Product We LOVE and HATE from La Roche-Posay | Doctorly Reviews

Summary

本期视频中，Dr. Shaw和Dr. Maxfield讨论了他们对L'Oréal（L Ro P）品牌的爱恨交织的情感，特别指出了品牌产品命名和包装的频繁变更给全球观众带来的困扰。他们分享了对该品牌最喜爱和最不喜爱的护肤产品，包括保湿霜、洁面乳和防晒霜等，同时提到了活性成分产品如乙醇酸和苯甲酸凝胶。虽然对某些产品的成分和包装有所保留，但总体上，他们对L Ro P品牌的评价是积极的，尤其是对其保湿产品线。

Takeaways

• 🌟 视频中讨论了L'Oréal（罗莱）品牌的护肤产品，包括最佳和最差产品。
• 💡 Dr. Shaw和Dr. Maxfield都对L'Oréal品牌有深厚的感情，尽管产品名称和配方经常变化。
• 🧴 Lipar AP Plus M（三重保湿霜）被认为是卓越的保湿产品，特别适合干燥皮肤。
• 🛁 CeraStimBalm（修复炸弹）是另一个备受推崇的产品，特别适合敏感和受刺激的皮肤。
• 🌞 Anthelios系列的防晒产品在美国和国际上都取得了巨大成功，特别是Melt and Milk 60。
• 🧼 Taran Purifying Foaming Cleanser（塔兰净化泡沫洁面乳）是一款不会过度干燥皮肤的优质洁面产品。
• 🥑 讨论了L'Oréal的清洁油，尽管不是典型的油基洁面产品，但因其出色的保湿和清洁效果而受到喜爱。
• 🍯 谈到了L'Oréal的果酸产品，它含有10%的果酸和互补成分，适合预算有限的用户。
• 💥 但是，该果酸产品含有较高浓度的酒精，可能会引起敏感肌肤的刺痛感。
• 🎯 L'Oréal的活性成分产品，如EPAR Duo（含有苯扎醌和水杨酸的产品），对痤疮有出色的局部治疗效果。
• 🚫 视频中提到L'Oréal的精华液系列普遍含有较高浓度的酒精和香料，这可能是该系列产品的弱点。

Q & A

视频中提到的L Ro P品牌的保湿产品有哪些特点？

L Ro P品牌的保湿产品在保湿方面表现出色，特别是Lipar AP Plus M三重保湿霜，它能够提供深层滋润而不留下油腻感。此外，该品牌还添加了神经酰胺等成分，增强了产品的保湿效果和适用性。

Dr. Shaw和Dr. Maxfield在视频中讨论了哪些L Ro P品牌的最爱产品？

他们讨论了L Ro P的Lipar AP Plus M三重保湿霜、Seaea Plast Bomb修复霜、Mattifying Moisturizer控油保湿霜、Taran Purifying Foaming Cleanser洁面乳和Cleansing Oil洁面油等产品。

为什么Dr. Shaw对L Ro P品牌的产品名称和包装变化感到沮丧？

Dr. Shaw感到沮丧的原因是，L Ro P品牌经常更改产品名称和包装，这导致不同地区的产品名称可能不一致，给他的全球观众带来困惑，使他们难以找到和购买之前讨论过的产品。

视频中提到的L Ro P品牌的Seaea Plast Bomb修复霜有什么特别之处？

Seaea Plast Bomb修复霜特别适合敏感和受刺激的皮肤屏障修复使用。它含有二甲硅油，使其比其它产品具有更强的修复功能。

Dr. Maxfield为什么推荐L Ro P的Cleansing Oil洁面油？

Dr. Maxfield推荐Cleansing Oil洁面油是因为它在保湿和清洁之间取得了完美的平衡。尽管它是一款油基洁面产品，但它不会给皮肤留下油腻感，而且能够有效地清洁皮肤。

L Ro P品牌的防晒产品有哪些值得推荐？

L Ro P的Anthelios系列防晒产品非常受欢迎，特别是Melt and Milk 60防晒乳，适用于身体和面部，量大且性价比高。在欧洲，UV M 400系列也很受欢迎，但因为美国不允许某些防晒剂，所以在美国买不到。

视频中提到的L Ro P品牌的glycolic acid产品有哪些优点？

L Ro P的glycolic acid产品是一个预算友好且直接的果酸产品，无香料，并且含有补充成分如凝血酸和氨甲环酸，有助于改善肤质和色素沉着。

Dr. Shaw和Dr. Maxfield为什么对L Ro P品牌的血清产品持保留意见？

他们对L Ro P品牌的血清产品持保留意见，主要是因为这些产品含有较高浓度的酒精和香料，可能会引起皮肤刺痛和敏感，而且包装设计也不是他们喜欢的。

L Ro P品牌的Adapalene Gel是一种什么成分？

Adapalene Gel是一种强大的痤疮治疗成分，适用于治疗开放性和闭合性粉刺，能够显著改善皮肤质地，是柜台上可获得的最强效的痤疮成分之一。

处方强度的Adapalene和柜台购买的Adapalene有什么区别？

处方强度的Adapalene浓度为3%，而柜台购买的Adapalene浓度为0.1%。研究表明，更高浓度的Adapalene可能更有效。此外，还有结合了Adapalene和苯甲酸过氧化物的产品，如Epiduo，可以从皮肤科医生那里获得。

Dr. Shaw和Dr. Maxfield如何评价L Ro P品牌的整体表现？

尽管L Ro P品牌有一些产品他们个人认为不完美，但整体上他们对该品牌的评价非常高。特别是保湿产品线给他们留下了深刻印象，使得L Ro P成为了他们心目中的前五名护肤品牌之一。

Outlines

00:00

🌟 品牌介绍与个人感受

本段介绍了Dr. Shaw和Dr. Maxfield对L'Oréal（L Ro P）品牌的看法，他们对该品牌有着复杂的爱恨关系。Dr. Shaw曾访问过法国的L Ro P源头，并对品牌有着良好的印象。然而，由于产品名称和配方在不同地区的变化，以及产品线的频繁更新，使得他们感到困扰。尽管如此，他们认为L Ro P的某些护肤产品在过去一年中非常受欢迎，并且拥有出色的配方。

05:01

🧴 推荐产品与使用体验

在这一段中，两位医生讨论了他们最喜欢的L Ro P产品，包括保湿霜、洁面油和防晒霜。特别提到了Lipar AP Plus M三重保湿霜，它以其滋润而不油腻的特性受到推崇。此外，他们还讨论了Seaplast炸弹和Mattifying Moisturizer，以及Taran净化泡沫洁面乳。这些产品因其出色的性能和成分而被推荐给患者。

10:02

🌀 产品优缺点分析

本段中，Dr. Shaw和Dr. Maxfield分析了L Ro P产品的优缺点。他们提到了L Ro P的洁面油和防晒霜系列，尽管在美国市场上，含油洁面产品的接受度较低。他们也讨论了L Ro P的活性成分产品，如glycolic acid和epar duo，以及adapalene凝胶。此外，他们对L Ro P的精华产品线持保留态度，因为这些产品含有较高浓度的酒精和香料，这可能会对皮肤造成刺激。

Keywords

💡护肤

护肤是指采取各种措施来维护和改善皮肤健康和外观的过程。在视频中，Dr. Shaw和Dr. Maxfield讨论了L'Oréal Paris（L Ro P）品牌的护肤产品，包括它们的优缺点，以及如何根据皮肤类型选择合适的产品。

💡L'Oréal Paris

L'Oréal Paris（简称L Ro P）是一家国际知名的化妆品和护肤品牌，以其广泛的产品线和创新的护肤配方而闻名。在视频中，两位医生对该品牌的产品进行了详细的评价和讨论。

💡保湿霜

保湿霜是一种护肤产品，旨在为皮肤提供水分，帮助维持皮肤的水分平衡，使皮肤保持柔软和滋润。在视频中，Dr. Shaw和Dr. Maxfield特别推荐了L Ro P的Lipar AP Plus M三重保湿霜，因为它能够提供长时间的保湿效果而不油腻。

💡洁面产品

洁面产品是用来清洁皮肤，去除污垢、油脂和化妆品残留的护肤产品。在视频中，提到了L Ro P的多种洁面产品，包括泡沫洁面乳和洁面油，这些产品旨在提供温和而有效的清洁，适合不同的皮肤类型和需求。

💡防晒霜

防晒霜是一种护肤产品，含有能够吸收或散射紫外线的成分，从而保护皮肤免受紫外线的伤害。在视频中，讨论了L Ro P的Anthelios系列防晒霜，这些产品提供了高效的防晒保护，并且有适合不同使用场合和肤质的配方。

💡活性成分

活性成分是指在护肤产品中添加的具有特定护肤功效的成分，如去角质、抗痘、美白等。在视频中，讨论了L Ro P含有不同活性成分的产品，例如含有水杨酸的产品适合去角质和淡化斑点，而含有苯扎酰过氧化物和乳酸的产品则适合局部治疗痤疮。

💡酒精

酒精在护肤产品中通常作为溶剂、防腐剂或稳定剂使用。然而，对于某些皮肤类型，尤其是敏感肌肤，高浓度的酒精可能会导致刺激或不适。在视频中，提到L Ro P的一些产品含有较高浓度的酒精和香料，这可能会影响部分消费者的使用体验。

💡皮肤类型

皮肤类型是指根据皮肤的特定特征，如油脂分泌、水分含量、敏感度和反应性等因素进行分类。了解皮肤类型有助于选择合适的护肤产品，以达到最佳的护肤效果。

💡产品评价

产品评价是指对某一产品的性能、效果、使用感受等方面进行系统的评价和分析。在视频中，两位医生根据自己的专业知识和使用经验，对L Ro P的多个护肤产品进行了详细的评价，包括它们的优点和缺点。

💡品牌忠诚度

品牌忠诚度是指消费者对某一品牌的持续偏好和支持，通常基于对品牌产品的质量、效果和信任度的认同。在视频中，虽然提到了对L Ro P产品的一些批评，但两位医生也表达了对该品牌的总体喜爱和忠诚。

💡护肤建议

护肤建议是指专业人士或有经验的消费者根据皮肤状况和需求提供的关于护肤品选择和使用的建议。在视频中，两位医生根据自己的专业知识和实践经验，为观众提供了关于如何选择和使用L Ro P护肤产品的建议。

Highlights

Introduction to the best and worst of L Ro POS skincare brand, highlighting a love-hate relationship.

Frustration with the brand due to constant changes in product names and differences between U.S. and European products.

High praise for Lipar AP Plus M, a top three moisturizer, especially recommended for dry skin.

Seea Plast Bomb recommended for sensitive, irritated skin with healing properties.

Discussion on the brand's mattifying moisturizer, ideal for oily skin.

Favorite cleanser: Taran Purifying Foaming Cleanser for clean yet non-drying effects.

The cleansing oil’s surprising balance between hydration and effective cleansing.

Anthelios sunscreen line’s popularity and recommendations for both tinted and untinted forms.

The mixed feelings about the serum line due to high alcohol content and fragrance.

Praise for the glycolic acid product for its budget-friendly and effective formula, despite high alcohol content.

Epar Duo product highlighted as a hero product for acne treatment.

Critical view of the high alcohol and fragrance content in most of the brand's serums.

Adapalene gel praised as a powerful over-the-counter acne treatment.

Distinguishing between over-the-counter and prescription strength adapalene.

Overall, L Ro POS is ranked in the top five skincare lines by the hosts despite some criticisms.

Transcripts

what's up everyone we're back I'm Dr

Shaw Dr Maxfield welcome back to our

Channel Dr Le where we talk about all

things skincare and dermatology and

today we are doing one of our favorite

Brands ever the best and worst of L

Ro L Ro POS I feel like I have an

intimate LoveHate relationship with this

brand and I really don't know why it's

probably not warranted and it's probably

unilateral but that's okay today the

best and the worst of L Ro POS what

should you be investing in here we go

here we

go so I will tell you LoveHate

relationship in some ways mostly a love

relationship I've been to France I've

been to L Ro Bose France where they get

their thermal water from in fact so

great relationship that I have with the

brand my frustration comes from the fact

that they Chang the names of the

products all the time and the same

product in the US will be different than

the products in Europe and we have a

global audience so somebody will say I

got this product it's not the same one

that you talked about so me it drives me

crazy and that's where mostly where my

frustration has been as well it's like I

find a product I love but then it

changes and I'm like wait or did it

change did the name and packaging just

change it makes it very complex for me

to keep up with the products that I love

I I want to continue using something and

I feel like I can't so that that's mine

too that's where most of my angst comes

from with this brand so L Ro P has had a

lot of viral skincare products over the

past year it's the fastest growing

skincare brand in the United States and

they have phenomenal formulas some of my

favorite products ever so we're going to

be talking about our favorite products

and our least favorite products so let's

start off with one of our favorite

products I think we both agree on we're

going to go into the moisturizing

category because this is where I think L

Ro POS really excels so lipar AP plus M

phenomenal product probably top three

moisturizers of all time

which one is this what's the AP plus M

which one is this the triple liar triple

moisturizing cream triple moist formerly

known as the uh balm cast balm yes no

not cast balm not seeast Bal you see

what we're talking about like this is

the problem but anyway I 100% agree one

of my favorite body moisturizers I

recommend this to patients all the time

they say can you recommend a good

moisturizer for me I'm like what skin

type blah blah blah this one often makes

my little sticky note that I hand

patience so yes lipar AP plus triple

moisturizing cream is outstanding the

reason I think it excels personally is

it's very hydrating it somehow balances

like a thick hydrating film without the

greasy stickiness that I find a lot of

body moisturizers leave behind

ingredients wise it shines they added

ceramides this year to the product which

the name changed apparently it warrants

it um but tremendous generalizable

recommendable moisturizer right and when

it comes to moisturizers of course you

look at the ingredients but it's really

the performance for me that really hits

home this thing when they say products

last all day sometimes I believe them

sometimes I don't don't this product

definitely lasts all day especially if

you have dry skin now this is not for

somebody who has oily skin especially on

the face but somebody who has dry skin

just a phenomenal product that's really

going to last all day for you this like

Dr Maxfield says has camide it has shea

butter it has glycerin but mostly it's

just the performance over using it over

a long period of time next up let's talk

about the seea plast bomb now we've

talked about this in another video we'll

just link it out if you want more

details from it this is definitely part

of the best of list from Ro POS this

product is phenomenal it also adds that

dimethicone into the moisturizer it's a

little bit of a heavier but which gives

it more healing properties than some of

the other products that we'll talk about

same thing these are products I

generally recommend in the office to

people in real life and this is for the

person who's struggling with the

sensitive irritated skin barrier they're

looking for Recovery balm this is where

that lives also the mattifying

moisturizer we can live in the

moisturizing category forever forever

but we won't the mattifying moisturizer

probably Best in Class maybe for this

for people with oily skin gives you the

n your skin needs protection hydration

but keeps you from being oily it's

outstanding the reason why I was smiling

was cuz I was thinking about the

products that I recommend in the office

versus the products I recommend online

and some there sometimes there's overlap

and sometimes there's not overlap so

it's just an interesting an interesting

point it is for me it has to do with

accessibility and demographics because

for you we know most of you are between

the ages of 20 and 40 in the office for

me the vast majority of my patients are

40 plus 60 plus 70 plus it's mostly like

can you navigate the St stanas and even

the Sora ultas Derm stores online no

well then I need to be picking a product

that you can just go to CVS and get you

know that's where a lot of my dichotomy

split is fair so let's move on to

cleansers so probably my favorite

cleanser and usually I don't like

products that are overly foaming let's

say I do like a good lather actually but

the Taran purifying foaming cleanser

this product is the one that comes in a

clear blue bottle it's a large bottle

it's going to last you a long time I

find that it leaves my skin clean

without overly drying my skin so this

product is a tremendous cleanser from L

Ro POS that is definitely one of my

alltime favorite cleansers as well did

you get the big box of this year where

they had like all the cleansers from L

Ro POS I don't think I got that I've

also moved three times so somebody got

it let's just put it that way it was

incredible it kind of actually stacked

up their cleansing line is just

phenomenal but one that I've fallen in

love with is their cleansing oil and I

didn't expect I would love it this much

it really is the only cleanser I've used

for probably the last last month and I

just don't want to move on from it it I

don't know why it's the season have

changed maybe I'm a little bit drier but

it's the perfect balance between

hydrating cleanser it still has a decent

amount of lather to it so I don't feel

like it leaves me greasy oily at all

it's functionally very effective I'm

pretty darn obsessed with this cleansing

oil right now ingredients wise it

doesn't have like a strong robust skin

oil as the core component that I can

find but it is just an oilbased cleanser

it has things like ninite all the blah

blah Blas surfactants um but it's just

anecdotally outstanding for drier skin

so it's interesting that you say that so

from my understanding when they're doing

Market insights at L'Oreal they found

that the American Consumer doesn't like

the oil cleansers that much very popular

apparently in Europe and abroad but in

America they find that consumers are not

yet there with oilbased cleansers or

cleansers that leave that more oil film

I guess you can call it once it's washed

off I particularly like it I think you

particularly like it and maybe a lot of

the people who watch our content like it

but for some reason they say Mass it

does they don't seem to like it or

they're not quite there yet so it should

be interesting to see if this product

really takes off in the United States or

not I feel like this one doesn't feel

like your prototypical cleansing oil

though and maybe that's why it's going

to have a chance similarly if I get a

real just creep cleans oil I'm not like

the hugest fan of that I feel like you

feel it too much but we'll see how this

lives over the next year next up let's

talk about their sunscreens because the

anthelios line from L Ro POS massive hit

especially abroad and in the United

state so I'll just give you a few of the

ones I really love so one that I really

love is of course the Melt and milk 60

this is good for the body and the face

what I like is that it comes in a really

large bottle for people who want to use

it on the body and the face seriously

because a lot of times you get a 2 O

bottle you're definitely not going to be

using that on the body and the face so

this is more affordable larger size

Blends in really well it's a chemical

sunscreen fragrance-free a product that

I really love and then if you go to

Europe or you go to French Pharmacy when

you're traveling I definitely recommend

checking out the UV mu line from L Ro

POS this is the UV M 400 line they come

in a tinted and an untinted form both

are really really popular but you can't

find them in United States because of

the filters yeah which is always such a

sad shame for the sunscreens I also like

the anthos line I've definitely used

them consistently while I've been

surfing like I've gone through the

bottles so I like them I don't think

this is actually where the brand like

super shines I don't have a strong

strong opinion I do like these

sunscreens I think they're great

generalizable again recommendable to

most people you're going to use it and

enjoy it but I don't have like a star

standout I also don't have a major flop

in this category so there's one product

I don't like from L Ro p and their

sunscreen category just because it was

so heavy for me and difficult to rub in

this is their anthelios UV correct face

sunscreen SPF 70 so this product was

just very difficult for me to rub in and

so I'd ended up not liking it if you

don't like that heavier sunscreen white

cast then I I wouldn't recommend it and

then the next category we'll go with our

active ingredients one that I also again

recommend to patients all the time is

their glycolic acid and I have a

specific reason why I feel like this is

actually a fairly budget friendly

straightforward glycolic acid product

it's fragrance free and it has

complimenting ingredients I think coic

and tranexamic acid live here too this

product is a easy recommend for someone

who's looking to approach that

exfoliating space for dark spots this

has a really good powerful blend of

ingredients that could treat texture and

pigmentation the issue with this product

for me and this is going to be dependent

on the person right if you look at the

studies on alcohol in skin care most of

the time it doesn't seem to disrupt the

Skin Barrier what I will tell you from a

consumer perception standpoint aka me in

some of my patients is that products

that have a lot of alcohol in them tend

to sting when you apply them and they

also have that strong alcohol fragrance

to them so this product the glycolic

acid product has more than 10% alcohol

in it because it's above glycolic acid

in the ingredient list in the glycolic

acid is a 10% glycolic acid so it is a

high concentration of alcohol so if you

get that stinging sens and you have

sensitive skin and you don't like that

sensation then I personally put this on

my kind of mid list but otherwise the

ingredients are phenomenal right and

this is going to be a common theme

you'll see why in a second but the other

side of this is the epar duo product for

active ingredients if you have acne

you're looking to spot treat this is a

hero combination hero product for you

right so this has Benzel peroxide plus

lipohydroxy acid in it that combination

is incredible especially for spot

treating acne you can certainly use it

all over the face but again could be

irritating for a lot of people so

especially as a spot tream and one of

the phenomenal products from L Ro P now

back to alcohol back to alcohol so this

is now the worst of their line and we're

basically going to be talking about the

serums in general their active

ingredient serums like I think some have

some nice combinations like the retinol

Plus nicomide Great Dynamic combination

right the vitamin C vitamin C plus

salicylic we love the the L'Oreal

vitamin C salicylic combo the ha here

that but there's the common theme that

they have a high concentration of

alcohol plus fragrance I don't know and

also I'm not a fan of the packaging I

know that's like trivial uh but the the

color I don't know I love colors but

this packaging I just really don't like

yeah so they have a lot of serums and to

me because of the plethora of skincare

products that are available to Consumers

I think that their serum line is a Miss

for me for the most part so their

retinol again has a lot of alcohol also

has fragrance their High Alo B5

alcohol and a lot of fragrance they're

vitamin C alcohol and a lot of fragrance

and when you have a lot of products that

are widely available that don't have

alcohol and don't have fragrance and

again like Dr Maxfield says this is not

us like disagreeing there's actually

nothing really wrong with alcohol in

your skincare products it could be a

preservative it also adds textural

benefits to the products I personally

don't like it because of the way it

feels on my skin he doesn't have as

sensitive skin as I do so it does it

doesn't bother him as much and so for me

it's a miss on almost all of the serums

from L Ro Bose and I think that that's

just coming down to preference and the

fact that it has fragrance I will say

though I do remember one of the first

serums I used on my skin was one of the

L Ro POS serums I don't remember I

genuinely don't remember which one it's

been years and I 100% got a very burning

stinging sensation off the bat and

that's uncommon for me just with my skin

type unless I already have a damaged

Skin Barrier I usually don't have a

problem with that but and I do think

that it was this constellation of

ingredients that may not be 100%

necessary the last product I'll mention

from L Ro b as far as treatments and

actives go has to be their adapalene gel

this is a phenomenal acne ingredient

it's probably the most powerful acne

ingredient you can find over the counter

it's incredible for those open en closed

coma dones and it's going to really

improve the texture of your skin short

of getting a prescription medication

from your dermatologist this is

definitely on the best list from l b but

I don't think that it is superior than

any of the other options out there so if

you can find it for a good price I

highly recommend it I'll put this here

too a prescription adapalene I was

rereading the adapalene studies myself

this last month for no reason whatsoever

but there is a prescription strength

adap that still exists so if your

dermatologist is prescribing adapalene

it actually may be different than what

you're getting over the counter the

Studies have shown that the higher

concentration adap may be more effective

compared to different trones and things

like that so there is that caveat we've

never said that before and I just wanted

to make it sure it lives somewhere so

there's not this confusion about doctor

prescribed adap your adap there can be a

distinction not always but there can be

right so ad appline that's prescribed

now is the 3% adoline and the one that's

available over the counter is the 0.1%

adline so it's a lower concentration you

can also get adapalene plus benzil

peroxide in one product called Epiduo

from your dermatologist so it simplifies

your routine by having those two

ingredients in one so of course senior

dermatologist is going to give you more

options and usually more effective

options especially when it comes to acne

that pretty much summarizes our video

there is a lot more excellent products

from LB that we didn't have a chance to

mention and we'll mention them in other

videos as we come along overall an

excellent line a few misses for me

personally uh but you know one of my top

favorite skincare lines has to be top

five for me oh yeah absolutely they won

me over with the moisturizers and now

I'm here to stay uh L Ro p is in my top

five as well thank you all so much for

tuning in please like comment and

subscribe and we'll see you in the next

video see you next time