سه‌ نکته درباره‌ی استعداد

Bplus Podcast

7 Apr 202212:14

Summary

TLDRThe script discusses whether creativity and artistry are more the result of innate talent or effort and practice. It explores writer Seth Godin's perspective - that almost no one is born with talent in a specific area, even renowned figures like Larry Bird. Godin argues we shouldn't focus on notions of genius, but on cultivating passion, perseverance and skills. He highlights three key skills to become better at anything: optimism, empathy, and learning how to learn. Godin also advises not overly relying on external feedback to chart your path, but simply doing good work without expectation of validation.

Takeaways

👨‍🎨 Creativity and success are more a result of effort and practice than innate talent.
🤩 Seth Godin argues that almost no one is born with a specific talent for a particular field.
🏀 Even celebrated figures like Larry Bird achieved greatness through hard work, not just natural ability.
📚 Passion and enthusiasm for something are skills that can be developed and are essential for creativity.
🔥 Focusing too much on the idea of innate talent can discourage effort and diminish morale.
🙋‍♂‍ Acknowledging someone's talent in a specific area might not always be constructive.
💻 Seth Godin emphasizes the importance of optimism, empathy, and the ability to learn as key skills for personal development.
😎 Optimism is a powerful tool for change, enabling people to envision and work towards better outcomes.
🤗 Empathy, or understanding others' perspectives and choices, is not inherent but can be cultivated through practice.
📚 Lifelong learning and adaptability are crucial in a rapidly changing world, making the skill of learning the most valuable.

Q & A

What does Seth Godin say about innate talent versus hard work and focus?
-Seth believes almost no one is born with innate talent in a specific area. Even renowned basketball player Larry Bird achieved more through hard work than raw talent.
What are the three most important skills Seth mentions?
-The three most important skills are: optimism, empathy, and learning.
How does Seth define optimism in this context?
-As the ability to believe things can get better, even if they are really bad now. It fuels people to build better lives.
What is empathy and why is it important?
-Empathy is the ability to understand where another person is coming from when they make certain decisions. It helps people cooperate better and prevents misunderstandings.
Why does Seth say the ability to learn is timeless?
-Because technologies and tools change so rapidly. Those who can adapt and learn new skills will always remain valuable.
Should we ignore all feedback from others?
-No, but we shouldn't organize our future path based solely on external validation. The people providing feedback don't actually know the future.
What happens if we rely too much on external validation?
-It can paralyze us and make us addicted to seeking approval. We should feel internally validated rather than looking for endless external confirmation.
How can optimism help fuel change?
-By giving people agency and making them believe they can be part of positive change, even in bleak circumstances.
Why is learning empathy useful for creators?
-To understand audiences better and figure out what they may want, even if different from what we want.
How can learning new skills make life better?
-By keeping our minds sharp as we age, maintaining a sense of purpose, and allowing us to better adapt to a rapidly changing world.

Outlines

00:00

🎨 The Nature of Creativity: Talent vs. Effort

This section explores the debate between innate talent and persistent effort in achieving creative success. It references various artists, musicians, and filmmakers, such as Abbas Kiarostami, Bob Dylan, Andy Warhol, Mohammad Reza Shajarian, Martin Scorsese, Pablo Picasso, Ludwig van Beethoven, and discusses Seth Godin's perspective on creativity. Godin argues that almost no one is born with a natural talent in a specific field, including figures like Larry Bird from 1980s basketball fame. Instead, Godin emphasizes the importance of effort over innate talent, suggesting that even skills like passion and enthusiasm can be developed. He advocates for focusing on effort rather than the notion of inborn talent, which can be demotivating and misleading.

05:00

🌟 The Power of Optimism, Empathy, and Learning

This paragraph delves into the critical skills of optimism, empathy, and learning as key to personal improvement and success. The speaker shares their personal stance on the difficulty yet necessity of maintaining optimism, even in challenging circumstances. Empathy is highlighted as a skill that can be developed with practice, allowing individuals to understand others' perspectives better, making it not just a moral attribute but also a practical asset in various endeavors. The importance of continuous learning is emphasized, with the argument that adaptability and the ability to learn new skills are invaluable in an ever-changing world. The speaker also touches upon the detrimental focus on seeking validation through feedback and the importance of self-reliance and confidence in one's path.

10:00

🔍 Reflections on Feedback and the Future

In this concluding section, the speaker reflects on the importance of disregarding excessive feedback and focusing on one's own work and decisions. Drawing from personal experience and the advice of others, the argument is made that feedback, while intended to be helpful, often does not account for the unpredictable nature of the future and can hinder personal progress if overemphasized. The speaker encourages viewers to trust in their own capabilities and to work towards their goals without the constant need for external validation. This approach, they argue, leads to more meaningful and self-determined success.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡Innate Talent

Innate talent refers to the natural abilities or aptitudes that individuals are born with. In the context of the video, the narrator debates whether creative success, like that of iconic figures such as Kiarostami, Bob Dylan, or Picasso, is more a result of inherent talent or the product of effort and practice. Seth Godin's perspective, as shared in the video, challenges the common belief in innate talent by suggesting that almost no one is born with a specific talent in a particular field, emphasizing instead the role of persistent effort and passion.

💡Effort and Practice

Effort and practice pertain to the disciplined and continuous application of work towards mastering a skill or craft. The video underscores this concept as crucial to achieving success and creativity, more so than relying on innate talent. It illustrates this through examples like Larry Bird, suggesting that even renowned talents are the result of relentless practice and dedication, not just natural ability.

💡Creativity

Creativity is the ability to generate innovative ideas and solve problems in unique ways. The video explores whether creativity is an innate talent or a skill that can be developed through learning and practice. Seth Godin is mentioned as advocating for the latter, emphasizing that passion and a willingness to engage deeply with one's interests can cultivate creativity, irrespective of one's starting point.

💡Passion

Passion, in this video, is depicted as a powerful driving force behind the pursuit of a craft or activity. It is presented not as a byproduct of innate talent but as a critical element that fuels the desire to excel and innovate. The narrator conveys that passion itself is a skill that can be nurtured, highlighting its importance in achieving mastery and creative success.

💡Learning

Learning is a key theme of the video, emphasizing the importance of acquiring knowledge and skills through experience or study. Seth Godin's message includes the idea that the capacity to learn, particularly to learn how to learn, is vital in a constantly changing world. This adaptability and willingness to embrace new challenges are portrayed as essential qualities for personal and professional growth.

💡Optimism

Optimism is highlighted as a crucial mindset for overcoming challenges and driving positive change. The video describes it as a skill that can significantly impact one's ability to improve circumstances, suggesting that a hopeful outlook on life's potential for improvement is both a personal benefit and a societal good. This perspective supports the idea that optimism can be cultivated and is valuable for fostering resilience and openness to better futures.

💡Empathy

Empathy is defined in the video as the ability to understand and share the feelings of another. It is portrayed as a skill of immense value, not only for personal relationships but also for broader societal interactions. By practicing empathy, individuals can bridge gaps of understanding and reduce conflicts, contributing to more harmonious and cooperative communities.

💡Feedback

Feedback is discussed in the context of its value and potential pitfalls. The video relays Seth Godin's advice to not overly depend on feedback, as it can lead to a constant search for external validation and hinder one's creative independence. It suggests that while feedback can be informative, it's crucial to focus on one's vision and goals rather than becoming too reliant on others' opinions.

💡Skill Development

Skill development is a central theme, with the video arguing that skills, including creativity and optimism, can be learned and enhanced through deliberate practice. This contradicts the notion that significant achievements are solely the result of innate talent, instead highlighting the transformative power of dedicated effort and continuous learning.

💡Creative Success

Creative success is the culmination of the themes discussed in the video, tying together the ideas of effort, learning, passion, and skill development. It presents the argument that achieving notable success in any creative endeavor is less about natural talent and more about the perseverance and dedication to constantly improve and innovate, supported by the examples of various renowned figures.

Highlights

Creativity and artistry are more the result of effort and practice rather than innate talent

Even someone considered very talented like basketball player Larry Bird achieved more through hard work than raw giftedness

Rather than focusing on notions of giftedness which can be demotivating, cultivate the skill of enthusiasm and perseverance