Comparing 3 Types of Sherwin Williams Paint (Don’t Waste $$$)

Summary

In this video, Jeff from Home Renovision compares three different Sherwin Williams paints, all claiming to be washable and having paint and primer in one. He tests their application, coverage, and washability, ultimately finding that the top-tier Emerald line performs best in removing stains and crayons, but at a significantly higher price.

Takeaways

• 🎨 Sherwin Williams offers a variety of paint lines, including different levels of washability and performance, tailored for commercial and residential needs.
• 🏠 Homeowners need to determine the right balance between price, performance, and washability when choosing paint for their home.
• 🔍 The script emphasizes the importance of reading labels for acrylic latex content to ensure the paint is washable.
• 💧 Paints that are not washable can literally wash off the wall, so understanding the paint's properties is crucial for durability.
• 📈 Sherwin Williams does not offer an eggshell finish in all their paint lines, indicating variations in sheen options.
• 💡 Higher sheen in paint shows more imperfections, so less preparation work might lead to choosing a lower sheen paint.
• 🛠️ The concept of 'paint and primer in one' is criticized for its limitations, suggesting that sometimes a separate primer is more cost-effective.
• 💰 The price difference between different Sherwin Williams paint lines is noted, with the top line being the most expensive at $110 per gallon.
• 🛡️ The 'Emerald' paint line is highlighted as the most washable and suitable for homes with children or high traffic areas.
• 🔬 A two-week test was conducted to evaluate the washability of the paints with various substances like coffee, wine, and crayons.
• 📉 The final verdict from the lifestyle testing suggests that all three tested paints performed similarly in terms of application and appearance, but the top line was superior in washability.

Q & A

What is the main purpose of the video?

The main purpose of the video is to compare three different paints from Sherwin Williams, focusing on their price, washability, and performance.

Why does Sherwin Williams have so many interior paint lines?

Sherwin Williams has many interior paint lines because they cater to both commercial and residential needs, offering different options for various painting scenarios and performance requirements.

What is the significance of 'acrylic latex' in paint?

Acrylic latex signifies that the paint has washability. It is important for consumers looking for washable paints to ensure the label says 'acrylic latex' to avoid paints that may wash off easily.

What is the difference between satin and eggshell finish in paint?

Satin and eggshell are both sheens of paint. Satin has a low sheen, while eggshell is even lower. The higher the sheen, the more it will show imperfections on the wall, so the choice depends on the level of shine desired and the amount of wall preparation one is willing to do.

Why does the video mention 'paint and primer in one' with skepticism?

The video expresses skepticism about 'paint and primer in one' because it can be less effective for certain situations like new drywall or when transitioning from oil to latex paint. It suggests using a separate primer for better results and cost-effectiveness.

What is the 'splatter test' in the context of the video?

The 'splatter test' is a test conducted in the video to see how messy a paint is to work with. It involves observing the splatter and drips when applying the paint to determine how clean and easy it is to work with.

What does the video suggest about one-coat coverage for paints?

The video suggests that one-coat coverage is not always desirable. It can lead to a saggy appearance and may not blend well on the wall. A good paint should have technology that allows it to dry and blend smoothly.

What is the significance of the 'Magic Eraser' test in the video?

The 'Magic Eraser' test is used to see how well the paint cleans off stains without damaging the paint itself. It's a practical test to determine the washability and durability of the paint under real-world conditions.

What does the video conclude about the difference in performance among the three paint lines tested?

The video concludes that despite the price differences, the three paint lines perform similarly in terms of application, look, and feel. However, for washability, especially with markers, the top-line paint (Emerald) performed better, though it may damage the paint surface during cleaning.

What advice does the video give for choosing the right paint for a home with children?

The video advises that for homes with children, especially where washability is a concern, it might be necessary to invest in the top-line paint from Sherwin Williams, as it offers better performance in terms of removing crayons and markers without damaging the paint.