Wind turbines are ‘ineffective’ and ‘ugly’: Cory Bernardi
Summary
TLDRThe New England wind project in Walcha, Australia, has sparked controversy within the community. Developers are offering farmers up to $30,000 annually per turbine, causing a divide. Critics argue that wind turbines are ineffective and unsightly, with only those receiving payments in favor. The debate highlights the tension between economic incentives and environmental concerns, with some suggesting turbines should be placed in urban, not rural, areas. Community consultation is emphasized as crucial for decision-making, reflecting the broader implications of renewable energy projects on local ecosystems and residents' quality of life.
Takeaways
- 🌬️ The New England wind project in Walcha is a controversial initiative that could see up to 119 wind turbines built in the area.
- 💸 Developers are offering farmers up to $30,000 a year for hosting a turbine on their property, which has divided the community.
- 🤔 Corey Bernardi expresses concern about the aesthetics and effectiveness of wind turbines, suggesting that only those receiving payment are in favor.
- 🏘️ Bernardi emphasizes the importance of community input, as those living in the area will have to deal with the consequences of the project.
- 💭 The script suggests that there is a debate about the location of wind turbines, with a preference for them to be placed in rural rather than urban areas.
- 🌳 Matt Canavan highlights the environmental impact of constructing wind turbines, including potential damage to pristine mountain ranges and wildlife habitats.
- 🚜 Canavan criticizes the double standards he perceives in environmental regulations, where farmers face penalties for tree cutting while renewable energy projects face fewer restrictions.
- 🏝️ The script mentions the proximity of the wind farm to the Great Barrier Reef, raising concerns about sediment runoff and its potential impact on the reef.
- 🤝 There is a call for community consultation and decision-making power over such large-scale projects that will affect the local environment and economy.
- 🎭 The tone of the conversation suggests a mix of humor and serious concern, with participants using sarcasm to express their views on the wind farm project.
- 🌐 The script touches on broader themes of renewable energy, environmental protection, and the balance between economic incentives and ecological preservation.
Q & A
What is the New England wind project and what is its scale?
-The New England wind project is a renewable energy initiative that plans to construct up to 119 wind turbines around the town of Walcha.
How is the community of Walcha divided over the wind farm project?
-The community of Walcha is divided due to the wind farm project, with some farmers being offered up to thirty thousand dollars a year for hosting turbines on their property, while others oppose the project due to aesthetic and environmental concerns.
What are the main concerns raised by Corey Bernardi about wind turbines?
-Corey Bernardi expresses concerns about the ineffectiveness and visual impact of wind turbines, suggesting that only those receiving financial incentives support them, while neighbors may not want them nearby.
What does Corey Bernardi suggest regarding community involvement in such projects?
-Corey Bernardi believes that the community should have a say in the decision-making process of such projects, as they are the ones who have to live with the consequences.
What is Matt Canavan's perspective on the location of wind turbines?
-Matt Canavan questions why wind turbines are not being placed in developed areas like Bondi Beach or the Blue Mountains, instead of being concentrated in rural areas.
What is the issue with placing wind turbines in pristine mountain ranges according to Matt Canavan?
-Matt Canavan is concerned about the environmental impact of placing wind turbines in pristine mountain ranges, including the potential damage to local ecosystems and the sediment runoff that could affect nearby reefs.
What is the irony Matt Canavan points out regarding the treatment of green energy companies compared to individual farmers?
-Matt Canavan highlights the irony that while individual farmers face severe penalties for environmental damage, green energy companies seem to be allowed to clear forests and level mountains for wind turbines under the guise of saving the planet.
What is the financial incentive offered to farmers for hosting wind turbines?
-Farmers are being offered up to thirty thousand dollars a year for each wind turbine hosted on their property.
What is the community consultation meeting that Matt Canavan is attending?
-Matt Canavan is attending a community consultation meeting for a wind farm in Queensland, where he will be proposing and discussing the concerns and implications of the wind farm project.
How does Matt Canavan feel about the renewable energy companies' actions?
-Matt Canavan humorously acknowledges that the actions of renewable energy companies are turning him into a 'Greenie,' suggesting that he is becoming more environmentally conscious due to their efforts.
What is the final remark made by Sherry about Bob Brown and protecting vegetation?
-Sherry jokingly suggests that Corey Bernardi and Matt Canavan should get tips from environmental activist Bob Brown on how to protect pristine vegetation from wind turbines.
Outlines
💨 Controversy Over Wind Farm Development
The script discusses the New England wind project in Walcha, which is causing a community divide. Developers are offering farmers up to $30,000 per year for hosting a turbine on their land. Corey Bernardi expresses his opposition to the project, criticizing wind turbines as both ineffective and unsightly. He argues that only those receiving payment are in favor, while neighbors suffer the consequences. Bernardi emphasizes the importance of community input in such decisions, as they have to live with the outcomes. Matt Canavan is heading to a community consultation meeting in Queensland, where he will propose that wind turbines should be placed in developed areas instead of rural ones, questioning the environmental impact and the fairness of targeting country areas.
Mindmap
Keywords
💡Wind Farms
💡Community Consultation
💡Subsidies
💡Renewable Energy
💡Economic Incentives
💡Environmental Impact
💡Pristine Environment
💡Land Rights
💡Public Opinion
💡Aesthetic Concerns
💡Environmental Regulations
Highlights
The New England wind project proposes to build up to 119 turbines around Walcha, causing community division.
Developers are offering farmers up to thirty thousand dollars a year for hosting turbines on their property.
Corey Bernardi expresses that wind turbines are ineffective and unattractive, and only those receiving money support them.
The community's opinion is important as they will live with the consequences of the wind farm.
Matt Canavan is attending a community consultation meeting for a wind farm in Queensland.
Canavan questions why wind turbines are not developed in urban areas like Bondi Beach or the Blue Mountains.
Renewable energy companies are facing criticism for their impact on pristine environments.
Canavan humorously suggests he might become a 'Greenie' due to the actions of renewable energy companies.
There is concern about the environmental impact of wind turbines, including potential damage to the Great Barrier Reef.
Farmers are restricted from cutting down trees, yet renewable energy companies can clear forests for wind turbines.
There is a perceived inconsistency in environmental regulations between individual actions and corporate projects.
The transcript suggests a need for community involvement in decisions about renewable energy projects.
The transcript highlights the economic temptation for farmers to host wind turbines despite potential environmental concerns.
There is a call for a more equitable distribution of renewable energy infrastructure across urban and rural areas.
The transcript raises questions about the true environmental benefits of wind turbines in the context of their impact on local ecosystems.
The discussion suggests that the community's voice should be central in the decision-making process for renewable energy projects.
Transcripts
now let's have a look at wind farms the
New England wind project that will see
up to 119 turbines built around the town
of walcha is dividing the community
developers are offering finer Farmers up
to thirty thousand dollars a year for
every turbine they host on their
property
um Corey Bernardi the community seemed
to be opposing this
yeah I'm not surprised I mean not only a
wind turbine's ineffective they're ugly
as anything and you know people the only
people who want them on their property
are those who are getting paid chunks of
money for them if you're the neighbor
you certainly don't want them around
um but you know ultimately the community
should have a say in some of these
things that go on because they've got to
live there the rest of us are just
saying oh yeah you know this is a
subsidized tilted nothing but it does
have real world implications so Sherry
let the community decide I mean it'll be
it'll be tempting for many families to
take the thirty thousand dollars Matt
Caravan you're headed to a community
consultation meeting tonight for a wind
farm in Queensland what what are you
going to be proposing when you're there
well I'm here at the moment I've just
popped out to to speak with you uh
meeting here this evening because yeah
at calapa here behind me The Clapper
Hall and and and people are worked up
about this as Corey said uh it's fine
for people to take the money but uh why
aren't these wind turbines going to
develop parts of our country where are
the wind turbines off Bondi Beach uh on
the in the Blue Mountains or on Mount
tamborine just off the Gold Coast they
don't seem to go there they just go to
Country areas and country people and
keep in mind here what I mean the the
renewable energy companies I give them
their due they're doing the impossible
Shari they're turning me into a Greenie
I think I'm about to go buy a koala suit
soon and put it on so I've been out here
today and these wind turbines are going
up into the mountain ranges here that
are absolutely pristine haven't been
touched even since Captain Cook arrived
as koalas as sugar gliders
and they're going to level the tops of
these mountains to put these massive
wind turbines on all that sediment is
going to end up in the reef for only 70
or 80 kilometers from The Reef here it's
just outrageous and a farmer can't cut
down a tree right now I feel like in
this area here they they cut down a tree
they go to jail uh yet apparently a
green Energy company can just level
whole forests and and Deuce into doing
so say they're saving the planet it
doesn't add up all right that's all
we've got time for great to see you
Corey Bernardi and Matt canavan you'll
have to get tips from Bob Brown to
protect those pristine vegetation from
the uh from the wind turbines
on your show first shary
Browse More Related Video
5.0 / 5 (0 votes)