Sự thật cụ bà vô gia cư "ngày đi ăn xin, tối về ngủ biệt thự chục tỷ" ở Hà Nội | THVN

Summary

In Hanoi, a controversial story unfolds as an 83-year-old woman, Phượng, known for her impoverished appearance and begging on the streets, is discovered living in a multi-million-dollar French colonial villa in Hai Bà Trưng District. Despite her claims of hardship, local investigations reveal her residence in a valuable property, sparking doubts about her situation. The story gains attention after a video of her daily struggles goes viral, but further inquiry shows her complex living conditions, including issues with neighbors due to hoarding behaviors. Despite offers of help, Phượng prefers her lifestyle, raising questions about social perceptions and the realities of urban poverty.

Takeaways

• 👵 An elderly woman, named Phượng, 83 years old, living in a valuable old French villa in Hà Nội, was followed by journalists revealing her daily life of collecting recyclables and seeking charity despite owning a property worth tens of billions of Vietnamese đồng.
• 🌠 The villa, located on Tô Hiến Thành street in Hai Bà Trưng district, is shared by Phượng and two other families. Despite its value, Phượng's living conditions are poor, with her choosing to sleep in a shared bathroom filled with garbage.
• 👍 Social media exploded with a video garnering over 2 million views, sympathizing with Phượng's plight, but also raising doubts about the authenticity of her hardships as portrayed in the report.
• 📝 The local community and authorities have attempted to assist Phượng, offering financial support and cleanup efforts, but face challenges due to her refusal to change her lifestyle and hoarding behavior.
• 🚮 Phượng's situation has led to complaints from neighbors about the adverse effects of her garbage collection on their living environment, including foul odors and blocked common areas.
• 🙏 Despite owning a valuable property, Phượng claims financial hardship, living off charity, and continues to collect and hoard recyclables, causing tension with her neighbors.
• 🛡️ The local government and community organizations have frequently offered support and aid to Phượng, including clean-up services and financial assistance, especially during holidays and special occasions.
• 👥 Neighbors have expressed a desire for Phượng to stop her garbage collection activities and have attempted to financially incentivize her to clean up her living space.
• 💻 Misconceptions about Phượng's financial situation have been clarified by local authorities, emphasizing that she is not homeless or in dire need, but chooses to live in suboptimal conditions.
• 💡 Phượng's story has sparked a broader discussion on social media and among the local community about the challenges of addressing hoarding behavior and the complexities of providing aid to those who appear in need but own significant assets.

Q & A

What was the initial public perception of the elderly woman's situation in Hanoi?

The initial public perception was of sympathy towards the elderly woman, named Phượng, who was believed to be living in difficult circumstances, begging for food and living under a porch, despite owning a valuable French colonial villa.

How did the journalist discover the true living conditions of the elderly woman named Phượng?

The journalist discovered the true living conditions of Phượng by secretly following her after she collected a cart full of gifts and waste, leading to a three-story house on Tô Hiến Thành street, revealing her residence in a valuable French colonial villa.

What did the video with over 2 million views reveal about Phượng's daily activities?

The video revealed that Phượng, despite being 83 years old, claimed to sleep under the porch of her house, begging for food and eating whatever she was given, which attracted significant public sympathy.

What is the estimated value of the villa where Phượng lives, and who else resides there?

The villa is estimated to be worth tens of billions of Vietnamese dong and is inhabited by Phượng and two other households.

What contradiction was found regarding Phượng's claimed financial and living situation?

The contradiction lies in Phượng's claim of hardship and begging for food, despite living in a valuable villa, and having a regular living situation with a monthly allowance, contradicting the poverty narrative presented in the video.

How have Phượng's actions affected her neighbors and their living environment?

Phượng's actions, particularly her collection and storage of waste, have caused distress to her neighbors due to unpleasant odors and misuse of shared spaces, leading to complaints and attempts to clean up the area.

What measures have been taken by local authorities and neighbors to address Phượng's situation?

Local authorities and neighbors have made several attempts to clean up the waste, offered financial assistance to change her behavior, and provided support during holidays and emergencies, despite her resistance to changing her living habits.

What is Phượng's health and activity level according to the local community leaders?

According to local community leaders, Phượng is healthy and active, enjoys collecting recyclables and waste, and has been regularly supported by the community and authorities, contradicting the notion of her being in dire need.

How did the community and authorities respond to the misleading portrayal of Phượng's situation?

The community and authorities clarified the reality of Phượng's situation, highlighting her actual living conditions, the support she receives, and her ownership of the villa, in response to the misleading portrayal in the video.

What does the story of Phượng reveal about the challenges of addressing homelessness and poverty?

Phượng's story reveals the complexities and challenges of addressing homelessness and poverty, including issues of perception, the importance of investigating claims of hardship, and the need for community and authority intervention to support vulnerable individuals.