Karl Marx & Conflict Theory: Crash Course Sociology #6

CrashCourse
17 Apr 201711:19

Summary

TLDRThis script explores Karl Marx's philosophical and scholarly contributions, focusing on his theories of history and society. It delves into Marx's concept of historical materialism, which views history as a series of modes of production shaped by class struggles. The video discusses the forces and relations of production, the development of capitalism, and the inherent contradictions that lead to crises and revolutions. It also touches on Antonio Gramsci's theory of hegemony and the broader impact of Marx's ideas on conflict theory in sociology.

Takeaways

  • 🧐 Karl Marx is recognized as a philosopher and scholar, not just for his political ideologies.
  • 🤔 Marx's central philosophical inquiry was about the nature of freedom and how it can be achieved.
  • 🏗️ Marx developed a theory of history based on the concept of labor and its organization, leading to societal change.
  • 🔄 He introduced the concept of historical materialism, focusing on the material conditions of life and their impact on society.
  • 🏭 Marx viewed the economy as the base of society, with politics, culture, and religion as the superstructure built upon it.
  • 🛠️ Modes of production, defined by forces and relations of production, represent stages in historical development.
  • 👷 The proletariat, or working class, are those without control over the means of production and are exploited under capitalism.
  • 💰 The bourgeoisie, or capitalists, own the means of production and benefit from the surplus value created by the proletariat's labor.
  • 📉 Capitalism is prone to crises of overproduction, where too much is produced relative to what people can afford.
  • ⚔️ Class struggle is a driving force in historical progress, with the proletariat seeking to change the relations of production.
  • 🌟 Marx's ideas have influenced conflict theories in sociology, including those focused on race, gender, and intersectionality.

Q & A

  • What was Karl Marx primarily concerned with in the 19th century?

    -Karl Marx was primarily concerned with the question of what it means to be free, which led him to develop a theory of history and the foundation for conflict theory in sociology.

  • How does Marx's view on human beings differ from other animals in terms of adapting to the natural world?

    -Marx believed that humans are poorly adapted to the natural world compared to other animals, and that our survival depends on changing the environment through cooperative labor to fit our needs.

  • What is the concept of 'historical materialism' as introduced by Marx and Engels?

    -Historical materialism is a perspective that focuses on the material conditions of life, including how production is organized and who has access to resources, and views historical development in terms of these economic conditions.

  • What are the two main components that define a mode of production according to Marx?

    -A mode of production is defined by a combination of forces of production, which include the technical and material aspects of the economy, and relations of production, which define how people organize themselves around labor.

  • How does Marx differentiate between the 'forces of production' and the 'relations of production'?

    -The forces of production refer to the technical, scientific, and material aspects of the economy, such as tools, resources, and technology. The relations of production refer to the social organization of labor, including how ownership and property are managed.

  • What are the two main classes that Marx identifies in the capitalist mode of production?

    -In capitalism, Marx identifies the working class (or proletariat), who do not own the means of production, and the capitalists (or bourgeoisie), who own and control the means of production and the products that come from them.

  • What is the source of surplus in capitalism according to Marx?

    -The source of surplus in capitalism is the difference between the value of the wage paid to the worker and the value of what they produce, which results in profit for the bourgeoisie.

  • What is the concept of 'crises of overproduction' in capitalism?

    -Crises of overproduction occur when the forces of production are so developed that more goods are produced than people can afford to buy, leading to economic collapse despite an abundance of goods.

  • How does Marx view the historical development of modes of production?

    -Marx views historical development as a series of advances in the forces of production that eventually stall due to the limitations created by the relations of production, leading to contradictions and crises that necessitate revolutionary change.

  • What is Antonio Gramsci's contribution to Marx's ideas with his theory of 'hegemony'?

    -Gramsci's theory of hegemony suggests that the ruling class maintains power not only through economic control but also through a dominant set of cultural and social ideas that shape the understanding of society and mask realities of exploitation.

  • How have Marx's ideas influenced the development of conflict theories in sociology?

    -Marx's ideas have given rise to various conflict theories in sociology, such as Race-Conflict Theory, Gender-Conflict Theory, and Intersectional Theory, which analyze power dynamics and struggles over resources in different social contexts.

Outlines

00:00

📚 Karl Marx: Philosopher of Freedom and Societal Change

This paragraph introduces Karl Marx as a philosopher and scholar whose work focused on the concept of freedom amidst the radical inequality and change of 19th century Europe. Marx developed a theory of history that became the foundation for conflict theory in sociology. He questioned how humans, being poorly adapted to nature, could achieve freedom through cooperative labor and societal organization. However, Marx also observed that as humans freed themselves from natural constraints, they became entangled in social constraints, leading to inequalities and class struggles. The paragraph sets the stage for understanding Marx's historical materialism and his views on labor and its organization as central to societal freedom.

05:01

🏭 Exploring Capitalism's Contradictions and Class Struggles

This section delves into Marx's analysis of industrial capitalism, highlighting the two main classes: the proletariat, who lack ownership of the means of production and must sell their labor to survive, and the bourgeoisie, who own the factories and control production. Marx argued that the proletariat's labor creates surplus value, from which the bourgeoisie profit, leading to exploitation and wage labor. The paragraph discusses the concept of crises of overproduction, where economies produce more than can be consumed, resulting in economic collapse despite abundance. Marx's historical materialism is further explained through the lens of modes of production, forces of production, and relations of production, which he saw as evolving and eventually conflicting, necessitating revolutionary change driven by class struggle.

10:03

🌟 Marx's Legacy: Hegemony and Conflict Theories in Sociology

The final paragraph summarizes Marx's contributions to understanding historical development through his lens of historical materialism, focusing on modes of production, class struggle, and revolution. It introduces Antonio Gramsci's concept of hegemony, which explains how the ruling class maintains power through dominant cultural ideas. The paragraph concludes by acknowledging the broader impact of Marx's work on conflict theory in sociology, which extends beyond economic struggles to include race, gender, and intersectionality, providing tools to analyze power dynamics and societal change.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡Karl Marx

Karl Marx is a foundational figure in sociology and political philosophy, known for his critical analysis of capitalism and his theories on historical materialism. In the video, Marx is presented as a philosopher and scholar whose work focused on understanding societal freedom and the dynamics of labor and production. His ideas laid the groundwork for conflict theory in sociology.

💡Historical Materialism

Historical materialism is a theory developed by Marx that posits that the economic system and control of material resources are the base upon which all other aspects of society, such as politics and culture, are built. The script explains how this perspective views historical development through the lens of modes of production and economic classes, rather than focusing on traditional narratives of wars and power struggles.

💡Modes of Production

Modes of production refer to the stages of historical development characterized by specific combinations of forces and relations of production. In the script, examples include primitive communism, feudalism, and capitalism. Each mode is defined by how production is organized and who benefits from it, which is central to Marx's analysis of societal change and class struggle.

💡Forces of Production

Forces of production encompass the technical, scientific, and material aspects of the economy, including tools, technology, and human labor. The script illustrates how these forces evolve over time, leading to increased productivity but also to contradictions within the economic system that can result in crises.

💡Relations of Production

Relations of production define the social organization of labor and the distribution of resources, including ownership and control over the means of production. The video explains how these relations can lead to exploitation, particularly in capitalism, where the bourgeoisie owns the means of production and the proletariat must sell their labor for survival.

💡Class Struggle

Class struggle is a central concept in Marx's theory, representing the conflict between social classes, particularly the bourgeoisie and the proletariat. The script describes how this struggle arises from the exploitation inherent in the capitalist mode of production and is the driving force behind societal change and revolution.

💡Proletariat

The proletariat, or working class, is defined by its lack of ownership or control over the means of production. In the script, Marx's analysis highlights how the proletariat is exploited under capitalism, selling their labor for wages that do not reflect the full value of what they produce.

💡Bourgeoisie

The bourgeoisie, or capitalist class, owns and controls the means of production. The video explains how this class benefits from the exploitation of the proletariat's labor, capturing surplus value as profit, which is a key source of class conflict.

💡Exploitation

Exploitation, in the context of Marx's theory, refers to the process by which the bourgeoisie extracts surplus value from the proletariat's labor. The script illustrates this through the concept of wage labor, where workers are paid less than the value of the goods they produce, resulting in profit for the bourgeoisie.

💡Crises of Overproduction

Crises of overproduction are economic downturns caused by the production of more goods than can be consumed, leading to economic collapse. The script uses this concept to demonstrate a fundamental contradiction within capitalism, where advanced forces of production can lead to surpluses that the majority of people cannot afford, causing economic instability.

💡Antonio Gramsci

Antonio Gramsci was an Italian theorist who expanded on Marx's ideas, particularly with his concept of hegemony. The script mentions Gramsci in the context of understanding how the ruling class maintains power through cultural dominance and the shaping of societal beliefs and values.

💡Conflict Theory

Conflict theory is a broad sociological paradigm that examines power dynamics and societal change through the lens of struggles over resources and power. The video explains how Marx's work on economic conflict inspired conflict theories that address various forms of social inequality, such as race and gender.

Highlights

Karl Marx is recognized as a philosopher and scholar, not just the figurehead of divisive political movements.

Marx's central question was 'What does it mean to be free?', leading to his theory of history and the foundation of conflict theory in sociology.

Marx believed that humans are not naturally free due to the constraints of our physical needs and the necessity to labor cooperatively to survive.

Labor is key to Marx's concept of freedom, as it allows us to change the world and gradually free ourselves from natural constraints.

Marx observed that as humans freed themselves from natural constraints, they created new social constraints, leading to inequalities.

Historical materialism, developed by Marx and Engels, focuses on how production is organized and the distribution of resources over time.

Marx viewed the economy as the foundation of society, with politics, culture, and religion as the superstructure built upon it.

Modes of production are defined by a combination of forces of production (tools, technology, human labor) and relations of production (how people organize around labor).

Marx identified the working class (proletariat) and the capitalists (bourgeoisie) as the main classes in industrial capitalism, with exploitation at the heart of their relationship.

Capitalism is characterized by wage labor, where the proletariat sells their labor for survival, leading to the creation of surplus value or profit.

Marx predicted crises of overproduction in capitalism, where production outpaces the population's ability to consume, leading to economic collapse.

Marx saw history as a progression of modes of production, each eventually leading to a conflict between the forces and relations of production.

Class conflict, according to Marx, is the driving force behind societal change, with the proletariat seeking to revolutionize the relations of production.

Antonio Gramsci expanded on Marx's ideas with the concept of hegemony, explaining how the ruling class maintains power through dominant cultural ideas.

Marx's ideas have influenced various conflict theories in sociology, including Race-Conflict Theory, Gender-Conflict Theory, and Intersectional Theory.

Marx's historical materialism provides a framework for understanding power, control, and freedom in modern society.

Transcripts

play00:00

You’ve probably heard of Karl Marx.

play00:02

He's remembered as the father of divisive political movements, and his name is sometimes still thrown around in American politics as a kind of slur.

play00:07

But I don't want to talk about that.

play00:09

I want to talk about Marx the philosopher. Marx the scholar.

play00:12

In the 19th century, a time defined by radical inequality and rapid technological and political change in Europe, Marx was concerned with one question:

play00:19

What does it mean to be free?

play00:21

Starting from this question, Marx developed an entire theory of history.

play00:24

And in doing so, he laid the foundation for the paradigm of conflict theory in sociology,

play00:29

ultimately pushing the discipline to look at questions of power, inequality, and how these things can drive societal change.

play00:35

[Theme Music]

play00:46

If Durkheim was concerned with social solidarity, with how society hangs together, Marx was concerned with freedom.

play00:52

The question that Marx asked was "how can people be free?"

play00:55

Because humans aren’t just naturally free.

play00:57

When you think about it, we're actually incredibly constrained.

play01:00

Our physical bodies have all kinds of needs we have to meet in order to survive, and they’re needs that we're not really adapted to meet.

play01:06

Like, if you take a hummingbird and put it in the middle of a forest somewhere, it'll just go on about its day, collecting nectar and living its life.

play01:12

But if you drop a person in the middle of the woods, they’ll probably starve.

play01:15

Compared to other animals, Marx thought, we're incredibly poorly adapted to the natural world.

play01:19

In fact, the only way for us to survive in nature is to change it, working together to remake it to fit our needs.

play01:25

This is labor, he said, and we must labor cooperatively in order to survive.

play01:29

As we labor, we change the world around us, and gradually free ourselves from our natural constraints.

play01:33

But what Marx saw was that just as we freed ourselves from these natural constraints,

play01:36

we entangled ourselves in new social constraints.

play01:39

Let's go to the Thought Bubble to explore this some more.

play01:41

Think about it like this.

play01:42

Ten thousand years ago, basically everybody spent all day trying to get food.

play01:46

In this "primitive communism," as Marx called it, people were strongly bound by natural constraints, but socially very equal.

play01:52

Now compare that to the Middle Ages when, under feudalism, you have an entire class of people, the nobility, who never spent any time worrying about where their next meal would come from.

play02:01

But you also have the peasantry, who still worked constantly, making food.

play02:05

In fact, they spent a lot of their time making food for the nobility.

play02:08

People were producing more than they needed to survive, but instead of that surplus being equally distributed,

play02:12

society was set up so that some people simply didn't need to labor at all, while others had to work harder.

play02:17

That's not a natural constraint anymore, that's a social one.

play02:20

Working together allowed us to transcend our natural constraints, Marx argued, but the way labor is organized leads to massive inequalities.

play02:27

Thanks Thought Bubble.

play02:28

So, central to the question of freedom for Marx is the question of labor, how it's organized

play02:32

and who it benefits, and how this organization changes over time.

play02:35

This focus on labor gave rise to the perspective created by Marx and his longtime collaborator Friedrich Engels – a perspective known as historical materialism.

play02:43

Historical materialism is historical because it looks at change over time, and it's materialism because it is concerned with these questions of material reality –

play02:51

that is, how production is organized, and who has things like food, or money, and who doesn't.

play02:55

Now, it's not that Marx didn't care about other things, like politics or religion.

play03:00

But he felt that they were secondary to the production and control of resources.

play03:03

And I don't mean secondary as in less important;

play03:05

I mean secondary because he thought that if you wanted to understand those things, you had to understand the material reality they were based on first.

play03:12

In this view, the economy – that is, the organization of labor and resources in a society

play03:16

– was the foundation, and everything else – politics, culture, religion, even families

play03:21

– was what Marx called the superstructure, which was built on top of material reality.

play03:25

So when Marx studied history, he didn't focus on wars and power struggles between states.

play03:29

Instead, he saw historical development in terms of modes of production and economic classes.

play03:34

Now, “modes of production” might sound like they’re about how stuff is made, but Marx understood them as stages of history.

play03:40

Primitive communism, feudalism, and capitalism are all modes of production.

play03:43

And modes of production are all defined by a combination of forces of production and relations of production.

play03:49

Forces of production are basically the technical, scientific, and material parts of the economy

play03:53

– tools, buildings, material resources, technology, and the human labor that makes them go.

play03:59

In modern capitalism, the forces of production include things like factories, oil, and the internal combustion engine.

play04:04

But they also include cultural or social technologies, like the idea of the assembly line and mass production.

play04:10

The relations of production, meanwhile, define how people organize themselves around labor.

play04:14

Do people work for wages, or does everyone produce and sell their own goods?

play04:18

How does ownership or property work?

play04:20

Is trade a central part of the economy?

play04:22

These are all questions about the relations of production.

play04:24

And these questions are important because, if you think in terms of social constraints and surplus,

play04:28

the relations of production specify how the surplus is taken from the people who produce it, and who gets to decide how the surplus is used.

play04:35

And, in capitalism, these relations aren’t all that clear-cut.

play04:38

For one thing, we don't have legally defined classes.

play04:41

In feudalism, being a lord or a peasant was a legal matter.

play04:43

If a peasant didn’t work, their lord could legally punish them.

play04:47

But under capitalism there aren't any legal rules about who labors and who doesn't.

play04:51

If you skip work you don’t get tossed in jail, you just get fired.

play04:54

But Marx was a historical materialist, so in his view, even in feudalism, classes weren’t really defined by laws,

play05:00

they were actually defined by their place in the relations of production.

play05:03

And when Marx looked at industrial capitalism taking shape around him, he saw two main classes:

play05:08

the working class (or proletariat) and the capitalists (or the bourgeoisie).

play05:11

The proletariat are defined by the fact that they don’t own or control the means of production

play05:15

– that is, the materials you need to use in order to labor and produce goods.

play05:19

One way of thinking about the means of production is as the inanimate part – the actual, physical stuff – that makes up the forces of production.

play05:25

So this includes everything from the land to stand on while you work,

play05:28

to the raw materials you need, like trees, and coal, and iron ore, to the tools and machines you use.

play05:33

To simplify things dramatically, the proletariat are defined by the fact that, while they work in the factories and use resources to make things, they don’t own the factories or the things they make.

play05:42

The bourgeoisie are defined by the fact that they do own the factories and the things that are made in them.

play05:46

They control the means of production and the products that come from them.

play05:49

It’s this difference in who controls the means of production, Marx said, that leads to exploitation in capitalism, in the form of wage labor.

play05:55

If the proletariat lack access to the means of production, he argued, then they only have one thing they can sell: their labor.

play06:02

And they must sell their labor. If they don't, they starve.

play06:04

Now you might argue that, hey, they're being paid, right?

play06:07

Well, Marx would counter that they’re only being paid enough to live on, if barely.

play06:10

However, Marx would also argue that they're being paid less than the worth of what they produce.

play06:14

And it is that difference – between the value of the wage and the value of what’s produced – which is the source of surplus in capitalism.

play06:21

You know this surplus as profit.

play06:22

And the bourgeoisie get to decide what to do with the profits.

play06:25

Because of this, Marx believed that the bourgeoisie will always be looking to make profits as large as possible, both by driving down wages and by driving up productivity.

play06:33

And this leads to one of the big problems with capitalism: crises.

play06:36

Specifically, crises of overproduction.

play06:38

Other modes of production had crises, too, but they were caused by not having enough.

play06:43

In capitalism, for the first time in history, there were crises of having too much.

play06:46

We reached a point where the forces of production were so developed that we could produce far more than we needed.

play06:51

But the vast majority of people couldn’t afford to buy any of it.

play06:54

And so we had crises where the economy collapsed, despite the fact that there was more than enough to go around.

play06:58

Crises of overproduction are an example of what Marx saw in every mode of production:

play07:02

the contradiction between the forces of production and the relations of production.

play07:06

Marx understood history as a series of advances in the forces of production –

play07:09

like, greater coordination among capitalists, more technological complexity, and more organizational innovation.

play07:15

But eventually, he said, those advances always stall, as the forces of production run up against the limits created by the relations of production.

play07:22

For example, in the early days of capitalism, the relations of production included things

play07:25

like private ownership of property, competition among capitalists, and wage labor.

play07:30

And these things allowed for explosive economic growth.

play07:33

But eventually, these very same things became limitations on the forces of production – stuff like factories, technology, and human labor.

play07:40

That’s because capitalists drove wages down in pursuit of profit, and they competed with each other, leading to a lack of coordination in the economy.

play07:46

So you wound up with a population that couldn’t afford to buy anything, while at the same time being offered way more goods than it would ever need.

play07:52

And, with the economy in shambles, there's no way for the forces to keep developing –

play07:56

there’s no money to invest in new factories or new technologies.

play07:59

So the relations of production that created economic growth became precisely the things that caused crises.

play08:04

Marx saw this as an impasse that all modes of production eventually meet.

play08:08

So how do you get a society to move past it?

play08:11

Marx said, the way forward was class conflict.

play08:13

History is a matter of struggling classes, he said, each aligned with either the forces or relations of production.

play08:18

The bourgeoisie are aligned with the relations of production, he said, because these relations are what allow them to extract surplus from the workers.

play08:25

So they're quite happy with the situation as it stands.

play08:27

But the proletariat want change.

play08:29

They want the further development of the forces of production – of which their labor makes up a large part – and they want a complete change in the relations of production.

play08:37

They want an end to exploitation and they want the surplus to benefit them.

play08:40

After all, it was their labor that created the surplus.

play08:42

In short, they want revolution.

play08:44

And so this is Marx's model of history: a series of modes of production, composed of forces and relations of production.

play08:50

These forces and relations develop together until they eventually come into conflict,

play08:54

leading to a revolution by the oppressed class and the institution of a totally new set of

play08:58

relations, where the workers benefit from the efforts of their labor.

play09:01

Plenty of theorists followed in Marx’s wake, taking his idea of historical materialism

play09:04

and expanding it to better deal with some of the areas that Marx had left out.

play09:08

Particularly interesting here is the work of the Italian theorist Antonio Gramsci, who wrote in the years preceding World War II.

play09:13

One of the big questions implicit in Marx’s theory is just how the bourgeoisie manages to stay in power so effectively.

play09:19

And Gramsci answered this with the theory of hegemony.

play09:21

He argued that the ruling class stays in power, in part, through hegemonic culture, a dominant set of ideas that are all-pervasive and taken for granted in a society.

play09:29

While they’re not necessarily right or wrong, these ideas shape everyone's understanding

play09:33

of the social world, blinding us to the realities of things like economic exploitation.

play09:37

But hegemonic ideas don’t need to be economic ones.

play09:40

They could just as easily be beliefs about gender, or race.

play09:42

And this points to possibly Marx’s biggest impact.

play09:45

While Marx’s model of history is specific to economic conflict, we can see in it the

play09:49

essence of the broader sociological paradigm of conflict theory.

play09:52

Conflict theory is the basic idea of looking at power dynamics and analyzing the ways in which struggles over power drive societal change,

play09:58

as all kinds of groups, not just workers and owners, fight for control over resources.

play10:02

Marx’s ideas gave rise to a host of conflict theories in sociology, including Race-Conflict Theory, Gender-Conflict Theory, and Intersectional Theory.

play10:10

These theories give us ways to understand power, control, and freedom in modern society, and we’re going to be looking at them over the next couple of weeks.

play10:16

But for today, you learned about Karl Marx,

play10:19

historical materialism and Marx’s basic perspective on history.

play10:21

You also learned about modes of production, their development, and how they fit into Marx’s

play10:25

overall theory of historical development, along with class struggle and revolution.

play10:28

And finally, we saw how Marx’s ideas gave rise to Gramsci’s idea of hegemony, and to conflict theories more generally.

play10:34

Crash Course Sociology is filmed in the Dr. Cheryl C. Kinney Studio in Missoula, MT, and it's made with the help of all these nice people.

play10:40

Our animation team is Thought Cafe, and Crash Course is made with Adobe Creative Cloud.

play10:44

If you'd like to keep Crash Course free for everyone, forever, you can support the series

play10:48

at Patreon, a crowdfunding platform that allows you to support the content you love.

play10:51

Speaking of Patreon, we'd like to thank all of our patrons in general, and we'd like to specifically thank our Headmaster of Learning David Cichowski.

play10:58

Thank you for your support.

Rate This

5.0 / 5 (0 votes)

Related Tags
Karl MarxPhilosophySociologyHistorical MaterialismClass StruggleCapitalismFeudalismModes of ProductionEconomic InequalityConflict Theory