Don't Buy This DUNE Edition!

Summary

In this video, the creator compares two editions of *Dune*: the *Fool Society* edition and the *Dune Deluxe Edition* from Ace Books (2019). The focus is on the quality of materials, binding, and overall durability. While the Ace Books edition features an attractive dust jacket and colorful design, it is criticized for its low-quality binding and paper that may degrade over time. In contrast, the *Fool Society* edition stands out for its premium materials, durability, and long-lasting design, making it the better choice for true collectors and *Dune* enthusiasts.

Takeaways

• 😀 The dust jacket of the 2019 Dune Deluxe Edition is visually attractive and colorful but prone to damage, especially at the top and bottom due to shipping.
• 😀 A slipcase provides much better protection compared to a dust jacket, ensuring better durability for the book.
• 😀 The binding of the 2019 Dune edition is a paper-blocked type, which is not very durable and can easily bend at the top and bottom of the spine.
• 😀 The book’s paper quality is questionable, feeling low-quality despite being acid-free, and there are concerns about its long-term durability due to the glued binding.
• 😀 The 2019 Dune Deluxe Edition is marketed as a 'deluxe' version, but it lacks the high-quality materials and craftsmanship that a true deluxe edition would offer.
• 😀 The fully cloth-bound edition from the Folio Society is far superior in terms of durability, look, and feel, with metallic cloth binding and a slipcase for added protection.
• 😀 The 2019 Dune Deluxe Edition is designed more for appearance on the shelf rather than for collectors or long-term readers.
• 😀 The paper in the 2019 edition appears acid-free, which is a positive, but no official confirmation is provided on the copyright page.
• 😀 The Folio Society edition features a durable slipcase, premium paper, and high-quality binding that ensures longevity, making it a better choice for dedicated Dune fans.
• 😀 The Folio Society edition is designed for readers and built to last a lifetime, with features like printed endpapers, textured paper, and acid-free paper made for long-term preservation.
• 😀 Overall, the 2019 Dune Deluxe Edition is considered a lower-quality option compared to the Folio Society edition, which offers more lasting value for serious readers.

Q & A

What are the main differences between the Fool Society Edition and the Ace Books 2019 Deluxe Edition of *Dune*?

The main differences lie in the quality of materials and construction. The Fool Society Edition features a slipcase, metallic cloth binding, and acid-free paper, making it a durable, long-lasting choice. In contrast, the Ace Books edition has a colorful dust jacket, paperboard binding, and low-quality paper, which is less durable and prone to damage over time.

What is the significance of the slipcase in the Fool Society Edition?

The slipcase provides superior protection for the book, shielding it from potential damage that dust jackets typically can't prevent. This is one of the key advantages of the Fool Society Edition, making it more durable and better suited for long-term storage.

How does the binding of the Ace Books 2019 Deluxe Edition compare to that of the Fool Society Edition?

The Ace Books edition uses a paperboard binding, which is not very durable and can easily bend, especially at the top and bottom of the spine. The Fool Society Edition, on the other hand, uses a more durable metallic cloth binding that is much sturdier and more resistant to wear.

What is the issue with the paper quality in the Ace Books Deluxe Edition?

The paper used in the Ace Books edition is of low quality, which may degrade over time. While it appears to be acid-free, it still feels less durable and is prone to yellowing and damage after extended use, especially when compared to the acid-free, pH-neutral paper in the Fool Society Edition.

Why does the speaker believe the Ace Books 2019 Deluxe Edition is marketed misleadingly?

The Ace Books edition is marketed as a deluxe version, but its lower-quality materials and construction do not align with what would traditionally be considered a 'deluxe' edition. The speaker feels this edition is designed to capitalize on the popularity of the *Dune* movie, offering a visually attractive but ultimately inferior product for long-term readers.

How does the paper in the Fool Society Edition differ from that in the Ace Books edition?

The paper in the Fool Society Edition is thicker, cream-colored, and acid-free, ensuring it will last for decades without yellowing. This is in contrast to the paper in the Ace Books edition, which feels cheaper and may deteriorate more quickly.

What does the speaker recommend for *Dune* fans looking for a long-lasting edition?

The speaker strongly recommends the Fool Society Edition for *Dune* fans who are looking for a long-lasting, premium edition. This version is built to endure over time, making it the better investment for serious readers and collectors.

How does the Fool Society Edition's construction ensure its durability?

The Fool Society Edition features a metallic cloth binding, a thick slipcase, and acid-free paper, all of which contribute to its durability. The smooth sewn binding allows the book to open fully without strain, and the sturdy materials ensure it will last for many years.

What does the speaker think about the value of the Ace Books Deluxe Edition for readers?

The speaker believes the Ace Books Deluxe Edition offers little long-term value, as it is more of a display piece intended to capitalize on the *Dune* movie's success. The materials and construction are not designed for lasting use, making it less suitable for readers who want a high-quality, long-lasting edition.

What specific features of the Fool Society Edition make it the 'best non-limited edition' of *Dune*?

The Fool Society Edition is considered the best non-limited edition because of its durable construction (metallic cloth binding and slipcase), high-quality acid-free paper, and the inclusion of printed endpapers with maps and illustrations. It is built to last and offers an overall superior reading experience compared to other mainstream editions.