VOCÊ REALMENTE ENTENDEU o QUE É AMOR? - CLÓVIS DE BARROS e ILAN BRENMAN

Cortes do Inteligência [OFICIAL]

5 Jul 202407:53

Summary

TLDRThe speaker delves into the multifaceted nature of love, emphasizing the desire for presence (Eros), the joy of presence, and the zeal in absence. They argue that love is not just longing but also the celebration of togetherness and the insubstitutability of the loved one. The script highlights the importance of recognizing the cause of joy in love, as stated by Spinoza, and discusses the societal challenges in expressing happiness and the uniqueness of love that cannot be replaced or substituted, making life more vibrant and meaningful.

Takeaways

💔 The concept of love involves a dimension of lack, which is the desiring part of love, or Eros, that is missing.
🏫 The speaker feels a strong sense of absence when not teaching, indicating a deep connection to their profession.
🎉 Love is not just about the feeling of absence; it also brings joy in presence, as explained by Spinoza.
🔥 The 'happy hour' mentioned is a metaphor for the intense relief and joy when work ends, contrasting with the love of teaching.
❤️ The speaker believes love is the joy in presence, accompanied by the awareness of its cause, which is the loved one.
👫 Love in a relationship requires the presence of desire, joy, and zeal, which are essential for a fulfilling marriage.
🤔 The speaker suggests that if love were only about absence, there would be no happiness in marriage, but there is.
👨‍👧‍👦 Zeal is described as the protective and caring feeling one has for someone they love, like a parent for their child.
🧩 Love is composed of three elements: desire in absence, joy in presence, and zeal, forming a triptych of love.
🎭 The speaker wants to add a fourth element to love: insubstitutability, meaning the unique and irreplaceable nature of the loved one.
🚫 In love, the loved one is not interchangeable; if a bond changes, the love for that person remains unique and insubstitutable.
🌈 The speaker concludes that the elements of desire, joy, zeal, and insubstitutability make love a colorful and enriching part of life.

Q & A

What does the speaker believe is the missing dimension of love?
-The speaker believes that the missing dimension of love is the part that desires, which is Eros, the lack of which is felt as an absence.
How does the speaker describe the 'happy hour' after work?
-The speaker describes 'happy hour' as a time of absurd violence and truculence because the best part of life, according to them, is being in the classroom, and the absence of it during holidays is felt deeply.
What does the speaker say about the presence of love in terms of joy?
-The speaker says that love is also joy in the presence, as stated by Spinoza, which is joy accompanied by the idea of its cause, meaning one is happy and knows the cause of happiness.
What is the difference between love and joy according to the speaker?
-The difference between love and joy is the consciousness of the cause, according to the speaker. Love involves being affected by the cause of joy and having awareness of it.
Why does the speaker believe that love is also Zelo?
-The speaker believes that love is also Zelo, which is the desire for presence in absence, joy in presence, and a protective concern for the loved one, whether they are near or far.
What does the speaker suggest as the fourth element to add to the definition of love?
-The speaker suggests adding 'insubstitutability' as the fourth element to the definition of love, emphasizing that the loved one is not replaceable or interchangeable.
What does the speaker mean by 'competent desire'?
-By 'competent desire,' the speaker means the ability to pursue what one wants with skill and effectiveness, which can make life more colorful.
How does the speaker view the importance of joy in life?
-The speaker views joy as an essential part of life that is often overlooked. They suggest that being able to find joy in what one has achieved is more difficult than the desire for it.
What does the speaker say about the societal view of joy?
-The speaker criticizes the societal view of joy as being undervalued and suggests that society is more geared towards desire and competition rather than happiness.
What is the speaker's opinion on the difficulty of loving in presence?
-The speaker believes that loving in presence, or during conviviality, is difficult and requires a level of maturity that is often not achieved.
How does the speaker describe the concept of 'insubstitutability' in love?
-The speaker describes 'insubstitutability' in love as the understanding that the love for a person is unique and cannot be replaced or substituted by another, even if one forms new relationships.

Outlines

00:00

💞 The Dimensions of Love

This paragraph delves into the multifaceted nature of love, highlighting the desire (Eros) as a fundamental component. It discusses the feeling of absence when love is not present, such as during holidays or when apart from loved ones, and the intense joy that comes with its presence. The speaker also touches on the philosophical aspect of love, citing Spinoza and the concept of love as 'joy accompanied by the idea of its cause.' Furthermore, the paragraph introduces the idea of 'Zelo,' or zeal, as a protective and possessive aspect of love. The speaker emphasizes the insubstitutability of love, arguing that true love cannot be replaced or substituted, and concludes by suggesting that love is a combination of desire, joy, presence, and zeal, forming an enriching network of affection.

05:01

🚀 Pursuit of Passion and Competence

The second paragraph focuses on the importance of pursuing one's desires with competence to add color to life, contrasting it with the negative aspects of inertia and cowardice. It stresses the difficulty of finding joy in what one has achieved, suggesting that the ability to celebrate one's accomplishments is more challenging than the pursuit itself. The speaker uses the metaphor of 'Eros' to describe the pursuit of love and the societal pressures that often prioritize desire over joy. They also discuss the societal conditioning that encourages competitiveness and the pursuit of goals over the celebration of achievements. The paragraph concludes with a reflection on the rarity of insubstitutable love, suggesting that true love is a profound and irreplaceable force in one's life.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡Eros

Eros is the Greek god of love and desire, often associated with romantic and passionate love. In the context of the video, Eros represents the longing aspect of love, the feeling of missing someone or something. The speaker mentions that love is not just about this absence or longing ('falta'), but also about the joy of presence, indicating a more complex understanding of love that includes both desire and fulfillment.

💡Joy

Joy, in the video, is described as the happiness that accompanies the presence of the loved one. It is the positive emotion felt when one is with the object of their affection. The speaker contrasts joy with the longing of Eros, emphasizing that love encompasses both the desire for someone when they are absent and the happiness when they are present, as expressed by 'alegria na presença'.

💡Zeal

Zeal, in this context, refers to the protective and possessive feelings one has towards the loved one, both in their absence and presence. The speaker uses the term to illustrate the intensity of love, where one feels a strong desire for the well-being and presence of the loved one, as shown when talking about their daughter Natália.

💡Insubstitutability

In the video, insubstitutability is a key aspect of love, suggesting that the love one has for a particular person or thing is unique and cannot be replaced by another. The speaker argues that true love is not interchangeable, using the example of a beloved pet to illustrate that the love for that specific pet cannot be substituted by another, even if similar.

💡Competence

Competence, as discussed in the video, is the ability to effectively pursue and achieve one's desires. It is tied to the idea that one should not only desire things or people competently but also be able to take joy in what has been achieved. The speaker implies that competence in love involves both the pursuit and the appreciation of the loved one.

💡Desire

Desire is a fundamental concept in the video, representing the longing and wanting aspect of love. It is the feeling of missing something or someone, which is a driving force behind the pursuit of love. The speaker mentions that everyone is educated to desire, indicating that it is a common human experience.

💡Presence

Presence in the video refers to the state of being with the loved one. It is associated with joy and the fulfillment of desire. The speaker contrasts the longing of absence with the happiness of presence, suggesting that love is a dynamic experience that includes both states.

💡Absence

Absence is the opposite of presence and is related to the longing and desire for the loved one when they are not around. The speaker uses absence to discuss the feeling of missing someone, which is a part of the love experience, as seen in the expressions of missing the classroom, students, and teaching during holidays.

💡Maturity

Maturity, in the context of the video, is linked to the ability to handle the complexities of love, including both the desire and the joy of presence. The speaker suggests that true love requires a high degree of maturity to navigate the feelings of zeal and insubstitutability.

💡Color

The term 'color' is used metaphorically in the video to represent the enrichment that love brings to life. The speaker argues that pursuing and achieving desires with competence can make life more colorful, indicating that love adds depth and vibrancy to one's existence.

💡Education

Education is mentioned in the video in the context of how people are taught to desire but not necessarily to experience joy. The speaker criticizes this aspect of education, suggesting that it focuses on the pursuit of desires without encouraging the appreciation of joy and fulfillment in love.

Highlights

Love has a dimension of lack, which is the desiring part of love, Eros.

The absence of someone or something can evoke a sense of longing, which is a part of love.

Love is not just about absence; it also brings joy in presence, as stated by Spinoza.

The presence of the loved one is a source of happiness, and this is a key aspect of love.

Love involves a consciousness of the cause of joy, which differentiates it from mere happiness.

The absence of love in a marriage would not lead to happiness, yet happiness exists due to the presence of love.

Love is also characterized by zeal, both in the presence and absence of the loved one.

Plato, Hypnos, and Jesus are mentioned as forming an interesting triad for the definition of love.

The concept of insubstitutability is introduced as a fourth element of love, emphasizing the unique and irreplaceable nature of the loved one.

The speaker argues against the idea of substituting one loved one for another, stating that true love is not interchangeable.

The speaker reflects on the difficulty of maintaining love in the presence of the loved one and during conviviality.

The importance of competence in pursuing what one desires is highlighted, as it enriches life.

The ability to find joy in what one has achieved is considered more challenging than the desire itself.

The speaker criticizes the societal view that discourages expressing joy and happiness.

The need for maturity in love is emphasized, as well as the recognition of the insubstitutable in love.

The transcript discusses the societal pressures and expectations that shape our understanding and expression of love.

The speaker encourages reflecting on personal experiences to understand the depth and uniqueness of love.