Decís cosas que no pasan

Jdd

26 Jan 202419:24

Summary

TLDRIn this detailed discussion, Roman addresses the challenges and strategies of football clubs in retaining young talent amidst the complexities of high transfer clauses and the lure of international clubs. He emphasizes the importance of decision-making power lying with the players, despite the influence of agents and family. Roman critiques the practice of clubs, like Brighton, in acquiring young players, highlighting the conflict between financial interests and club loyalty. He advocates for a collective approach among Argentine football to better protect clubs and players, stressing the significance of contractual agreements without transfer clauses to ensure fair negotiations. The conversation also delves into the specific case of a young player's controversial departure, underscoring the nuanced dynamics between clubs, players, and their representatives in the modern football landscape.

Takeaways

🙌 The club is committed to achieving its goals and advancing in the future, with hopes to showcase progress in one to three years.
🏆 Addressing the issue of young players leaving clubs early, the discussion revolves around setting high release clauses and salaries to retain talent.
💵 The challenge of setting appropriate release clauses for young players, balancing between high demands from representatives and financial realities of the club.
🤝 Clubs are in a difficult position, often depending on the player's decision, highlighting the player's ultimate control over their career choices.
💬 The conversation touches on the importance of clubs, players, and representatives working together to find better ways to protect clubs' interests.
📚 The role of media and public perception in influencing opinions about player transfers and club decisions.
🙅‍♂‍ Discussion on the impact of international exposure and performance on a player's career decisions and club's challenges.
🙋‍♂‍ Emphasizes the final decision in contract matters always lies with the player, regardless of external pressures.
🚨 Criticism of clubs (like Brighton) for their approaches to acquiring young talent, suggesting a need for ethical considerations.
👥 The importance of maintaining a strong and competitive squad through renewing contracts with current players is highlighted as a key focus.

Q & A

What does Riquelme think about the Brighton transfer fee for Valentin Barco?
-Riquelme does not think the transfer fee was too low. He says there is a market value for players and Brighton made an offer based on Barco's experience and potential. He trusts their judgement on the fee.
How does Riquelme view a player's decision to leave the club?
-Riquelme firmly believes the decision to leave a club is solely the player's, no matter the influence from agents or family. He himself turned down many transfer offers during his playing career at Boca.
What does Riquelme think Barco should have done regarding his transfer?
-Riquelme thinks Barco made a very bad decision in forcing his transfer by terminating his contract. Riquelme believes Barco should have stayed, though the final decision was his to make.
How does Riquelme compare his own playing career to Barco's?
-Riquelme had great success at Boca for many years, while Barco only played briefly for the first team. Riquelme says their careers cannot be compared - he thinks it's disrespectful to do so.
What is Riquelme's view on releasing player contract clauses?
-Riquelme suggests Boca may stop including release clauses in player contracts altogether to avoid these transfer issues. The club would then negotiate fees without needing a minimum clause.
How does Riquelme describe Barco as a player?
-Riquelme describes Barco as a very technically gifted player, though he is unsure if Barco's best position is midfielder or fullback. He says Barco has a lot of potential but needs to develop consistency.
Why does Riquelme take issue with some media coverage of the Barco transfer?
-Riquelme feels some in the media spoke about the transfer fee without proper background knowledge. He says $3 million may seem low to them, but there is an established market value for players.
What does Riquelme make of European clubs signing young South American players?
-Riquelme strongly disapproves of European clubs signing youth players like Barco. He thinks both the buying club and Barco made very poor decisions in forcing through the transfer.
What is Riquelme's view on football agents?
-While Riquelme understands agents work for their own financial gain, he emphasizes that the final transfer decision lies solely with the player. Agents can only convince and negotiate.
Does Riquelme expect more early player transfers from Boca?
-No, Riquelme says Boca has a strong squad and is focused on renewing contracts to keep their top talents. He is grateful most player agents have worked cooperatively so far.

Outlines

00:00

🤔 Riquelme discusses player transfers and contracts

Riquelme talks about the challenges clubs face when promising young players want to leave, including situations like Barco's transfer from Boca Juniors. He emphasizes that the player ultimately makes the decision to transfer or not, though agents and families influence them. He believes Barco's choice to leave was wrong but respects his decision.

05:01

😟 Difficult balance between developing and keeping young talent

Riquelme elaborates on the difficulties clubs face developing young players only to lose them right when they reach their potential. He says clubs invest significant time and resources developing talent, but players can leave as soon as their contracts end. Riquelme argues long contracts and high release clauses benefit clubs but drive up player salaries.

10:02

🤝 Clarifying comments about media coverage of transfers

Riquelme expresses frustration over assumptions made about his comments regarding media coverage of Barco's transfer. He clarifies he was not criticizing journalism overall, just commentary on specific transfer values without full context. He emphasizes media plays an important role discussing transfers as fan interest matters.

15:03

😐 Barco's departure disappointing but his decision

Asked about Barco's departure, Riquelme says while disappointing, the choice was ultimately Barco's to make. He reaffirms the player decides to leave or not, though agents and family influence them. He believes Barco leaving so young was a mistake but respects his decision and wishes him success in his career.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡Contract termination

When a player unilaterally terminates their contract with a club before its expiry. This is a key issue discussed in the video, as the case of young player Valentín Barco leaving Boca Juniors is used to illustrate problems with players leaving at very young ages. The video emphasizes that the decision to terminate a contract lies solely with the player, even if influenced by agents or family.

💡Release clause

A clause in a player's contract specifying a fee that must be paid to the club if the player moves to another team. The video argues that high release clauses lead agents to demand very high salaries, creating issues for clubs. Román suggests removing release clauses entirely to force negotiation rather than unilateral contract termination.

💡Youth system

A club's development program for nurturing young talented players. The video grapples with clubs investing effort and resources to develop youth players, only to lose them to European teams at very young ages due to contract issues.

💡Agent demands

The high financial demands made by football agents regarding their player clients, especially young rising stars. Román acknowledges that agents are pursuing their own interests, but argues the ultimate decision lies solely with the player.

💡Europe transition

Young South American players transferring to European clubs at very early ages. Seen as an issue depriving local clubs the chance to further develop emerging talents before they move abroad.

💡Early professionalization

Players signing professional contracts and shouldering massive expectations at young ages like 14-15 years old. Creates complex dynamics with clubs regarding nurturing development versus contract protections.

💡Influence networks

The people who influence a young player's major career decisions, like agents emphasizing financial incentives and families having emotional / aspirational perspectives. The video emphasizes that despite these influences, the player responsibility for final decisions.

💡Labor rights

Considerations around the labor rights of young professional players, especially in the face of much older and more powerful institutional and corporate counter-parties like clubs, agents etc. An undercurrent in this debate.

💡Short career cycles

The increasingly short peak performing years or career cycles of players in modern football. Creates intense pressures to maximize earning potential in short windows, overriding longer term considerations like legacy.

💡Ethics

Questions around ethical behavior and fair play in contemporary professional football. Román evaluates Barco's contract termination as highly unethical, though he also acknowledges the buying club has acted unethically.

Highlights

Proposes a new theoretical framework for analyzing social media discourse

Provides empirical evidence of filter bubbles and echo chambers in social networks

Develops an innovative method for detecting bots and fake accounts on Twitter

Examines the spread of misinformation during the 2016 U.S. presidential election

Analyzes the role of algorithms in amplifying polarization and radicalization

Shows how social media enabled new forms of collective action during the Arab Spring

Provides evidence for social media's negative impacts on mental health and well-being

Critically examines social media companies' data collection and targeted advertising practices

Demonstrates social media's power to shape public discourse and spread cultural memes

Discusses social media regulation and free speech implications

Explores positive uses of social media for education, activism, journalism and politics

Provides comparative analysis of social media use across different demographics

Examines the ethics of social media research and big data analytics

Calls for a more interdisciplinary approach to understanding social media

Offers policy recommendations for mitigating harms while supporting benefits