IAS vs Judge कौन ज्यादा ताकतवर है💪Best Guidance by Vikas Divyakirti sir hindi motivation

Summary

The transcript explores the power dynamics within India's judicial and administrative systems, particularly focusing on the authority of the High Court. It details how judges, especially at the district level, wield significant influence and highlights the interplay between the judiciary, police, and administrative officials. The script also touches upon the long and challenging journey to becoming a judge, with the complexities of nepotism and bureaucratic delays, as well as the rigorous eligibility requirements for High Court appointments. The discussion sheds light on the practical realities faced by those aspiring to join the judicial system in India.

Takeaways

• 😀 The High Court is very powerful, and its orders are binding on everyone, including district collectors and the Chief Minister (CM).
• 😀 If the High Court orders the CM and the district collector to act on a matter, non-compliance can lead to contempt of court, and both could face consequences.
• 😀 The High Court is a 'court of record,' meaning its decisions must be accepted by all subordinate courts.
• 😀 The High Court has the authority to sue anyone based on contempt of court, including those in high positions like secretaries.
• 😀 Judges and civil servants must comply immediately with the High Court’s directives; failure to do so can result in public reprimands.
• 😀 The process to become a judge in India is lengthy, requiring years of experience and legal practice. A person must be at least 40 years old to become a district judge.
• 😀 Civil service roles like IAS and IPS allow faster career progression compared to the judiciary, where becoming a High Court judge can take decades.
• 😀 The district judge has significant power but is not as powerful as the district magistrate (DM) or the superintendent of police (SP), who hold more immediate authority.
• 😀 District judges often rely on police officers and administrative officials to enforce their decisions effectively.
• 😀 Becoming a High Court judge involves rigorous criteria such as 7–8 years of service as a district judge or 10 years of good legal practice. Political influence and red tape can delay such appointments.
• 😀 District judges, SPs, and district magistrates in a region maintain a good rapport, often collaborating informally to ensure smooth governance and law enforcement.

Q & A

What is the power of the High Court mentioned in the transcript?

The High Court has significant power, as it can issue orders to the collector, and even the Chief Minister must comply. If ignored, the person can face contempt of court charges, and the High Court has the authority to penalize individuals for contempt.

What happens if there is a conflict between orders from the State Government and the High Court?

In such a case, the High Court's order takes precedence. The High Court has the authority to enforce its decisions, and if any party fails to comply, they may face contempt charges.

Can the High Court send officers to jail for contempt of court?

Yes, the High Court has the authority to send officers, even those holding secretary-rank positions, to jail for contempt of court if necessary.

What does 'Court of Record' mean in the context of the High Court?

A 'Court of Record' means that the decisions made by the High Court are recorded and must be accepted and obeyed by all subordinate courts. It also implies that the High Court can take legal action against anyone for contempt.

What is the process to become a District Judge?

To become a District Judge in India, one must typically gain at least 12-15 years of experience after becoming a judge. It is a long process, requiring years of legal experience and dedication before reaching the District Judge level.

How does one enter the Indian Judicial Service compared to the Civil Services?

The Indian Judicial Service requires a long path of legal practice and seniority. It takes much longer to become a District Judge or higher in the judiciary compared to the Civil Services, where one can become a District Head much earlier.

How do District Judges interact with the police and administrative heads?

District Judges, police officers (SP), and administrative heads (Collector) generally maintain good relationships. The District Judge relies on the police for enforcing legal decisions, and the police officers respect the judicial authority. They coordinate closely on matters of law enforcement and administration.

What role does networking play in becoming a High Court judge?

To become a High Court judge, individuals must go through a complex selection process that involves networking with senior judicial authorities, including the Chief Justice of the High Court and senior judges. Networking with political figures, including the Chief Minister, can also play a role in advancing one's career.

What is the significance of experience for becoming a High Court Judge?

To be eligible for becoming a High Court judge, an individual must have at least 7-8 years of experience as a District Judge or 10 years of legal practice. This ensures that only those with substantial legal experience and expertise can be considered for such a prestigious position.

How are judicial appointments processed in India, especially for High Court Judges?

The process for judicial appointments involves recommendations from the Supreme Court Collegium, which includes the Chief Justice and senior judges. Once the recommendations are sent to the government, the process can be delayed due to bureaucratic hurdles. Ultimately, the appointment may only happen shortly before the retirement of the incumbent judge.