Social Security: The Greatest Government Policy of All Time?

The Atlantic

20 Oct 201402:54

Summary

TLDRThe Social Security Act, signed by FDR in 1935, has been instrumental in reducing poverty among the elderly. Despite criticisms as a Ponzi scheme or facing bankruptcy, it has been a successful government policy, lifting 22 million Americans out of poverty, including a significant portion of seniors. The program is funded by payroll taxes and provides benefits to retirees, families of deceased workers, and disabled individuals. While concerns exist about its sustainability due to the aging population, the program's effectiveness in combating poverty is undeniable, and adjustments can ensure its continued success.

Takeaways

📜 Social Security was signed into law by Franklin Delano Roosevelt in 1935 to combat poverty among the elderly.
💼 It operates as a payroll tax, taking about 1/8 of a worker's salary up to a certain cap, and funds approximately 96% of the program.
👵👴 Social Security benefits are not only for retirees but also for families of deceased workers and disabled Americans.
💼 The amount one receives upon retirement is based on their earnings and work duration; higher earners get larger checks.
🚫 Critics argue Social Security is a Ponzi scheme or is on the verge of bankruptcy, but the program is financially stable and successful.
🏆 It has been incredibly effective, eliminating the majority of elderly poverty and lifting 22 million Americans out of poverty.
🌐 Social Security is a critical source of income for a significant portion of Black and Hispanic retirees.
👎 Some fear it will go bankrupt due to the aging baby boomer population, but adjustments can be made to sustain it.
💸 Contrary to claims of excessive generosity, the U.S. has one of the least generous public retirement programs among wealthy nations.
💡 The program encourages a prudent approach to retirement, offering security in exchange for responsible contributions during working years.
🤔 The debate around Social Security reflects broader discussions on the role of social welfare and individual responsibility in society.

Q & A

What was the primary purpose of establishing Social Security in 1935?
-The primary purpose of establishing Social Security in 1935 was to reduce poverty among the elderly.
What percentage of a worker's salary is typically taken for Social Security, and is there a cap on this?
-Social Security takes about 1/8 of each worker's salary, and there is a cap, with the payroll tax applying only to income up to about $113,000.
How does Social Security distribute its benefits?
-Social Security provides benefits to retired workers, families of deceased workers, and disabled Americans and their families.
What are the two main factors that determine the amount of Social Security benefits one receives upon retirement?
-The two main factors that determine the amount of Social Security benefits are how much one has earned and how long one has worked.
How does Social Security benefit higher earning workers compared to lower income workers?
-Higher earning workers receive larger Social Security checks upon retirement because they paid more into the system, but lower income workers receive checks that represent a larger percentage of their income.
What impact has Social Security had on poverty rates among the elderly in the United States?
-Social Security has eliminated the vast majority of elderly poverty in America, lifting 22 million Americans out of poverty, including about a third of senior citizens.
Is Social Security considered a Ponzi scheme by some, and what does the script suggest about this view?
-Some people consider Social Security a Ponzi scheme, but the script argues that it is actually much better than fine and might be the largest and most successful government policy in U.S. history.
What are the concerns regarding the financial future of Social Security, as mentioned in the script?
-The script mentions concerns that the baby boomer generation will deplete the $3 trillion stockpile Social Security has, potentially affecting payments to senior citizens by 2033.
What is suggested as a solution to the potential financial challenges facing Social Security?
-The script suggests that rather than dismantling Social Security, it should be tweaked, as it has been many times before, to address financial challenges.
How does the script address the argument that Social Security is too generous?
-The script argues that the U.S. has one of the least generous public retirement programs among rich economies and that Americans do not save enough on their own, suggesting that Social Security is probably not generous enough.
What is the script's stance on the idea of Social Security being a form of socialism?
-The script acknowledges that Social Security might be considered a form of socialism but frames it as a necessary socialism that saves people from the consequences of their lack of savings.

Outlines

00:00

📊 Social Security: A Historical Overview and Its Impact

This paragraph discusses the inception of Social Security in the United States under President Franklin D. Roosevelt in 1935. It was designed to combat poverty among the elderly. Despite criticisms ranging from being a Ponzi scheme to facing bankruptcy, the Social Security program has been remarkably successful, potentially being the largest and most effective government policy in U.S. history. It operates through payroll taxes, which fund about 96% of the program, and provides benefits to retired workers, families of deceased workers, and disabled Americans. The amount one receives upon retirement is determined by their earnings and work duration, with higher earners getting larger checks but lower-income workers receiving a higher percentage of their income back. The program has been instrumental in eliminating elderly poverty, lifting 22 million Americans out of poverty, including a significant portion of senior citizens and minority retirees who rely heavily on Social Security for their income.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡Social Security

Social Security refers to the government program established in 1935 by Franklin Delano Roosevelt, aimed at reducing poverty among the elderly. It is a cornerstone of the U.S. social safety net, providing financial support to retired workers, families of deceased workers, and disabled Americans. The video script discusses the program's effectiveness in eliminating elderly poverty and its role as a significant anti-poverty measure, lifting millions of Americans out of poverty.

💡Ponzi scheme

A Ponzi scheme is a fraudulent investing scam promising high rates of return with little risk to investors, where returns are actually paid to earlier investors using the capital of newer investors. The script addresses the misconception that Social Security is a Ponzi scheme, arguing that it is a stable and successful government policy that has provided financial security to millions.

💡Payroll tax

The payroll tax is a tax levied on an employee's earnings, with a portion of it going towards funding Social Security. The script explains that about 1/8 of each worker's salary, up to a certain limit, is subject to this tax, which is how the Social Security program is primarily funded. This tax is a key component of the program's financial structure and its ability to provide benefits.

💡Retired workers

Retired workers are individuals who have reached the age of retirement and are no longer actively employed. In the context of the video, retired workers are a primary beneficiary group of Social Security, receiving financial support after they stop working. The script highlights that Social Security plays a crucial role in their financial well-being, often providing a significant portion of their income.

💡Elderly poverty

Elderly poverty refers to the economic hardship faced by older adults, often due to lack of savings, limited income sources, or increased medical expenses. The video emphasizes the role of Social Security in virtually eliminating elderly poverty in America, demonstrating its effectiveness as a social program aimed at ensuring the financial security of the aging population.

💡Baby boomers

Baby boomers are the demographic cohort following the World War II baby boom, generally referring to those born between 1946 and 1964. The script mentions baby boomers in the context of their impact on Social Security's financial sustainability, as their retirement will gradually draw down the program's reserves, raising concerns about the program's future funding.

💡Anti-poverty program

An anti-poverty program is a government initiative designed to reduce or eliminate poverty. The video positions Social Security as one of the most effective anti-poverty programs in U.S. history, emphasizing its role in lifting millions out of poverty, particularly among senior citizens and minority groups.

💡Public retirement programs

Public retirement programs are government-sponsored systems that provide financial support to individuals upon retirement. The script compares the U.S. Social Security program with other rich economies' public retirement programs, noting that the U.S. has one of the least generous such programs, suggesting that Social Security's benefits may not be as extensive as those in other countries.

💡Financial sustainability

Financial sustainability refers to the ability of a program or system to maintain its operations over the long term without depleting its resources. The video discusses concerns about Social Security's financial sustainability, particularly in light of the retiring baby boomer population, and suggests that adjustments may be necessary to ensure the program's continued viability.

💡Income replacement

Income replacement is the practice of providing benefits to replace a portion of an individual's lost income, often due to retirement, disability, or unemployment. The script explains how Social Security provides income replacement for retired workers, with higher earners receiving larger checks but lower-income workers receiving a larger percentage of their previous income.

💡Socialism

Socialism is an economic and political system where the means of production, distribution, and exchange are owned or regulated by the community as a whole. The video briefly touches on the idea that Social Security might be considered a form of socialism, providing a collective benefit funded by individual contributions, and it reflects on the program's role in mitigating the effects of human nature regarding individual savings and financial planning.

Highlights

Social Security Act was signed by Franklin Delano Roosevelt on August 14th, 1935, to reduce poverty among the elderly.

Social Security is often criticized as a Ponzi scheme or being on the verge of bankruptcy, but it is actually very successful.

Social Security is funded by a payroll tax of about 1/8 on each worker's salary up to approximately $113,000.

The program provides benefits to retired workers, families of deceased workers, and disabled Americans and their families.

Retirement benefits are determined by considering an individual's earnings and work duration.

Higher earning workers receive larger checks upon retirement, reflecting their greater contributions.

Lower income workers receive a larger percentage of their income in Social Security checks.

Social Security has been instrumental in eliminating the majority of elderly poverty in America.

The program lifts 22 million Americans out of poverty, including about a third of senior citizens.

Half of Black and Hispanic retirees rely on Social Security for 90% of their income.

Social Security might be the most effective anti-poverty program in U.S. history.

Concerns about Social Security going bankrupt are based on the impact of baby boomers on the $3 trillion stockpile.

By 2033, adjustments may be necessary to maintain full benefits for all senior citizens.

Critics argue that Social Security is too generous, but the U.S. has one of the least generous public retirement programs among rich economies.

Many Americans do not save adequately, making Social Security a necessary support system.

Social Security represents a form of socialism that protects against the consequences of human nature.