My reaction to the Hans Niemann interview

GothamChess
17 Sept 202426:44

Summary

TLDRIn this video, the commentator reflects on his experiences at the first-ever live Speed Chess Championship finale in Paris, featuring grandmasters like Magnus Carlsen and Hikaru Nakamura. He discusses the explosive interview with Hans Niemann, the chess.com report allegations, and the event's fallout. The video also touches on the potential impact on the future of chess, the role of 80,000 Hours in career planning, and the dynamics between top players. It concludes with thoughts on the live event's success and the future of chess as an esport, hinting at the untold series on Netflix that might bring new perspectives to the cheating scandal.

Takeaways

  • 🎥 The speaker was a commentator and media personality for Chess.com's live Speed Chess Championship finale in Paris, featuring players like Magnus Carlsen, Hikaru Nakamura, Alireza Firouzja, and Hans Niemann.
  • 🔥 The Hans Niemann interview became explosive, with Niemann accusing the speaker of being a Chess.com sponsored propaganda voice, which was unexpected and intense.
  • 🏆 The event results saw Magnus Carlsen as the champion, with Alireza Firouzja coming in second, and Hikaru Nakamura losing in the semi-final to Firouzja.
  • 🤔 The speaker expressed surprise at Niemann's post-tournament interview, where he seemed humbled and reflective, contrasting with his earlier combative stance.
  • 👨‍🏫 It was revealed that Vladimir Kramnik is coaching Hans Niemann, and Kramnik continued to accuse Hikaru Nakamura of cheating, even while coaching the US Chess team for the Olympiad.
  • 📈 The speaker shared thoughts on the future of chess, including the potential for growth in the esports and live event space, and the need for bigger sponsorships.
  • 🎙️ The speaker reflected on their role and approach to interviewing, acknowledging feedback about their style and the challenge of maintaining fairness in coverage.
  • 📺 An upcoming Netflix Untold series on the chess grandmaster cheating scandal was announced, promising new perspectives on the Niemann controversy.
  • 🌟 The live event at ESPORT was a success with around 3-400 attendees, indicating potential for larger chess events and the possibility of selling out even larger venues.
  • 🤝 The speaker enjoyed meeting fans and signing autographs, highlighting the positive community engagement aspect of the live chess event.

Q & A

  • What was the commentator's role at the live Speed Chess Championship finale in Paris?

    -The commentator was a media personality on site, on camera talent for chess.com, interviewing players and providing commentary for the event.

  • Which players were featured in the Speed Chess Championship finale that the commentator attended?

    -The featured players in the Speed Chess Championship finale were Magnus Carlsen, Hikaru Nakamura, Alireza Firouzja, and Hans Niemann.

  • What is the name of the YouTube video by Hans Niemann that the commentator discusses?

    -The name of the YouTube video by Hans Niemann that the commentator discusses is 'The Explosive Hans Niemann Interview'.

  • What was the commentator's initial expectation for the interview with Hans Niemann?

    -The commentator expected a fun and light-hearted interview, not one that would be confrontational or deeply delve into the cheating scandal.

  • How did the commentator feel about the intensity of the Hans Niemann interview?

    -The commentator found the interview to be fascinating and intense, and it exceeded his expectations, leaving him with a lot to process.

  • What was the commentator's response to Hans Niemann accusing him of being a chess.com sponsored propaganda voice?

    -The commentator was surprised and taken aback by the accusation, as he did not expect such directness and felt they had a cordial relationship prior to the interview.

  • What was the commentator's view on the impact of the Hans Niemann interview on public perception?

    -The commentator felt that the interview might have shifted public perception against Hans Niemann, as it was intense and left a strong impression.

  • What was the commentator's take on the results of the Speed Chess Championship?

    -The commentator found the results to be surprising, particularly Magnus Carlsen's dominant performance and Fabiano Caruana's loss to Magnus in the final.

  • What did the commentator think about the live venue and the future of chess as an esport?

    -The commentator was optimistic about the potential for chess to grow as an esport, suggesting that it could reach 30% the size of some of the biggest esports in the world.

  • What upcoming project involving chess was mentioned in the script?

    -An upcoming project mentioned was a new Untold series on Netflix, which will include a documentary on the chess Grandmaster cheating scandal.

Outlines

00:00

🌟 Paris Chess Adventure and Sponsor Highlight

The speaker opens by recounting their recent experience in Paris as a commentator for chess.com's first live Speed Chess Championship finale. They discuss their interviews with players like Magnus Carlsen, Hikaru Nakamura, Alireza Firouzja, and Hans Niemann. The video's focus is on the aftermath of the explosive Hans Niemann interview and its implications for chess. The speaker thanks the sponsor, 80,000 Hours, a nonprofit guiding individuals towards impactful careers, and encourages viewers to explore their free career guide.

05:02

🎙️ Hans Niemann Interview Controversy

The speaker reflects on their interview with Hans Niemann, which unexpectedly became confrontational. They discuss Niemann's accusations of bias and the contentious nature of the discussion, which deviated from the intended light-hearted interaction. The speaker expresses surprise at Niemann's claims, especially given their previous positive interactions. They also touch upon the high viewership of the interview and the polarized reactions it received, including criticisms of their interviewing style and shifts in public opinion regarding Niemann.

10:03

🏆 Chess Championship Results and Future Implications

The speaker delves into the outcomes of the chess event, with a focus on the performance and attitudes of the players, particularly Hans Niemann. They recount the intensity of the games and Niemann's post-match interview, which displayed a humbled perspective after his loss. The speaker speculates on the future of chess, the players' careers, and the impact of high-stakes events on the sport. They also mention the involvement of Vladimir Kramnik, a renowned chess player, as Niemann's life coach and his controversial statements about other players.

15:04

👴 Kramnik's Involvement and Chess's Future

The speaker discusses Vladimir Kramnik's role as a coach, his public accusations of cheating in chess, and his influence on Niemann. They find it intriguing that Kramnik, despite his respected status in chess, continues to make bold allegations without seeming repercussions. The speaker also expresses optimism for the growth of chess as a spectator sport, highlighting the successful live event in Paris and suggesting potential improvements for future events to enhance the experience for both players and audiences.

20:05

🏆 Reflections on the Chess Event and Its Impact

The speaker concludes with a retrospective on the chess event, the players' performances, and the broader implications for the chess community. They discuss the potential for chess to grow in popularity, the need for larger sponsorships, and the challenges faced during the live event, such as broadcast issues and crowd dynamics. The speaker remains hopeful for the future of chess as an esport and a mainstream sport, eager to see how the community and its events evolve.

25:07

🌐 Hans Niemann's Future and Chess's Growth

In the final paragraph, the speaker expresses curiosity about Hans Niemann's future behavior and performance, considering the recent developments and his public statements. They also look forward to potential new sponsorships and collaborations that could elevate chess's profile. The speaker ends on a note of anticipation for future interviews and events, hinting at the ongoing drama and excitement in the world of chess.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡Chess.com

Chess.com is an online chess-playing website that provides services such as playing online games, watching live chess, and accessing chess tutorials. In the video, the speaker mentions being a commentator for Chess.com during the live Speed Chess Championship finale, indicating the platform's role in organizing and broadcasting major chess events.

💡Speed Chess Championship

The Speed Chess Championship is an online chess tournament that features rapid games between top players. The video discusses the finale of this event, emphasizing its significance in the chess community and the excitement it generates among fans, as well as the speaker's role as a commentator for the event.

💡Commentator

A commentator provides live commentary and analysis of an event, often explaining what is happening and providing insights to the audience. The speaker in the video describes their experience as a commentator for Chess.com, highlighting the role of providing real-time analysis and engaging the audience during the Speed Chess Championship.

💡Media Personality

A media personality is someone who is regularly featured in media content, often due to their expertise or popularity. The video script mentions the speaker as a media personality, suggesting their public presence and involvement in the chess community, particularly in the context of the Speed Chess Championship.

💡Hans Niemann

Hans Niemann is a professional chess player who became a central figure in the video due to an interview and controversy surrounding his play. The speaker discusses an 'explosive' interview with Niemann, indicating the player's significant role in the chess event and the subsequent discussions and debates his performance sparked.

💡Interview

An interview is a conversation where questions are asked about someone's experiences or opinions. In the context of the video, the speaker reflects on their interview with Hans Niemann, which became a significant part of the narrative around the Speed Chess Championship due to the contentious nature of the discussion.

💡Sponsorship

Sponsorship refers to the support, usually financial, that an event or individual receives from a company or organization. The video mentions the lack of big brand sponsorships in chess, suggesting an opportunity for growth and highlighting the need for more corporate involvement to elevate the sport.

💡Esports

Esports is a form of competition using video games. The video discusses the potential for chess to grow as an esport, indicating the speaker's belief in the potential for chess to attract a larger audience and sponsorships similar to those found in the esports industry.

💡Kasparov

Garry Kasparov is a retired chess grandmaster and former World Chess Champion. The video mentions Kasparov in the context of the potential size of the chess audience, comparing it to other sports and esports, and suggesting that chess could grow to a similar level of popularity.

💡Live Event

A live event is a public gathering where an activity or performance takes place in real-time. The video describes the first-ever live Speed Chess Championship event, emphasizing the excitement and challenges of hosting such an event, including managing audience reactions and ensuring a fair competition environment.

💡Kayfabe

Kayfabe is a term from professional wrestling, referring to the presentation of staged events as genuine. The speaker uses the term to question the authenticity of Hans Niemann's behavior and statements, suggesting that there might be more to the story than meets the eye, and hinting at the potential for theatrics in the world of competitive chess.

Highlights

Traveled to Paris, France to commentate for chess.com at the first-ever live Speed Chess Championship finale.

Interviewed players including Magnus Carlsen, Hikaru Nakamura, Alireza Firouzja, and Hans Niemann.

Shared thoughts on the explosive Hans Niemann interview and the event's fallout.

Discussed the potential future impact of these events on the chess community.

Expressed gratitude to the sponsor, 80,000 Hours, a nonprofit guiding career choices for positive impact.

Mentioned the importance of planning one's career to make a difference, referencing the 80,000-hour work life span.

Highlighted the free resources provided by 80,000 Hours for career planning.

Revealed initial plans for the video's content, including a discussion on Hans Niemann's performance.

Reflected on personal bias and the challenge of covering the cheating scandal and Hans Niemann's situation.

Described the intense atmosphere of the interviews, especially with Hans Niemann.

Commented on the popularity of the Hans Niemann interview, which gained significant views.

Discussed the dynamics of the interview with Hans Niemann, including accusations and personal attacks.

Shared personal feelings of being blindsided by the confrontational nature of the Hans Niemann interview.

Mused on whether the interview's confrontation was genuine or staged for the audience.

Reflected on the community's reaction to the Hans Niemann interview and its impact on public perception.

Discussed the results of the Speed Chess Championship and the implications for the players involved.

Highlighted the potential for chess to grow as an esport and the need for bigger sponsorships.

Shared experiences from the live event in Paris, including the venue and audience interaction.

Speculated on the future of Hans Niemann and the chess community's response to his actions.

Announced an upcoming Netflix series on the chess Grandmaster cheating scandal, featuring Magnus Carlsen and Hans Niemann.

Transcripts

play00:00

ladies and

play00:02

gentlemen recently I traveled to Paris

play00:07

France and in Paris I was a commentator

play00:12

I was a media personality I was on site

play00:15

on camera talent for chess.com uh for

play00:19

the first ever live speeches

play00:21

Championship finale which features

play00:23

Magnus Carlson hiar Nakamura Ali ruja

play00:26

and Hans Neiman uh and when I was there

play00:30

I was interviewing all the players

play00:33

beforehand and it was pretty wild in

play00:36

today's video the first thing that I'm

play00:37

going to do is give you my thoughts

play00:40

which I haven't really shared fully just

play00:43

yet uh about the explosive Hans nean

play00:46

interview which is the name of the

play00:48

YouTube uh video uh and also the results

play00:50

of the event The Fallout of the event

play00:52

and what this could mean for the future

play00:54

of Chess sometimes I like to make these

play00:56

videos where there are no chess moves if

play00:59

you care to hear my perspective on uh my

play01:02

position in the ecosystem of Chess and

play01:04

what this could mean uh for the future

play01:06

of the game uh before we uh jump into

play01:08

all of this I'd like to thank the

play01:09

sponsor of today's video 880,000 hours

play01:11

80,000 hours is a nonprofit that helps

play01:14

people have a positive impact with their

play01:16

career now you may be wondering why does

play01:18

this exist and why is it important well

play01:20

most folks work 40 hours a week 50 weeks

play01:23

a year for 40 years that's 880,000 hours

play01:26

and that is a long time and thus it's

play01:30

your biggest opportunity to make a

play01:32

difference which is why it's worth

play01:33

planning and you don't have to be a

play01:35

doctor teacher charity worker or even a

play01:37

chess YouTuber to make some sort of

play01:39

positive impact in the world there are

play01:41

many career paths where your impact

play01:44

could potentially be even higher some

play01:46

that you may not even be aware of just

play01:47

yet and over the last 10 years 80,000

play01:50

hours has worked alongside academics at

play01:52

the University of Oxford looking for the

play01:55

best available evidence on what it takes

play01:56

to have a fulfilling career and after

play01:58

reviewing over 60 stud studies on what

play02:00

makes a dream job they think that the

play02:02

best available evidence suggests that

play02:04

you can't just follow the most common

play02:06

advice like look for a high-paying job

play02:09

and maybe one that isn't too stressful

play02:11

generic advice is okay but it doesn't

play02:14

always hold up so what does well the

play02:17

free 80,000 hours in-depth career guide

play02:19

if you go to 80,000 hour.org Gotham you

play02:22

can check out this free in-depth career

play02:25

guide and it'll help you learn for what

play02:27

makes a high impact career help you get

play02:29

new ideas ideas for impactful paths and

play02:31

make a new plan based on what you've

play02:32

learned and how to put it into action

play02:34

everything they provide is free they're

play02:36

a nonprofit and their only goal is to

play02:37

help you find a fulfilling high impact

play02:40

career now let's get back to the video

play02:42

okay hello it's me again um the first

play02:46

thing that we are going to do uh in

play02:48

today's video is I'm going to show you a

play02:51

you know like kind of crappy outline of

play02:55

uh what we're going to talk about I

play02:57

don't know why this bullet point is here

play02:59

we're going to talk about Hans demon

play03:01

thoughts on speeches Championship 2024

play03:02

of course Hans demon that's what we're

play03:03

going to start with am I biased we're

play03:05

going to talk a little bit about the

play03:06

report then we're going to talk about

play03:08

the results in Paris and what what

play03:10

what's next uh and then we're going to

play03:12

talk about everything else and of course

play03:13

we will have a little moment we talk

play03:15

about Vladimir karnick so uh basically

play03:19

let's start with Hans

play03:21

demon

play03:23

uh when I went to Paris I knew that I

play03:26

was going to interview all the players I

play03:28

was going to talk to them I had had

play03:30

questions there already uh some were

play03:32

going to be fun segments like we were

play03:34

going to solve blindfolded chess puzzles

play03:36

with some of the players we solved them

play03:37

with three of the players we also were

play03:39

going to do a segment about your mobile

play03:41

phone like what apps do you use and how

play03:43

much screen time do you have we managed

play03:44

to do that with Magnus hicaro and with

play03:45

fuja because the earlier part of their

play03:47

interview was about 1520 minutes and

play03:49

then uh the other uh segment was also

play03:52

about 15-20

play03:54

minutes we didn't manage to get to it

play03:56

with Hans because the interview was

play03:57

supposed to be 30 minutes total like The

play03:59

Others went 46 minutes and then there

play04:02

was a press conference so we weren't

play04:03

able to get into that I also do not know

play04:05

if he would have agreed

play04:08

now before I like react to certain

play04:10

points of the interview the interview

play04:12

was fascinating so it was at uh it was

play04:15

on it was filmed on a couch and there

play04:16

was a camera like basically where you

play04:18

are you see you you are like the camera

play04:20

we had a couple of cameras on us but at

play04:21

the same time there were folks there

play04:22

filming for secret projects that I can't

play04:25

talk about when Hans came for the

play04:27

interview there was double the amount of

play04:28

cameras as normal

play04:31

which was already a pretty big deal it

play04:33

was a fascinating deal and you know if

play04:37

you go to

play04:38

YouTube you will see that he's given an

play04:40

interview he had given an interview

play04:43

right before the speeches championship

play04:44

and it was this one it was the full

play04:46

interview with naroditsky and it was

play04:49

after he uh won the quarterfinals match

play04:51

against and you'll notice that I've

play04:53

watched the entire thing and this one

play04:55

was was intense but nitzki was quite

play04:59

good at hearing everything Hans had to

play05:01

say and then sort of kind of rolling

play05:04

with the punches and they went back and

play05:05

forth on a couple of things and you can

play05:07

watch this one if you'd like and so I

play05:09

was expecting maybe something similar

play05:10

but again I wasn't really interested in

play05:14

putting Hans on the spot or asking him

play05:16

about the chess.com report or any of

play05:19

that stuff uh what's what's said has

play05:21

been said and I was ready to talk about

play05:24

uh his event that's not really what

play05:28

happened though uh we covered a lot of

play05:29

subjects but we sort of went in circles

play05:31

at some points um I made you know a

play05:34

couple of bullet points here which are

play05:36

my level of bias and covering Hunts uh

play05:39

the chess.com report and so on um I will

play05:43

say though the Hunts even interviews do

play05:45

quite well 665,000 views in 10 days the

play05:49

Magnus Carlson interview from this event

play05:52

did like

play05:53

400k Hikaru and alza did you know I

play05:56

don't know 300

play05:58

100K and you can see here like even the

play06:00

official Channel had a lot of views 227

play06:03

the listen the Pierce Morgan interview

play06:04

had 215 I mean we're talking about this

play06:06

the this is the biggest H interview we

play06:08

we have yet so you know this kind of

play06:11

stuff uh is really fascinating

play06:13

because most

play06:15

sports are first of all team sports

play06:18

right team sporting uh events and

play06:21

there's that whole element of it

play06:23

individual sports very rarely

play06:25

get high intensity interviews where the

play06:28

interviewee might argue with the person

play06:30

who's uh interviewing them or might be

play06:32

making very pointed uh statements

play06:34

because a lot of top athletes just get

play06:36

like tons of PR training and they say

play06:37

like well I couldn't have done it

play06:39

without my team and I got to thank my

play06:41

team and I got to thank this person and

play06:43

that and we're just trying to do our

play06:44

best and um yeah Hans he went right into

play06:48

it and I said he he he stated uh that I

play06:52

am a chess.com

play06:54

sponsored um propaganda voice I'm

play06:58

paraphrasing

play07:00

uh and I was like oh wow like we're just

play07:02

we're just getting right into it and

play07:05

that was kind of fascinating because

play07:07

that's not what I was expecting I wasn't

play07:08

expecting it to be so pointed and I

play07:11

listen I don't have

play07:13

anything I mean I don't have anything to

play07:16

hide

play07:17

I Hans had mentioned that I had streamed

play07:19

on hikaru's channel in 2020 and 2021 OG

play07:22

chess fans like pre- pandemic and early

play07:25

pandemic uh remember those days it was

play07:28

hikaro playing in the Champions chess

play07:30

tour the Melt water whatever they were

play07:31

called and I would commentate on his

play07:33

channel um but I also didn't understand

play07:36

what that had to do with the issue at

play07:38

hand I guess it was mostly a question of

play07:40

can I cover the cheating scandal and

play07:42

hikaru's actions and chc's actions in an

play07:45

unbiased fashion um one thing that

play07:48

totally slipped my mind by the way be

play07:50

during the

play07:51

interview Hans at some point said he had

play07:54

like 2,000 viewers or something and I

play07:56

had like 50 this was maybe 2019 2020

play08:00

and what totally slipped my mind is um

play08:03

around that

play08:04

time I think he was like quite literally

play08:07

working with chess.com to to to improve

play08:09

his streaming presence like I I had no

play08:12

recollection because I didn't stream

play08:14

much in 2019 in 2020 and then I came

play08:17

back like obviously during Co and then

play08:18

all those online tournaments happened

play08:20

but I was like wait I thought I thought

play08:22

he like was streaming on trcom all the

play08:24

time in fact like the Nexus of all of

play08:26

these the the whole report and

play08:28

everything was like I cheated online in

play08:31

meaningless games that's what he was

play08:32

saying and it was like maybe to boost

play08:35

his rating to play the other players I

play08:36

don't exactly know but

play08:39

regardless I was mildly blindsided by

play08:43

the the the the level of the

play08:47

vitriol but here's where what I couldn't

play08:49

shake off uh and I actually said this to

play08:52

him in the interview I was like I

play08:54

thought we were cool

play08:57

like I thought we were cool we we had a

play09:00

couple of pretty normal interactions

play09:01

leading up to this point uh and I did

play09:03

say in the interview at some point Hans

play09:05

even was in one of my live streams and

play09:07

said oh we don't have any problems I've

play09:10

only got problems with Hikaru

play09:12

paraphrasing and I was like okay cool

play09:16

cuz I don't really need problems with

play09:18

anybody um except Andrea botes but

play09:21

that's a you know that's a separate

play09:23

issue uh even that is not serious and uh

play09:27

yeah I was like oh okay and he said he

play09:29

was rolling me we actually did we did a

play09:31

uh beef

play09:33

and

play09:35

so there is a there is a a sport the WWE

play09:39

and there's a sport in the

play09:41

UFC and in those Sports it's well known

play09:44

that sometimes athletes turn it on for

play09:46

the cameras even though behind the

play09:47

scenes they might be pretty

play09:49

chill I'm still trying to exactly

play09:52

pinpoint whether that whole interview

play09:54

was a work and if it was I'm not going

play09:57

to tell you okay because that's the

play09:59

that's the magic of it all right I'm not

play10:00

going to sit here and tell you oh he's

play10:02

actually a sweetheart behind the

play10:04

scenes he wasn't a sweetheart but he

play10:07

wasn't like he wasn't that guy you know

play10:09

what I mean like

play10:12

um and then the last thing obviously we

play10:15

we talked a lot about the chess.com

play10:16

report I have I have nothing to add I

play10:18

have nothing to say they publish the

play10:20

report he disputes parts of the report

play10:22

and says it's got mistakes in it and

play10:25

there was a huge lawsuit and ultimately

play10:26

that was that now one thing he also said

play10:28

in the interview was

play10:30

I don't care about Hikaru I also like

play10:32

didn't fully process this until later he

play10:33

said I don't care about Hikaru I want

play10:35

Hikaru to be old retired in a in a in a

play10:38

in a old folks home and I'm still going

play10:40

to be winning and he's going to have to

play10:41

watch me win and there's nothing he can

play10:43

do about

play10:44

it so I made a joke to him because I was

play10:46

like so you're going to be 70 years old

play10:48

winning cuz like they're like 10 15

play10:49

years apart if Hikaru is 80 hans's 65

play10:52

he's not winning anything at

play10:54

65

play10:56

uh but also I had this thought after I

play10:59

was like wait but he he doesn't want to

play11:03

beat Hikaru he wants Hikaru to retire

play11:05

and watch him win

play11:07

things and I I just kind of was like

play11:09

wait a minute wouldn't like an elite

play11:13

Alpha athlete want to like dominate a

play11:16

fellow athlete as opposed to like yeah

play11:18

let that guy leave and then you know I'm

play11:19

just going to keep winning stuff so

play11:20

there was a couple of things where I

play11:21

left the interview was like wait a

play11:22

minute what did he say I didn't quite

play11:24

get it but then there was the there was

play11:27

the event and and ultimately I left that

play11:29

interview like wow that was a lot I wow

play11:32

that's not what I was

play11:33

expecting but listen um it's kind of the

play11:36

name of the game look at the numbers

play11:37

that interview

play11:39

did and I would

play11:41

say what that interview did was leave

play11:44

people with a couple of final

play11:45

Impressions number one some people were

play11:47

critical of my interview skills and I

play11:49

and they said I was too combative I did

play11:50

this I did that um some of that is uh

play11:54

actually accurate like and I would

play11:56

listen to some of that feedback the

play11:57

problem is I'm not a journalist and I'm

play11:59

not an interviewer in that setting I'm a

play12:01

feel-good interviewer I want to talk to

play12:02

somebody for 20 minutes crack some jokes

play12:04

make them do some fun things create some

play12:05

cool content make it interesting for you

play12:07

guys I don't want to argue with someone

play12:08

for 45 minutes on an interview like I

play12:10

have better things to do uh and I

play12:13

ultimately at some point I got fed up

play12:14

but I did kind of keep my cool I didn't

play12:16

you know people were messaging me like

play12:18

how did you not punch Hans and I was

play12:20

like what does that even like what I'm

play12:22

just going to sucker punch him

play12:25

like what not like he was like attacking

play12:28

my family or something all right uh you

play12:31

know I I I got like a few texts like

play12:33

that um so that was I mean that was a

play12:36

little bit of an overreaction but that

play12:37

that was part of the feedback the other

play12:39

part of the feedback was people who

play12:40

supported Hans and were giving him the

play12:42

benefit of of the doubt in the whole

play12:44

thing were

play12:46

uh they were like changing their mind I

play12:50

think that interview actually tilted

play12:52

things not in his Direction and I but

play12:57

then there was the results right then

play12:59

there was this

play13:00

interview um there there was that

play13:03

interview and you know if he had won

play13:05

against Magnus or he had won against

play13:06

Hikaru or whatever the the second match

play13:08

would have been it would have been crazy

play13:10

but then he gave this

play13:12

interview uh this was the one after

play13:15

losing to Hikaru and here I think you

play13:17

know he he did what what a what a person

play13:19

that loses is supposed to do especially

play13:21

a person that that that talks a big game

play13:23

and loses and um I I don't know how many

play13:27

people like there's a pretty big View

play13:29

discrepancy here right uh and people

play13:32

will not want to give him the benefit of

play13:33

the doubt after seeing the first

play13:34

interview but but in my opinion he lost

play13:36

the way a person uh should lose uh if

play13:39

that is you know if if they are uh that

play13:41

kind of personality now again the

play13:43

biggest mystery to me is I have no idea

play13:45

if the whole thing is a personality

play13:47

thing um or if he's really like that if

play13:50

he's really like

play13:52

that he's not he's not very nice I mean

play13:56

and

play13:57

I but maybe that is something in your

play14:01

mind that has to be flipped and you

play14:03

don't have to be very nice but you have

play14:05

this Killer Instinct and you know you're

play14:06

going to become a 27 2800 level player I

play14:09

don't know but uh I I I I don't know

play14:12

which of the two uh theories uh I

play14:14

subscribe

play14:15

to um and listen I get it I mean I like

play14:19

I said I talked about it quite openly I

play14:20

thought my coverage of him was quite

play14:22

Fair compared to some other folks who I

play14:26

will not name because I've named them

play14:27

before but

play14:29

I didn't participate in this whole witch

play14:31

witch hunt early on in 2022 of like

play14:34

dissecting all his games and claiming

play14:36

that I think something is off because

play14:39

that's not my job that's not my that was

play14:40

not my role ever uh and

play14:43

um yeah I guess he still felt like you

play14:46

know I was a part of the uh the machine

play14:48

that was working against him somehow uh

play14:50

but I thought I did a pretty nice job

play14:52

covering him but I still do get comments

play14:54

like you were part of the you and hikaro

play14:56

ruined his life and I was like

play14:59

I don't think

play15:01

so I think we did quite separate things

play15:04

actually um and you know but that's Hans

play15:09

that's hun and uh he came up

play15:11

short but very curious to see where he

play15:14

goes from

play15:15

here uh and

play15:18

uh what his next results are he did say

play15:20

karnick is his life coach by the way

play15:22

speaking of we will talk about kramnick

play15:23

right now uh kramnick

play15:27

uh karnick is with the Olympiad coaching

play15:30

the USBC team what I find fascinating

play15:31

about kramnick you know with all his

play15:33

Clash of claim stuff like how he played

play15:35

against

play15:36

Jose

play15:38

um then he played a second edition of

play15:41

the match I don't know if any of you saw

play15:43

this he played something called Clash of

play15:47

blames which originally they tried to

play15:50

call Clash of claims 2 nobody was

play15:53

involved in it who was involved in Clash

play15:55

Of Claims One except the players the

play15:58

Chess World is like ridiculous I don't

play15:59

know how they just thought that they

play16:01

could copy the exact same name and exact

play16:03

same concept and it was played on a

play16:05

totally different website it was played

play16:06

on some sort of online Arena run by the

play16:08

international governing body of the game

play16:10

I don't exactly know but Vladimir

play16:12

karnick himself is the fair play officer

play16:15

of that new chess

play16:18

company and their whole thing is it is

play16:21

the fairest play place to play chess and

play16:23

then there were Reddit threads of

play16:26

people claiming they've been cheating on

play16:28

the website for months and not getting

play16:29

banned you can go down this rabbit hole

play16:31

if you like my point is I have no idea

play16:34

what Vladimir kick is up to ever since

play16:37

the Karu stuff the big Crusade of the

play16:39

anti-cheating Clash of claims won then

play16:41

he played the second edition against

play16:42

Jose that when he won by a game like it

play16:45

was very closer two games um so he had

play16:49

some things to say and he's apparently

play16:50

coaching Hans now and Hans offered me a

play16:53

training camp with him and karnick and I

play16:54

have to pay them me $100,000 technically

play16:56

I think it

play16:57

expired uh

play16:59

but you know maybe if I if I offered

play17:01

them the cash they would do it so um

play17:04

this

play17:05

uh this is what uh kramnick said about

play17:08

Hikaru he said this match played this

play17:11

tongue and Chek under unfair conditions

play17:13

for hikaro far away from the comfortable

play17:15

chair at home congratulations to fua

play17:17

someone breaking all normal chess.com

play17:19

standards being the same level player

play17:21

over theboard online from home online

play17:22

under surveillance unique nowadays um

play17:26

look yeah karnick basically continued

play17:28

the narrative and he's even turned it up

play17:30

on notch in in just straight up accusing

play17:34

hikaro of cheating um he he just keeps

play17:38

doing it I I don't even and the craziest

play17:41

thing is like then in the match against

play17:43

Hans he

play17:44

said you know there's something more

play17:47

important than Mastery of Chess it's the

play17:48

Mastery of your emotions and he said

play17:50

that Hikaru did not play well against

play17:52

Hans in the five plus1 segment um but

play17:55

then he uh you know he beat him a few

play17:58

times in the three minute and Hans you

play18:00

know

play18:01

tilted and

play18:04

um yeah see hearo losing I told you he's

play18:07

cheating he's winning I told you

play18:09

like and the craziest thing now about

play18:12

karnick besides being apparently H's

play18:14

life coach is he's coaching the

play18:16

usbekistan team for the

play18:19

Olympiad I I just find the whole thing

play18:22

wild that he he's obviously unbelievably

play18:25

well respected for his chess

play18:26

accomplishments and there is a level of

play18:28

like separation the art from the artist

play18:29

separate the the the person from the

play18:32

artist there is a element of that like

play18:34

you have to respect all his

play18:35

contributions to chess and probably his

play18:37

ability as a trainer as well it's so

play18:40

wild to me though that you could just go

play18:41

online and accuse like 50 different

play18:43

people of cheating maybe even more at

play18:45

this point and the community is like

play18:47

what's up man hey it it just I I think

play18:52

yeah maybe it's chess players maybe it's

play18:55

just in general people are just so

play18:57

unbelievably fake like to each other's

play18:59

face like I I but I don't know I can't

play19:02

really handle it I I I don't know I sort

play19:05

of wear my heart on my sleeve and I I

play19:06

don't know how these people all coexist

play19:08

in the same room when you know they go

play19:10

home and you know they talk uh then they

play19:14

write whatever they want on social media

play19:15

but Kick's got a wild trajectory I have

play19:18

no idea what what's next but that's Hans

play19:20

and kramnick um and now I would just

play19:22

like to give you some thoughts

play19:24

about um the results of the overall

play19:27

event and then the live venue and what

play19:29

this means for the future of like sports

play19:31

uh and sorry for chess and Esports so

play19:34

Magnus was

play19:35

unbelievable you almost start wondering

play19:38

like it's a shame hikaro lost in the

play19:40

semi-final to fuja because an inform

play19:43

hikaro a motivated hikaro would have

play19:44

been given him a better fight than fuja

play19:47

did in the final and Hans did in the

play19:49

semis fuja lost to Magnus by 16 points

play19:53

which was crazy and he tilted like an

play19:56

hour into the match if even he tilted

play19:58

game six and then they had to play 24

play20:01

more games so he lost game six and

play20:05

literally immediately totally fell apart

play20:07

he took a onegame lead in the early

play20:08

portion then Magnus tied it up and then

play20:11

they had this really you know odd game

play20:13

where fua was just like crushing in the

play20:14

opening and then and then didn't you

play20:16

know just allowed a lot of counterplay

play20:17

and ended up losing the game he couldn't

play20:18

recover from that uh and he didn't yeah

play20:21

he didn't play his best and and Magnus

play20:23

was just in in quite good form uh Hikaru

play20:26

losing to fuja in the semi-final is a

play20:29

is definitely a big story uh fuja was

play20:32

very sharp clearly very motivated but

play20:35

it's unclear what it means I mean hearo

play20:37

in a lot of interviews now is talking

play20:38

about his age he's talking about some

play20:40

motivation stuff and you really never

play20:42

know because then he showed up to the

play20:43

bronze medal match and played a

play20:45

fantastic match against Hans so it's

play20:48

unclear uh but you do some somehow get

play20:50

the sense hikaro does have a foot out

play20:52

the door maybe like half a foot out the

play20:54

door um he's you know turning 37 this

play20:58

year that's that's that's older when it

play21:00

comes to top players and yet he's top

play21:01

three in the world in classical still

play21:04

and he's uh quite good and and strong

play21:05

still in Rapid and Blitz so we'll see

play21:08

we'll see what it means but obviously uh

play21:10

the Chess World will definitely be less

play21:13

interesting if he Caro chooses to retire

play21:15

hopefully he's got you know a couple of

play21:17

years remaining fua had a monster year

play21:19

we'll see if he can continue uh playing

play21:22

well like in the candidates for example

play21:24

and uh the next candidate cycle same

play21:27

with Hans I mean we're going to see if

play21:28

if this kind of carries over to to

play21:30

classical uh over theboard chess and

play21:32

listen I'm going to have to probably

play21:34

interview him at future events so I I

play21:36

doubt the the next Edition is going to

play21:37

be that uh exciting

play21:40

but I think we've turned of we've sort

play21:42

of turned a page uh in the Hans demon

play21:45

thing uh

play21:47

although then this was

play21:51

announced uh and um this is the last

play21:55

thing I'm going to I'm going to pan over

play21:56

here to this was announced

play21:59

that they're going to do

play22:03

a a there's going to be a new Untold

play22:06

series on Netflix which is behind the

play22:08

scenes Sports documentary stuff very

play22:10

cool stuff I've seen a couple of

play22:11

episodes I saw one about um Jake Paul uh

play22:15

there's me responding to get attention

play22:17

and uh there's going to be the uh chess

play22:19

Grandmaster cheating scandal so it's

play22:20

going to be Magnus and uh and Hans

play22:24

pretty wild so I don't know if I'm going

play22:26

to make an appearance in that uh but uh

play22:29

crazy absolutely crazy stuff maybe we're

play22:32

going to get a whole bunch of New

play22:33

Perspective that we haven't been given

play22:36

yet uh so yeah I think we've turned a

play22:39

page for now until the untold comes out

play22:41

and then maybe it generates a bunch of

play22:43

excitement last but not least this was

play22:45

the first ever live event with uh with

play22:47

this many chess fans I think in

play22:48

attendance there was fans in the arena

play22:51

uh this is what it looked like it was at

play22:52

espot which is a very cool venue it's

play22:54

got different rooms and locations this

play22:56

is the uh Arena the players played here

play23:00

normally they have you know a row of

play23:01

five cuz it's Esports on the opposite

play23:03

side of this which you cannot see here

play23:05

they have a like where my cursor is they

play23:06

have seating so there was people who

play23:08

could sit here uh the most difficult

play23:11

thing there was the fact that um if the

play23:14

players in the arena had an evaluation

play23:16

bar they would be able to react they

play23:18

would see the bar and go and then the

play23:21

players in the next would go oh I can

play23:23

hear the crowd is getting restless so I

play23:25

have something and that's the struggle

play23:26

about Chess the maybe the only way to

play23:28

mitigate this when the audience has more

play23:30

information than the chass players is to

play23:32

put the players like this but in a big

play23:34

glass box which is soundproof and

play23:36

apparent this has been done before where

play23:38

the players sit there's a glass you can

play23:40

see the players but the players cannot

play23:42

see you and the fans can be as loud as

play23:43

possible cheering you know and they see

play23:45

the players there um and maybe that's

play23:49

the way to do it and and and then the

play23:50

the audience can get a live commentary

play23:53

like in the ear you know like they have

play23:54

silent Raves you have headphones but

play23:56

there is music playing so everybody's

play23:57

dancing but it's silent

play23:59

so maybe that's that's one way to do it

play24:00

there was about 3 400 people there I met

play24:02

a bunch of people took a bunch of

play24:04

pictures with with people sign signed

play24:06

stuff for people uh and uh it was it it

play24:10

was quite special it was quite cool and

play24:12

and and a lot of a lot of people were

play24:13

were very nice I do wonder if we can

play24:15

sell you know a th000 or 2,000 or 5,000

play24:19

for some of the elite players of the

play24:21

world uh I'm really hopeful you know I'm

play24:23

really hopeful because I think I think

play24:25

chess can can easily you know grow to to

play24:28

an ort like 30% the size of some of the

play24:31

biggest orts in the world I would hope

play24:33

but we have to uh we have to get there

play24:35

and there were problems you know there

play24:36

were problems even

play24:37

though Hans said I have you know we have

play24:39

non-disparagement agreements with ch.com

play24:42

um or something along those lines but uh

play24:47

yeah like the you know the events page

play24:48

was lagging at some points uh there were

play24:50

there were some broadcast issues uh

play24:52

there were uh little things that I you

play24:54

know I would change about like player

play24:55

walkouts or uh the crowd you know

play24:59

elements of the crowd and and things

play25:01

like that uh but that's all stuff that

play25:03

gets solved over time and these are kind

play25:07

of like the early additions and I'm

play25:09

staying positive and optimistic that

play25:11

these things can be can be mitigated but

play25:13

espot was super cool uh chess say an

play25:16

esport is a is a fascinating

play25:18

phenomenon and hopefully more things are

play25:21

coming in the future more Big Brand

play25:23

collabs like there was no big brand uh

play25:26

title sponsor for speechs championship I

play25:28

know they partnered with like displate

play25:30

that was a big one but you know why does

play25:33

chess not have a watch sponsor watch

play25:35

companies Tio scitec Casio Rolex hit us

play25:41

up man I mean the clock is like integral

play25:43

to the game how do we not have a watch

play25:45

sponsor we need bigger sponsorships in

play25:47

chess and uh that's what I'm hoping that

play25:50

you know some of these things can

play25:51

ultimately lead to but a wild time in

play25:53

Paris it was uh the Hans demon interview

play25:56

don't know if it's kayf

play25:59

if you don't know what kayfabe is I will

play26:02

um kayfabe is uh the fact or Convention

play26:06

of presenting stage performances as

play26:08

genuine or authentic I don't know how

play26:10

much of it is kayab I don't know how

play26:13

much of it is real and I don't know what

play26:15

the future holds because now that Hans

play26:17

lost up Magnus and Hikaru and gave that

play26:19

interview where he had a kind of

play26:21

refreshing new and humble perspective

play26:22

we'll see if it carries on or we'll see

play26:25

if he rattles off a few wins and says

play26:28

I'm back baby Hans demon is back you

play26:30

know I can't wait for the next interview

play26:32

cuz um it's going to be a wild one

play26:34

so those are my perspectives and

play26:39

uh yeah the Chess World Keeps on

play26:41

chugging

play26:42

along get out of here

Rate This

5.0 / 5 (0 votes)

Related Tags
Chess ChampionshipLive CommentaryMedia PersonalityParis EventChess ScandalHans NiemannMagnus CarlsenHikaru NakamuraEsports CultureChampionship FinaleChess.com