India Calls Rapid Growth of E-commerce "Concerning" | Vantage with Palki Sharma

Summary

India's Commerce Minister raises concerns over the rapid growth of e-commerce, fearing social disruption and the impact on local businesses. He criticizes e-commerce giants like Amazon for predatory pricing, which could harm small retailers. With only 4.3% of Indians shopping online, the market is poised for growth, but the government is exploring ways to regulate it, including the creation of an open-source marketplace to foster fair competition and protect small businesses.

Takeaways

• 🛍️ The rapid growth of e-commerce in India is seen as a concern by the Commerce Minister, who fears it could lead to social disruption and a lack of pride in the market becoming part of the e-commerce network.
• 🍽️ The rise of cloud kitchens is highlighted as a potential health impact, suggesting that it could lead to a more sedentary lifestyle with people becoming 'couch potatoes'.
• 🏪 The minister raises concerns about the impact of e-commerce giants on local businesses, suggesting that they are disrupting the market and edging out small retailers.
• 📉 The Commerce Minister accuses Amazon of predatory pricing, pointing to the company's reported losses as evidence of their strategy to undercut the market and gain customers.
• 📊 E-commerce platforms in India are not allowed to sell directly but are instead marketplaces; however, the minister suggests that they engage in direct selling through shady networks.
• 💰 The minister presents data on Amazon's losses, implying that the company's business practices may be unsustainable and harmful to the Indian economy.
• 🌐 The e-commerce market in India is significant and projected to grow, with the potential to become the third-largest online market globally by 2030.
• 📈 Despite the growth, only a small percentage of the Indian population shops online compared to other countries, indicating there is still room for expansion.
• 🛑 The government's stance is not to halt e-commerce but to regulate it for fair pricing and organized growth.
• 🏢 The pandemic has accelerated the adoption of e-commerce in India, with many turning to online shopping out of necessity.
• 🤝 The government's attempt to create an open-source, nonprofit marketplace (ONC) to offer an alternative to major e-commerce platforms has had limited success, indicating the dominance of existing players.

Q & A

What is the primary concern expressed by India's Commerce Minister regarding the growth of e-commerce?

The Commerce Minister is concerned about the potential social disruption and negative impact on local businesses due to the massive growth of e-commerce, which could lead to a lack of social interaction and predatory pricing practices.

What does the term 'cloud kitchens' refer to in the context of the script?

Cloud kitchens refer to commercial kitchen spaces that are used by multiple food businesses to prepare meals for delivery, often without a physical dining area for customers.

How does the minister view the potential health impact of the increasing reliance on e-commerce for food and shopping?

The minister believes that the reliance on e-commerce for food and shopping could lead to a sedentary lifestyle, turning people into 'couch potatoes' who spend more time at home watching content and ordering online rather than engaging in physical activities.

What is the minister's concern about the impact of e-commerce giants on small retailers?

The minister is concerned that e-commerce giants are disrupting the market and edging out millions of small retailers, potentially leading to predatory pricing and a loss for the local economy.

What is predatory pricing and how is it related to the discussion in the script?

Predatory pricing is a strategy where companies intentionally sell products at a loss to drive out competition and attract new customers. The minister suggests that e-commerce platforms like Amazon might be using this strategy, as evidenced by their reported losses.

What is the current market share of Amazon and Flipkart in India's online market?

Flipkart holds 48% of India's online market, while Amazon accounts for 26%, indicating a duopoly that controls three-quarters of the market.

What is the projected value of India's e-commerce market by 2030?

The e-commerce market in India is projected to reach $325 billion by 2030, potentially making India the third-largest online market.

What percentage of India's population currently shops online?

Only 4.3% of India's population shops online, which is significantly lower compared to other countries like China and the UK.

What was the government's attempt to offer an alternative to e-commerce giants like Amazon and Swiggy?

The government set up an open-source nonprofit marketplace called ONDC (Open Network for Digital Commerce) to provide a transparent and cost-effective alternative without predatory pricing.

How does the script suggest addressing the concerns raised by the Commerce Minister about e-commerce in India?

The script suggests that more competition in the market and fair pricing regulations by the government could address the concerns, while also considering the adaptation of small retailers to the online shopping trend.

What is the significance of the 'One Tree' project mentioned in the script?

The 'One Tree' project is an initiative aimed at combating climate change by encouraging the planting of trees, symbolizing a collective effort to create a sustainable future for humanity and the planet.

Outlines

00:00

🛒 E-Commerce Concerns in India

India's Commerce Minister expresses concern over the rapid growth of e-commerce, fearing it could lead to social disruption and negatively impact local businesses. He criticizes the potential health effects of a sedentary lifestyle driven by online shopping and food delivery, leading to a lack of social interaction. The Minister also accuses e-commerce giants like Amazon of predatory pricing, suggesting their deep discounts and market dominance are not sustainable and harm small retailers. Despite e-commerce's current small market share in India, it's projected to grow significantly, raising questions about regulation and the future of traditional retail.

05:02

🌐 Alternatives to Big E-Commerce Platforms

The Indian government's attempt to provide an alternative to major e-commerce platforms like Amazon and Flipkart is discussed through the example of ONC, an open network for digital commerce. ONC aims to offer transparency and fair pricing, contrasting with the alleged predatory practices of established platforms. However, the adoption of ONC is significantly lower compared to its competitors, indicating a long road ahead for such initiatives. The paragraph also touches on the broader issue of market duopoly and the need for more competition to ensure a fair market. It raises concerns about the future of small retailers and the potential societal shift towards a more sedentary lifestyle due to the convenience of e-commerce.

Keywords

💡E-commerce

E-commerce refers to the buying and selling of goods and services online. In the video, India's Commerce Minister expresses concern about the rapid growth of e-commerce, highlighting its potential to disrupt traditional retail markets and reduce social interaction. The Minister argues that while e-commerce offers convenience, it may also lead to issues like predatory pricing and the decline of small retailers.

💡Cloud kitchens

Cloud kitchens are commercial facilities that allow restaurants to prepare food solely for delivery, without a dine-in option. The video mentions these as part of the broader impact of e-commerce on society, where the Minister is concerned that such trends contribute to people staying home more, leading to less physical activity and reduced social interaction.

💡Predatory pricing

Predatory pricing is a strategy where companies sell products at very low prices, often at a loss, to drive competitors out of the market. The Commerce Minister in the video accuses companies like Amazon of using this tactic in India, leading to significant losses for the company but gaining a larger customer base. This practice raises concerns about its impact on competition and small businesses.

💡Local businesses

Local businesses refer to small, often family-owned shops that serve communities in specific areas. The video highlights the threat that e-commerce giants pose to these businesses, as they struggle to compete with the low prices and convenience offered by online platforms. The potential decline of local businesses is a significant concern raised by the Commerce Minister.

💡Social interaction

Social interaction is the way people communicate and engage with each other in person. The video discusses how the rise of e-commerce, online content consumption, and cloud kitchens are reducing face-to-face interactions, as more people opt to stay home for shopping, dining, and entertainment. The Minister views this shift as a negative consequence of technological advancements.

💡Amazon

Amazon is a major global e-commerce company that operates a marketplace for a wide range of products. In the video, Amazon is specifically mentioned by the Commerce Minister, who criticizes the company's business practices in India, particularly accusing it of predatory pricing and raising concerns about its impact on the local economy and small retailers.

💡Open Network for Digital Commerce (ONDC)

The Open Network for Digital Commerce (ONDC) is a government-backed initiative in India aimed at creating an open, nonprofit e-commerce platform to offer an alternative to giants like Amazon and Flipkart. The video discusses ONDC as part of the government's effort to regulate e-commerce, promote fair pricing, and provide more competition in the market.

💡Couch potatoes

The term 'couch potatoes' is a colloquial expression used to describe people who spend a lot of time sitting on the couch, usually watching TV or using electronic devices, leading a sedentary lifestyle. In the video, the Commerce Minister uses this term to criticize the lifestyle changes brought about by e-commerce and online entertainment, which he believes are contributing to a lack of physical activity and social engagement.

💡Retail market

The retail market refers to the sector of the economy that involves the sale of goods and services directly to consumers. The video provides insights into the Indian retail market, noting that while e-commerce is growing rapidly, it still represents a small percentage of the total market. The Minister's concerns revolve around the potential future dominance of e-commerce and its implications for traditional retail.

💡Competition

Competition in the context of the video refers to the rivalry between businesses to attract customers and gain market share. The Commerce Minister advocates for increased competition in the e-commerce sector to prevent a duopoly, where two companies (Amazon and Flipkart) dominate the market. More competition, he argues, would lead to fairer pricing and better opportunities for smaller businesses.

Highlights

India's Commerce Minister expresses concern over the rapid growth of e-commerce, fearing potential social disruption.

E-commerce is accused of turning people into 'couch potatoes', impacting social interaction and local businesses.

Cloud kitchens are highlighted as a new trend, potentially leading to a sedentary lifestyle and reliance on home deliveries.

The Minister raises the issue of predatory pricing by e-commerce giants, such as Amazon, to gain market share.

Amazon's reported losses in India are scrutinized as a possible sign of predatory pricing strategies.

E-commerce platforms in India are not allowed to sell directly but are suspected of doing so through indirect means.

The Indian e-commerce market is valued at nearly $70 billion and is projected to reach $325 billion by 2030.

Only 4.3% of India's population shops online, compared to 25% in China and 23% in the UK.

The pandemic has accelerated the adoption of e-commerce in India as a primary shopping option.

The Indian government is seeking to regulate e-commerce to ensure fair pricing and protect small retailers.

ONC (Open Network for Digital Commerce) is introduced as a government initiative to provide an alternative to major e-commerce platforms.

The current e-commerce market in India is dominated by a duopoly, with Flipkart and Amazon controlling 74% of the market.

The Minister's concerns include the potential loss of millions of jobs in small neighborhood shops due to e-commerce dominance.

The need for more competition in the e-commerce market to prevent market manipulation and ensure fairness.

The government is urged to find solutions to support small retailers in adapting to the online shopping trend.

Firstpost's commitment to delivering unfiltered and unbiased news to its 5 million strong audience.

One Tree for Humanity, a news18 Network initiative emphasizing environmental responsibility.

Coverage of the T20 World Cup and its significance in the sports news landscape.

Transcripts

imagine you're looking to buy something

maybe a gadget or a kitchen utensil or a

piece of clothing what's the first thing

you would do probably go to an

e-commerce website your Amazon's or

Minas it's the default reaction for most

of us it tells you how common online

shopping is but India's Commerce

Minister says that's not necessarily a

good thing he's called it a matter of

concern just think about it are we going

to cause huge social

disruption with this massive growth of

e-commerce and I don't see it a matter

of Pride that half our Market could

possibly become a part of the e-commerce

Network 10 years from

now it's a matter of concern Cloud

kitchens what is the impact of these

Cloud kitchens very nice four or five

chefs will get a work there and four or

five delivery boys of course we'll end

up becoming a country of couch potatoes

watching OT and having food at home

every

day the minister basically raised two

problems number one the health impact he

says Ecommerce is turning us into couch

potatoes we're watching content on Ott

ordering food from home and even

shopping from our couch so the minister

asks where is the social interaction

what happened to going out for dinner or

physical shopping which brings us to

concern number two the impact on local

businesses push goel says e-commerce

Giants are disrupting the market they're

edging out millions of small retailers

and he specifically targeted Amazon

listen to this when Amazon says we're

going to invest a billion dollars in

India and we all celebrate we forget the

underlying story that that billion doar

is not coming in for any great service

or any great investment to support the

Indian economy they made a billion

dollars loss in their balance sheet that

year they have to fill in that loss if

you make 6,000 CR loss in one year does

that not smell of predatory pricing to

any of

you what did that loss come on they are

after all a e-commerce

platform some background first Global

e-commerce Giants cannot sell directly

in India they cannot stock or sell

anything they can only let others sell

on their platform basically they're a

Marketplace but the reality is quite

different these platforms do sell

directly using Shady networks have you

wondered how Amazon or flip cart are

able to give such steep discounts or why

products always seem cheaper online the

minister says it could be predatory

pricing and what is that well companies

purposely charge less for a product yes

they will incur a loss but they will

also add plenty of new customers so the

tradeoff is worth it or so they say the

Commerce Minister also came with numbers

he says Amazon reported 6,000 CR rupees

in losses that's $714 million us which

is a bit high for a Marketplace company

so the theory is that this loss is

because of predatory pricing of course

Amazon will deny all of this but it

gives us a chance to look at the

e-commerce Market in India it's worth

almost $70 billion already 770 billion

which is 7% of the total retail Market

by the year 2030 it is projected to

reach

$325 billion now if this projection

holds $325 billion India will become the

third largest online

market and what about the users how many

Indians actually shop

online just 4.3% of the population that

is all compare that to other countries

in China it is 25% in the UK it is 23%

in India only 4.3% of the population

shops online but the bottom line is

quite clear India's e-commerce industry

is still growing which is why The

Minister's comments are strange does the

government want to put the brakes on

e-commerce well not quite push

accepted that e-commerce is here to stay

but he wants it to be more organized he

wants the pricing to be

fair well that's actually up to the

government because consumers will always

prioritize two things one is low price

and second comfort right now e-commerce

offers both and the pandemic is also

responsible for this change most Indians

were locked down for more than a year so

they discovered e-commerce in fact it

became their only option in a lot of

cases to buy groceries to buy medicines

and to buy most essential Goods the

pandemic may be behind us but this

practice has stayed so the onus is now

on the government how can they regulate

e-commerce in

India well they did try we saw an

attempt in late 2021 the government set

up an open source nonprofit Marketplace

onc open network for digital Commerce

onc the idea was quite simple offer an

alternative to the likes of Amazon or

swiggi or

zato that was what they were trying to

do no hidden costs no predatory prices

everything was supposed to be

transparent and how is onc doing well

they get around 60,000 food orders per

day 60,000 per day swiggy and zomato get

2 million each

so there's a long way to go but

ultimately there's only one solution we

need more competition because right now

it is a duopoly Flipkart makes up 48% of

India's online Market Amazon makes up

26% that's two companies with three qus

of the market so it's easier for them to

manipulate it a more crowded Market

would certainly be fairer but even then

some of The Minister's concerns remain

laziness for sure but also the issue of

small retailers we're talking about

Millions of small neighborhood shops

entire families depend on them so if

e-commerce takes over what will these

people do will they adapt to the online

shopping Trend or will they be wiped

out we say it's good that the government

is asking the right questions but I'm

afraid the answers too must come from

[Applause]

[Music]

them across continents one powerful news

source

bringing you diverse perspectives on the

issues that

[Applause]

matter we go beyond the boundaries to

give you that little extra about every

sporting

[Music]

moment so thank you for making first

post 5 million strong we're counting on

your support and you can trust us to

bring you the news unfiltered and un

[Music]

banished climate change is on our

doorstep it's time for a revolution to

take

rout and it starts with 1.4 billion

Indians

it starts with one tree one tree for

Humanity one tree for Mother Earth one

tree for a

future project one tree a news 18

Network

[Music]

initiative on the T20 World Cup bang

move across West

new hello I'm Al coming to you from

South Africa today we have a

special start with an report on India

shifting nuclear for the first time

since

begin hello and welcome to First P

America I'm Eric ham coming to you live

from the nation's capital of Washington

DC e