Kenapa Mobil BMW Gampang Rusak ? | BMW Mobil Penyakitan ??

FUSE BOX

1 Aug 202409:25

Summary

TLDRThe script discusses the popularity of Japanese cars in Indonesia, favored for their affordability, design, and reliability, with Toyota, Honda, and others being top choices. In contrast, American and European cars, particularly BMW, are criticized for their unreliability and frequent electrical issues due to complex electronic systems and poor installation practices. Plastic parts in BMWs are prone to damage, and the brand's lack of concept testing contributes to its reputation for requiring more maintenance and higher costs, making it a less desirable option for the Indonesian market.

Takeaways

🇮🇩 In Indonesia, Japanese car brands like Honda, Toyota, Daihatsu, Subaru, and Suzuki are popular due to their comprehensive range of affordable and well-designed vehicles.
🚗 Subaru stands out as a favorite among these brands, possibly due to its reputation for reliability and the variety of car models it offers.
💰 Japanese cars are favored for their cost-effectiveness and historical presence in Indonesia, with a long-standing popularity since the Dutch colonial era.
🔩 The reliability of Japanese cars is highlighted by the number of old Japanese vehicles still in use without needing an overhaul, and the community of enthusiasts for these vintage cars.
🇺🇸 American cars, such as Ford, have seen a decline in Indonesia, with some manufacturers like Ford having ceased operations in the country.
🇪🇺 European car manufacturers, while popular among a niche audience, are not as widely chosen by young Indonesian drivers, despite brands like BMW and Mercedes-Benz being known for affordability and appeal to young entrepreneurs.
🚫 BMW is often criticized for its unreliability and frequent electrical issues, which can be attributed to its complex electronic systems and the implementation of new technologies.
🔌 Electrical problems in BMWs are often due to poor installation practices, such as cables being installed in a way that creates pressure points and poor placement of electrical components, leading to potential short circuits and failures.
🚗 Excessive use of plastic parts in BMWs is identified as another issue, with parts like water pumps, thermostat housings, and radiator hoses made from materials that are prone to quick degradation.
🛠 BMW's lack of thorough testing and concept validation is suggested as a reason for the frequent breakdowns, especially in engines like the N47 diesel, which has a history of timing belt failures and maintenance challenges.
💡 Despite the maintenance challenges, BMW cars are praised for their timeless and modern design, high-quality interiors, and overall comfort, even in older models that are nearly two decades old.

Q & A

Why are Japanese cars popular in Indonesia?
-Japanese cars are popular in Indonesia due to their affordability, design, and reliability. Brands like Honda, Toyota, Daihatsu, Subaru, and Suzuki offer a range of vehicles that cater to various price points and preferences.
What makes Subaru stand out among the Japanese car brands in Indonesia?
-Subaru is favored by many in Indonesia because it offers a complete range of vehicles in terms of price and design, and it is known for its reliability and durability.
Why do some Indonesians prefer European cars over Japanese ones?
-Some Indonesians prefer European cars like BMW and Mercedes Benz for their luxury and performance, especially among young entrepreneurs, despite their higher maintenance costs compared to Japanese cars.
What are the common issues with BMW cars according to the script?
-The script mentions that BMW cars are often criticized for their electrical issues, excessive use of plastic parts that are prone to breaking, and lack of thorough concept testing which can lead to reliability problems.
Why are BMW's electronics considered complex and prone to failure?
-BMW's electronics are complex due to the brand's tendency to implement new designs and technologies. This complexity can lead to a higher risk of errors and failures, especially in electrical systems.
What is the issue with the installation of electrical systems in BMW cars?
-The script points out that some BMW models have poor cable installation practices, creating pressure points and using poor drainage systems, which can lead to water damage and electrical failures.
How does the use of plastic parts in BMW cars contribute to their unreliability?
-BMW's extensive use of plastic in sensitive parts such as the cooling system and engine components can lead to premature wear and failure, contributing to the car's unreliability.
What is the common problem with the timing belt in BMW's N47 diesel engine?
-The N47 diesel engine is known for its timing belt that frequently breaks, which can cause severe engine damage and is considered a significant reliability issue.
Why is the maintenance cost of BMW cars higher compared to Japanese cars?
-The maintenance cost for BMW cars is higher due to the complexity of their systems, the use of specialized parts, and the need for specialized technicians, making them more expensive to maintain than Japanese cars.
What is the impact of BMW's design and technology on its resale value?
-The script suggests that BMW's cutting-edge design and technology can make the cars feel modern even after many years, but their reliability issues and high maintenance costs can significantly decrease their resale value.
Why might the script suggest that owning a BMW in Indonesia might not be practical for everyone?
-The script implies that owning a BMW in Indonesia might not be practical due to the high traffic conditions which can stress the engine, the high maintenance costs, and the need for frequent visits to specialized workshops.

Outlines

00:00

🚗 Popularity of Japanese Cars in Indonesia

This paragraph discusses the preference for Japanese cars in Indonesia, highlighting brands such as Honda, Toyota, Daihatsu, Subaru, and Suzuki. It emphasizes the reliability and affordability of these vehicles, which have a long history in the country dating back to the Dutch era. The paragraph also touches on the popularity of Japanese cars among car enthusiasts and their tendency to require less maintenance compared to their European counterparts. The script mentions that while American car brands like Ford have declined in popularity, European brands like BMW and Mercedes-Benz are favored by young entrepreneurs, although not all prefer European cars due to their complexity and maintenance requirements.

05:00

🛠 Common Issues with BMW Cars in Indonesia

The second paragraph delves into the reasons behind the perceived unreliability of BMW cars in Indonesia. It outlines three main issues: complex electrical systems that are prone to failure, excessive use of plastic components that are quick to deteriorate, and inadequate testing of new concepts. The paragraph provides examples of specific models, such as the e46 and S90, which have experienced problems with plastic parts, and the N54 engine, which is known for its unreliability due to the use of plastic in critical components. It also mentions that BMW's design and testing may not be well-suited for the traffic conditions in Asia, particularly in Indonesia, where high engine temperatures can be a challenge. The paragraph concludes by suggesting that the high cost of maintenance and parts, along with the frequency of visits to BMW specialists, contribute to the brand's poor resale value.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡Japanese Cars

Japanese Cars refers to automobiles manufactured in Japan, known for their reliability and affordability. In the video's context, they are the preferred choice for daily use in Indonesia due to their comprehensive range of prices and designs. Brands like Honda, Toyota, Daihatsu, Subaru, and Suzuki are mentioned, with the exception of Subaru, which is a favorite among people for its competitive pricing and design.

💡Reliability

Reliability in the video refers to the dependability and longevity of a vehicle. It is a key factor that makes Japanese cars popular in Indonesia, as many old Japanese cars are still operational without needing an overhaul. The script mentions the high number of Japanese cars that have aged well and are still in use, highlighting their durability.

💡American Cars

American Cars in the script represent vehicles manufactured in the United States. The video discusses their decline in popularity in Indonesia, with examples like Ford, which has ceased operations in the country. The script implies that American cars are not as favored due to their manufacturers' reduced presence and possibly other factors not explicitly mentioned.

💡European Cars

European Cars are vehicles from European manufacturers, some of which are popular among young enthusiasts in Indonesia, such as BMW and Mercedes Benz. However, the video suggests that not all young people prefer European cars over Japanese ones, indicating a preference for Japanese cars despite the availability of European alternatives.

💡BMW

BMW is a German luxury vehicle brand that is discussed extensively in the video. It is portrayed as having a reputation for being less reliable due to various issues, particularly with its electrical systems. The script uses BMW as a case study to explore common problems associated with European cars, especially in the context of their electrical complexity and use of plastic components.

💡Electrical Issues

Electrical Issues are problems related to the vehicle's electrical systems. The video script highlights that BMWs are prone to such issues due to their complex electronics, which can be challenging even for professional mechanics. Examples from the script include problems with the iDrive system and other electrical features, which contribute to the brand's reputation for unreliability.

💡Plastic Components

Plastic Components in the video refer to the use of plastic materials in critical parts of the car, such as the cooling system and engine components. The script criticizes BMW for using plastic in these areas, suggesting that it leads to a higher likelihood of parts breaking or leaking, which affects the car's reliability and longevity.

💡Maintenance

Maintenance in the context of the video is the upkeep and servicing required to keep a vehicle in good condition. The script suggests that BMWs require more frequent and specialized maintenance compared to Japanese cars, which contributes to their higher ownership costs and potential for more issues over time.

💡Design

Design in the video refers to the aesthetic and functional aspects of a car's construction. BMW is praised for its timeless and modern design, even in older models. The script contrasts the stylishness of BMW's design with the reliability issues, suggesting that while the cars look good, they may not perform as well over time.

💡Resale Value

Resale Value is the amount for which a vehicle can be sold in the second-hand market. The video discusses how BMWs tend to depreciate quickly, losing a significant portion of their original price soon after purchase. This is attributed to the high maintenance costs and the brand's reputation for unreliability.

💡Turbocharged Engines

Turbocharged Engines are a type of internal combustion engine that uses a turbocharger to increase the engine's power. The script mentions the N54 engine as an example of a BMW engine that, despite its impressive power, is not reliable due to the use of plastic in its turbo and cooling systems, which can crack and leak easily.

Highlights

Japanese car brands are popular in Indonesia due to their affordability and design.

Subaru is a favorite among Indonesians for its comprehensive range of cars in terms of price and design.

Japanese cars are historically favored in Indonesia, with a long-standing presence since Dutch colonial times.

The reliability of Japanese cars is highlighted by the number of old Japanese cars still in use without overhauls.

There is a significant community of people who appreciate and maintain old Japanese cars.

American car manufacturers like Ford have withdrawn from the Indonesian market.

European car brands are popular among young Indonesian enthusiasts but are not as widespread as Japanese cars.

BMW and Mercedes Benz are notable European car brands in Indonesia, but not all young enthusiasts prefer them.

Old and new European cars, particularly BMW, are known for their complexity and potential for electrical issues.

BMW's electronic systems are complex, leading to difficulties in troubleshooting and repairs, even at authorized workshops.

BMW often leads in implementing new designs and technologies, which can sometimes lead to implementation risks.

The installation of electrical components in BMWs can create pressure points and poor drainage, increasing the risk of electrical failures.

Excessive use of plastic parts in BMWs can lead to premature wear and failure, affecting the car's reliability.

BMW's N54 engine, despite its power, is not reliable due to the use of plastic in its turbo and cooling systems.

BMW's diesel engines, such as the N47, have had issues with timing belts and engine filters, making maintenance challenging.

The high cost of maintenance and parts for BMWs in Indonesia makes them less appealing for some consumers.

The depreciation rate of BMWs in Indonesia is significant, with new cars losing value quickly upon resale.

Despite their maintenance challenges, BMWs are known for their stylish and timeless design, even in older models.

BMW interiors remain luxurious and comfortable, often surpassing the comfort of contemporary Japanese cars in the same price range.

The video concludes by questioning whether the audience is willing to invest in the maintenance and care required for a BMW.