A financial overview of the European and global healthcare systems – Prof. Monika Steffen EUHEALTH
Summary
TLDRCe script vidéo explore les dépenses de santé par rapport au PIB et au revenu par habitant dans différents pays européens, révélant des différences marquées entre les systèmes de santé. Il met en lumière l'impact de la médecine sur l'espérance de vie et comment celle-ci est influencée par les facteurs de vie, la nutrition et les conditions socio-économiques. La méditerranée, avec son régime alimentaire riche en poisson et en huile d'olive, est un exemple de bonnes pratiques. L'écart de dépenses de santé entre les pays riches et pauvres souligne les défis de l'égalité en matière de santé.
Takeaways
- 📊 Les dépenses de santé par rapport au PIB et par habitant sont des indicateurs clés pour comprendre le type de système de santé d'un pays.
- 🌐 Les pays du nord-ouest de l'Europe, tels que la Norvège, l'Allemagne et les Pays-Bas, dépensent plus d'argent en pourcentage du PIB et par habitant sur les soins de santé.
- 💶 Les dépenses en euros PPA (Puissance d'achat parité) permettent de comparer les dépenses entre les pays en tenant compte de la valeur réelle de la monnaie.
- 📉 Alors que les dépenses par habitant en pourcentage du PIB sont élevées dans certains pays, les dépenses réelles par habitant peuvent être faibles, indiquant un système de santé coûteux par rapport à la richesse économique.
- 🌡 La prévision de vie n'est pas directement liée aux dépenses de santé; d'autres facteurs tels que les conditions de vie, l'alimentation et les conditions de travail jouent un rôle plus important.
- 🍽 Les pays méditerranéens, comme l'Italie et l'Espagne, ont une longue prévision de vie malgré des dépenses de santé relativement faibles, ce qui est attribuable à leur régime alimentaire sain.
- 📉 Les pays de l'Europe de l'Est, tels que la Pologne et la Slovénie, ont des dépenses de santé plus faibles et des prévisions de vie plus courtes, reflétant des défis économiques et de santé persistants.
- 🔍 Les différences entre les dépenses de santé par habitant et le PIB révèlent des inégalités au sein de l'Union européenne, avec les pays du nord-ouest étant les plus grands dépenseurs.
- 🌍 Les pays avec une couverture santé universelle tendent à dépenser plus, car ils ont développé ce système qui devient ensuite une habitude culturelle.
- 👥 La différence de prévision de vie entre les hommes et les femmes dans l'Union européenne est de cinq ans en moyenne, avec les femmes vivant généralement plus longtemps.
Q & A
Quels sont les principaux indicateurs utilisés pour évaluer les dépenses de santé dans les pays de l'OCDE?
-Les principaux indicateurs sont les dépenses de santé en pourcentage du PIB, les dépenses par habitant (par capita) et les dépenses en euros PPA (Purchasing Power Parity).
Quelle est la signification des dépenses de santé en pourcentage du PIB?
-Cela indique la part du PIB que chaque pays alloue aux dépenses de santé, reflétant ainsi la priorité accordée à la santé par rapport à d'autres secteurs de l'économie.
Pourquoi les dépenses par habitant sont-elles importantes dans l'évaluation des systèmes de santé?
-Les dépenses par habitant montrent l'investissement moyen fait par un pays pour chaque individu en matière de soins de santé, ce qui peut être un indicateur de la qualité et de l'accessibilité des services de santé.
Quel est le rôle du PPA (Purchasing Power Parity) dans la comparaison des dépenses de santé entre les pays?
-Le PPA permet de comparer les dépenses de santé entre les pays en tenant compte de la puissance d'achat locale, ce qui élimine les différences dues aux variations des taux de change et des niveaux de prix.
Quels sont les pays nordiques et occidentaux qui dépensent le plus en pourcentage du PIB pour la santé?
-Les pays comme la Norvège, l'Allemagne, les Pays-Bas, l'Autriche, la Suède et le Danemark sont parmi ceux qui dépensent le plus en pourcentage du PIB pour la santé.
Pourquoi les dépenses de santé par habitant en France sont-elles plus faibles comparativement à d'autres pays européens?
-Cela peut être dû à la structure du système de santé qui, bien que coûteux en termes de PIB, ne se traduit pas nécessairement par des dépenses plus élevées pour chaque individu.
Quelle est la corrélation entre les dépenses de santé et l'espérance de vie en Europe?
-L'espérance de vie ne dépend que partiellement des dépenses de santé. D'autres facteurs tels que les conditions de vie, l'alimentation, et les conditions de travail jouent également un rôle significatif.
Quels sont les pays méditerranéens qui ont une espérance de vie élevée malgré des dépenses de santé relativement faibles?
-L'Italie, l'Espagne, le Portugal et la Grèce ont une espérance de vie élevée, ce qui est attribué à leur régime alimentaire méditerranéen riche en poisson et en huile d'olive.
Quelle est la différence d'espérance de vie entre les hommes et les femmes dans l'Union européenne?
-Dans l'Union européenne, les femmes ont en moyenne une espérance de vie de cinq ans et quelques mois de plus que les hommes.
Quels sont les défis auxquels les anciens pays communistes font face en termes de dépenses de santé et d'espérance de vie?
-Les anciens pays communistes luttent souvent contre la corruption, la pollution et des infrastructures médicales insuffisantes, ce qui affecte leur dépense en santé et leur espérance de vie.
Outlines
💹 Les dépenses de santé et leur lien avec les types de systèmes de santé
Le paragraphe 1 introduit les dépenses de santé comme un moyen d'examiner les différents types de systèmes de santé. Il utilise des statistiques de dépenses de santé par PIB et par habitant pour illustrer comment les dépenses publiques et privées révèlent le type de système de santé d'un pays. L'OECD est cité comme source de données fiables. Les dépenses par habitant sont expliquées comme étant le montant total des dépenses divisé par le nombre d'habitants, offrant une image de la dépense moyenne par personne dans un pays. L'importance de la parité de pouvoir d'achat (PPP) est également abordée pour permettre des comparaisons internationales justes.
🌍 Disparités géographiques dans les dépenses de santé
Le paragraphe 2 met en évidence les différences géographiques dans les dépenses de santé, montrant que les pays du nord-ouest de l'Europe sont grands dépenseurs, tandis que les dépenses diminuent vers le sud et l'est. L'analyse des dépenses par rapport au PIB révèle des écarts significatifs, notamment en France où les dépenses par habitant sont faibles par rapport à celles du PIB. Cette section souligne également les défis économiques que posent les systèmes de santé onéreux pour les économies moins prospères.
📊 La dépense de santé et l'espérance de vie en Europe
Le paragraphe 3 explore la relation entre la dépense de santé et l'espérance de vie, révélant qu'il n'y a pas nécessairement de lien direct. Les pays du nord-ouest de l'Europe, comme l'Allemagne et les Pays-Bas, dépensent beaucoup mais n'ont pas nécessairement les plus hautes espérances de vie. D'autres pays comme l'Italie et l'Espagne, qui dépensent moins, ont des espérances de vie élevées. Cette section souligne que l'espérance de vie est plus influencée par les conditions de vie, l'alimentation et d'autres facteurs environnementaux que par les dépenses de santé.
🍽️ L'impact de l'alimentation et des conditions de vie sur l'espérance de vie
Le paragraphe 4 se concentre sur l'importance de la nutrition et des conditions de vie dans la détermination de l'espérance de vie. Il est souligné que les pays méditerranéens, avec des régimes alimentaires riche en poisson et en huile d'olive, ont des espérances de vie élevées. En revanche, les pays du nord de l'Europe, qui consomment plus de viande de porc, ont des espérances de vie moins élevées. Cette section met en évidence le rôle des facteurs culturels et environnementaux dans la santé et la longévité.
👥 Disparités de genre dans l'espérance de vie et les dépenses de santé
Le paragraphe 5 aborde les différences de genre dans l'espérance de vie, notant que partout dans les pays développés, les femmes vivent en moyenne plus longtemps que les hommes. Il suggère que cela pourrait être un indicateur des problèmes de genre dans d'autres pays, comme l'Inde. La section se termine par une carte des dépenses de santé par habitant dans les différents pays de l'UE, montrant les inégalités et les impacts de l'histoire et des systèmes de santé universels.
Mindmap
Keywords
💡Dépenses de santé
💡PIB par habitant
💡Parité de pouvoir d'achat (PPP)
💡Système de santé
💡Espérance de vie
💡Décès liés aux soins de santé
💡Conditions de vie
💡Méditerranée
💡Ex-républiques communistes
💡Genre et espérance de vie
Highlights
Health expenditure statistics can reveal the type of healthcare system in place.
OECD provides comprehensive health statistics, including public and private health spending as a percentage of GDP and per capita.
Norway spends nearly 12 percent of its GDP on healthcare.
Per capita spending means the total healthcare expenditure divided by the country's population.
Figures are in euros PPP (Purchasing Power Parity), which adjusts for differences in purchasing power between countries.
Northern and northwestern European countries tend to spend more on healthcare.
Southern and eastern European countries generally spend less on healthcare.
Per capita spending does not always follow the same trend as GDP spending.
France has a significant difference between its high GDP spending and lower per capita spending.
High GDP spending compared to per capita spending indicates a healthcare system that is expensive relative to the country's economy.
Life expectancy does not necessarily correlate with health expenditure.
Mediterranean countries like Italy, Spain, and Greece have high life expectancy despite lower healthcare spending.
Life expectancy is influenced more by living conditions, diet, and social factors than healthcare spending alone.
There is a 10-year difference in life expectancy within the European Union between the countries with the highest and lowest.
Gender differences in life expectancy show that women generally live longer than men.
Cultural factors, such as diet and lifestyle, play a significant role in life expectancy statistics.
Healthcare spending per capita varies widely across Europe, with northern and western countries spending more.
The legacy of communism and the transition to liberal economies is reflected in the health expenditure and life expectancy of eastern European countries.
Transcripts
so to start this lesson about the health
care system types in order to make it
sort of somehow empirical and touchable
for you we will start with statistics
with health expenditure statistics
and we will see what statistics can tell
us
and it's quite surprising that will tell
us the type of healthcare system already
now here you have the figures from the
oacd
they have very good health statistics
you can look at it in internet this
comes from from their database
so here we have head spending
public and private together
where
per gdp per percentage of gdp and per
capita so it's a little bit difficult to
read because everything is in this
little statistic
and we will see lots of interesting
things
so you have here
these these
green
uh
sticks they will tell you how much there
is um in percentage the percentages here
of gdp spent in each country for
instance in norway they spend nearly
12 percent of their gdp in health care
and where you have to do oh no sorry
sorry the little point is the is the gdp
part and
the the
the sticks are the share of per capita
spending i hope you understand what it
means per capita spending it means when
you take the whole public and private
expenditure in a country for health care
in one year and you divide it by the
number of inhabitants by the number of
heads
in the country taking all the babies and
all the old ladies then you have a
figure which is suspending
an average
per capita in that country for one year
and you will see figures are surprising
so here we have what can we see on this
statistic
there's another thing i have to explain
to you before because you may not know
it
the figures are euros ppp
i don't know whether you know what it
means it's the same thing than dollars
ppp it means
a
parity purchasing power so this is not a
money you can buy in a bank it's not a
real money it is just taking either in
dollars or in euros or in yen or
whatever
uh
different
amounts of of of expenditure for for
transport or for healthcare
and then you adapt this amount
to the purchasing power in the country
so how much money do people have in the
country
how much do they earn how much do they
spend to live there is
international criteria to calculate this
and then you can compare
you know when i have figures let's say
healthcare is one dollar in some
strange country a year you would say
well it's very little but if for one
dollar you can buy nearly a house in
that country then you see it's quite a
lot of money so this is what it means
ppp purchasing
uh parity no parity purchasing power and
here we have it in euros because europe
formerly we calculated in dollars now we
do it also in europe in euros so here
you have these figures let's see norway
for instance
it has
uh
nearly five or five thousand four
thousand five hundred
uh ppp euros
for each person is spent in health care
and
it means in terms of gdp where the point
here is 4 000. so we can see they spend
more money per head
than for instance
france
they are
the share of gdp is very high but the
spending per head is very low i come
back to this problem in a minute because
it has a certain signification
so here we have the spendings and let's
say first what we see is the northern
countries
north western countries norway germany
netherland austria sweden denmark all
those who are in the west and in the
north they spend quite a lot of money
and as we go further down
but there are some isolated northern
cases like iceland or finland
uh but basically as we go to the south
italy spain portugal and to the east
estonia poland slovakia it gets less and
less
that's the first thing we see so not on
europe the western continental european
countries are big spenders for health
care
and it's followed by a mix of southern
countries and eastern countries you know
you have a mix of you know malta and
ireland and
spain and then you have slovenia they
are sort of in the middle
and as you go further on you have more
or less the former communist countries
it means the economy has not yet quite
recovered and they cannot afford to
spend on health as much as we do in the
west
or in the north
norway by the way is not a member of the
european union but it is very often in
the statistics because it is a member of
what we call the european economic area
so it's sort of privileged partner so we
take them in in the statistics
so the second thing we see is
per capita spending is not following
quite the same curb then the gdp here
you have the gdp
high high high and then it drops to the
ruler
this is the gdp line and this is per
capita
and per capita is what people are
interested in it's what you spend on
health care for each person
and if you have a family of four you
will have to multiply this money by four
for that family and if there's only one
earner in the family it means somewhere
else there are three people who pay for
that family
you understand the logic this is the
price you have to pay when you want
really universal universal health care
as i said you pay according to your
means into the system and what you get
out is according to your needs so if you
have three children and you are a single
mother you will have probably more needs
than a couple
without children so
this is the logic of the system
um
yeah i wanted to show you to explain
an economic problem look at france
and look at germany so germany has
practically the same amount of spending
for per capita then it has percentage of
gdp i mean it's sort of
equalizing huh and in france you have
quite a big difference we have also
difference in sweden but it's smaller
than the french one
and in belgium
and then comes france
luxembourg don't look at luxembourg they
spend a lot of money per capita but it's
a small part of the gdp because they are
fiscal paradise they have lots of banks
and
with a lot of money which is not
from their
citizen so that is a
special special example you have the
same in ireland it's the same type of
profile so
now why does france have this problem
that it's has a low
sorry
a low per capita spending here right
corresponds to what is said here
government and compulsory insurance and
you with the lighter green you add any
private insurance this part
sorry this part here would be the
private one
and then um
the share of gdp is is quite higher
if i was in the classroom i would ask
you to write down on a little paper the
answer what this
signifies what is the meaning of
a case when you have high gdp spending
compared to other countries
and
a much lower
per capita spending compared to these
same other countries what do you think
it means
well as i'm not in a classroom i will
have to give you the answer it means
that the gdp per capita is very low in
that country
that's what it means so it means in
other terms the healthcare system which
this country has it's very expensive
compared to the means economic means
this country has
and if we go along the line
we will see that it's
sorry
a sort of general rule as we go to the
poorer countries we have here
a share of gdp much higher
than the per capita spending this is
what i tried to show you with this
little
um
[Music]
little text here
low per capita spending but high in gdp
it means that you have a minimum of
heads expended so which you can probably
not lower much otherwise you have bad
care
but as your economy is not very rich and
not very productive it takes you this
little per capita money
takes you a lot of your gdp
and this is what you see here from here
onwards to distance it's really very big
here huh
so and if you look at these countries
you can see that you have a mixture of
southern european countries
and uh eastern european countries
so the southern european countries like
france who is the first to in to
initiate this sort of bad theory all
these countries france and then we have
italy
sorry
with
a southern country with a big difference
here then we have spain even bigger
and then we have portugal even bigger
and then come the eastern and greece
even bigger
and the rest are eastern countries so
what unites france portugal spain italy
and greece
but they had enormous public depth and
that is what puts the economy down
and this is what you can read in these
figures so they have a health care
system which is just too expensive for
the economy it costs them a lot of money
because they are not so productive or
they pay a lot of money to pay back
their debts
and the eastern european countries
the new member states of the european
union you know all these uh
poland slovakia hungarian latvia budget
countries romania bulgaria
they had to struggle very hard to get
out of their communist past
and i think in your reading it is
explained
some of these countries succeeded very
well in getting into a new economy a
liberal economy and they managed very
well and others succeeded
less well and even failed and the
countries you have here in the at the
end are these failures and what they
mainly failed was fighting against
corruption
so you can
this statistic tells you only about head
spending but you can reach sort of you
know the mirror of society you can read
the whole history of the last 30 years
of the economy in these countries and
political history
okay i hope this is clear for you
you know in france you can see it for
capita francis you know quite a rich
developed country but it is sort of
second with germany
for gdp spending they spent from gdp
an e
equivalent part but in capita in per
capita
france drops to the ninth position one
two three four five six seven eight nine
so from top to the ninth position that
is this economic discrepancy
between the health care system and
the general economy
so these statistics explain you a lot
about the relationship between society
economy and health care
now let's let's see what else we have
this is life expectancy in european
countries
it is figures for 2020
but they integrate the figures from 2000
these little squares here from 2000 and
then from 2010 and 2020.
now 2020 it is not quite sure whether
they have already let's take france
whether they integrated already
the drop of kovit you know in 2019
france had a life expectancy of of 83
years i think
and then it dropped and this is the
period drop
and now what did they tell us here
32 yeah these are figures to from 2020
so it integrates already the first year
of covet when there was a drop in life
expectancy
now if you look this into this statistic
and we look at the countries here which
are top highest life expectancy whatever
year in 2000 2010 it's about you know
figures are high here and then they drop
we find quite a different
picture than in the expenditure so the
first thing we can
deduct from this is
life expectancy does not depend on
health expenditure otherwise it would
have a very similar statistic like we
had here
uh with these countries germany in front
and netherlands and austria but this is
not what we see for life expectancy west
germany
you can't even see it germany is very
much behind just above the average
and uh where's austria
germany austria
austria very much behind for spending it
was very high
so uh
and and countries who spend very little
because they have such a lot of depth
like italy spain
and uh
cyprus maybe
well they suddenly are very much on top
for life expectancy it explains clearly
that life expectancy depends only to a
certain extent for medical expenditure
for instance to save
birth giving that mothers don't die and
that babies don't die that will push
your life expectancy high up and if you
save somebody who had a heart attack
when is 40 years old and
in a good health care system you can
save this person in a bad one he will
die that changes the statistic about
life expectancy but apart these cases
life expectancy depends on your living
conditions on what you eat on your food
on your lodging on your working
conditions transport conditions
i think in india you have a lot of train
accidents
we don't have so many in europe so
it's probably the organization
of the train infrastructure which makes
more people die in india than in in most
european countries you have all this and
the poverty
people are very poor then they tend to
die earlier
so life expectancy does not depend
on health expenditures so when the heads
people always want more money because
they have to save more lives they are
telling us somehow propaganda for their
business even if the business is public
so we can see germany is 14 oh sorry it
slips always away
germany here is number 40 when you count
for life expectancy among these
countries
but it was second for health spending
per capita and per gdp
austria
austria where's austria
austria
is number 13 for life expectancy it was
fourth for capita per capita spending
netherlands is 12th year for life
expectancy
and for capital spending in healthcare
how much is spent for each person per
year it was second no third
so
and france is ranking very nicely in top
here somewhere no
a quite good life expectancy in france
you know among the top countries it
starts to drop really from here as you
come to the eastern countries
because they have a lot of pollution
from the former industry and they're
still poor
so most of them
so um
let's take a little bit about germany
now
germany spends much more on health care
per person than france but you live
longer in france but simply because the
food it is much better in france and in
germany and recently i heard in a
cultural french german television chain
a very interesting
talk about some european commissioner
and
and a doctor and a few other people who
look after prevention and i i dropped by
accident into that into that show
and into that discussion and they
explained that the european commission
had launched had had
given
how do you say that in english an
advertisement a warning to germany to
say they should stop their sheep food
because it was causing too much risk for
health
oh i was a bit surprised when i heard it
i know how peop that people spend much
more money on food in france and
in germany
uh where young people like to spend
money on that's a cultural thing they
like to spend money on things that are
sustainable
they will have a very nice house they
will have nice furniture and a very good
car but they wouldn't spend much money
on food because that is pleasure just
for a moment and the friendship will
spend lots of money in the restaurant to
drive a bad dangerous car and live in a
very sort of modest lodging but then we
go to the restaurant with all the
children and the grandparents
so um
and if you look here at life expectancy
to the different european countries you
see norway iceland ireland malta italy
spain sweden cyprus france
even finland up to here they all have
seaside there are either islands or on
the seaside on the atlantic ocean or on
the mediterranean
sea so they eat a lot of fish
and these other countries denmark
netherlands well denmark also is on the
sea cycle
netherlands austria germany they ate a
lot of pork
that's not the best meat for your heads
so you can see that the food is really
present in this statistic
and you have all the mediterranean
countries italy spain
now why are there so good greece
despite a bad health care system and
despite an economy which is not the
richest and celeries are not the best
they they cook with olive oil not with
grease from animals or butter they cook
with olive oil and that's a very good
regime and they have because of their
climate they have fresh fresh vegetables
all year round
they can eat fresh salad and fresh
things so
there is a lot of studying on the
mediterranean food regime and it turns
out to be one of the best in the world
together with japanese and some others
so if you look at the seaside you eat a
lot of fish and you cook with olive oil
of course you must not drink so much
alcohol and if you do then drink rather
wine rather than whiskey it's not so
strong and you have a whole story about
these cultural
factors in this statistic
so this is why i wanted to show you this
statistics can be much more interesting
than what the figures just taken
so the general point we can see here is
um
there are 10 years of different life
expectancy within the european union
between the countries where you live
longest and the countries where you live
live
least
and you know you have all the former
communist countries here lined up and
that's very sad because
it's not the people's fault what
happened to them to their economy and to
their country there's a lot of pollution
still there's a lot of electricity still
made with coal
and so on
now uh i want to make a last point on
this about gender
these statistics this statistic here is
men and women mixed
but normally we do livestock
expectancy statistics separated for
women and for men because women live
much longer than
in general women live longer than men
it's probably the genetics because they
have to give birth and carry children
so
in all developed countries women live
much longer than men now the question i
would have to indian students is is this
also true for india
we know that india is a country where
there are quite a lot of gender problems
do indian women
in average live
five or six years longer than indian men
or is it the other way around that would
be a good test to know what the real
the real situation of gender problem is
in india
so
i didn't put statistics on this because
we can't go into all these details but
in the european union women live in
average
five years longer than men
five years five years and a few months
so life expectancy for men in the
european union are sorry in the richer
in the richer part in western europe so
the richer countries those who are sort
of here somewhere
men live uh 79 years
in average in women 84 in average so
this is life expectancy at birth
so it's five years of difference
and prove it of course this
decrease life expectancy in all the
countries
whatever
now here you have summed up
now this is in euros ppp euros
the per capita spending is just to show
you a nice map to show where are the
countries where you have good capital
per capita spending on health care and
those where there's much less so here
are the figures for instance in turkey
it's not member of the european union
but the candidate they spend 906 bpp
euros per year per inhabitant on health
care
and in germany it is thousand five
hundred
for ppp euros now if you look at the
colors you know here you have the
different colors the more it's dark the
more they're spent you can very well see
northern europe and
western continental europe
and ireland they are big spenders for
healthcare probably because they were
among the first countries to have a
universal healthcare system and then it
becomes a habit
and the second then this light blue here
they are sort of around there's a sort
of a ring around
you know from britain and then spain
italy and then
uh trekuslo
how do you say the czech republic and
then two two bicycle publics already for
more communist countries in finland
they are in this middle range
and then you have the poorer ones who
spend very little and they're all at the
east
well
one biotic republic and then poland and
slovakia and romania
this is bulgaria hungary
and so on so you can see the traces of
history
the breakaway from communism communism
and the
transformation into liberal systems was
all very hard for these countries and
you can say it and see it in life
expectancy in health expenditure and so
on
Browse More Related Video
Health policy in Europe – Prof. Monika Steffen EUHEALTH
Comprendre le droit à la santé avec Julien Ménielle (Dans ton corps)
Conceptualize healthcare systems – Prof. Monika Steffen EUHEALTH
Partage éthique: le bonheur et l'argent
PERTE DE GRAS | OMAD | GLUCIDES | INSULINE | GH avec @hcoaching & @Florent_dorizon Florent Dorizon
B4- Biodiversité des sols et santé humaine [Marc André Selosse]
5.0 / 5 (0 votes)