CBS 4 BOOT CAMP MIAMI
Summary
TLDRCBS4 News investigates Florida's last remaining boot camp for juvenile offenders, offering a second chance to carjackers, burglars, and armed robbers. The program's rigorous discipline aims to reduce recidivism, with only 11% re-arrested within a year. Emotional stories of cadets like Jennifer Flores and Justin Martinez highlight the struggle and potential for rehabilitation amidst the harsh realities of crime and punishment.
Takeaways
- 🏢 The last remaining boot camp in Florida is a rehabilitation program for young offenders, including carjackers, burglars, and armed robbers.
- 🕗 The program begins at 4:00 a.m. with a rigorous schedule designed to instill discipline and teach consequences for actions.
- 👮♂️ Cadets face a verbal campaign of shock and awe upon arrival, intended to test their limits and prepare them for the challenges ahead.
- 🎓 The boot camp offers an alternative to prison, with the opportunity to complete the program and avoid incarceration.
- 🔢 Only 11% of boot camp graduates are rearrested within a year, a significantly lower recidivism rate compared to the state prison system.
- 👨👧👦 Many cadets come from difficult backgrounds, with some being homeless or having failed to finish high school.
- 🔄 The boot camp focuses on discipline and self-control, aiming to rebuild the cadets' character and prepare them for reintegration into society.
- 🏥 The program also includes education and job training components, with the goal of equipping cadets with the skills needed to succeed after graduation.
- 🚫 The boot camp has faced controversy due to physical punishments and the death of a cadet, leading to the closure of other similar programs in the state.
- 💼 Success stories from the program include cadets who have gone on to complete their education and find stable employment, demonstrating the potential for rehabilitation.
Q & A
What is the main focus of the special edition of CBS4 News?
-The main focus is on rehabilitation, specifically exploring the last remaining boot camp in Florida and its effectiveness in rehabilitating young offenders.
What is the boot camp program's success rate in terms of rearrest within a year for its graduates?
-Only 11% of the boot camp graduates are rearrested within a year.
What is the age range of the cadets featured in the CBS4 News report?
-The cadets in the report range in age from 16 to 24 years old.
What types of crimes are the cadets in the boot camp program guilty of?
-The cadets are guilty of various crimes including carjacking, burglary, armed robbery, and aggravated battery.
What is the significance of the 11% rearrest rate within a year for the boot camp graduates?
-The 11% rearrest rate is significant as it is substantially lower than the 27% recidivism rate in prison, indicating the program's effectiveness in rehabilitation.
How does the boot camp program differ from traditional prison sentences?
-The boot camp program focuses on discipline, self-control, and teaching consequences for actions, with the aim of rehabilitating the participants, unlike traditional prison sentences which are punitive.
What is the role of drill instructors in the boot camp program?
-Drill instructors in the boot camp program are responsible for teaching discipline, self-control, and the importance of following orders, often using physical exercises and verbal commands to instill these values.
What are the potential consequences for cadets who fail to complete the boot camp program?
-If a cadet fails to complete the boot camp program, they may have to serve the remainder of their prison sentence in state prison.
What support does the boot camp program offer to help prevent recidivism?
-The boot camp program offers education, including GED classes and job training, to help participants reintegrate into society and reduce the likelihood of reoffending.
How does the boot camp program impact the perception of the cadets towards their families and responsibilities?
-The program helps the cadets realize the importance of family and taking responsibility for their actions, with some expressing a desire to be better parents and children upon completion.
What was the outcome for the cadets mentioned in the CBS4 News report after their time in the boot camp?
-The report highlights that some cadets, like Justin Martinez and Jennifer Flores, successfully graduated from the program and were reunited with their families, while others, like Mark Andino, did not complete the program and faced further prison time.
Outlines
🛡️ Introduction to Florida's Last Boot Camp
The segment introduces a CBS4 News special edition focusing on rehabilitation within the criminal justice system, specifically the last remaining boot camp in Florida. The program offers a chance for young offenders, including carjackers, burglars, and armed robbers, to avoid prison by completing a rigorous training. The news team follows a class of 38 cadets, aged 16 to 24, as they endure the intense discipline and physical challenges of the boot camp. The program's goal is to reduce recidivism, with only 11% of graduates being rearrested within a year. The narrative features cadets like Jennifer Flores, who discusses her crime and the program's impact on her life.
🏛️ The Boot Camp's Impact and Challenges
This paragraph delves into the rehabilitative nature of the boot camp, contrasting it with traditional prison sentences. The program's effectiveness is discussed through the lens of Judge Nan Safy, who oversees serious offenses and believes in the camp's potential to transform lives. The narrative highlights the boot camp's methods, including instilling discipline and teaching consequences for actions. It also touches on the program's history, the public's skepticism, and the tragic death of a young cadet, Martin Lee Anderson, which led to the closure of other boot camps in the state. The financial and social implications of the program are also considered, with boot camp being a more expensive but potentially more effective alternative to prison.
🚨 Struggles and Setbacks in the Boot Camp
The focus shifts to the personal stories of cadets, including their struggles with the boot camp's demands and the impact on their lives. Lieutenant Rose Green, the camp's commander, discusses the slow progress of the cadets and the importance of their success. The narrative includes the story of a cadet who was shot after completing the program, emphasizing the challenges of reintegrating into society. Justin Martinez, another cadet, shares his desire to be a better father and person, while 16-year-old Christian Or Rojo grapples with the responsibility of fatherhood and the absence of his own. The boot camp's intense environment is portrayed, with drill instructors pushing cadets to their limits and the emotional toll it takes on them.
🏅 Success Stories and the Road to Redemption
This segment showcases the transformative power of the boot camp through the story of Jason Bravo, a former cadet who turned his life around after completing the program. Bravo's journey from a life of crime to becoming a successful lawyer is highlighted, emphasizing the boot camp's role in his rehabilitation. The narrative also follows current cadets as they approach graduation, with personal reflections on their growth and the challenges they've overcome. The emotional reunions of cadets with their families during the graduation ceremony underscore the program's human impact and the hope for a better future.
🎓 Graduation and the Path Forward
The final paragraph culminates in the graduation ceremony of platoon 141, where cadets receive their boot camp diplomas. The ceremony is a mix of emotions, with pledges, prayers, and speeches marking the cadets' achievements. Personal stories, such as Justin Martinez being named the platoon leader and Jennifer Flores overcoming her struggles, are highlighted. The narrative concludes with the cadets being reunited with their families, offering a glimpse into their future as they prepare to re-enter society, find jobs, and continue their education under supervision. The segment ends with an update on the cadets' progress, emphasizing the program's lasting impact on their lives.
Mindmap
Keywords
💡Rehabilitation
💡Boot Camp
💡Recidivism
💡Cadets
💡Discipline
💡Consequences
💡GED
💡Drill Instructors
💡Self-Control
💡Recidivism Rate
💡Graduation
Highlights
CBS4 News investigates the last remaining boot camp in Florida for rehabilitation of young offenders.
11% rearrest rate within a year for boot camp graduates, significantly lower than the national average.
The boot camp challenges cadets with a rigorous program designed to instill discipline and self-control.
Cadets range from 16 to 24 years old, facing sentences of up to 15 years in prison if they fail the program.
Judges offer the boot camp as a last chance for redemption, aiming to rehabilitate rather than punish.
Cadet Jennifer Flores shares her story of carjacking under the influence of drugs.
The youngest cadet, Christian or Rojo, was arrested for aggravated battery at 15, reflecting the camp's diverse cases.
Half of the class failed to finish high school, and six were homeless, indicating the socioeconomic challenges faced.
Sergeant William Das emphasizes the program's focus on building discipline and the consequences of actions.
Judge Nan Safy discusses the program's goal to create functioning members of society rather than hardened criminals.
The program's annual budget of $3.5 million faces scrutiny, with debates on its cost-effectiveness compared to prison.
Cadets are required to attend classes and work towards a GED or job training, preparing them for life after the program.
Justin Martinez, a former gang member, aims to turn his life around to be a better father to his children.
Cadet struggles are highlighted as they deal with the loss of a friend and the pressure to succeed.
Former Cadet Jason Bravo shares his success story, now a practicing lawyer after completing the boot camp.
Graduation marks a significant milestone for the cadets, symbolizing their progress and potential for a better future.
Post-boot camp, cadets return home to work and study, still under supervision for a year.
Transcripts
good evening and welcome to a special
edition of cbs4 news I'm investigator
Jim daiti in local news we spent a lot
of time talking about crime and
occasionally punishment but tonight
we're going to go in depth and talk
about Rehabilitation is it possible over
the next 30 minutes we are going to take
you inside the last remaining boot camp
in the State of Florida cbs4 news spent
four months following one class of
cadets a collect of carjackers and
burglars and armed robbers some will
Embrace this last chance others will not
for those who graduate only 11% will be
rearrested within a year but that's a
long way away for now they just have to
survive day
one that
go it's 4:00 a.m. and the first class of
2014 has arrived at the Miami day County
boot
camp move you going say something
understand that sir
understand
what there are 38 Cadets on the bus
ranging in age from 16 to 24 we going to
do it my way are we going to do it my
way there ain't no other way understand
that sir yes sir they have all put
guilty to a myriad of crimes and fac
sentences of up to 15 years in prison
let's go let's go let's go hurry up get
off the bus but the judges who sentenced
them offered them one last reprieve
complete the boot camp program and they
won't have to go to
prison I can't hear you I can't hear
you from the moment they arrive the
cadetes are subjected to a verbal
campaign of shock and awe designed to
test their
limits fre here everyone is treated the
same whether they look hard and
StreetWise or scared and in
f f f i can't see you f I can't hear you
my name is Jennifer I'm 18 years old I'm
in here for carjacking aggravated OFA FS
imprisonment and burgies Jennifer Flores
was 17 when she and her friend forced
their way into a stranger's car let's go
I was a my best friend which is a girl
and we were just messed up on drugs and
just wanted to take somebody's car we
got in his car and I grabbed him by the
back of his head and my codend started
just beating on him let's go today today
as a light rain falls the youngest Cadet
in the class appears
Overwhelmed Christian or Rojo was 15
when he was arrested for aggravated
battery after getting into a fight at a
party leaving the victim in a coma for 3
months and you hit him because cuz I was
drunk and he looked at me in the wrong
way the lack of self-control is a common
trait among the cadets half the class
failed to finish High School six of the
cadets were homeless and living on the
streets the key in boot camp is
discipline and the realization that
there are consequences for screwing up
no matter how small the screw up might
be
all right sir my name is Justin Martinez
I'm 22 and I was born and raised in
Colorado
Springs boot camp was designed for those
at are Crossroads and few fit that
description better than Martinez
Martinez's father spent most of Justin's
childhood in prison and Justin was well
on his way down that path as well his
father was the notorious street gang pyu
in Colorado after his mother moved into
Florida Martinez joined the homestead
gang nine try the gang tattoos evident
on his arms last year he was arrested
for a series of burglaries in which he
stole a gun why' you why'd you take a
gun it's easy to sell at the time I was
in my own apartment and I was short on
rent he said what haunt him is knowing
how much he hurt his mother a son always
knows his mother's pain look she gave me
she look she gave me when she came and
saw me the last time I knew she was
hurting because she couldn't look me in
my eyes so I know I put a lot of pain on
her test it's been 19 months since he
last saw his mother she told me the last
thing she said was to keep my head on
straight and she wrote me a letter the
other day that said to keep my head
forward because I have a hot head she
knows I have bu welcome to freaking
Miami g county freaking boot camp
Sergeant William Das helped launch the
County's boot camp program back in
1995 since then more than a thousand
Cadets have completed the program the
program is here for you it's not for us
all we want is your freaking best do you
understand me sir yes sir I'm a big fan
of boot camp tell me why um in part
because I think it's it's it is probably
the only program we have that is
rehabilitative in nature for adults
first of all for young adults it is it's
the only program we have that's not
prison Miami D circuit court judge Nan
safy oversees the Criminal Division of
the courthouse and knows she isn't
sending choir boys into the program some
of these folks have been convicted of
some really bad things I mean I would
say by and large it's pretty serious
offenses I would say most of the people
that I have sent to Camp were pretty
serious offenses you know there's a lot
of I mean you know the general sentiment
in the public if you ask the public you
know what should happen to somebody who
commits an armed robbery or a carjacking
or any of these things they say throw
them away throw them in prison I think
that that's people's initial reaction
but what I would tell you is that I've
had many cases where um I thought it was
my responsibility to make sure that the
people involved in the case knew what I
was about to do so the prosecutors would
bring the victims on these cases into
court and I did that on multiple
occasions and the one person that
disagreed with me said to me judge safy
I don't agree with you but I agree with
what you're trying to do so um what is
it that we're trying to do we're trying
to
ultimately create a a person that's
going to be a functioning member of
society and not create a person who's
going to come out of prison and be a
bigger batter better Criminal according
to judge safy for many of these young
criminals boot camp may be their last
opportunity to learn right from wrong
what they tell you in boot camp is that
they basically strip the kid down to
they strip the person down to to Bare
Bones and they build them back up and
they're they're part of a team they're
part of a
platoon and they're definitely taught
consequences which I think is huge
they're they're taught to really believe
in themselves and all it is is about
giving the kid a chance ultimately if
the if the cadet fails prison is waiting
prison the bus is waiting their Prison
number is waiting from the moment they
arrive they are told there is a right
way to do something and a wrong way they
teach them how to stand how to feet how
to hold their canteens they teach them
how to sit I'm not taking my littley
time I'm not do I'm not taking my time
all to se dirty whatever I'm sitting
down like a rock you understand they
even show them the right way to lower
their head in prayer ready ready ready
PR and if they mess up they'll all be
smoked smoking them is when they have
done something incorrectly and we get
them to do whatever the excise exercises
that we as them to do if you move and I
don't give you permission you will pay I
if he messes up you will all pay I if he
doesn't sound off you will all PID out
of the corner of her eye she catches one
of the cadetes scratching his face when
I tell you stop freaking moving stop
moving but using exercise's punishment
has proved dangerous let's go let's go
get it going let's
go in 2006 14-year-old Martin Lee
Anderson died in a City Boot Camp
Anderson who suffered from asthma was
unable to run as guards ordered videos
showed the guards punishing him by
taking him to the ground and forcing him
to breathe in ammonia the public outcry
marked a turning point for boot camps as
a result the legislature closed all five
of its camps across the state and in
2007 the Broward Sheriff closed its boot
camp program to save money miam me D's
program is the last in the state and
with an annual budget of $3.5 million it
too faces a carious future mayor Carl s
menz proposed closing the program this
year to save tax dollars but came up
with the money under pressure at the
last minute to save it for now boot
camps are an inherent gamble the safe
bet would be to send these offenders to
State Prison where cost just
$47.50 a day to house and feed them but
this is a long-term bet you might even
call it an investment an investment in
all our names take Justin Martinez a
5-year prison term would cost tax payers
$86,900 the 16-month boot camp just
46,4 53 more important than the money
though is the hope that the program will
keep Cadets from committing new offenses
the recidivism rate in prison is 27%
within the boot camp it's just 11% in
boot camp they are required to attend
classes and most war in a GED while here
those who already have a high school
diploma receive job training hey
but the cadets of platoon 14-1 are still
a long way from success when we come
back which Cadets will make it and who
will wash
[Music]
out two weeks into boot camp and the
cadets of class 141 are proving to be
more difficult than the instructors had
hoped
every time she act crazy you going to
pay for it talking to you little mama
the drill instructors have them so
rattled one Cadet keeps referring to his
male drill instructor as a woman all
right man you call me a man you got be
at your freaking you ever call me a
again we going have a problem you
understand me you understand me you hear
me get your
eyeb p p p p p get your M and your s
together you fig it out the boot Camp's
Commander is Lieutenant Rose green I've
watched the progression it's very slow
at this point and I I still see that
they're very raw on this day in January
there was a stark reminder of what's at
stake and why getting them to succeed is
so important to De M St Flo green had
just learned a Cadet who completed the
program in December was shot and killed
in front of his house Mackenzie St FL um
17 years old we released him December
19th I believe he went back to the same
home that he came from so if that's the
case he he went back to the very streets
that he came from unfortunately well
there there not a lot of options
sometimes they have to go back to a lot
of times they have to go back to the
same streets don't they absolutely
absolutely and that's why we try to
fortified them St FL had passed his GED
exam while at the boot camp but he never
received the actual diploma the
certificate didn't arrive from
Tallahassee until the day of his funeral
Justin Martinez is hoping for a
different fate I want to know how to be
a father for one I have a son that's one
and my daughter's three the most
important thing he said he can do is
provide a better example for his kids as
they grow up I never knew how to work
for anything and if I when I did work I
never appreciate working I could have
gave back to my mother and my kids but
instead I spent it on myself 16-year-old
or Rojo is already the father of a boy
and a girl and Flora is a three-year-old
son I had him when I was 15 she hasn't
seen her son in 8 months my mom told him
that mommy's way for being mad that Mom
mom is a Time M so when I talk to him he
tells me to behave
good
and and I get pictures of him too I have
pictures of him
and I just I feel so bad for not being
there for him right
now like it's crazy I had to go through
all this to
realize how important
family
is oh I'm
[Music]
sorry since the start of boot camp one
frequent Target for the drill
instructors was a familiar
face Mark Andino is what is known as a
recycle he was in the program last year
but ran into trouble and quit he then
pleaded to the judge to let him try
again now he's back and the drill
instructors are all over I know how you
that you me son the charge that landed
him here in boot camp armed robbery my
girlfriend was pregnant I was under a
lot of pressure and I made a stupid
decision and I robbed a jewelry store
anything you think I don't remember
you I'm talking to
you you know what son you better get new
this your second time around right you
need to get right you understand me
don't be a freaking statistic do you
understand me nearly two months have now
passed and the cadets are starting to
show some signs of improvement they seem
to be getting it for me to be able to
contain my anger and contain my
self-control in this place as long as
I've did shows a lot about what these
people do here and you know they talk to
us yeah they yell at us but nobody sees
the the behind the scenes act when they
talk to us and give us words of
encouragement for some the drill
instructors transition from guards to
the parents they never had they they
beat on us but I realized the difference
between picking on me and trying to help
me one person who failed to make that
connection was Andino the cadet had
finally run out of Second
Chances Mr adino um refuse you honor to
comply with the instructions
and orders for the program not even
halfway through the program Andino has
had enough after refusing orders and
threatening staff the drill instructors
decided it was time for him to get on
that bus for state prison on this day
they were updating the judge that
granted him boot camp your client is
potentially facing some very serious
consequences flunking out of boot camp
many he would have to serve the
remainder of a six-year sentence in
state prison we caught up to him a
couple weeks later inside the jail where
he was waiting to be transferred to
State custody once you got out of boot
camp and once they brought you here yeah
I felt stupid you realiz you
made I felt stupid because you know I
know what I traded out I traded out some
months for some
years and Dino said he couldn't handle
being disrespected by the drill
instructors and forced to endure some of
the physical punishments like crawling
through the
pit go at the moment is like my mind's
just I want to escape I want to get out
of here I want to get out of here I want
to get out of here and when I had the
time to sit there and I'm they brought
me back to the jail and I had the time
to sit there and really think about it I
felt stupid cuz I you
know I gave it all up I gave my freedom
up I I let a lot of people
down you know what I mean for just for
[Music]
nothing if Andino represents the failure
of the boot camp system former Cadet
Jason Bravo is one of the Seasons the
instructors have hope if I wanted to do
something I'd just do it and and looking
back on it all I did was everything I
did was self-destructive few people
understand where these Cadets are coming
from better than Jason bravo bravo was
17 when he was arrested for armed
robbery and assault he was facing a
15-year prison sentence when the judge
offered him a chance at boot camp that
was in
1998 this was my b top uh bottom bottom
this was my bunk right here I left the
line up this this is where uh we'd eat
Chow three times a day
um lot of lot of good memories here are
there really yeah I mean looking back at
it it it was only for the best at least
for me and and like I said I made uh
real friends here with the officers
particularly they they took a vested
interest in those who really took their
recovery seriously it's a discipline
right it's that idea of of you got to do
what you got to do it's it's it's more
than that it's the discipline but it's
also a level of respect that you earn
from them and then once they get once
you earn that respect they treat you
like a human being and then you
understand why they're doing it then you
see that their motives and their
intentions are are good and it only then
you worry about disappointing them or
you want to uh earn their approval the
jural instructors not only helped him
get through the program but the staff
wrote letters of recommendation to get
him into college and then law school
after Bravo passed his bar exam in 2008
the Florida bar held up his license
because of his prior felony arrest but
once again it was the drill instructors
who came through vouching for his
character now at 33 he's been practicing
law for 4 years and he's paying it back
by talking to the cadets there's nothing
that I accomplished before my life I
accomplished nothing before I came to
boot camp probably the first thing that
I did in my life that was worth
mentioning in a positive way was
graduating from boot camp the when we
return the big day for these Cadets has
finally
[Music]
[Music]
arrived by may just three boot camp
Cadets from Platoon 141 had washed out
of phase one that left 35 headed toward
graduation hours before the ceremony
Justin Martinez's thoughts turned to his
family yeah I'm hoping that that that
the the accomplishment that I may here
proves myself worthy to them prove
myself worthy to them and myself because
um that's my main goal trying to trying
to please myself but also show my family
that I am something other than what they
always lab me as a nobody his drill
instructors say he's made an amazing
turnaround during the 4 months he's been
in boot camp everyone thinks it's easy
while you're in here because they're on
you they're yelling at you they're
telling you what to do the question is 6
n months from now when you're out of
here yeah what's going to be different
that's the test this right here like you
said is the easy part you got somebody
always over your head it's it's it's not
so difficult to fight temptation but
when you get in the streets you have
nobody to to stop that Temptation from
hitting you and if you don't have the
the quality of that they teach you here
and you keep it up when you're on the
outside you going to fall regardless
Jennifer Flores had a harder time in
boot camp she admits she didn't think
she would make it to graduation when you
come here they put you down and you just
feel like you ain't going to be able to
do it it's so hard but it's like now
it's the end like you finally see the
light a week earlier one of flores's
best friends 19-year-old Viva karea was
shot to death standing in front of a
house in Little Havana I know she wasn't
around guns or anything like that cuz
she's not that type but I know she was
around with guys that probably had guns
after learning about the shooting Flora
started acting out refusing orders
rather than coddling her because her
friend had died the instructors went at
Flores harder telling her everyone has
to deal with horrible events on the
outside the world isn't fair but that
doesn't give them permission to screw up
it happened to her but it could have
been
me as platoon 14-1 marches onto the
field friends and family members trained
to get a look it's the first time in
months they've seen their loved ones and
the ceremony lasts an hour with pledges
and prayers and speeches and then one at
a time they're called forward to receive
their boot camp diplomas Christian aru
sir Jennifer
Flores Justin Martinez Martinez has
excelled in the boot camp and was named
the platoon's leader boot camp has
restored our confidence and our will to
fight for what we believe in but all of
it is Prelude to that moment when their
finally
[Applause]
[Applause]
dismissed across the yard the tearful
scene is repeated
Christian is reunited with his two
children as well as his mom his name is
Conor he's 5 months that's Christopher
he's 2 years old I'm proud of him and
and I thank God because I see him and he
changed a lot a short distance away
Justin is with the women in his life his
baby girl his mother and his grandmother
he's happy he's at peace with himself I
can tell he's at peace and I'm happy
about that before he went into this
where was he heading down a dark road
down a dark Road the next phase will
begin the process of finding jobs and
entering the work release phase of the
program but for now the five minutes
they're given to see and hold family
members is enough to keep them going the
drill instructor counts down the final
16 14 13
[Music]
11 you bye
seven 6
5
4 and with that they're gone and for
some they can begin imagining their
future
to the
rare third to the
rare to the rear third spot to the r two
months after this ceremony the cadets
were allowed to return home and begin
working and going to school again they
will remain under supervision for
another year and if they stay out of
trouble their court cases will be closed
now we finish tonight with an update on
how some of the cadets are doing thanks
for watching I'm Jim
cbs4 news in depth
[Music]
تصفح المزيد من مقاطع الفيديو ذات الصلة
I Want To Be A K-Pop Idol: Can Intensive Bootcamps In South Korea Help? - Part 2 | Talking Point
Juvenile Delinquency: Two Types of Criminal Careers
Who Created The Juvenile 'Superpredators'?
Inside Juvenile Detention
How I learned to read - and trade stocks - in prison | Curtis "Wall Street" Carroll | TEDxSanQuentin
Pros & Cons - Juvenile Justice and Welfare Act
5.0 / 5 (0 votes)