Siswa Dilarang Pilih Ketua OSIS Nonmuslim, Guru SMAN 58 Jakarta Dimutasi

Summary

In 2002, a teacher from SMA Negeri 58 Jakarta, identified as TS, allegedly prohibited students from voting for a non-Muslim candidate as the OSIS president. This sparked controversy after screenshots of racist instructions from TS surfaced. The Jakarta Education Office responded by transferring the teacher, citing public feedback. Despite the teacher’s directive, the elected OSIS president was a non-Muslim. The incident also led to discussions by the PDIP faction about forced hijab usage in schools, further highlighting concerns over intolerance in the educational system.

Takeaways

• 😀 A teacher from SMA Negeri 58 Jakarta, identified as TS, was transferred after prohibiting students from electing a non-Muslim student as the head of the student council in 2002.
• 😀 The teacher's action, which was deemed intolerant, came to light after a screenshot of a WhatsApp message containing discriminatory instructions was circulated.
• 😀 The head of DKI Jakarta's Education Department, Nahdiana, confirmed the teacher's transfer during a session with the DKI Jakarta DPRD's PDIP faction on August 10.
• 😀 Nahdiana explained that the teacher's transfer was prompted by the need for more than just disciplinary punishment, suggesting a lack of sufficient punishment for the teacher's actions.
• 😀 Despite the teacher’s prohibition against electing a non-Muslim student council president, the actual outcome was the election of a non-Muslim student as president.
• 😀 The controversy surrounding the teacher's actions escalated after the viral WhatsApp screenshot exposed racist instructions from the teacher.
• 😀 The PDIP faction in the DKI Jakarta DPRD summoned the DKI Education Department to investigate the incident and also raised concerns about the forced use of hijabs in schools.
• 😀 The issue of religious intolerance within schools in Jakarta has been a focal point of public debate after the incident involving the teacher.
• 😀 The teacher's actions sparked outrage, as many viewed it as an attempt to impose religious discrimination within the school system.
• 😀 The Education Department's response to the controversy underscores the seriousness with which it is addressing intolerance and discriminatory actions in educational institutions.

Q & A

What was the reason for the teacher's transfer at SMA Negeri 58 Jakarta?

The teacher, identified as TS, was transferred after allegedly preventing students from voting for a non-Muslim candidate for the position of OSIS (Student Council) President in 2002.

Who took action regarding the teacher's behavior and what was their stance?

The Head of the Jakarta Department of Education, Nahdiana, responded by saying that the teacher's actions were not only against school rules but also discriminatory, and therefore a transfer was necessary instead of merely imposing disciplinary sanctions.

What evidence led to the teacher’s mutasi (transfer)?

The issue was brought to light when a screenshot surfaced showing racist instructions allegedly sent by TS in a WhatsApp group.

What was the nature of the controversial instruction given by the teacher?

The teacher reportedly instructed students not to vote for a non-Muslim candidate for OSIS President, which was considered an act of intolerance.

What was the reaction of the PDIP faction in the Jakarta DPRD (Regional People's Representative Council)?

The PDIP faction called in the Jakarta Department of Education to investigate the case, particularly regarding allegations of forced use of the hijab in schools.

Was there a contradiction between the teacher’s instructions and the actual outcome?

Yes, despite TS's instructions, the elected OSIS President was a non-Muslim, which contradicted the teacher's actions.

How did the Jakarta Department of Education handle the situation?

The department decided to transfer the teacher as a response to the incident, emphasizing that simply giving a disciplinary sanction would not have been sufficient to address the issue.

What was the timeline of events regarding this issue?

The incident occurred in 2002, and the teacher was transferred following the public disclosure of the WhatsApp messages in 2022, with the PDIP faction raising concerns in August 2022.

What did Nahdiana emphasize about the disciplinary actions taken against TS?

Nahdiana emphasized that while a disciplinary sanction alone would not suffice, a transfer was necessary to address the intolerance shown by the teacher.

What additional issue was raised by the PDIP faction during the investigation?

The PDIP faction also questioned the Jakarta Department of Education about allegations of schools forcing students to wear the hijab, which was brought up alongside the case of TS.