SUNGGUH MEMALUKAN USTADZ NURUDIN PAMER KITAB ISINYA KEDUSTAAN & TUDUHAN KEJI TERHADAP IBNU TAIMIYAH

Summary

In this video, the speaker critically examines the book *Al-Kasyif As-Saghir* by Said Faudah, which aims to challenge the beliefs of Sheikhul Islam Ibn Taymiyyah. The speaker highlights the inaccuracies and false accusations in the book and urges Ustaz Nuruddin to read the rebuttals, particularly *Fathul Aliil Kabir*, before presenting the book to the public. Emphasizing intellectual honesty, the speaker encourages readers to engage directly with Ibn Taymiyyah’s works, free from bias and external influence, to form a fair understanding of his teachings.

Takeaways

• 😀 The speaker begins with a greeting and introduction, emphasizing the importance of discussing a controversial book, *Al-Kasyif al-Saghir*, by Said Faudah.
• 😀 The speaker criticizes the book for containing falsehoods and accusations against Sheikhul Islam Ibn Taymiyyah, claiming that the book's content is filled with lies and unjust criticism.
• 😀 The speaker points out that Ustaz Nuruddin is showcasing *Al-Kasyif al-Saghir* despite its controversial nature, and the speaker suggests that Ustaz should have read the rebuttals to this book before promoting it.
• 😀 A rebuttal to *Al-Kasyif al-Saghir* called *Fathul Ali al-Kabir* exists, which counters the arguments in Faudah's book, and the speaker intends to review it as part of the discussion.
• 😀 The speaker highlights that *Fathul Ali al-Kabir* was written by Sheikh Ramadan bin Abdul Karim Almri and praises the academic approach of this rebuttal.
• 😀 The speaker encourages a fair evaluation of Ibn Taymiyyah's writings, urging people to read his works directly, without any biases or preconceived notions.
• 😀 The speaker suggests that many critics of Ibn Taymiyyah's ideas have not read his works but instead have based their opinions on hearsay or other people's biased views.
• 😀 The speaker laments that people often criticize Ibn Taymiyyah without making an effort to understand his actual teachings, relying instead on rumors or unfounded opinions.
• 😀 The speaker urges a critical, fair, and unbiased approach to evaluating religious texts and scholars, particularly those who are often criticized.
• 😀 The speaker concludes by expressing concern that the book *Al-Kasyif al-Saghir* is full of hostile language and misleading accusations, and advises Ustaz Nuruddin to read the rebuttals before publicly endorsing such works.

Q & A

What is the main topic discussed in the video?

The main topic of the video is a critique of a book titled 'Alkasyif Assagir' by Said Faudah, which attempts to criticize the beliefs of Sheikhul Islam Ibn Taimiyah. The video presents an argument that the book contains false accusations and misleading information about Ibn Taimiyah's teachings.

Who is the author of the book 'Alkasyif Assagir' and what is its purpose?

The author of 'Alkasyif Assagir' is Said Faudah. The book is intended to criticize and challenge the beliefs and doctrines of Sheikhul Islam Ibn Taimiyah, with the goal of exposing what Faudah perceives as deviations in Ibn Taimiyah’s theological views.

How does the speaker in the video describe Said Faudah's book?

The speaker describes Said Faudah's book as being full of slander, false accusations, and misleading arguments. The speaker criticizes the book for its unfair and biased portrayal of Ibn Taimiyah’s beliefs, suggesting that it is driven by personal animosity and lack of academic integrity.

What is the book 'Fathul Aliil Kabir' and how does it relate to 'Alkasyif Assagir'?

'Fathul Aliil Kabir' is a book that serves as a rebuttal to 'Alkasyif Assagir'. It is authored by a prominent scholar and provides a critique of Faudah’s claims. The speaker in the video recommends reading 'Fathul Aliil Kabir' to gain a more accurate understanding of Ibn Taimiyah’s beliefs and to counter the arguments presented in 'Alkasyif Assagir'.

What is the speaker’s critique of Ustaz Nuruddin in the video?

The speaker criticizes Ustaz Nuruddin for promoting and showcasing 'Alkasyif Assagir' without first examining the rebuttals or criticisms of the book. The speaker believes that Ustaz Nuruddin should have been more thorough in his academic approach and familiarized himself with the counterarguments before presenting Faudah’s book.

What does the speaker suggest to people who criticize Ibn Taimiyah’s beliefs?

The speaker suggests that those who criticize Ibn Taimiyah’s beliefs should read his works directly, without being influenced by preconceived notions or the opinions of others. The goal is for readers to approach Ibn Taimiyah’s writings with an open mind and make their own informed judgments based on the content, rather than relying on hearsay.

Why does the speaker emphasize the importance of reading Ibn Taimiyah’s works directly?

The speaker emphasizes the importance of reading Ibn Taimiyah’s works directly to avoid being misled by biased interpretations or false claims. By reading his original writings, individuals can form their own opinions and ensure a more accurate understanding of his teachings, free from external biases or doctrinal influence.

What is the underlying criticism of the people who oppose Ibn Taimiyah’s teachings?

The underlying criticism is that many people who oppose Ibn Taimiyah’s teachings do so without thoroughly reading his works. Instead, they base their opinions on the criticisms of others, often without understanding the full context of his ideas. The speaker laments this approach as misguided and urges a more thoughtful and independent examination of Ibn Taimiyah’s writings.

How does the speaker characterize the writing style of Said Faudah in 'Alkasyif Assagir'?

The speaker characterizes Said Faudah’s writing style in 'Alkasyif Assagir' as harsh, disrespectful, and filled with personal attacks. The language is described as inappropriate and the tone is considered aggressive and filled with animosity, rather than constructive criticism.

What does the speaker recommend to those who have negative views of Ibn Taimiyah’s beliefs?

The speaker recommends that individuals who hold negative views of Ibn Taimiyah’s beliefs should read his works carefully and critically, with an open mind, and without any preconceived biases. The goal is to understand Ibn Taimiyah’s true teachings and to evaluate his ideas fairly, based on the evidence provided in his own writings.