Constructivism as a Philosophy of Research

Summary

Constructivism is a philosophical approach that emphasizes the active role of individuals in constructing knowledge and reality. It contrasts with positivism by suggesting that reality is not an objective, singular truth but a product of various forces and interactions. This perspective views reality as relative and context-dependent, shaped by individual and collective experiences. Constructivists argue that objects exist but derive meaning through human perception and interaction. In research, constructivists acknowledge the influence of subjective experiences and values, seeking truth through a nuanced understanding that respects diverse perspectives.

Takeaways

• 🏗️ Constructivism is a theory that emphasizes the construction of reality and knowledge through social interaction and individual experiences.
• 🔍 It contrasts with positivism, which assumes an objective reality and knowledge that can be discovered as it is.
• 🌟 Constructivism views reality as multiple and relative, co-created within the contexts individuals are part of, rather than a single, universal reality.
• 🤔 A constructivist believes that individual realities are unique due to the influence of one's community, society, and other external forces.
• 👥 It acknowledges the role of both individual and collective interactions with the physical world in shaping reality.
• 🌐 Constructivists do not deny the existence of an external world; instead, they see it as an interactive force in the construction of reality.
• 🎓 In constructivism, objects exist but their meaning is derived from human perception and social context, not from an inherent, objective quality.
• 📚 Constructivist epistemology is relativist, valuing diverse and nuanced understandings of the world, and not seeking a single 'right' interpretation.
• 🔎 Constructivists believe that meanings are not equally valid but are assessed based on their relevance and fulfillment, and how well they reflect the subject-object interaction.
• 🔬 As researchers, constructivists recognize the impact of subjective experience and values on the knowledge creation process, often seeking to leverage this subjectivity.

Q & A

What is the main idea behind constructivism?

Constructivism is about the construction of reality and knowledge. It posits that reality and knowledge are co-created through the interaction of various forces, contrasting with the positivist view that there is one objective reality to be discovered.

How does constructivism differ from positivism?

While positivism assumes there is one objective reality and knowledge to be discovered, constructivism believes in multiple, relative realities that are co-created by individuals, their communities, societies, and the physical world.

What does constructivism say about the existence of objects outside human perception?

Constructivists acknowledge the existence of an external world but believe that objects only gain meaning through human perception and interaction. The external world is one of the forces that contribute to the construction of reality.

What is constructivism's view on relativism?

Constructivism holds a relativist view, believing there are many relative realities rather than one absolute reality. These realities are specific to the contexts they are part of and are co-created through social and physical interactions.

Does constructivism reject the existence of truth altogether?

No, constructivism does not reject truth. While it denies one objective reality, it does recognize the validity of different meanings and perspectives. Constructivists believe that some meanings are more relevant or fulfilling, depending on how they interact with the object they reflect.

How does constructivism view the role of communities and societies in constructing reality?

Constructivism emphasizes that reality is constructed not just by individuals, but through the interaction of individuals with their communities, societies, and social conventions. These social forces play a crucial role in shaping and constructing reality.

What is the epistemology of constructivism?

Constructivism's epistemology is often classified as relativist. It acknowledges that subjective experience and values influence knowledge. The varied perspectives people bring to the world enrich our understanding rather than detracting from it.

How do constructivists view the value of different meanings or perspectives?

Constructivists believe that meanings and perspectives are not equally valid. Their value depends on how relevant or fulfilling they are and how well they balance the interaction between the subject (observer) and object (the external world).

What is the role of subjectivity in constructivist research?

In constructivist research, subjective experiences and values are recognized as playing a role in the research process. Rather than trying to eliminate subjectivity, constructivists often use it to enrich their research and understanding of reality.

Why is constructivism sometimes difficult to define clearly?

Constructivism has been applied in different fields such as philosophy, sociology, and research, and is sometimes used interchangeably with terms like constructionism and social constructionism. This varied usage makes it difficult to pin down a single, clear definition.

Outlines

00:00

🏗️ Constructivism Overview

Constructivism is a philosophical approach that emphasizes the active role of individuals in constructing their own understanding of reality. It contrasts with positivism, which assumes an objective reality waiting to be discovered. Constructivism views reality and knowledge as interrelated, suggesting that multiple realities exist, each shaped by individual and social contexts. It acknowledges the influence of culture, society, and physical interactions in shaping these realities. Constructivists believe that while objects exist independently of perception, their meanings are constructed through human interaction. This perspective is not fully relativistic; it allows for the existence of multiple valid meanings, evaluated by their relevance and coherence with the object of study. In research, constructivists recognize the impact of subjective experiences and values, seeking to leverage these to enrich knowledge.

Keywords

💡Constructivism

Constructivism is a philosophical theory that emphasizes the role of the individual in constructing knowledge and reality. In the video, it is contrasted with positivism, which assumes an objective reality waiting to be discovered. Constructivism suggests that reality and knowledge are actively created through the interaction of individuals with their environment and society. The video script mentions that constructivism views reality as something that is 'constructed' and not merely discovered, highlighting the dynamic nature of knowledge creation.

💡Construction of Reality

The construction of reality refers to the idea that our understanding of the world is not a direct reflection of an objective truth but is instead built through our experiences and interactions. The video script discusses how constructivists believe that reality is not a fixed entity but is shaped by various forces, including individual and societal interactions, which bring reality into being.

💡Positivism

Positivism is a philosophical approach that asserts there is a single, objective reality that can be discovered through empirical observation and logical reasoning. The video script contrasts this with constructivism, noting that positivism assumes an objective knowledge that can be gained, whereas constructivism sees knowledge as being constructed and relative.

💡Relativism

Relativism is the concept that knowledge, truth, and morality are not absolute but are relative to individuals, societies, or cultures. The video script describes constructivism's ontology as relativist, suggesting that there are multiple realities that are specific to and co-created within their contexts, rather than a single, universal reality.

💡Interplay of Forces

The interplay of forces in constructivism refers to the various elements and influences that interact to shape reality and knowledge. The video script uses this term to describe how constructivists view the complex interactions between individuals, societies, cultures, and the physical world as integral to the construction of reality.

💡Social Constructionism

Social constructionism is a perspective within constructivism that emphasizes the role of social interaction in the creation of knowledge and reality. The video script mentions that constructivism is sometimes used interchangeably with social constructionism, indicating that societal forces play a significant role in shaping our understanding of the world.

💡Epistemology

Epistemology is the branch of philosophy concerned with the nature and scope of knowledge. In the context of the video, constructivism's epistemology is described as relativist, suggesting that knowledge is not absolute but is constructed and understood differently by different people based on their experiences and perspectives.

💡Subjective Experience

Subjective experience refers to personal perceptions, feelings, and interpretations that are unique to each individual. The video script notes that constructivists acknowledge the role of subjective experience in shaping knowledge, implying that individual perspectives are integral to the construction of reality.

💡Values

Values are principles or standards that guide beliefs, attitudes, and actions. The video script mentions that constructivists recognize the influence of values on knowledge, indicating that personal and cultural values are part of the process of constructing reality and understanding.

💡Dialectical Process

The dialectical process refers to the interaction and resolution of opposing ideas or forces, leading to the development of new understandings. The video script suggests that constructivists view the process of mediating the interaction between subject and object as dialectical, contributing to the richness and complexity of knowledge.

💡Criteria for Truth

Criteria for truth in constructivism refer to the standards or principles used to evaluate the validity of knowledge claims. The video script explains that while constructivists do not adhere to a single, objective meaning, they still recognize the importance of criteria for assessing the relevance and value of different perspectives.

Highlights

Constructivism is about the construction of reality and knowledge.

Contrasts with positivism's belief in a single, discoverable reality.

Constructivism views reality and knowledge as interplay of forces.

Term used in philosophy, sociology, and research, sometimes interchanged with constructionism and social constructionism.

Constructivism's ontology is relativist, suggesting multiple realities.

Reality is co-created in the context of individual and societal interactions.

Constructivists acknowledge the existence of a world outside human perception.

Objects have existence but not meaning outside of human perception.

Constructivist epistemology is relativist, valuing varied and nuanced understandings.

Meanings are not equally valid but vary based on relevance and fulfillment.

Constructivists believe in criteria for getting to truth within subjective experiences.

Meanings' value can be informed by attentiveness to the object they reflect.

Constructivist researchers acknowledge the role of subjective experience and values in knowledge.

Constructivist research may take many paths, embracing opportunities from subjectivity.

Constructivism enriches our knowledge of the world through diverse perspectives.

Constructivists mediate the interaction between subject and object dialectically.

Transcripts

so what is constructivism

well let's look for clues constructivism

construct a construct construction

constructivism is about construction

the construction of reality and

knowledge it stands in contrast to

positivism's assumption

that there is one reality out there to

be discovered just as it is

and objective knowledge out there to be

gained

constructivism looks at the interplay of

forces that bring reality and knowledge

into being

constructivism is a term applied in

different ways at different times in

philosophy

sociology and research it is also

sometimes used interchangeably with

constructionism and social

constructionism

so nailing down what it is exactly can

be difficult

but we'll try to get a general idea

constructivism's ontology or

understanding of being

is generally classified as relativist

there is not one reality rather there

are many relative realities

specific to and co-created in the

context they are part of

a constructivist would likely say that

my reality

will not be the same as your reality

because we have each constructed our

realities together with our communities

our societies and other forces

it is not just people and our cultures

conventions and institutions

that constructivists see as forming

reality

rather the interaction between people as

individuals or groups with the physical

world around them

construct reality constructivists

generally therefore do not deny the

existence of a world outside of human

perception

rather that external world has a place

as one of the forces that bring reality

into existence

through interaction constructivists

believe that objects have existence

but not meaning outside of human

perception the epistemology or

understanding of knowledge and

constructivism

is often classified as a relativist one

though not as fully relativistic as some

perspectives

this relativism is not to be bemoaned

though

as positivists may be tempted to do

rather

a constructivist sees the varied nuanced

understandings that different people

bring into being as enriching our

knowledge of the world

and within these varied perspectives

there are still criteria for getting to

truth

for constructivists meanings are not all

equally valid

there is not one right or objective

meaning but meanings vary on how

relevant or fulfilling they are

their value can be informed by how

attentive they are to the object they

reflect

or how well they balance the dialectical

process

of mediating the interaction between

subject and object

as researchers constructivists may take

many paths

however they all acknowledge the role

that subjective experience and values

play on knowledge in the research

process

many will attempt to harness these

opportunities that arise from

subjectivity