Me ataca un adiestrador, a dónde vamos a llegar

Summary

In this video, the speaker responds to criticism from a dog trainer who has been disparaging others in the animal care community. The speaker defends their methods, specifically their use of discipline, such as occasional physical correction, in training their dogs. They emphasize the importance of hierarchy, respect, and firm discipline, especially for working dogs like mastiffs. Drawing from years of experience in animal husbandry, the speaker critiques the disconnect between modern ideologies and traditional animal training practices, stressing that such methods are rooted in real-world needs rather than idealized training techniques.

Takeaways

• 😀 The speaker defends their use of physical discipline in training animals, particularly dogs, as part of a method based on years of experience with rural life and farming animals.
• 😀 They emphasize that the criticism against their training methods often comes from people who don't understand the realities of working with animals in a rural environment.
• 😀 The speaker argues that dogs, especially working breeds like mastiffs, need firm discipline to prevent dangerous behavior, not just positive reinforcement or 'pet' training techniques.
• 😀 They distinguish between urban dog training (focused on tricks) and rural dog training (focused on functionality and behavior control in the field).
• 😀 The speaker refutes the idea that their dogs are mistreated, explaining that the use of physical correction is done to teach respect and establish a hierarchy.
• 😀 They use personal examples, such as disciplining their dog Perla for killing a cat, to illustrate that such actions lead to more responsible behavior without causing fear or trauma.
• 😀 The speaker stresses that their dogs are not afraid of them but understand the boundaries and respect the authority they have established.
• 😀 The speaker argues that the practice of training mastiffs, especially in farm environments, involves exposure to natural behaviors and forces (like interactions with other animals) that teach them discipline.
• 😀 They criticize the disconnect between urban animal care practices and the reality of life on farms, where animals are exposed to more challenging and potentially dangerous situations.
• 😀 The speaker calls out the rise of ideological approaches to animal training, arguing that science should guide training methods rather than political views or opinions.

Q & A

What is the speaker's main point in the video?

The speaker is defending their approach to dog training, particularly with mastiffs, and criticizing the negative judgments from others, especially a self-proclaimed dog trainer. They emphasize the importance of discipline, hierarchy, and hands-on experience in training animals, particularly in a farming or working environment.

Why does the speaker defend their use of physical discipline with animals?

The speaker argues that physical discipline, such as a slap or correction, is not abusive but rather a necessary method to establish boundaries and ensure the animals' safety and functionality in a natural environment. They believe that without such discipline, animals could become dangerous or uncontrollable.

How does the speaker respond to accusations of animal abuse?

The speaker acknowledges giving their dogs a slap or correction, but clarifies that it is done in a controlled and minimal way, especially when they misbehave. They stress that these actions are meant to teach the animals respect and boundaries, and that the dogs are not harmed or mistreated.

What does the speaker mean by the 'hierarchy' in animal training?

The speaker refers to the 'hierarchy' as the clear structure of authority between them and their animals. The animals must understand their place in the structure, where their behavior is monitored and corrected to ensure their obedience and safety in a working environment.

What example does the speaker give to explain their training methods?

The speaker shares a story about their dog Perla, who once killed a litter of kittens. They explain that they punished Perla with a slap, which led to Perla never harming another cat again. The speaker believes this method teaches the animals respect for boundaries without causing fear or harm.

What does the speaker say about the criticism they receive from the other dog trainer?

The speaker criticizes the other dog trainer for focusing on negative judgments of their training methods. They feel that the trainer lacks a practical understanding of working with animals in a real-world context, where discipline and functionality are prioritized over competition-style training.

How does the speaker differentiate their approach from competition-style dog training?

The speaker distinguishes their approach by highlighting that they train animals for practical purposes in the field, not for performance or entertainment. They argue that in farming and working environments, dogs need to be functional, disciplined, and able to handle real-life challenges, unlike dogs trained for tricks and competitions.

What is the speaker's opinion on the role of political ideologies in animal training?

The speaker is critical of political ideologies influencing animal training, stating that animal care should be based on science and real-world experience rather than political views. They argue that ideologies can distort the practical and effective methods needed to train animals properly.

How does the speaker defend the use of mastiffs in farming environments?

The speaker defends the use of mastiffs by explaining that, unlike other breeds, they are naturally suited to protecting livestock. They believe that mastiffs are trained through experience, including physical discipline, and that their effectiveness comes from a strong bond with their work environment and respect for the animals they protect.

What is the significance of the speaker's comment about having nine mastiffs and other animals on their farm?

The speaker uses the example of having nine mastiffs and other animals on their farm to illustrate how they maintain harmony between predators (mastiffs, dogs, cats) and prey (sheep, chickens). Despite having potentially dangerous animals and multiple species, the speaker emphasizes that their farm operates smoothly and safely due to the disciplined and functional training of the animals.