Jordan Peterson’s Opinion On The Incel Movement

Summary

In this insightful discussion, the speaker explores the origins and psychological implications of the incel and black pill movements, linking them to the pickup artist (PUA) community. He highlights the dangers of using manipulative tactics, like feigning confidence and psychopathy, to attract women, and the resulting emotional toll it can take on individuals. Drawing parallels to figures like Andrew Tate, the speaker discusses the complex dynamics of confidence, cynicism, and personal development, emphasizing the value of intellectual humility and learning from criticism, even when it comes from adversarial sources.

Takeaways

• 😀 The origins of the 'incel' and 'black pill' movements can be traced back to disillusioned members of the Pickup Artist (PUA) community who became increasingly jaded and cynical after attempting manipulative dating techniques.
• 😀 Pickup Artist techniques often involve feigning confidence and competence, which can provide temporary success but ultimately leave practitioners feeling hollow and disconnected from their true selves.
• 😀 The process of learning manipulative behaviors, such as those promoted by PUA, can lead to emotional detachment and jadedness, turning individuals into more callous and psychopathic versions of themselves.
• 😀 Andrew Tate is appealing to many young men due to his blend of real-world success (e.g., physical bravery, wealth) and toxic masculinity, which resonates with men looking for validation and a model of confidence.
• 😀 While Tate's confidence and success are real, much of his ideology is rooted in manipulation and objectification, offering an unhelpful model for personal growth and development in the long term.
• 😀 Pickup Artist techniques, though criticized for their manipulative nature, can also offer value by helping individuals build resilience through rejection therapy, which desensitizes them to failure and fosters emotional toughness.
• 😀 Intellectual humility, such as being willing to admit ignorance and ask questions, is key to personal growth. Those who avoid vulnerability by pretending to know everything remain intellectually stagnant.
• 😀 The philosophy of embracing criticism, even from enemies, is crucial for self-improvement, as harsh critiques can uncover flaws that individuals might not recognize themselves.
• 😀 The false confidence taught in PUA communities is a form of 'scripted psychopathy,' where individuals act out a persona of calmness and self-possession, often masking deeper insecurities and leading to long-term psychological harm.
• 😀 Despite the manipulative nature of PUA methods, some individuals may find value in these practices as a stepping stone toward overcoming personal limitations, such as social anxiety or fear of rejection.

Q & A

What is the origin of the incel and black pill movements?

The incel and black pill movements can be traced back to a community called 'PUA Hate,' a subreddit or website where men, after experiencing pickup artistry, became disillusioned with its teachings and developed a more jaded view of relationships and self-worth.

How does learning pickup artistry affect someone's view of relationships?

Learning pickup artistry may initially make someone more successful with women, but it often leads to a realization of the vast disconnect between the persona they project and their true self, which can increase feelings of self-loathing and jadedness.

Why does practicing manipulation through pickup artistry lead to negative outcomes?

Manipulating others through psychopathic techniques, such as feigning confidence and competence, can distort one's genuine self, leading to emotional detachment and a more cynical, unproductive view of relationships.

What role does psychopathy play in the teachings of pickup artistry?

Pickup artistry often involves techniques that resemble psychopathy, such as feigning competence and emotional stability, which can ultimately train individuals to manipulate others without genuine emotional engagement, leading to a hollow sense of success.

How does Andrew Tate's persona appeal to certain audiences?

Andrew Tate attracts followers with his outward displays of confidence, wealth, and success, especially among young men seeking a way to overcome their feelings of inadequacy, though much of his approach to women is controversial and manipulative.

What is the potential danger of adopting Andrew Tate's model for self-improvement?

While Tate's model may offer a sense of empowerment through confidence and self-assurance, it can promote harmful, manipulative behaviors towards women, ultimately hindering genuine emotional growth and self-development.

What are the benefits of confronting rejection in the pickup artist community?

One benefit of the pickup artist community's exercises, such as asking for 50 women's phone numbers in a day, is that it helps individuals overcome their fear of rejection, teaching them resilience and the ability to persist despite failure.

How does intellectual humility relate to personal growth and relationships?

Intellectual humility, which involves being open to the possibility of being wrong and seeking learning opportunities, is key to personal growth, as it encourages self-reflection and the ability to adapt in the face of new information and challenges.

What does the concept of 'loving your enemy' teach about self-improvement?

Loving your enemy means accepting criticism, even from those who oppose you, as it can reveal hidden flaws and areas for growth, forcing you to confront and improve aspects of your character you might otherwise ignore.

What is the significance of dealing with hostile journalists in the context of personal growth?

Dealing with hostile journalists, as Jordan Peterson has experienced, forces individuals to step carefully and critically evaluate their responses, which can lead to a more refined, resilient public persona and personal understanding of their values.