Gravel Shop Floor vs. Concrete - Is Cheaper Better?

Summary

In this video, the speaker discusses the unique flooring choices in his blacksmith shop, particularly the use of gravel alongside concrete. He explains the practicality of a gravel floor, which absorbs dropped tools and minimizes the hassle of cleaning forge scale. Despite its benefits, gravel creates more dust and poses safety risks for visitors with mobility issues. The speaker contemplates pouring a concrete floor but is deterred by the costs and complexity of making necessary adjustments. Ultimately, he balances the need for efficiency in his projects with the challenges of upgrading his workspace, emphasizing the ongoing work in his shop.

Takeaways

• 😀 Gravel is a preferred flooring material in blacksmithing shops due to its durability and functionality in high-speed environments.
• 😀 Concrete floors have been poured multiple times in the shop for various purposes, including creating storage and work areas.
• 😀 Gravel flooring allows for tools to be dropped without damaging the floor or tools, making it more forgiving than concrete.
• 😀 Scale from forging can accumulate on the floor, but gravel hides the scale, saving time and effort for cleanup compared to concrete floors.
• 😀 The choice of using gravel over finer materials like 3/4 minus gravel was driven by practical considerations like avoiding problems with barn cats and reducing dust.
• 😀 Gravel floors are easier on the back for those who spend a lot of time standing or working in the shop, thanks to the irregularity of the surface.
• 😀 Gravel can pose a safety hazard for individuals with balance problems, such as those with neuropathy or a history of strokes, as it is less stable than concrete.
• 😀 Concrete floors would provide a smoother, safer surface, but the cost and effort involved in implementing them outweighs the benefits for now.
• 😀 If the floor were to be replaced with concrete, significant infrastructure adjustments, such as raising the forge and power hammer, would be necessary.
• 😀 The decision to not immediately switch to a concrete floor is influenced by both financial considerations (roughly $7,000 to $12,000) and the ongoing need to complete other projects, such as building benches and swords.

Q & A

What types of flooring are discussed in the video?

The video discusses a combination of wood, concrete, and gravel flooring in the blacksmith shop.

Why does the speaker prefer gravel over concrete in their blacksmith shop?

The speaker prefers gravel because it allows tools to be dropped without damage, makes cleanup easier, and is more comfortable for standing.

What is the main benefit of having a concrete floor in a blacksmith shop?

Concrete floors are generally considered the best option in most applications due to their durability and ease of cleaning.

How does gravel affect the dust levels in the shop?

While gravel reduces some issues with cats digging, it does increase dust in an already dusty environment.

What challenges does the speaker face regarding the gravel floor?

The speaker faces challenges with the irregularity of the gravel, which can be treacherous for friends with balance issues.

What factors contribute to the speaker's decision not to pour more concrete?

The high cost of pouring concrete, estimated between $7,000 and $12,000, and the need to modify existing infrastructure are significant factors.

What type of gravel does the speaker use and why?

The speaker uses one-inch open gravel to prevent cats from digging and to minimize dust in the shop.

How does the speaker's personal experience influence their flooring choice?

The speaker values the practicality and comfort of gravel for their own use, allowing them to continue working on personal projects.

What impact does the flooring have on the speaker's physical comfort?

Standing on gravel is easier on the speaker's back compared to a hard, flat concrete floor, though the irregular surface can pose safety risks.

What future projects does the speaker have that may affect their flooring decision?

The speaker has various projects to complete, including building a bench and making swords for their grandkids, which are prioritized over flooring renovations.