Patriotism Vs Nationalism | What is the difference between Patriotism and Nationalism?
Summary
TLDRIn 'Illustrate to Educate,' Dan Zimmerman explores the nuanced differences between patriotism and nationalism. He traces the origins of both terms, noting that while patriotism emerged in 1653, emphasizing love and unity for one's country, nationalism appeared later, around the 19th century, and has evolved to include a sense of superiority and exclusivity. Zimmerman highlights that patriotism is generally positive, associated with devotion to a country's values like freedom and justice, whereas nationalism can carry negative connotations, often linked with distrust of other nations. He also discusses the potential positive role of nationalism in uniting people against injustice, such as in the Zionist movement. The video invites viewers to reflect on these concepts and their implications in contemporary society.
Takeaways
- 📜 The term 'patriotism' dates back to around 1653, while 'nationalism' didn't emerge until the late 18th century, about 150 years later.
- 🔍 Initially, 'nationalism' and 'patriotism' were used interchangeably, but their meanings have diverged over time.
- ❤️ Patriotism is defined as a love for one's country and unity with fellow citizens who share that love.
- 🏛 Nationalism involves loyalty and devotion to one's nation, with an emphasis on promoting its culture and interests above others.
- 🤔 The distinction between patriotism and nationalism is debated, with no official consensus among scholars.
- 🌟 Patriotism is often associated with positive values like freedom, justice, equality, and bravery.
- 🏅 Nationalism can imply a belief in the superiority of one's nation and may include distrust or disapproval of other countries.
- 💭 Patriotism is seen as inherently good, believing in the goodness of the government and people working together for a better life.
- 🏙 Nationalism can be associated with political ideologies that promote extreme and exclusionary love of one's country.
- 👍 Nationalism has been a motivator for independence movements and can be used to unite people against injustice.
- 🌐 The script suggests that embracing a strong national identity might be key to achieving peace in regions divided by tribal and religious identities.
Q & A
What is the main topic of the video 'Illustrate to Educate' by Dan Zimmerman?
-The main topic of the video is to explore and explain the essential differences between patriotism and nationalism.
When does the word 'patriotism' date back to, according to the script?
-The word 'patriotism' dates back to around 1653, with the word 'patriot' traceable even further to the Greek word 'patrio', meaning 'one's father'.
How does the script describe the early use of the word 'nationalism' in comparison to 'patriotism'?
-The script indicates that 'nationalism' was not in use until just before the 19th century, almost 150 years after 'patriotism', and initially, the two terms were largely interchangeable.
What is the current definition of 'patriotism' as per the video?
-Patriotism is defined as the feeling of love for one's country, along with a feeling of unity with those who share those feelings, and is also described as devoted love, support, and defense of one's country.
What is the modern definition of 'nationalism' according to the script?
-Nationalism is defined as loyalty and devotion to a nation, with an added emphasis on exalting one's nation above all others and promoting its culture and interests over those of other nations.
What is the key difference between patriotism and nationalism as discussed in the video?
-The key difference is that patriotism is based on positive values and the belief in the inherent goodness of one's country and its people, while nationalism is based on the belief in the superiority of one's country over others and can carry connotations of distrust or disapproval of other countries.
How does the video describe the connotation of the term 'nationalism' in contemporary usage?
-The video describes the term 'nationalism' as generally having a negative connotation, often associated with extreme and exclusionary ideologies that prioritize one's country at the expense of others.
What is the perspective of Sidney J. Harris on the difference between patriotism and nationalism, as mentioned in the video?
-Sidney J. Harris suggests that the difference between patriotism and nationalism is that a patriot is proud of their country for what it does, while a nationalist is proud of their country no matter what it does.
Can nationalism ever be seen as positive or beneficial, according to the video?
-Yes, the video suggests that nationalism can be a strong motivator for uniting people, driving independence movements, and potentially contributing to peace negotiations by fostering a strong national identity over tribal or religious identities.
What is the script's advice on how to use the terms 'patriotism' and 'nationalism'?
-The script advises to keep context and connotation in mind when using these terms, as 'patriotism' generally has a positive connotation associated with love of country and serving the greater good, while 'nationalism' often has a negative connotation linked to extreme ideologies.
What does the video suggest for viewers to do after watching?
-The video encourages viewers to like, share, and subscribe to 'Illustrate to Educate', comment on their thoughts about patriotism and nationalism, and to check out other videos on the channel.
Outlines
📚 Introduction to Patriotism and Nationalism
Dan Zimmerman introduces the topic of the difference between patriotism and nationalism, inviting viewers to subscribe for more educational content. He begins by exploring the historical origins of both terms, noting that patriotism dates back to 1653, while nationalism emerged later, around the 19th century. Initially, the two were used interchangeably, but their meanings have since diverged. Patriotism is described as a love for one's country and unity with fellow citizens, whereas nationalism involves loyalty and devotion to one's nation, often with an emphasis on superiority over others.
🏛 Definitions and Distinctions
This section delves into the definitions of patriotism and nationalism, highlighting their essential differences. Patriotism is characterized by a love for one's country and a belief in its inherent goodness, promoting a positive value system such as freedom, justice, and equality. Nationalism, in contrast, is defined by loyalty and devotion but also includes the belief in the nation's superiority and the promotion of its interests above others. The summary also touches on the debate among scholars regarding the distinction between the two concepts, emphasizing the subjective nature of these definitions.
🤔 Comparing Patriotism and Nationalism
The script discusses how to compare the two concepts, noting the ongoing debate and lack of consensus among scholars and social scientists. Patriotism is associated with positive values and the belief in the goodness of the country's system and people, while nationalism is tied to a belief in the nation's superiority and can carry connotations of distrust towards other countries. The comparison is further illustrated with a quote from Sidney J. Harris, which differentiates the two by the motivations behind one's pride in their country.
🌐 Contemporary Usage and Perceptions
This paragraph examines the contemporary use of the terms patriotism and nationalism, emphasizing the importance of context and connotation. Patriotism generally carries a positive connotation, associated with love for one's country and actions that serve the greater good. Nationalism, however, often has a negative connotation, linked to extreme ideologies and movements that prioritize national interests over others, sometimes leading to exclusionary practices towards foreigners and immigrants.
💭 The Role of Nationalism
The final paragraph explores the role of nationalism, challenging the assumption that it is always negative. It acknowledges nationalism's potential as a unifying force in struggles against injustice and its role in driving independence movements, such as the Zionist movement that led to the creation of modern Israel. The discussion also considers the potential for nationalism to contribute to peace in regions like the Middle East by fostering a strong national identity that could facilitate negotiations and unity over divisive tribal and religious identities.
Mindmap
Keywords
💡Patriotism
💡Nationalism
💡History
💡Unity
💡Devotion
💡Exaltation
💡Policies
💡Positive Values
💡Superiority
💡Connotation
💡Struggle Against Injustice
Highlights
Dan Zimmerman introduces the topic of the difference between patriotism and nationalism.
Patriotism is the older term, with evidence dating back to 1653, while nationalism emerged around the 19th century.
Nationalism was initially used interchangeably with patriotism but has since evolved to have a distinct meaning.
Patriotism is defined as love for one's country and unity with fellow citizens.
Nationalism involves loyalty and devotion to one's nation, with an emphasis on promoting its culture and interests above others.
Nationalism can include the policy of asserting one's nation's interests over those of other nations or the common good.
The difference between patriotism and nationalism is largely debated, with no official consensus among scholars.
Patriotism is associated with positive values such as freedom, justice, equality, bravery, and devotion.
Nationalism is often based on a belief in the superiority of one's country and can carry connotations of distrust towards others.
Patriotism is generally seen as inherently good, working for a better quality of life, while nationalism can be more exclusionary.
Sidney J. Harris' outlook differentiates the two by stating that a patriot is proud of their country for its actions, whereas a nationalist is proud regardless of actions.
Patriotism is used positively for sentiments and actions involving love of country and service to its people.
Nationalism often has a negative connotation, associated with extreme ideologies and movements that exclude others.
Nationalism can be a motivator for uniting people against injustice and has driven independence movements like the Zionist movement.
Some political analysts believe that a strong national identity is key to achieving peace in regions divided by tribal and religious identities.
The video encourages viewers to like, share, subscribe, and comment on their thoughts about patriotism and nationalism.
Transcripts
hey it's dan zimmerman welcome to
illustrate to educate
don't forget to subscribe for weekly
objective videos on topics that matter
have you ever wondered what is the
difference between patriotism and
nationalism
in this video we will look at the
essential differences between these two
let's take a brief look at the history
of the two words and where they
originated
patriotism is the older of the two words
with written evidence dating back to
around 1653
the word patriot itself could even be
traced back further
to the greek word patriots meaning of
one's father
there isn't much evidence of nationalism
occurring until just before the 19th
century
almost 150 years after patriotism and in
its early use and for a number of
decades
nationalism appears to have been largely
interchangeable with patriotism
however in the 19th century and up until
today
nationalism has changed meaning while
the meaning of patriotism has remained
largely unchanged
now let's look at how they're defined
patriotism is the feeling of love for
one's country
along with a feeling of unity with those
who share those feelings
it has also been defined as devoted love
support
and defense of one's country nationalism
on the other hand
is defined as loyalty and devotion to a
nation
but the definition of nationalism also
includes exalting one's nation
above all others and placing primary
emphasis on promotion of its culture
and interests as opposed to those of
other nations
others have defined it as the policy or
doctrine of asserting the interests of
one's own nation
viewed as separate from the interests of
other nations or the common interests of
all nations
now that we've defined them how do we
compare them with each other the
difference between the two words is
largely debated and even today there's
not an official consensus among scholars
and social scientists
some attribute that the feelings of
patriotism are based on the positive
values the country embraces
like freedom justice equality bravery
value and devotion
with patriotism one believes that both
the system of government and the people
of their country are inherently good
and work together for a better quality
of life in contrast feelings of
nationalism are based on a belief that
one's country
is superior to all others it can often
carry the connotation of distrust or
disapproval of other countries
leading to the assumption that other
countries are rivals nationalism tends
to find itself modified by movements of
political interest
one outlook by sidney j harris says the
difference between patriotism and
nationalism
is the patriot is proud of his country
for what it does and the nationalist is
proud of his country no matter what it
does
so how do we use patriotism and
nationalism today
when using these words it's important to
keep context and connotation
in mind patriotism generally has a
positive connotation
it's used for various positive
sentiments attitudes and actions
involving loving one's country
and serving the greater good of all its
people where nationalism generally has a
negative connotation
it's used for political ideologies and
movements that have a more extreme and
exclusionary love of one's country
at the expense of foreigners immigrants
and even people in a country
who aren't believed to belong in some
way often on racial and religious
grounds
right now you might be thinking
nationalism just sounds like it's always
bad
so is that true is nationalism always
bad
according to some people not always
nationalism has its uses
as a very strong motivator for uniting
people together in the struggle against
injustice
it has driven independence movements
like the zionist movement that created
modern israel
some political analysts feel that the
peace in the middle east
can only be achieved through a strong
national identity
of the countries involved as opposed to
the current tribal
and religious identities that divide
them embracing national identities
over religion may make it easier to
negotiate through national
amenable laws rather than ambiguous
religious laws
did you enjoy this video comparing
patriotism and nationalism
hopefully it gave you a good
introduction of the similarities and
differences between the two
please like and share the video
subscribe to illustrate to educate
and comment on your thoughts about
patriotism and nationalism
and don't forget to check out some of my
other videos to the right
5.0 / 5 (0 votes)