Why Soda Tastes Different In A Can Or Bottle

Insider

27 Mar 201805:46

Summary

TLDRThis script explores whether the container type affects the taste of soda. Despite soda companies using the same ingredients, factors such as container materials, carbonation levels, and light exposure can influence flavor. Glass bottles are inert, while cans and plastic bottles have linings to prevent metal or chemical tastes. Carbonation can vary due to container permeability, and light can alter flavor compounds. Personal sensory experiences and expectations also play a role in taste perception.

Takeaways

🥤 People have varying preferences for soda containers, with some favoring cans and others preferring bottles or glass.
🧊 Soda companies, including Coca-Cola, claim to use the same recipe regardless of the container type, ensuring consistent flavor.
🧪 Glass bottles are considered inert, containing no chemical ingredients that could alter the soda's taste.
🛡 Aluminum cans have a polymer lining to prevent metal contamination, which is believed to have minimal impact on taste.
🤔 Some individuals report a metallic taste from canned sodas, possibly due to the can's material or the can opening process.
🍶 Plastic bottles are made with PET, which is safe for consumption but could theoretically allow for minor chemical leaching.
🔍 The FDA regulates contaminants in beverages to ensure safety, though humans can detect contaminants at levels below instrumental detection.
❄️ Carbonation levels can affect taste, with different packaging materials potentially allowing CO2 to escape at varying rates.
🌡️ Temperature changes, such as warmth, can cause more CO2 to be released, which might make the soda taste flat.
💡 Light can induce chemical reactions in soda, potentially altering flavor compounds, especially if the container lacks light protection.
🧠 Taste perception is complex, influenced by both molecular interactions and individual experiences, including expectations and memory.

Q & A

Do people have different opinions on soda containers?
-Yes, people have strong opinions about soda containers, with some preferring cans, others preferring bottles, and some even preferring glass bottled soda.
Do soda companies claim to use the same ingredients regardless of the container type?
-Yes, soda companies, including Coca-Cola, claim to use the same proportion of ingredients and the same recipe regardless of the package type.
What is the primary material used in glass bottles and how does it affect the taste?
-Glass bottles are made of basic glass material and contain no other chemical ingredients that could change the taste of the soda.
What material is typically used to line the inside of aluminum cans and does it affect the taste?
-Aluminum cans are lined on the inside with a polymer that can contain BPA (Bishphenol A). However, a retired chemist from the American Chemical Society states that this has little to no effect on the taste.
Why might some people perceive a metallic taste from canned soda?
-The metallic taste might come from the can itself, especially when the can is opened and the tongue comes into contact with the metal, which can leave a slight metallic residue.
What is PET and how does it relate to plastic soda bottles?
-PET, or Polyethylene terephthalate, is the material typically used in plastic soda bottles. While it contains chemicals, it is safe for consumption and has been tested to ensure minimal leeching into the liquid.
How does carbonation affect the taste of soda and can packaging influence carbonation levels?
-Carbonation can affect the taste of soda by creating a tingly sensation and carrying flavors into the nose. The packaging material can influence carbonation levels, with plastic bottles potentially allowing CO2 to leak out more slowly than glass bottles.
How does temperature affect the carbonation and taste of soda in different containers?
-If the container is warm, more CO2 will be released when the soda is opened, which can make the soda taste flat. Most bottles are designed to prevent CO2 from escaping quickly.
Can light exposure affect the flavor of soda, and how?
-Yes, light can cause chemical reactions that may change the flavor compounds in the soda. Containers without light protective layers are more susceptible to these changes.
How does the storage of soda in glass versus plastic affect its flavor profile and carbonation?
-Soda bottled in glass and stored away from light can maintain its flavor profile and carbonation levels much longer compared to soda in plastic, due to the tighter structure of glass that slows down the diffusion of CO2.
How can personal experience and expectations influence the perception of taste in soda?
-Experience can affect the way we taste by enhancing our sensory awareness and memory of the expected sensory experience. What we can taste is sometimes as much affected by what we expect as by what's actually there.

Outlines

00:00

🥤 Soda Container Impact on Taste

The paragraph discusses the varying opinions on soda containers and whether they affect the flavor of soda. Despite soda companies' claims of using the same ingredients regardless of container type, there are factors that could influence taste. Glass bottles are inert, while cans have an interior lining to prevent contamination. Although the lining's impact on taste is minimal, some people perceive a metallic taste. Plastic bottles are made with PET, which is safe for consumption. The FDA regulates contaminants to ensure safety, but humans can detect minute amounts that might affect taste. Carbonation, influenced by packaging, can also alter taste, with glass and metal containers being less permeable to CO2 loss than plastic. Finally, light can cause chemical reactions in soda, potentially changing flavor compounds.

05:00

🤔 The Role of Expectation in Taste Perception

This paragraph delves into the subjective experience of taste, suggesting that frequent consumption can heighten sensory awareness. It highlights the difficulty in separating the objective and subjective aspects of taste, as expectations can significantly influence what we perceive. The paragraph concludes by acknowledging that soda drinkers are unlikely to change their preferences based on these insights, indicating a strong personal connection to their choice of soda container.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡Soda containers

Soda containers refer to the different types of packaging used for soda drinks, such as cans, glass bottles, and plastic bottles. The video discusses how these containers might affect the flavor of soda. For instance, it mentions that people have strong opinions about which container type is superior, with some preferring cans for keeping the drink colder and others favoring glass bottles for taste.

💡Coca-Cola

Coca-Cola is a well-known brand of soda, and the video uses it as an example to illustrate that the company claims to use the same recipe for its soda regardless of the container type. This point is made to emphasize that while the ingredients might be the same, the container could still influence the perceived taste due to other factors.

💡Chemical ingredients

Chemical ingredients in the context of the video refer to the substances that make up the containers, such as the polymer lining in cans or the PET used in plastic bottles. The video discusses how these ingredients might minimally affect the taste of soda, with experts suggesting that the amount that could leach into the soda is too low to significantly alter the flavor.

💡BPA (Bisphenol A)

BPA, or Bisphenol A, is a chemical compound that was mentioned in relation to the lining of aluminum cans. The video suggests that while BPA is present, it has little effect on the taste of soda due to the protective nature of the lining. This term is important as it addresses consumer concerns about potential health impacts from chemicals in food and beverage containers.

💡Metallic taste

The term 'metallic taste' is used in the video to describe a perceived flavor that some people believe comes from drinking soda out of cans. The video suggests that this sensation might not be from the can itself but rather from the act of touching the metal can with the tongue, which can be especially noticeable for those who are sensitive to such tastes.

💡PET (Polyethylene terephthalate)

PET, or Polyethylene terephthalate, is a type of plastic used in the production of soda bottles. The video explains that while PET bottles contain chemicals that might be of concern if consumed in large quantities, they are safe for drinking and have been tested to ensure that minimal contaminants leach into the soda.

💡Carbonation

Carbonation is the process of dissolving carbon dioxide gas under pressure in a liquid, which creates the fizzy texture and sensation in soda. The video discusses how carbonation levels can affect the taste of soda and how different packaging materials can influence the rate at which carbon dioxide is retained or lost.

💡Contamination

Contamination in the context of the video refers to the potential for substances from the container to leach into the soda, which could alter its taste. The video mentions that while the FDA regulates the amount of contaminants allowed in beverages, humans can detect very small amounts of such substances, which could affect the taste for some individuals.

💡Flavor compounds

Flavor compounds are the chemical substances responsible for the taste and aroma of food and beverages, including soda. The video points out that light can cause chemical reactions that may change these compounds, thus affecting the flavor of the soda. This is particularly relevant when discussing how soda should be stored to maintain its taste.

💡Sensory awareness

Sensory awareness refers to the ability to perceive and interpret sensory information, such as taste and smell. The video suggests that frequent soda drinkers might have a heightened sensory awareness, allowing them to detect subtle differences in taste that others might not notice. This concept ties into the idea that taste can be influenced by both objective chemical properties and subjective experiences.

💡Subjective taste

Subjective taste implies that individual perceptions of flavor can vary greatly and are influenced by personal experiences and expectations. The video concludes by highlighting that what people taste is not only determined by the actual chemical composition of the soda but also by their prior experiences and what they anticipate the taste to be.

Highlights

People have strong opinions about soda containers, with preferences varying between cans, bottles, and glass.

Coca-Cola claims to use the same recipe for all packaging types, emphasizing that their soda is best enjoyed ice cold.

Glass bottles are chemically inert, which means they do not affect the taste of the soda.

Cans are lined with a polymer that protects the soda from the metal, though some people still detect a metallic taste.

The sensation of a metallic taste may come from brief contact between the tongue and the metal when opening the can.

Plastic bottles are made from PET, a material that is safe but may affect the taste over time as carbonation slowly leaks.

Carbonation in soda is detected using the same taste receptors that recognize sour foods.

The release of CO2 from the soda when opened can affect both the flavor and the sensation experienced by the drinker.

Glass bottles and cans have tightly packed structures, which makes them better at retaining carbonation than plastic bottles.

Plastic bottles are designed with multiple layers to prevent CO2 from escaping and oxygen from entering, preserving the soda's taste.

Light exposure can cause chemical reactions in soda, altering its flavor, which is why glass bottles offer better protection.

Storage conditions, such as keeping soda in a glass bottle away from light, can help maintain its flavor and carbonation over time.

Experienced soda drinkers, particularly those who frequently consume Diet Coke, may detect subtle differences in taste more easily.

Taste is influenced by both objective factors like chemical composition and subjective factors like personal experience and expectations.

Despite the science behind soda packaging and taste, consumer habits and preferences are unlikely to change.