Who makes the ALL TIME Man Utd x Liverpool combined XI? 👀 | Saturday Social

Summary

In a lively debate, football enthusiasts discussed the greatest combined Man United and Liverpool team from the Premier League era. Notable players like Peter Schmeichel, Allison Becker, Virgil van Dijk, and Mohamed Salah were highlighted for their exceptional contributions. The conversation touched on the impact of these players on their respective teams and the league, with a special emphasis on the evolution of their roles and the tactical systems they thrived in.

Takeaways

• 🥅 The debate on the greatest combined Man United and Liverpool goalkeeper in Premier League history revolves around Peter Schmeichel and Alisson Becker, with Schmeichel's influence in the early years of Sir Alex Ferguson and Alisson's statistical excellence being highlighted.
• 🛡️ In the right back position, there's a strong argument for Trent Alexander-Arnold's creativity and attacking prowess, despite Gary Neville's significant contributions and longevity at Manchester United.
• 🥊 The center back pairing is unanimously agreed upon as Rio Ferdinand and Virgil van Dijk, both recognized for their technical ability and reading of the game, representing different eras of the Premier League.
• ⚽️ The left back position sparks a disagreement, with Patrice Evra's defensive qualities and leadership being weighed against Andy Robertson's attacking numbers and influence on the modern game.
• 🏆 The midfield three of Steven Gerrard, Roy Keane, and Paul Scholes is largely agreed upon, with Gerrard's all-around abilities, Keane's defensive skills, and Scholes' ball-playing and control being praised.
• 🏃‍♂️ The forward line sees Wayne Rooney and Mohamed Salah as undisputed picks, with a debate on the third spot between Sadio Mane and Cristiano Ronaldo, highlighting their goal scoring, adaptability, and overall impact.
• 🤔 The exercise is not solely about determining the final 11, but also about appreciating and discussing the great players and their contributions to the Premier League era.
• 📈 Alisson Becker's statistical performance, including preventing a high amount of expected goals (XG), is emphasized as a key factor in Liverpool's recent success.
• 🎭 The conversation underlines the importance of considering both individual talent and the system in which players perform, as well as the evolution of playing styles over time.
• 🏅 The script acknowledges the achievements and legacy of players like Dennis Irwin and Michael Carrick, who, despite not being center-stage in the debate, have made significant contributions to their respective clubs.
• 🌟 The script serves as a reminder that player evaluations can be subjective and are influenced by factors such as era, playing style, and personal bias.

Q & A

What is the main topic of the discussion in the transcript?

The main topic of the discussion is the selection of the greatest combined Manchester United and Liverpool team in Premier League history, based on player positions.

Which goalkeeper was argued as the greatest for the combined Man United and Liverpool team?

Peter Schmeichel was argued as one of the greatest goalkeepers for the combined team due to his massive influence, style of play, and the number of Premier League titles he won with Manchester United.

What is the main argument for Allison Becker as the top goalkeeper for the combined team?

The main argument for Allison Becker is his statistical performance, such as preventing expected goals (XG), and his crucial role in Liverpool's success, including winning multiple cups and trophies.

What was the counterargument made for Peter Schmeichel against Allison Becker?

The counterargument for Peter Schmeichel was his difficulty to replace, as evidenced by the struggle Sir Alex Ferguson had in finding a suitable replacement, and Schmeichel's significant contributions and character in the dressing room during his time at Manchester United.

Which right back was chosen for the combined team and why?

Trent Alexander-Arnold was chosen for the combined team due to his technical ability, creativity, and being a part of one of the best teams in the world, despite the argument initially being made for Gary Neville.

What are the main attributes of Rio Ferdinand that make him a top choice for the combined team's center back?

Rio Ferdinand is considered a top choice due to his era-defining play, technical ability, reading of the game, and being an absolute giant for his team during his time.

Why was Virgil van Dijk paired with Rio Ferdinand for the center back position?

Virgil van Dijk was paired with Rio Ferdinand because both possess great technical ability and reading of the game, and they represent defining center backs for their respective eras in the Premier League.

Which left back was chosen for the combined team and what was the main argument for this choice?

Patrice Evra was chosen for the combined team, with the main argument being his defensive numbers and leadership qualities, as well as his adaptability to different systems.

What was the disagreement on the left back position and which player was argued for?

The disagreement on the left back position was between Patrice Evra and Andy Robertson. Andy Robertson was argued for due to his attacking numbers and influence on the modern game as a left back.

Which three players were agreed upon for the midfield in the combined team?

The three players agreed upon for the midfield in the combined team were Steven Gerrard, Roy Keane, and Paul Scholes, due to their significant contributions and influence in the Premier League era.

What was the main point of contention for the forward selection in the combined team?

The main point of contention for the forward selection was between Sadio Mane and Cristiano Ronaldo, with arguments focusing on their respective contributions, adaptability, and impact on their teams and the Premier League as a whole.

Outlines

00:00

🏆 Debating the Greatest Keepers: Schmeichel vs. Alisson

The paragraph discusses a debate between two goalkeepers, Peter Schmeichel of Manchester United and Alisson Becker of Liverpool. Schmeichel is praised for his commanding presence and impact during the early years of Sir Alex Ferguson's era at United, winning 11 major trophies. In contrast, Alisson's statistical excellence is highlighted, with his significant contribution to Liverpool's recent successes, including numerous cups and the Premier League title. The discussion also touches on the longevity and adaptability of both goalkeepers, with Schmeichel's influence in the past and Alisson's ongoing contributions to the current Liverpool team.

05:00

🥇 Comparing Legendary and Modern Right Backs: Neville vs. Alexander-Arnold

This section of the script compares two right backs, Gary Neville of Manchester United and Trent Alexander-Arnold of Liverpool. Neville's longevity and role as Club Captain at United are discussed, along with his overall contribution to the team. On the other hand, Alexander-Arnold's creativity and technical ability as a modern right back are praised, with his significant number of assists at a young age. The conversation acknowledges both players' impact on their respective teams, with a nod to the changing expectations and roles of right backs over time.

10:01

🏆 Evaluating Center Backs: Ferdinand and Van Dijk

The paragraph focuses on the comparison between Rio Ferdinand of Manchester United and Virgil van Dijk of Liverpool. Both players are considered defining center backs of their respective eras, with Ferdinand's era-defining presence and Van Dijk's adaptability and technical ability highlighted. The discussion also touches on the hypothetical scenario of each player in the other's era, with the consensus that both would have been successful. The paragraph emphasizes the impact of both players on their teams and the Premier League as a whole.

15:02

🏃‍♂️ Disagreement on Left Backs: Evra vs. Robertson

This part of the script presents a debate between Patrice Evra and Andy Robertson as the best left back in the Premier League era. Evra's leadership and defensive contributions are contrasted with Robertson's attacking prowess and influence on modern full-backs. The conversation acknowledges Evra's role in defining the left back position during his time, while also recognizing Robertson's impact on the current generation of left backs. The debate highlights the different styles and systems each player was part of and their respective legacies.

🌟 Midfield Mastery: Gerrard, Keane, and Scholes

The paragraph delves into the midfield maestros of the Premier League, focusing on Steven Gerrard, Roy Keane, and Paul Scholes. Gerrard is lauded as a two-way midfielder with adaptability and a complete game, while Keane's defensive prowess and influence are discussed. Scholes is recognized for his deep-lying playmaker role and his pure footballing ability. The conversation also briefly mentions other notable midfielders like Michael Carrick and highlights the importance of these players in defining the Premier League's midfield landscape.

🏃‍♂️ Front Three Favourites: Rooney, Salah, and Ronaldo

The final part of the script debates the front three attackers, focusing on Wayne Rooney, Mohamed Salah, and Cristiano Ronaldo. Rooney's all-around game, longevity, and silverware are praised, while Salah's current form and impact on the Premier League are highlighted. Ronaldo's transformative career, his two-time Premier League Player of the Year award, and his influence as a goalscoring winger are discussed. The conversation also touches on the underrated nature of some players and the evolving roles of attackers in the Premier League.

Keywords

💡Premier League

The Premier League is a top English football league consisting of 20 teams. It is one of the most competitive and popular football leagues globally. In the video, the participants are discussing the greatest players from two Premier League teams, Manchester United and Liverpool, and their contributions to the league's history.

💡Goalkeeper

A goalkeeper is a crucial position in football responsible for preventing the opposing team from scoring by guarding the goal. In the context of the video, Peter Schmeichel and Alisson Becker are discussed as two of the greatest goalkeepers in Premier League history, with their impact on their respective teams and the league.

💡Defensive Style

Defensive style refers to the tactics and strategies employed by a team or individual player to prevent the opposing team from scoring. In the video, the participants discuss how different goalkeepers have adapted to various defensive styles, such as high lines, and their effectiveness in the Premier League.

💡Midfield

Midfield refers to the central area of the football field and the players who operate in this zone. These players often play a key role in controlling the game's flow and creating scoring opportunities. The video highlights the importance of midfielders like Steven Gerrard and Paul Scholes in defining the Premier League era for their respective teams.

💡Winger

A winger is an attacking player who typically operates on the wide areas of the field, usually close to the touchlines. Wingers are known for their pace, skill, and ability to deliver crosses into the penalty area. The video script mentions players like Sadio Mane and Cristiano Ronaldo, who have excelled as wingers in the Premier League, contributing significantly to their teams' successes.

💡Striker

A striker, also known as a forward, is an attacking player whose primary role is to score goals. In the video, Wayne Rooney and Mohamed Salah are mentioned as prolific strikers who have had significant impacts on the Premier League, with their goal-scoring abilities and overall contributions to their teams.

💡Trophy

In the context of football, a trophy represents the championship or award won by a team or individual player. The video participants discuss the number of trophies won by various players during their time in the Premier League, emphasizing the importance of these achievements in evaluating a player's greatness.

💡Longevity

Longevity in sports refers to a player's ability to maintain a high level of performance over an extended period. In the video, the participants consider the longevity of players like Gary Neville and Patrice Evra when discussing their contributions to the Premier League and their teams' successes.

💡System

In football, a system refers to the tactical approach or formation employed by a team. The video highlights how certain players, like Sadio Mane and Cristiano Ronaldo, have adapted to and even defined the systems of their respective teams in the Premier League, showcasing their versatility and impact on the game.

💡Leadership

Leadership in a sports context refers to the ability of a player to guide, motivate, and inspire their teammates, often taking on a captain's role. The video script mentions Patrice Evra as an example of a player who displayed strong leadership qualities, even captaining his team during peak periods.

💡Creativity

Creativity in football refers to a player's ability to create goal-scoring opportunities through skillful play, vision, and innovative actions. The video participants discuss the creativity of players like Trent Alexander-Arnold and Paul Scholes, who have been instrumental in defining their teams' playing styles in the Premier League.

Highlights

The discussion revolves around creating a combined Man United and Liverpool team for the Premier League era.

Peter Schmeichel is considered one of the greatest goalkeepers in Premier League history due to his influence and style of play.

Allison Becker is praised for his statistical performance and contribution to Liverpool's success.

The argument that Schmeichel's impact at Man United was short but very successful is made, with 11 major trophies won.

Trent Alexander-Arnold's creativity and attacking force as a right back are highlighted.

Gary Neville's longevity and importance at Man United are discussed, with his role as Club Captain being emphasized.

The comparison between Neville and Alexander-Arnold showcases the evolution of the right back role in the Premier League.

Rio Ferdinand and Virgil van Dijk are recognized as defining center backs for their respective Premier League eras.

Patrice Evra and Andy Robertson are compared, with Evra's leadership and defensive abilities being noted.

Robertson's role in the current Liverpool system and his influence as a modern fullback are discussed.

The midfield trio of Steven Gerrard, Roy Keane, and Paul Scholes is agreed upon as exceptional Premier League midfielders.

Gerrard is lauded as the greatest two-way midfielder and for his adaptability in the Premier League.

Scholes is recognized for his deep play and control in the midfield, contributing to the Premier League's style of play.

The front three of Wayne Rooney, Mohamed Salah, and Cristiano Ronaldo is acknowledged as a formidable line-up.

Ronaldo's transformative impact on the Premier League and his evolution as a player are discussed.

Salah's current form and his place among the greatest Premier League players are highlighted.

The debate concludes with a focus on the importance of discussing and recognizing great players in the Premier League.

Transcripts

Saturday social brought to you by EA

Sports FC with PlayStation 5 well the

Whiteboard is out uh Man United

Liverpool fan the plan yeah very very

simple we've kind of mixed up our usual

combined 11 today we're going to be

doing one from the Premier League era so

combined Man United and Liverpool 11 for

the Premier League era we couldn't do it

this season could we because it would

have been 11 players been 11 Liverpool

players so we've mixed it up some big

names in here big emissions potentially

yeah as always usual rules apply reveal

the name and then Joe and I will decide

based on the best argument brought

forward so goal who do you have as the

greatest man United Liverpool combined

Keeper in premier league history I'll

let you go first for this one yeah I've

gotone with potentially the greatest

goalkeeper in premier league history

period Peter schmeichel I think he's

someone who was such a massive force in

the Premier League kind of brought in a

new style of goalkeeper in terms of just

making yourself absolutely massive and

when you look at the guy I'm sure who

Lawrence has gone for he is almost in

that style of goalkeeper of just

physically imposing goalkeepers who just

make it scary for opposition attackers

to even attack you and you look at the

number of Premier League titles that had

the influence that he had and honestly

not that long of a time at United but it

was it was short but sweet with United

so for me I think the influence he had

in those early years of Sir Alex

Ferguson still won 11 major trophies

with man united didn't he so huge huge

volume a lot of big trophies with

Manchester United I think you're right

he probably is one of the greatest

Premier League goalkeepers of all time

second to this guy you think Allison's

the greatest PR I think statistically

you can prove it in terms of XG faced in

terms of expected XG all these kind of

things Allison massively outperforms

these things and Liverpool have got

Allison obviously Kell her now but

predominantly Allison to thank for a lot

of the cups trophies all the things that

they've won because frankly he is a huge

part of the style that they play Young

klopp needed someone like this we

couldn't have done it with another

goalkeeper and I think arguably down the

year manchest United have had a lot of

great goalkeepers this guy defines that

position out Liverpool to

give give you that St by the way law is

what 21.5 XG prevented in Premier League

career now that's the best record of any

Premier League goalkeeper since

Allison's Premier League debut just to

put that into perspective can I give a

quick give a counter argument when you

talk about doing it with him or doing it

without him I think the biggest

compliment to pet Peter schmeichel is

how difficult Sir Alex Ferguson found it

replacing him I mean you had the likes

of taibe you had the likes of Tim Howard

you had the likes of Roy Carroll only

until he found an aging Edwin V derar in

around what 2006 2005 was he able to

replace what a massive not even just

player but character this guy was to the

dressing room and all I'd say is and i'

be I just urge a little Caution on your

guys part when judging this is a lot of

the people we're putting up for

Manchester United here have ended their

career they've actually had that that

time to do that yeah the longevity in

there I I mean if we're discussing him

versus him and he's only halfway through

his career imagine what's going to be

like what do you think he'll be like

post clop you think he'll still be able

to maintain the level and be at that uh

yeah because I think he's obviously

there's high quality goalkeeper in there

I think a huge amount of credit I want

to say goes to the coaching staff at

Liverpool I think they've made him into

the goalkeeper of the years but they saw

that potential in the first place I

think any other team in in all of Europe

actually would take Allison over any

other goalkeeper five major trophies of

Liverpool we've biged Allison up a lot

got to give it context though schichel

11 major trophies of man united

including five Premier League titles in

Seven Seasons 112 clean sheets do we

Edge can I

just one thing one thing about that um

there are still two asterisks in terms

of Premier League titles there that we

we may see concluded at some point

and and on top of that you also see the

difference in defensive Style is with a

massively High Line at Liverpool and

that was a much deeper defense there

this guy and think could have done it in

a club team I I think High Line I'm not

saying that I don't think he could have

done it but I'm saying he's doing it and

the fact that we have a theory that he

could have done it the fact that he is

doing it and he's playing with probably

the highest line in the Premier League

outside of maybe Man City or another

dominant side is just Testament to the

fact that he can also play football oh

Michael yeah two quality Keepers I think

schichel just edged I think you guys

have made a massive mistake let's move

on let's think

you think yeah let not you think's go to

the right back now I think we maybe have

a slight confusion with magnets here I

don't know if we actually have have we

made an error on the maget I don't know

if you made an error I do you want to

turn should we turn around at the same

time yeah go ahead one two

three Gary Neville your go the Liverpool

Fan's going with Gary Neville man united

player and the man united fan is going

with the Liverpool player yeah I am I

like that should I give my argument

first or you want to go is it a mistake

firstly your magnet uh I do think it's a

mistake but so I gave an initial list

and Gary Neville was on that initial

list again down to longevity and

obviously he's on Sky Sports and you can

see him probably this weekend right I

think when it comes to Neville he's

serly disrespected yeah I totally agree

he had such longevity at Manchester

United I think the only argument the

reason I would put Trent on it would be

the technical ability the other things

that he does have and you can make an

argument that in terms of the player

that he is you know Trent merits it I

still think that what Gary Neville

achieved the fact he was Club Captain

which obviously we think Trent could be

at Liverpool but fact he was Club

Captain the fact that he had that

massive like era that he he defined that

Era 16 major trophies 400 Premier League

appearances I think by the time that

Trent finishes his career there'll be an

equivalency but I think it's it's

disrespectful to probably at this point

one of the greatest you know I sometimes

think Gary puts himself down too much

watch him on show I think come on Gary

you are unbelievable I mean Gary Neville

I completely agree with you I think it's

down to his own humble personality that

sometimes he does downplay himself

I wouldn't really have a qual about this

but I just think this guy right here has

revolutionized the position as a right

back especially in the Premier League

but I think you just look in general at

the greatest right backs of all time no

one has been as creative an attacking

force from right back he is the creative

force of one of the best teams in the

world from right back I just think the

numbers are unparalleled at such a young

age as well too and the assist 58

assists he go to be fair though which is

incredible underrated assist sister and

played behind some of the greatest right

wings of all time had that iconic

relation we're talking about a guy put

out the role of the right then was very

different to a role of a right back now

expected to go forward and everything

we're talking in adverts so you know

okay but we're talking about possibly

the greatest passer in the Premier

League like this is the level that we're

talking about with Tren Alexander Arnold

so I I can never disrespect Gary Neville

what he's done in that team staying in

it as long as he did as well too cannot

be underestimated but I just think this

is a special like Transcendent player in

my opinion can I shock you I'm willing

to concede you're right no you're

totally right I'm willing to concede

that one I think Trent's fair enough cuz

otherwise if we just do retired players

we're going to be here with just the man

united 11

problem second most assist by a defender

in premier league history behind Andy

Robertson right next up center backs

let's go for your pairings I see who you

got your pairings there's any yeah we

all agree on both Rio ferand I mean Rio

is he's the era the Premier League

defining Center back for me best center

back in premier league history for you

yes I'm okay equal with one other guy

okay he he's up there for me definitely

up there and who who else have you gone

with well I've gone with Virgil the pet

together dude we yeah we were so similar

on that then I mean these two are the

two that Define the Premier League eras

the modern era and R Ferdinand back then

I think both of them could have swapped

and they'd have had similar careers I

think it's just the fact that they

possess such great technical ability

such great reading of the game both of

them were

absolute Giants for their teams who who

was the better who is the better back

ask the same go on then I have to go

with my guy man real Rio is my guy so

I'll go with Rio F then this guy yeah

this guy again plays in a super high

line has been super adaptable I think

Rio possesses a lot I would love to have

seen Rio in this era if that makes sense

but the fact he's playing in this era

means that one thing I will say about

Rio though is that we often hear a lot

of times people who believe the older

generation of center backs would

struggle on today's high line I don't

think he would struggle to adapt to

today's game because of fall playing

ability his his graceful I think he

would be one of the few center backs

that in today's game excels sort of set

the mold didn't he as well for that he

was one of the first center backs that

was a ball playing Center back that you

could imagine playing which which now

you see there's so many ball playing

center backs but he I feel like he was

like a Trailblazer in that in a similar

way with Virgil Van djk like you see

Defenders now doing Virgil Van djk moves

the way they cut the ball out the air

you see quono these agree where they sit

off the there was an incident the other

week with quono wasn't there like

basically mirroring exactly V van mov

sck on any just any other shouts were

close yapan

maybe didn't do it for long enough for

me viit was the bside to what Ferdinand

was and I think you can't make an

argument for vidit over Virgil vany okay

yeah happy that yeah left back left back

left back I think this is disagreement I

went for

patri who do you want to hear from first

I think let's go to you l so I

originally also put Patrice ever in the

list but we agreed on so many things

that I thought okay let's let's mix this

up a little bit that's my argument

done yeah um the the thing with ever is

again I think it was a slightly

different system back then so playing as

left back was a little bit different to

the way that Andy Robertson plays if you

compare their attacking numbers Andy

Robertson completely eclipses Patrice

Evra but if you compare defensive

numbers then they are I'd say broadly

you could compare the two I just think

patri ever Define that eror every left

back looks at Andy Robertson and goes

what does Andy Roberts do in this era

every Young Center back that you every

young left back that you've spoken to

haven't it yes I've literally seen

interviews on Sky Sports done by you

guys

where where they say I can't remember

where you say who do you watch and they

go I watch tape of Andy Robertson to

Define what I do at left back thank you

for watching our interviews by the way

first you know I love you Robertson is

is a brilliant left back I would say top

three in in premier league history but

the difference between Trent and

Robertson for me where I call Trent a

Transcendent footballer I think

Robertson my opinion is a bit more a

byproduct of the club system like I

think the the the manner in which the

fullbacks go blazing forward and putting

in crosses I just think this guy has a

bit more guile and a bit more creativity

to him where Robertson is really get it

down to the end line and just blast it

into the box and I do think that in

terms of who's an actual better

footballer and who has more to their

game I do think it was Patrice everan

and I think as well too the leadership

that he displayed he ended up being the

captain because vidit and Rio were out

so many times he was he was really

captaining the sides at their Peak so I

would go for p 37 tough this one cuz Rob

I think he's almost like I know you say

he's a product of the system but I think

he is almost like a pace Setter within

that Klo side the amount of times I've

seen the Press like triggered by

Robertson from left back silent leader

as well and I think if he was English

we'd only have one choice for left back

for this

Euros well there's not too much

competition let's be real I mean that's

your own club that's got the other

person in competition play five games a

season man yeah so do most of the left

back I'm prob too bias on this one do we

let the fact that we've given we've

given yourself on La and you actually

did originally pick Patrice Evra in your

original list I think that's an

interesting shout that I'd be willing to

trade and put Allison in goal if you put

your original

list

that because I'm being so nice to other

people okay I understand yeah you're

right by Way Dennis Irwin didn't even

mention Dennis Irwin more I think more

tropies than both of them like long long

stay in that in that man

united more like a center back playing

at man greater penalties I'll I'll put

it up to Youth played both fullbacks

Midfield three should we go to Midfield

three I feel like we're going to agree

from here on out am I wrong I think

these three should be I think these

three in Midfield at least should be set

in stun wow do you want to go first then

with my three yeah I've gone with Steven

jarard Roy Keenan posals oh yeah yeah I

think I've also now on easy tap out of

the three L which one has the greatest

was the greatest Premier League player

uh in terms of achievements or in terms

of actual play player that guy Stevie

Stevie G was is the greatest two-way

Premier League midfielder of all time

and I don't think it's I I don't think

there's anyone else that comes close

people can make an argument for Kevin De

bruyne attacking wise being a better

player people can make a better

defensive argument for maybe Roy Kean or

someone like that this guy did

everything and even played right wing

for a whole season for Liverpool because

he was so adaptable this guy defines

what it is to be a premier league player

in this era and would be amazing now le

here's your number one it's a good show

I mean I have to go for Paul skulls man

I mean the guy is

just in the Premier League who defines a

premier league midfielder I agree it's

Steven jar but who defines just what it

means to be a ball playing midfielder

somebody who's capable of controlling

games from Deep someone who's capable of

of drifting into the number 10 positions

and getting goals someone who's more of

a pure footballer if you want to call it

that that was Paul schols for me and I

think you look at the way that the top

managers around the world the top

players from around the world gloss over

this guy it's not a coincidence well

Midfield three by the way can we just sh

a few of Midfield options I suppose cuz

you're playing a 43 but you shabby

Alonzo I was going to say giggsy beex

beex Beck was definitely a consideration

for me but it was just when he came up

against Gerard the amount of Seasons

that Geral played in the league all

these kind of things we we were asked to

make a 433 yeah and we we saw gigs

playing yeah yeah top player I think

Michael Carrick was was very underated

for United was close me yeah Carrick did

so much for that United

Team really really brilliant jabby

Alonzo by the way I think jabby Alonzo's

overall career yes

yeah they've done well with the AUG I

like

it again this front three should be

clearcut n there's disagreement I think

you've got disagreement here well then

that's that's wrong so should we go with

the two that the two that nailed on one

from each Club yeah yeah those two I

have as well yeah okay that's not

unreasonable Rooney that would be that

is a team is scary yeah staggering

against I I think look Salah is probably

the outstanding player in the Premier

League at the moment and I think Rooney

bartier HRI is in those conversations

for greatest Premier League player of

all time and only player I think to be

in what you wouldn't have salary in

those conversations too uh I mean I

think at the rate he's going he will

probably retire in those conversations I

think if you want to look at everything

going on silverware no matter whether

you like it or not will end up kind of

playing a part in those conversations

but I think that's the thing with with

Rooney he has everything he has the

silverware he has the stats he passes

the ey test he has the longevity he is

everything that Premier League was at

the time he also could have done like

that or that yeah he could have also

played it

right he played on the even at times he

played on the wing like two team just

yeah's nailed on nailed on salah's

nailed on here's the disagreement okay

disag I'm surprised there's a

disagreement I'm not all right go on who

have you gone for let's reveal let's

reveal sad man and Cristiano Ronaldo L

you first serly disrespected serly

underrated uh longev it in the league

played all the way along the front line

right wi left wing C Center forward

basically a striker false n for us at

times uh I think he's someone that for

some strange reason because he played on

the opposite Wing to sell people just

underrate him he was a huge part of jgen

klopp system if not the biggest part of

triggering presses the effort all those

different things he defined that era and

the way that they played and actually if

you look at the com like the comparison

in terms of stats these two actually

really close to each other and even in

terms of the way that they play I think

Ronaldo definitely fantastic player but

this guy's got twice as many passes

twice as many other goal involvements

for other players all these kind of

things there's so many different things

that he does out there on the field that

I think we think Ronaldo does but again

if you want to talk about system and the

way the system played this guy defined

as a player Cristiano I think again

though we said jabbi Alonzo because

jabbi Alonzo went on to have an even

better career after that in the

absolutely this guy would have won the

Bal Andor but I think I I'll be honest I

I think where he was from had a massive

impact on the way that other people in

Europe saw him and you know let's be

real about this some people just don't

give a lot of African players in the

Premier League their Jews and we need to

no look no doubt about it I completely

agree but Cristiano Ronaldo I think

comparing him to shavei Alonzo in terms

of the whole thing of like oh did he do

his best in the Premier League no he was

better at Real Madrid but this was still

a two-time premier league Player of the

Year back-to-back Seasons before Salah

and Holland stepped in the league had

the what the the the greatest single

goal scoring season in premier league

history from the wing basically had two

eras in the Premier League as well too

one where he was this all- action flashy

Winger who could destroy any fullback

you can imagine and transforming himself

into the ultimate goalscoring Winger

probably being the prototype for guys

like manate to even exist right what was

the other era what you the the the first

one where he was basically this flashy

all- action Winger basically that was a

shortlived I okay I can't say that's an

era but yeah no like I for him he had

two separate like careers if you want to

call it that but I look I mean the goals

the excitement the trophies the the the

individual Awards one of what only two

premier league players ever to win the

Bal onor I think this is a

straightforward one I think um it's no

doubt yeah I love s man I respect the

argument I think you forgotten how good

he was in the Prem man people also

forget people also forget what this kind

of exercise is and I feel like this

exercise is not actually about the final

11 but is actually just about having a

discussion of who the great players are

exploring that and this is why he's just

never involved in these conversations

and you know I'm not saying he's a

better player than Cristiano Ronaldo

there's an obvious choice there but sad

Oman is like as you said there's a

prototype there there's a prototype

there for other modern Wingers yeah this

guy just doesn't get the respected

deserves and I don't know why there work

as well too is unparalleled all of well

there it's it's a good shout but there

is confirmation of the combined Man

United Liverpool Premier League era both

GIC on the left wing the left wing let's

not you think home anyway if there's any

disagreement that let us know what you

think