Debat Panas RK VS Rano Karno Singgung IPM Banten Turun [Debat Pilkada 2024]

Summary

In this debate, a discussion takes place about the development of Banten Province in Indonesia. The speaker asks former Vice Governor and Governor of Banten, Rano Karno, why the Human Development Index (HDI) in Banten declined from 2012 to 2017, despite significant political power. Karno explains his brief tenure as governor and the challenges Banten faces, including its divided administrative structure and underdeveloped areas like Pandeglang and Lebak. He highlights efforts to improve the region, such as national projects like the Sukarno-Hatta Airport expansion and infrastructure development, with hopes of boosting the province's development moving forward.

Takeaways

• 😀 The speaker was asked about the development of Banten and its human development index (HDI).
• 😀 The speaker acknowledged that Banten's HDI has decreased between 2012 and 2017, highlighting the challenge faced during that time.
• 😀 The speaker inquired about the leadership of Rano Karno, who served as vice governor and then governor of Banten.
• 😀 The speaker expressed disappointment over the stagnant and decreasing HDI in Banten despite leadership efforts.
• 😀 Rano Karno shared his brief time as governor (2012-2013) and acting governor (2013-2015) and explained the challenges of governing Banten.
• 😀 Rano Karno discussed the unique administrative setup of Banten after it split from West Java, mentioning the two police chiefs (Kapolda) and two military regional commanders (Pangdam).
• 😀 Rano Karno mentioned the challenge of coordinating between different regional authorities, which made governance complex.
• 😀 Rano Karno praised President Jokowi's initiative to provide Banten with 13 national projects, including improvements to Sukarno-Hatta Airport and the Panimbang toll road.
• 😀 Rano Karno emphasized that Banten's prosperity is largely tied to the Tangerang region, but acknowledged the difficulties in developing areas like Pandeglang and Lebak.
• 😀 The speaker expressed hope that Banten's economy would soon improve with the establishment of the Tanjung Lesung Special Economic Zone, which aims to boost development in the region.

Q & A

What is the main issue discussed by the speaker regarding Banten's development?

The main issue discussed is the stagnation and even decline in the Human Development Index (HDI) of Banten from 2012 to 2017, with a specific focus on why this occurred despite efforts made by the local government.

What position did the speaker hold in Banten, and for how long?

The speaker held the position of Vice Governor of Banten from 2012 to 2013 and then became the Acting Governor (PLT) of Banten from 2013 to 2015. He served as Governor for one year, from 2015 to 2016.

What challenge did the speaker face while coordinating Banten's development?

The speaker faced coordination challenges due to the division of the region into two separate jurisdictions: the police forces and military were split between Banten and Jakarta, making governance and development efforts more complicated.

How did the speaker describe the situation in Tangerang compared to other parts of Banten?

The speaker mentioned that the Tangerang area (Tangerang, Tangerang Selatan, and Kota Tangerang) is already an established population center, making it easier for development. In contrast, areas like Pandeglang and Lebak face greater challenges in terms of development.

What national projects were awarded to Banten to help with its development?

Banten was awarded 13 national projects, including the development of the Sukarno-Hatta Airport as a major regional hub (considered Banten’s airport), the Panimbang toll road, and a special economic zone in Tanjung Lesung to boost local economic growth.

What is the significance of the Sukarno-Hatta Airport for Banten?

Sukarno-Hatta Airport is significant for Banten as it is considered part of Banten’s territory rather than Jakarta’s, marking it as a crucial infrastructural asset for the province's development.

What is the role of the Panimbang toll road in Banten’s development?

The Panimbang toll road is intended to improve connectivity within Banten and help drive the region’s economic development by facilitating easier access to key areas and encouraging investment.

What are the challenges faced by areas like Pandeglang and Lebak?

Pandeglang and Lebak are more difficult to develop due to their geographical and infrastructural limitations, which are less established compared to the Tangerang region.

How does the speaker believe Banten can improve its Human Development Index (HDI)?

The speaker believes that the development of key infrastructure projects, such as the economic zone in Tanjung Lesung and continued investments in regions like Pandeglang and Lebak, will help improve Banten’s HDI over time.

What was the speaker's message regarding the leadership of Banten during his tenure?

The speaker emphasized the importance of leadership and governance, pointing out the complexities of coordinating across different regions and sectors, especially in Banten, which faced challenges due to its administrative split from Jakarta.