Che penserebbe WALT della DISNEY di oggi? -- parte 1

Summary

In this video, the speaker explores how Walt Disney might have reacted to various animated films produced by Disney after his death, ranging from 'Hercules' to 'Frozen.' The discussion delves into Disney's conservative views on themes like sexuality, political correctness, and his focus on traditional storytelling. The speaker speculates on Disney's appreciation for advancements in animation technology and his preference for simpler, moral-driven narratives. The analysis highlights how modern Disney films both align with and diverge from Disney's original vision, reflecting on the evolution of the company and its characters.

Takeaways

• 😀 Disney would have appreciated the innovation in animation technology, particularly the use of computer-generated animation in films like 'Tarzan'.
• 😀 Disney would have disliked the political and social commentary in films like 'Mulan' and 'Hercules', finding them too modern and politically charged.
• 😀 In 'The Hunchback of Notre Dame', Disney would have disapproved of the film's simplification of the original material and Esmeralda's sexualization.
• 😀 Disney would have enjoyed the animal animation in 'Tarzan', which was noted for its realistic portrayal of animal movement, something he highly valued.
• 😀 Disney would not have supported the idea of anthropomorphizing religious themes, like the humorous portrayal of Christianity in some modern films.
• 😀 Disney, a product of his time, would have been confused and possibly offended by the more contemporary references, such as those seen in 'Hercules'.
• 😀 He would have been particularly opposed to the portrayal of villains without depth, such as in 'The Hunchback of Notre Dame', where antagonists lacked motivation beyond being 'evil'.
• 😀 Disney would have disliked modern interpretations of characters, like Megara in 'Hercules', for being too sexualized and disconnected from his values.
• 😀 He would have been critical of the overt political and racial references in 'Mulan', especially in relation to the character of Mushu and the inclusion of African American music in 'Hercules'.
• 😀 Despite his likely disapproval of the contemporary approach in many films, Disney would have been fascinated by the artistic potential of 'Hercules', especially its Greek-inspired style.

Q & A

What would Disney have thought of 'The Hunchback of Notre Dame'?

Disney would have likely disapproved of 'The Hunchback of Notre Dame' due to its darker themes, including racism, war, and religion. He would have been uncomfortable with the sexualized portrayal of Esmeralda and the film's focus on complex, politically charged issues. Disney preferred films that avoided such mature and controversial topics.

How would Disney have reacted to the character of Esmeralda in 'The Hunchback of Notre Dame'?

Disney would have strongly disliked the sexualization of Esmeralda, as he was opposed to the eroticization of characters in his films. He believed in maintaining innocence and purity in his characters, and Esmeralda's portrayal would have contradicted his vision of animated films.

What were Disney's views on integrating modern political issues in films like 'Hercules'?

Disney would have found the inclusion of modern political references and social critiques in 'Hercules' confusing and out of place. He preferred films that focused on timeless values rather than directly engaging with current political discourse, which he would have seen as unnecessary in a family-friendly movie.

What did Disney think about the representation of religion in films like 'The Hunchback of Notre Dame'?

Disney would have accepted religious themes in films but was cautious about how they were handled. He had no issue with religious content, as seen in his earlier works, but he would have rejected any trivialization or overly simplistic treatment of serious religious matters in films like 'The Hunchback of Notre Dame'.

How did Disney feel about animation techniques and advancements, particularly regarding 'Tarzan'?

Disney was a visionary and would have embraced the innovative animation techniques used in 'Tarzan', especially the realistic depiction of animal movements. He would have been thrilled by the use of computer-generated imagery (CGI) to enhance the animation, as he was always keen on pushing the boundaries of technology in animation.

Would Disney have appreciated the musical style in 'Hercules', especially its use of Afro-American music?

It is unclear how Disney would have reacted to the use of Afro-American music in 'Hercules'. Disney was raised in a time when such musical styles were not common in mainstream animation, and he might have found it jarring or inappropriate, considering his traditional sensibilities regarding culture and race.

What did Disney think about complex or mature themes in movies like 'Tarzan'?

Disney preferred films that were more family-oriented and avoided complex, mature themes like the father-son conflict seen in 'Tarzan'. However, he might have appreciated the way the film handled the emotional depth of Tarzan's relationship with his father, as it was portrayed in a redemptive and heartfelt way.

How would Disney have responded to the hero character in 'Hercules'?

Disney might have found the hero character in 'Hercules' too didactic and simplistic. He preferred heroes whose virtues were more internal, focusing on heart and personal growth rather than external, action-driven heroism. Disney believed that a true hero is defined by the strength of their character.

What were Disney's thoughts on films with a more adult approach, like 'The Hunchback of Notre Dame'?

Disney was not in favor of films that tackled adult themes or had a more mature, complex approach. He believed that animation should appeal to all ages but remain rooted in family-friendly, innocent storytelling. He would have rejected 'The Hunchback of Notre Dame' for its mature, complicated themes.

How would Disney have felt about the evolution of Disney princesses as seen in films like 'Tarzan' and 'Hercules'?

Disney would have appreciated the more independent and dynamic princess characters in films like 'Tarzan' and 'Hercules', such as Jane. However, he might have found the way some of these characters expressed themselves to be too modern or divergent from the classic Disney princess mold, which focused more on purity and traditional roles.