It Begins… Army Troops Take Over NYC

Summary

The video script discusses the deployment of the National Guard to New York City subway stations in response to rising crime rates. Despite the increased security presence, critics argue that the measures are ineffective, as they do not address the root causes of the crime wave. Concerns are raised about the militarization of public transport, the potential infringement on civil liberties, and the temporary nature of the solution. The script also highlights the challenges faced by law enforcement in an environment with progressive justice policies and the need for a more comprehensive approach to public safety.

Takeaways

• 🏗️ The New York City subway system is experiencing a high crime rate, averaging about six felonies a day, prompting the deployment of the National Guard to subway stations for increased security.
• 🛡️ Governor Kathy Hochul is deploying the National Guard in addition to the thousand additional police officers Mayor Eric Adams had already deployed to the subways in February to enhance safety.
• 👀 There is a psychological impact on the public, with concerns about personal safety and the potential for stereotyping due to the increased security measures.
• 🚫 The New York Civil Liberties Union criticizes the heavy-handed approach, comparing it to stop-and-frisk practices and raising concerns about potential violations of civil liberties.
• 👮‍♂️ The deployment of the National Guard and additional police officers is seen as a temporary solution, with the understanding that they cannot be a permanent fixture in the city's subway system.
• 🔍 Critics argue that the increased security measures are not addressing the root causes of the crime wave in New York City, and thus may not lead to long-lasting change.
• 🚨 The presence of the military in civilian spaces like subway stations is unusual and raises questions about the balance between security and civil liberties.
• 🎯 The effectiveness of random bag checks is questioned, as they may not catch criminals who are already on the subway cars or those who wait until security is absent.
• 🕊️ Despite potential flaws, some subway riders report feeling safer with the increased security presence, which has led to a 12% reduction in overall subway crime.
• 📉 The temporary nature of the security surge is a concern, as it may not provide a sustainable solution to the ongoing crime issues in the subway system.
• 📈 The governor's plan is not guaranteed to be a long-term solution, but there is a possibility of extending it using the state's surplus funds.

Q & A

What measures is Governor Hok taking to address safety concerns in the subway system?

Governor Hok is deploying the National Guard to city subway stations to enhance safety for riders, in addition to the thousand additional police officers Mayor Eric Adams had previously deployed.

How frequently are felonies occurring in the subway system according to the script?

The subway system is averaging about six felonies every day.

What is the psychological impact of the current situation on people using the subway?

People are worried they could be the next victims of crime, which is causing a psychological impact of fear and insecurity.

What concerns does the New York Civil Liberties Union have about the deployment of the National Guard in subway stations?

The New York Civil Liberties Union is concerned that the heavy-handed approach is akin to stop-and-frisk practices and could lead to stereotyping certain people.

What is the main argument against the effectiveness of random bag checks in subway stations?

Critics argue that random bag checks are not effective because criminals can evade them by waiting or using unguarded stations, and most crimes happen inside the trains or on platforms, not at entry points.

How has the increase in security presence affected the public's perception of safety?

The increased security presence, including bag checks and the presence of the National Guard, has made some riders feel safer, although others are skeptical about its long-term effectiveness.

What is the criticism regarding the temporary nature of the security measures?

Observers argue that the temporary nature of the security measures, including the deployment of troops and additional police, will not bring about lasting change because criminals are aware that this is not a permanent solution.

What are the concerns about the militarization of the subway system?

Concerns include the potential infringement on civil liberties and privacy, the inappropriateness of using the military for domestic law enforcement, and the focus on security theater rather than addressing the root causes of crime.

How do some people feel about the random bag checks conducted by the National Guard?

Some people are okay with the random bag checks as they believe it is for security reasons and makes them feel safer, while others are worried about the potential for a more draconian system emerging if the current measures are not effective.

What is the criticism regarding the justice system in New York City in relation to the crime wave?

Critics argue that New York City's progressive justice system, which includes reforms to the bail system and lenient pre-trial sentencing, contributes to the crime wave by not holding criminals accountable and allowing them to be released without bail.

What is the role of the National Guard in the subway system, and why is it controversial?

The National Guard is conducting random bag checks at subway stations. This is controversial because the military is not designed for domestic law enforcement, and there are concerns about the effectiveness of this approach and the potential infringement on constitutional rights.