Karim Suryadi - Ketika Demokrasi Tanpa Demos
Summary
TLDRThe script addresses the concerns over the nomination of presidential candidates in 2024, questioning the transparency and public participation in the process. It critiques the dominance of party leaders in selecting candidates and the lack of open nomination. The speaker calls for a more democratic approach, emphasizing the importance of ethical decision-making and accountability to both God and the people. The script also urges the media to provide comprehensive coverage of potential leaders, advocating for a democracy that truly represents the people's will.
Takeaways
- 🗳️ The script discusses the nomination of presidential candidates in 2024, suggesting that the process is influenced by party leaders rather than public participation.
- 🤔 It questions whether there will be any change in the nomination process, given past experiences where party leaders decide the candidates.
- 👥 The script highlights the importance of public participation in the nomination process, emphasizing that democracy should involve the people.
- 📜 It points out that while there are no laws requiring open nomination of candidates, the spirit of democracy and Pancasila principles suggest that decisions should be accountable to the people.
- 🤝 The script calls for party leaders and activists to act wisely and honor the voice and will of the people in the nomination process.
- 📢 It urges the media to provide more coverage of potential leaders, offering a broader perspective beyond surveys and polls.
- 🚫 The script warns against using party politics as a tool to manipulate public opinion or to rubber-stamp decisions made by a few within the party.
- 🙅♂️ It criticizes the notion of party politics overshadowing the will of the people, suggesting that parties should not become a 'stomach' for the desires of a few.
- 🌟 The script ends with a call for integrity and the elevation of the voice of the people in the political process, aiming for a democracy that truly represents the people.
Q & A
What is the main concern expressed in the script about the nomination of presidential candidates?
-The main concern is the lack of transparency and public participation in the nomination process, which is often controlled by party leaders rather than reflecting the will of the people.
What historical event from 2019 is mentioned in the script that illustrates the issue with the nomination process?
-The script refers to a fragmentation incident in 2019 where a potential vice-presidential candidate had to wait until the end of the process, only to be proven wrong, illustrating the unpredictability and control by party leaders.
What is the speaker's fear regarding the future of the nomination process?
-The speaker fears that there will be no change in the nomination process and that party politics will continue to overshadow the democratic will of the people.
How does the script use the story of Jalaluddin Rumi to convey a message about the nomination process?
-The story of Jalaluddin Rumi is used as a metaphor to criticize the self-righteousness and lack of self-awareness in the nomination process, where people might not realize the true reasons behind their decisions.
What does the script suggest about the role of party politics in the nomination process?
-The script suggests that party politics should not be a tool to manipulate the will of the people but should instead serve to amplify the voices and aspirations of the public.
What is the importance of the media's role as highlighted in the script?
-The script emphasizes the media's role in providing extensive coverage of potential leaders, offering a strength map and alternative views beyond surveys, to ensure a more democratic and informed nomination process.
What is the script's stance on the ethical principles that should guide the nomination process?
-The script advocates for the nomination process to be guided by ethical principles that ensure decisions are accountable to both God and the people, reflecting the true spirit of democracy.
Outlines
😀 Public Nomination for Presidential Candidates
The paragraph discusses the nomination of a presidential candidate for the 2024 election, suggesting that the public is being encouraged to nominate a candidate. It questions whether this is a sign of improved public participation in the nomination process. The speaker reflects on past experiences where the choice of candidates was entirely up to the party leaders, even leading to a fragmentation incident in 2019. The paragraph emphasizes the importance of considering the public's voice in the selection process and not just relying on party politics. It also mentions the ethical teachings of Pancasila, which call for decisions to be accountable to God and the people, suggesting that party politics should not overshadow the will of the people.
Mindmap
Keywords
💡Partai
💡Pencalonan Presiden
💡Relawan
💡Pimpinan Partai
💡Demokrasi
💡Pancasila
💡Kedaulatan Partai
💡Media
💡Kehendak Masyarakat
💡Etika
💡Permusyawaratan
Highlights
The discussion suggests that the selection of a presidential candidate for 2024 is being influenced by party leaders rather than public participation.
There is a historical pattern where party leaders decide the presidential candidate without full public involvement.
The speaker expresses concern that the current process may not change and could continue to be dominated by party politics.
The narrative includes a historical reference to the 2019 political fragmentation and its impact on the selection of presidential running mates.
The speaker warns against prematurely judging the decision-making process based on outcomes, as there are many factors at play.
An anecdote is shared about Jalaluddin Rumi to illustrate the consequences of not considering the full context of decisions.
The speaker questions the necessity of open nominations for presidential candidates, suggesting that current laws may not require them.
The importance of democratic principles is emphasized, with a call for government truly 'of the people, by the people, and for the people'.
The speaker argues that party politics should not overshadow the will of the people or the democratic process.
The ethical principles of Pancasila are invoked, emphasizing accountability to God and the community in decision-making.
The role of party politics in channeling the voice and aspirations of the people is discussed, with a call for ethical conduct.
The speaker warns against using party politics as a tool to enforce the will of a few and against treating the people as mere rubber stamps.
A call to action is made for party leaders and activists to make wise decisions that honor the voice and will of the people.
The hope is expressed for a democracy that is not devoid of the people or the 'demos', emphasizing the need for a true democratic process.
The media is encouraged to provide more coverage on potential leaders who are worthy of leading the republic, offering a broader perspective beyond surveys.
The conclusion is a call for honor and integrity in the decision-making process, ensuring that democracy is served by the people and for the people.
Transcripts
Hai
[Musik]
[Tepuk tangan]
[Musik]
Wah lama pimpinan partai menebar baliho
yang mengarah kepada pencalonan Presiden
2024
Hai dan beberapa kelompok masyarakat pun
mengatasnamakan relawan seorang yang
disebut-sebut sebagai bakal calon
presiden 2024
Halo apakah ini merupakan gejala
membaiknya partisipasi masyarakat dalam
nominasi Resident
Ayo kita tidak melihat perubahan kearah
itu
Hai karena pengalaman kita menunjukkan
siapa yang akan diusung oleh partai atau
koalisi partai
sepenuhnya diserahkan kepada pimpinan
partai politik bahkan ketua umum partai
politik tentu kita masih ingat fragmen
yang terjadi pada 2019 Ketika seseorang
yang digadang-gadang akan mendampingi
salah satu calon presiden harus menunggu
sampai akhir penantian dan yang terbukti
Jadi bukan dia
ini apakah kita akan terus menjalani
pragmen seperti ini
Hai Saya khawatir tidak akan ada
perubahan dan mungkin ada pimpinan
partai politik mengatakan kamu jangan
sok tahu tentang bagaimana cara kita
memilih
bakal calon presiden karena terbukti apa
yang kita putuskan menjadi pemenang kita
ingin Ingatkan wahai bom Jangan pernah
sekali-kali menilai proses pengambilan
keputusan dari hasilnya karena banyak
sekali faktor yang menentukan
keberhasilan
jangan sampai
Ayo kita dicap
berpikiran seperti beonya Jalaluddin
Rumi
hai ketika dia ngoceh dan membuat marah
pemiliknya lalu dipukul kepalanya hingga
botak dan dia tidak bisa bicara beberapa
bulan sampai suatu hari ada seorang yang
lewat didepan tokonya dan terlihat oleh
beol dia berteriak wahai botak
Hai kesalahan apakah yang kau lakukan
hingga membuat Tuan mau marah dan
memukul kepalamu hingga botak
Hai beo mengira setiap kebotakan
disebabkan oleh kesalahannya dan pukulan
sang pemilik toko mungkin pula dan
berdalih mengapakah kita harus
mempersoalkan pemilihan calon presiden
Bukankah tidak ada satupun pasal yang
mengharuskan kita melakukan nominasi
kandidat secara terbuka betul tetapi
anda tidak akan lupa bahwa tidak semua
kebajikan tertuang di dalam pasal-pasal
undang-undang
Hai kalau kita kembali kepada kesejatian
demokrasi
Hai Pemerintahan dari rakyat oleh rakyat
dan untuk rakyat sejatinya
kemeriahan antusiasme dan keinginan
layak menominasikan seseorang tidak
dibajak oleh pimpinan partai politik
atas nama kedaulatan partai betul apapun
boleh dilakukan oleh partai politik
melalui permusyawaratan tetapi etika
Pancasila mengajarkan Setiap keputusan
yang diambil harus bisa
dipertanggungjawabkan kepada Tuhan dan
kepada masyarakat lantas Mengapa Ribuan
Orang dihimpun di dalam partai politik
kalau bukan Untuk didengar suaranya
disalurkan aspirasinya dan dibimbing ke
langkah yang benar tentang pemikiran
berbangsa dan bernegara jangan sampai
jadikan partai politik sebagai kedok
untuk menggembalakan kehendak ketuanya
dan jangan sampai jadikan rakyat sebagai
stempel untuk mengesahkan keputusan yang
diambil oleh seseorang yang bernaung di
dalam partai klik kita ingin mengetuk
Nurani Pimpinan dan aktifis partai
politik untuk mengambil langkah cerdas
pemuliaan suara dan kehendak masyarakat
agar jangan sampai demokrasi kita tanpa
rakyat atau demokrasi tanpa demos dan
kita pun berharap kepada media untuk
memperbanyak liputan khusus tentang
sosok-sosok yang layak memimpin republik
ini sehingga menjadi peta kekuatan
sekaligus alternatif pandangan diluar
survei
Hai inilah jalan Kemuliaan bagi kita
semua
hai hai
[Musik]
[Tepuk tangan]
[Musik]
تصفح المزيد من مقاطع الفيديو ذات الصلة
DELOGU NE SAIT PAS LIRE, BOYARD HUMILIÉ ET SHESHOUNET MONTE AU CRENEAUX
What is Good Governance?
“We Have Been LIED TO...” The Dr Banned For Speaking Out | Dr Aseem Malhotra
JANGAN MENGAKU DEMOKRASI, TAPI MEMUPUK DINASTI!!
COULD KAMALA BEAT TRUMP?
VIRAL || HARAM PILIH PRABOWO, RIBUAN KADER GOLKAR BERSAMA GANJAR PRANOWO DI PILPRES 2024_2029
5.0 / 5 (0 votes)