, indicating that in the U.S., payment is directly related to the level of service and attention an athlete receives.

Q & A

What is the main topic discussed in the script?
-The main topic discussed in the script is the difference in coaching styles and the importance of a coach's role in an athlete's development, particularly in the context of Brazilian and American approaches.
Why is it suggested that going to a foreign coach might be beneficial for an athlete?
-It is suggested that going to a foreign coach, particularly an American one, might be beneficial because they can help polish an athlete who is already good and gaining notoriety, taking their skills to the next level.
What is the criticism mentioned about José Aldo's career?
-The criticism mentioned about José Aldo's career is that he never evolved or improved technically, suggesting that he should have sought training outside of Brazil to progress further.
What is the opinion on athletes training in the United States?
-The opinion expressed is that training in the United States might not be the best for athletes in formation stages, as the training there is more about refining already well-established athletes rather than forming new ones.
What are the three different roles mentioned for someone working with an athlete?
-The three different roles mentioned are a professor, a trainer, and an athlete developer. Each role has a distinct function, with the developer focusing on the overall formation of the athlete.
What is the importance of a coach's connection with an athlete during a fight?
-The coach's connection with an athlete is important because the coach needs to understand the athlete's state of mind and physical condition during a fight, knowing when to push and when to hold back.
Why is the coach-athlete relationship considered underestimated in the current context?
-The coach-athlete relationship is considered underestimated because the coach's role in the athlete's success is crucial, and the athlete's respect and trust in the coach can significantly impact their performance.
What is the view on the necessity of an athlete having a manager or agent?
-The view expressed is that having a manager or agent is very important for an athlete, as they handle the business aspects, allowing the athlete to focus on their training and performance.
How is the American approach to coaching described in the script?
-The American approach to coaching is described as very professional and business-like, with a focus on results and efficiency, often lacking the personal connection that is more common in Brazilian coaching styles.
What is the difference between Brazilian and American coaches mentioned in the script?
-The difference mentioned is that Brazilian coaches tend to be more personal and emotionally invested, while American coaches are described as more detached, focusing on schedules and professionalism without personal attachment.
What is the role of a wrestling coach from the United States mentioned in the script?
-The role of the American wrestling coach mentioned in the script is to provide a different perspective and approach to training, being professional and sticking to schedules, which contrasts with the more flexible and personal style of Brazilian coaches.

Outlines

00:00

🥊 The Evolution of Athlete Training and Coaching

The first paragraph discusses the evolution of athlete training, emphasizing the importance of having a dedicated coach or formador for an athlete's development. It touches on the idea that going to the United States for training is not always beneficial, especially for athletes who are already well-established and do not need to be 'formed' but rather 'polished'. The speaker mentions that American Top Team is an example of an organization that has seen success with this approach. The paragraph also highlights the difference between a professor, a treinador (coach), and a formador de atleta (athlete shaper), suggesting that each role is distinct and crucial for an athlete's growth. The speaker also points out that the connection between an athlete and their formador is often underestimated but plays a vital role in the athlete's success and respect for their trainer.

05:00

🤼‍♂️ Cultural Differences in Coaching and Business Practices

The second paragraph explores the cultural differences between Brazilian and American coaching styles and business practices. It contrasts the more personal, flexible approach of Brazilian coaches with the structured, business-like attitude of American coaches. The speaker uses the example of Tim Ruberg, an American wrestling coach living in Brazil, to illustrate these differences. The American approach is described as more professional and less personal, with a focus on business and efficiency rather than building personal relationships. The paragraph also discusses the perception of Brazilian coaches as being overly attentive compared to their American counterparts, who are seen as more detached and focused on the job at hand. The speaker suggests that this difference in approach can lead to misunderstandings and dissatisfaction among athletes who may have different expectations.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡American Top Team

American Top Team is a reference to a prominent mixed martial arts (MMA) gym based in the United States. In the context of the video, it symbolizes the pursuit of high-level training and the idea that to achieve the best, one must train with the best. The script mentions the gym as an example of where Brazilian athletes often go to further their careers and improve their skills.

💡Coach

A 'Coach' in this script refers to a mentor or trainer who helps athletes improve their skills and performance. The video discusses the importance of having a coach, especially one from the United States, to gain recognition and improve in their sport. It suggests that a foreign coach might offer a different perspective or advanced techniques.

💡Evolution

Evolution in the video script pertains to the growth and development of an athlete's skills and abilities. The speaker criticizes the idea that athletes should only train with foreign coaches for evolution, implying that local coaches can also facilitate significant improvement and that evolution should be a continuous process.

💡Hard Training

Hard training is a concept mentioned in the script that highlights the importance of rigorous and intense physical preparation for athletes. It is contrasted with technical evolution, suggesting that some athletes might prioritize the physical aspect of their training over technical refinement.

💡Veteran Athlete

A 'veteran athlete' refers to an experienced sportsperson who has been in the field for a long time. The script suggests that veteran athletes might seek out foreign training not for basic skill development but for advanced, specialized training to fine-tune their abilities.

💡Formation

Formation in the context of the video refers to the initial and ongoing process of developing an athlete's skills from the ground up. The speaker argues that it's crucial for athletes, especially those in the early stages of their careers, to have a dedicated person or coach focused on their formation rather than just hard training.

💡MMA

MMA stands for Mixed Martial Arts, a full-contact combat sport that combines elements of various martial arts. The video script discusses MMA in the context of Brazilian athletes seeking training abroad and the importance of having a coach who understands the sport's technical and mental aspects.

💡Professionalism

Professionalism in the video is associated with the work ethic and the business-like approach to training and coaching. The script contrasts the American style of coaching, which is described as more professional and less personal, with the Brazilian style, which might be more personal and less formal.

💡Coaching Style

Coaching style refers to the methods and approaches used by a coach to train athletes. The video script highlights the differences between American and Brazilian coaching styles, with the American style being more structured, time-bound, and less emotionally involved.

💡Business

In the script, 'Business' is used to describe the transactional nature of coaching in the United States, where services are paid for, and there is an expectation of professionalism. It contrasts with a more personal or emotional approach to coaching that might be more common in Brazil.

💡Connection

Connection in the video script emphasizes the importance of the bond between an athlete and their coach. It suggests that a strong connection is essential for the coach to understand the athlete's mental state during competition and provide the necessary support and motivation.

💡Respect

Respect is mentioned in the context of the relationship between an athlete and their coach. The script implies that an athlete will respect and listen to the coach who has formed them, indicating the significance of the coach's role in shaping the athlete's career and personality.

Highlights

The importance of seeking a foreign coach for athletes to gain notoriety and improve.

Criticism of José Aldo for not evolving and the notion of needing to train in the United States.

The concept that American teams are not for athlete development but for refining already prepared athletes.

The preference for hard training over technical evolution for veteran athletes.

The distinction between a coach, a trainer, and an athlete developer, emphasizing the need for a dedicated athlete developer.

The role of a coach in teaching not just technical but also physical and mental aspects.

The idea that going to the United States for training is an illusion and not always beneficial.

The high cost of living and working in the United States as a professional athlete.

The business-oriented nature of American sports and the importance of having a good manager.

The underestimation of the coach-athlete relationship and its impact on an athlete's success.

The need for a coach to understand the athlete's mental state during a fight.

The cultural differences in coaching styles between Brazilian and American coaches.

The professionalism expected from American coaches and the difference in expectations.

The comparison between Brazilian coaches who give too much and American coaches who are more detached.

The importance of respecting the coach who has formed the athlete and the cultural significance of this relationship.

The business aspect of American sports and the lack of personal attachment compared to Brazilian culture.

The experience of having an American wrestling coach in the team and his professional approach.

The contrast between Brazilian coaches who are more involved and American coaches who are more detached and schedule-oriented.