Harris and Trump speak on immigration policy during presidential debate

Summary

In a heated exchange, Vice President Harris addresses border security, emphasizing her experience prosecuting transnational criminal organizations and supporting a bill to increase border agents. She criticizes the Trump administration for not fixing problems, accusing Trump of preferring to run on issues rather than solving them. Trump counters by highlighting his support from prominent Republicans and accuses the Biden administration of allowing criminals and terrorists into the country, claiming this has led to a rise in crime. The discussion touches on immigration, border control, and the political strategies of both parties.

Takeaways

• 🗣️ Vice President Harris was tasked with addressing the root causes of migration from Central America.
• 📈 Illegal border crossings reached a record high under the Biden administration in June.
• 🔽 Despite record highs, the numbers of illegal crossings have dropped significantly since then.
• 🤔 The administration is questioned on the timing of their actions, specifically why they waited until six months before the election to act on immigration issues.
• 🛂 Harris highlights her experience prosecuting transnational criminal organizations involved in trafficking.
• 🚨 She supports a border security bill that would increase border agents and resources to combat drug and human trafficking.
• 🏛️ The bill was reportedly killed due to intervention from former President Trump, according to Harris.
• 🇺🇸 Harris criticizes Trump for not addressing problems and instead running on them, suggesting he prefers to use issues for political gain rather than solving them.
• 🗳️ Trump claims to have received more votes than any sitting president in history and points to his endorsement from prominent Republicans.
• 🚨 Trump alleges that the current administration has allowed criminals and terrorists into the country, contributing to a rise in crime.

Q & A

What was the task assigned to Vice President Harris regarding migration from Central America?

Vice President Harris was tasked with addressing the root causes of migration from Central America.

What was the record high number of illegal border crossings in the Biden administration?

Illegal border crossings reached a record high in June during the Biden administration, though the exact number is not specified in the transcript.

How has the administration's approach to border security been criticized?

The administration was criticized for waiting until six months before the election to act on border security issues.

What is the claim about the border security bill supported by Vice President Harris?

The border security bill supported by Vice President Harris would have added 1500 more border agents and aimed to stem the flow of fentanyl into the United States.

Who is accused of killing the border security bill according to the transcript?

Former President Donald Trump is accused of killing the border security bill.

What is the critique of former President Trump's approach to problems as mentioned in the transcript?

Former President Trump is critiqued for preferring to run on a problem rather than fixing it, as exemplified by his approach to immigration and border security.

What is the claim about the attendance and authenticity of Vice President Harris's rallies?

It is claimed that Vice President Harris's rallies have low attendance and that she allegedly buzzes and pays people to be there.

What is the counter-claim made about former President Trump's rallies?

The counter-claim is that former President Trump's rallies are the biggest and most incredible in the history of politics, with people attending because they want to take their country back.

What is the accusation regarding the endorsement of the current president by high-profile Republicans?

The current president is accused of having the endorsement of 200 Republicans, including former Vice President Dick Cheney and Congress member Liz Cheney.

What is the criticism of the former president's handling of Afghanistan and the Taliban?

The criticism is that the former president did not fire anyone responsible for the situation in Afghanistan and the rise of the Taliban, which is described as one of the most incompetently handled situations.

What is the claim about the increase in crime in the United States as per the transcript?

The claim is that crime in the United States is up and through the roof, with a new form of crime called 'migrant crime' happening at unprecedented levels.

Outlines

00:00

🗣️ Debate on Border Security and Immigration

The paragraph revolves around a debate on border security and immigration policies. Vice President Harris is questioned about the Biden administration's approach to tackling the root causes of migration from Central America and the record high illegal border crossings. The discussion shifts to the administration's delay in acting before the elections and what differentiates Vice President Harris's approach from President Biden's. The speaker criticizes former President Trump for not supporting a border security bill that could have added more agents and resources to combat drug trafficking and illegal immigration. The speaker also accuses Trump of prioritizing political gain over problem-solving and invites the audience to Trump's rallies to observe the focus on fictional characters and irrelevant topics rather than addressing the audience's concerns.

05:10

🔍 Scrutiny of Political Rhetoric and Endorsements

This paragraph focuses on the scrutiny of political rhetoric and endorsements. It highlights the endorsements received by a candidate from notable Republicans, including former Vice President Dick Cheney and Congress member Liz Cheney, who have worked with President Bush, Mitt Romney, and John McCain. The paragraph emphasizes the candidate's ability to gain support from across the political spectrum. It also discusses the candidate's criticism of former President Trump, citing statements from his former staff and advisors who have called him dangerous and unfit for office. The paragraph concludes with a comparison between the candidate's approach to leadership and problem-solving versus Trump's alleged focus on self-promotion and avoidance of responsibility.

Keywords

💡Transnational Criminal Organizations

Transnational criminal organizations refer to groups that operate across national borders, engaging in illegal activities such as drug trafficking, human trafficking, and arms smuggling. In the video, Vice President Harris mentions her experience in prosecuting such organizations, highlighting the complexity of border security and the need for international cooperation to combat these threats. The term underscores the video's theme of addressing the root causes of migration and the interconnectedness of global security issues.

💡Border Security

Border security pertains to measures taken by a country to monitor and control the movement of people, goods, and vehicles across its borders. The video discusses the proposal for more border agents and the use of technology to stem the flow of illegal substances like fentanyl, indicating the importance of border security in preventing criminal activities and protecting public health.

💡Fentanyl

Fentanyl is a powerful synthetic opioid that is 50 to 100 times more potent than morphine. It has been a significant contributor to the opioid crisis in the United States. In the script, the mention of fentanyl reflects the video's focus on the impact of drug trafficking on American society and the role of border security in mitigating this issue.

💡Immigration

Immigration is the process by which people move from one country to another with the intention of residing there. The video script addresses the contentious issue of immigration, particularly the debate over border control, deportation policies, and the impact of immigration on the country's social fabric. The term is central to the video's theme, as it encapsulates the political and humanitarian challenges faced by the administration.

💡Deportation

Deportation is the act of expelling a person from one country to another, often due to violations of immigration laws. The video discusses proposals for large-scale deportation operations, which are contentious due to their potential impact on families and communities. The term is used to illustrate the harshness of certain immigration policies and the debate over how to handle undocumented immigrants.

💡National Guard

The National Guard is a reserve military force in the United States that can be called upon for domestic operations, including support for law enforcement. In the video, the mention of the National Guard being used in immigration control signifies the escalation of measures to manage border security and the potential militarization of immigration enforcement.

💡Asylum Restrictions

Asylum restrictions refer to policies that limit or regulate the granting of asylum to individuals seeking protection from persecution in their home countries. The video script mentions President Biden's opposition to new asylum restrictions, which is indicative of the broader debate over humanitarian policies and national security concerns.

💡Human Trafficking

Human trafficking is the illegal trade of human beings for the purposes of forced labor or sexual exploitation. Vice President Harris' reference to prosecuting transnational criminal organizations involved in human trafficking underscores the video's focus on the serious crime that often intersects with issues of migration and border control.

💡Rallies

Rallies in the context of the video refer to political gatherings where candidates or parties express their views and rally support. The script mentions the size and enthusiasm of rallies as a measure of public support and a reflection of the electorate's concerns and priorities.

💡Make America Great Again

Make America Great Again (MAGA) is a slogan associated with former President Trump's political campaign and presidency. It encapsulates his policy agenda aimed at restoring American economic dominance and national pride. The phrase is used in the video to criticize the current state of the nation and to evoke a sense of nostalgia for a perceived past greatness.

💡Venezuela

Venezuela is a country in South America that has been facing a severe economic and political crisis, leading to high crime rates and mass emigration. In the video, the mention of Venezuela serves as a cautionary example of what could happen to the United States if current immigration policies are not changed, highlighting the video's theme of national decline and the need for strong leadership.

Highlights

Vice President Harris discusses the Biden administration's efforts to address the root causes of migration from Central America.

Illegal border crossings reached a record high in the Biden administration in June, but numbers have since dropped significantly.

President Biden opposed new asylum restrictions, which is contrasted with the administration's later actions on immigration.

Vice President Harris highlights her experience prosecuting transnational criminal organizations involved in trafficking.

A border security bill supported by Vice President Harris is mentioned, which would have increased border agents and resources.

The former President Trump is criticized for allegedly killing a bill that could have helped with border security.

Vice President Harris emphasizes the need for a leader who engages in solutions rather than running on problems.

President Trump's approach to immigration and his rallies are criticized, with an invitation to attend to observe the content.

President Trump responds to criticism by highlighting the size and enthusiasm of his rallies.

The discussion turns to the endorsement of 200 Republicans for President Trump, including high-profile figures like Dick Cheney.

President Trump defends his administration's handling of personnel, citing the firing of those who did a bad job.

The economic performance and inflation under the current administration are criticized by President Trump.

President Trump claims to have received more votes than any Republican or sitting president in history.

President Trump outlines a proposal for the largest domestic deportation operation in U.S. history, including the use of local police.

The issue of crime rates and the impact of immigration on crime in the U.S. is a central point of discussion.

President Trump accuses the current administration of allowing criminals and terrorists into the country, impacting crime rates.

Transcripts

.

WE KNOW THIS IS AN ISSUE THAT IS

IMPORTANT TO VOTERS ACROSS THE

BOARD.

VICE PRESIDENT HARRIS, YOU WERE

TASKED WITH PRAISING BIDEN

GETTING TO THE ROOT CAUSES OF

MIGRATION FROM CENTRAL AMERICA.

WE KNOW THAT ILLEGAL BORDER

CROSSINGS REACHED A RECORD HIGH

IN THE BIDEN ADMINISTRATION THIS

PAST JUNE, PRESIDENT BIDEN

OPPOSED TO NEW ASYLUM

RESTRICTIONS.

WE KNOW THE NUMBERS SINCE THEN

HAVE DROPPED SIGNIFICANTLY.

BUT MY QUESTION TO YOU TONIGHT

IS, WHY DID THE ADMINISTRATION

WAIT UNTIL SIX MONTHS BEFORE THE

ELECTION TO ACT?

AND WHEN YOU HAVE DONE ANYTHING

DIFFERENTLY FROM

PRESIDENT BIDEN.

>> SO I'M THE ONLY PERSON ON

THIS STAGE, HAS PROSECUTED

TRANSNATIONAL CRIMINAL

ORGANIZATIONS WITH THE

TRAFFICKING OF GUNS, DRUGS, AND

HUMAN BEINGS.

AND LET ME SAY, THAT THE UNITED

STATES CONGRESS INCLUDING SOME

OF THE MOST CONSERVATIVE MEMBERS

OF THE UNITED STATES SENATE CAME

UP WITH A BORDER SECURITY BILL

WHICH I SUPPORTED.

AND THAT BILL WOULD HAVE PUT

1500 MORE BORDER AGENTS ON THE

BORDER TO HELP THOSE FOLKS WHO

ARE WORKING THERE RIGHT NOW,

OVER TIME TRYING TO DO THEIR

JOB.

IT WOULD HAVE ALLOWED US TO STEM

THE FLOW OF FENTANYL COMING INTO

THE UNITED STATES.

I KNOW THERE ARE SO MANY

FAMILIES WATCHING TONIGHT WHO

HAVE BEEN PERSONALLY AFFECTED BY

THE SURGE OF FENTANYL IN OUR

COUNTRY.

THAT BILL WOULD HAVE PUT MORE

RESOURCES TO ALLOW US TO

PROSECUTE TRANSNATIONAL CRIMINAL

ORGANIZATIONS FOR TRAFFICKING IN

GUNS, DRUGS, AND HUMAN BEINGS.

BUT YOU KNOW WHAT HAVE BEEN TO

THE BILL?

DONALD TRUMP GOT ON THE PHONE.

HE CALLED UP SOME FOLKS IN

CONGRESS AND SAID, KILLED THE

BILL.

AND YOU KNOW WHY.

BECAUSE HE PREFERRED A RUN ON A

PROBLEM INSTEAD OF FIXING A

PROBLEM.

AND UNDERSTAND, THIS COMES AT A

TIME WHERE THE PEOPLE OF OUR

COUNTRY ACTUALLY NEED A LEADER

WHO ENGAGES IN SOLUTIONS, WHO

ACTUALLY ADDRESSES THE PROBLEMS

AT HAND.

BUT WHAT WE HAVE IN THE FORMER

PRESIDENT IS SOMEONE WHO WOULD

PREFER TO RUN ON A PROBLEM

INSTEAD OF FIXING A PROBLEM.

AND I WILL TELL YOU SOMETHING,

HE IS GOING TO TALK ABOUT

IMMIGRATION ALLOTMENT EVEN WHEN

IT IS NOT THE SUBJECT THAT IS

BEING RAISED AND I'M GOING TO

ACTUALLY DO SOMETHING REALLY

UNUSUAL AND I'M GOING TO INVITE

YOU TO ATTEND ONE OF THE TRUMP

RALLIES BECAUSE IT IS A REALLY

INTERESTING THING TO WATCH.

YOU WILL SEE DURING THE COURSE

OF HIS RALLIES HE TALKS ABOUT

FICTIONAL CHARACTERS LIKE

HANNIBAL LECTOR, HE WILL TALK

ABOUT WHEN WINDMILLS CAN CAUSE

CANCER.

AND WHAT YOU WILL ALSO NOTICE

THAT PEOPLE START LEAVING HIS

RALLIES EARLY OUT OF EXHAUSTION

AND BOREDOM.

AND I WILL TELL YOU THE ONE

THING YOU WILL NOT HEAR HIM TALK

ABOUT IS YOU.

YOU WILL NOT HEAR HIM TALK ABOUT

YOUR KNEES, YOUR DREAMS, AND

YOUR DESIRES.

AND I WILL TELL YOU, I BELIEVE

YOU DESERVE A PRESIDENT WHO

ACTUALLY PUTS YOU FIRST AND I

PLEDGE TO YOU THAT I WILL.

>> BRYSE PRESIDENT HARRIS,

THINKING.

AND TRUMKA WANT TO GET YOUR

RESPONSE.

>> I WOULD LIKE TO RESPOND.

>> WHY DID YOU TRY TO KILL THAT

BILL THAT WOULD PUT THOUSANDS OF

ADDITIONAL AGENTS AND OFFICERS

ON THE BORDER?

>> I'M GOING TO RESPOND.

SHE SAID PEOPLE START LEAVING.

PEOPLE DON'T GO TO HER RALLIES.

THERE'S NO REASON TO GO.

AND THE PEOPLE THAT TO GO, SHE

IS BUZZING THEM AND THEN PAYING

THEM TO BE THERE.

UP AND THEN SHOWING THEM IN A

DIFFERENT LIGHT.

SO SHE CAN TALK ABOUT THAT.

PEOPLE DON'T NEED MIKE GRELLA'S.

WE HAVE THE BIGGEST RALLIES, THE

MOST INCREDIBLE RALLIES IN THE

HISTORY OF POLITICS BUT THAT'S

BECAUSE PEOPLE WANT TO TAKE

THEIR COUNTRY BACK.

OUR COUNTRY IS BEING LOST.

WE ARE A FAILING NATION.

AND IT HAPPENED 3 1/2 YEARS AGO

AND WHAT IS GOING ON HERE,

YOU'RE GOING TO END UP IN WORLD

WAR II JUST TO GO INTO

PHRASE: MAKE

AMERICA GREAT AGAIN.

IF SHE BECOMES PRESIDENT, THE

COUNTRY DOESN'T HAVE A CHANCE

FOR SUCCESS.

NOT ONLY SUCCESS: WE WILL BE

VENEZUELA ON STEROIDS.

>> YOU BRING UP SPRINGFIELD OF

OHIO.

"ABC NEWS" REACHED OUT TO THE

MANAGER, TOLD US THERE HAD BEEN

NO CREDIBLE REPORTS OF SPECIFIC

CLAIMS OF THEM BEING HARMED

OR -- INDIVIDUALS IN THE

IMMIGRANT COMMUNITY.

>> PEOPLE ON TELEVISION SAY MY

DOG WAS TAKEN AND USED FOR FOOD,

SO MAYBE HE NEEDS THAT.

>> I'M SPEAKING FROM THE CITY

MANAGER TO BE INVOLVED, THE

PEOPLE THAT WENT THERE.

>> THE SPRINGFIELD CITY MANAGER

SAYS THERE IS NO EVIDENCE OF

THAT.

I WILL LET YOU RESPOND TO THE

REST OF WHAT YOU HEARD.

>> YOU TALK ABOUT EXTREME.

I HAVE THE ENDORSEMENT OF 200

REPUBLICANS WHO HAVE FORMERLY

WORKED WITH PRESIDENT BUSH,

MITT ROMNEY, AND JOHN McCAIN,

INCLUDING THE ENDORSEMENT OF

FORMER VICE PRESIDENT

DICK CHENEY AND CONGRESS MEMBER

LIZ CHENEY.

IF YOU WANT TO KNOW THE INSIDE

TRACK -- IF YOU WANT TO MAKE

CLEAR ALREADY, ASK PEOPLE WHO

HAVE WORKED WITH HIM PERIODS

FORMER CHIEF OF STAFF, A

FOUR-STAR GENERAL, HAS SAID HE

HAS CONTEMPT FOR THE

CONSTITUTION OF THE

UNITED STATES.

HIS FORMER NATIONAL SECURITY

ADVISOR SAID HE IS DANGEROUS AND

UNFIT.

HIS FORMER SECRETARY OF DEFENSE

HAS SAID THE NATION, THE

REPUBLIC WOULD NEVER SURVIVE

ANOTHER TRUMP TERM.

WHEN WE LISTEN TO THIS KIND OF

RHETORIC WITH ISSUES THAT AFFECT

THE AMERICAN PEOPLE, NOT BEING

ADDRESSED, I THINK THE CHOICE IS

CLEAR IN THE SELECTION.

>> PRESIDENT TRUMP, I WILL GIVE

YOU A MINUTE TO RESPOND.

>> THANK YOU, BECAUSE WHEN I

HEAR THAT -- SEE, I'M A

DIFFERENT KIND OF A PERSON.

I FIRE MOST OF THOSE PEOPLE.

NOT SO GRACIOUSLY PICKED THEY

DID BAD THINGS OR A BAD JOB.

I FIRED THEM.

THEY NEVER FIRED ONE PERSON.

THEY DIDN'T FIRE ANYBODY HAVING

TO DO WITH AFGHANISTAN, THE

TALIBAN, THE 13 PEOPLE WHOSE,

WHO WERE JUST KILLED VICIOUSLY

AND VIOLENTLY.

I GOT TO KNOW THE PARENTS AND

THE FAMILY.

THEY SHOULD HAVE HIRED ALL THOSE

GENERALS.

THAT WAS ONE OF THE MOST

INCOMPETENTLY HANDLED SITU

SITUATIONS.

WHEN SOMEBODY DOES A BAD JOB, I

FIRE THEM.

YOU TAKE A GUY LIKE ESPER.

HE WAS NO GOOD, I FIRED HIM,

THEY CAN WRITE BOOKS.

THEY CAN WRITE BOOKS WITH ME,

BUT NOBODY ELSE, CAN THEY?

THEY'VE DONE A POOR JOB AND

NEVER FIRE ANYBODY.

LOOK AT THE ECONOMY.

LOOK AT THE INFLATION.

THEY DIDN'T FIRE ANY OF THEIR

ECONOMISTS.

THEY HAVE THE SAME PEOPLE.

THAT'S A GOOD WAY NOT TO HAVE

BOOKS WRITTEN ABOUT YOU.

JUST TO FINISH, I'VE GOT MORE

VOTES THAN ANY REPUBLICAN IN

HISTORY BY FAR.

IN FACT, I GOT MORE VOTES THAN

ANY PRESIDENT, ANY SITTING

PRESIDENT IN HISTORY, BY FAR.

>> LET ME CONTINUE ON

IMMIGRATION.

THIS IS WHAT YOU WANTED TO TALK

ABOUT EARLIER SO LET'S GET BACK

TO YOUR DEPORTATION PROPOSAL THE

VICE PRESIDENT HAS DIRECTED TO

AS WELL.

PRESIDENT TRUMP, YOU CALLED THIS

THE LARGEST DOMESTIC DEPORTATION

OPERATION IN THE HISTORY OF OUR

COUNTRY.

YOU SAY YOU WOULD USE THE

NATIONAL GUARD, IF THINGS GET

OUT OF CONTROL YOU HAVE NO

PROBLEM USING -- --

>> LOCAL POLICE.

>> YOU'VE ALSO SAID YOU WOULD

USE LOCAL POLICE.

HOW WOULD YOU DEPORT 11 MILLION

A DOCUMENT OF IMMIGRANTS?

I KNOW YOU BELIEVE THE NUMBER IS

MUCH HIGHER.

WILL AUTHORITIES BE GOING

DOOR-TO-DOOR IN THIS COUNTRY?

>> IT IS MUCH HIGHER BECAUSE OF

THEM.

THEY ALLOWED CRIMINALS, MANY,

MANY, MILLIONS OF CRIMINALS.

THEY ALLOWED TERRORISTS.

THEY ALLOWED COMMON STREET

CRIMINALS.

THEY ALLOWED PEOPLE TO COME IN,

DRUG DEALERS, TO COME INTO OUR

COUNTRY, AND THE UNITED STATES,

AND TOLD BY THEIR COUNTRIES LIKE

VENEZUELA "DON'T EVER COME BACK,

OR WE'RE GOING TO KILL YOU."

THE CRIME IN VENEZUELA AND CRIME

IN COUNTRIES ALL OVER THE WORLD

IS WAY DOWN.

YOU KNOW WHY?

THEY'VE TAKEN THEIR CRIMINALS

OFF THE STREET AND HAVE GIVEN

THEM TO HER TO PUT INTO OUR

COUNTRY.

THIS WILL BE ONE OF THE GREATEST

MISTAKES IN HISTORY FOR THEM TO

ALLOW -- AND I THINK THEY

PROBABLY DID IT BECAUSE THEY

THINK THEY ARE GOING TO GET

VOTES, BUT IT'S NOT WORTH IT.

THEY ARE DESTROYING THE FABRIC

OF OUR COUNTRY BY WHAT THEY'VE

DONE.

THERE HAS NEVER BEEN ANYTHING

DONE LIKE THIS AT ALL.

THEY HAVE DESTROYED THE FABRIC

OF OUR COUNTRY.

MILLIONS OF PEOPLE LET IN, AND

ALL OVER THE WORLD, CRIME IS

DOWN, ALL OVER THE WORLD EXCEPT

HERE.

CRIME HERE IS UP AND THROUGH THE

ROOF DESPITE THEIR FRAUDULENT

STATEMENTS THEY'VE MADE, CRIME

IN THIS COUNTRY IS THROUGH THE

ROOF.

WE HAVE A NEW FORM OF CRIME:

MIGRANT CRIME, AND IT'S

HAPPENING AT LEVELS NOBODY