لماذا رفض الفريق سعد الدين الشاذلي اتفاقية السلام مع إسرائيل؟.. يجيب أحمد منصور في شاهد على العصر

Summary

The video script is a detailed account of the speaker's military and political experiences, including his time in prison for allegedly leaking military secrets. It touches on his views on peace agreements, the importance of democracy, and his belief in destiny. The speaker reflects on his life's challenges, his commitment to truth and justice, and expresses hope for the Arab and Muslim world's victory over Israel, citing divine promise. He also emphasizes the importance of reading the Quran and shares his contentment with his life's journey.

Takeaways

• 📜 The speaker spent a year and a half in a military prison accused of espionage and revealing military secrets.
• 🗣️ There is a detailed account of the disagreements and conflicts between the speaker and Ahmed Ismail during the period leading up to December 12th, highlighting a tense relationship within the military leadership.
• 🔄 The speaker emphasizes the rapid passage of time during their imprisonment and their extensive reading of the Quran, from which they gained significant insights.
• 💡 A pivotal moment is described on December 13, 1973, when President Sadat made a decision that led to the speaker's potential transfer to the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, which the speaker contemplates rejecting.
• 🤔 The speaker reflects on their professional military character, even in personal life situations, and their approach to making decisions based on various possible outcomes.
• 🏆 The speaker discusses the concept of honor and dignity in the military and the importance of maintaining a stance against peace agreements they perceive as detrimental to national interests.
• 📖 The speaker's books and public speeches after their conflict with the president are mentioned, accused of revealing military secrets, which the speaker disputes.
• 🌐 The speaker talks about the broader implications of their actions, touching on the relationship between democracy, state secrets, and the public's right to know.
• 🕊️ Despite past disagreements, the speaker expresses a hopeful vision for the future of the Arab and Muslim world, believing in the ultimate victory over Israel as divinely promised.
• 📝 The speaker's resignation from the military is mentioned, highlighting their refusal to accept a position that they believe is not in line with their principles.
• 👴 The speaker shares their contentment with life, having made decisions based on what they believed to be right, and expresses faith in destiny and divine justice.

Q & A

What was the main reason for the speaker's imprisonment?

The speaker was imprisoned for a year and a half on charges of revealing military secrets and espionage.

How did the speaker spend their time during the last period of their testimony?

The speaker spent their time reading the Quran and benefiting greatly from it during the last period of their testimony.

What significant event is mentioned as occurring on December 13, 1973?

The significant event mentioned is the decision of President Sadat to dismiss the head of the armed forces.

What was the speaker's opinion on the decision to open the way to the Third Army on October 25?

The speaker objected to the decision, stating that it would lead to the destruction of the Fourth Armored Division and was not a strategic move.

What was the speaker's role during the period leading up to December 12?

The speaker was involved in a continuous conflict with Ahmed Ismail over leadership decisions, including the operation to open the way to the Third Army.

Why did the speaker refuse the presidential order to move the Fourth Armored Division?

The speaker refused the order due to the fear that it would lead to the division's destruction and was not a strategically sound decision.

What was the speaker's reaction to the news about the Third Army being surrounded?

The speaker mentioned that there were errors in the news reporting, which led to widespread misinformation about the situation of the Third Army.

What was the speaker's response to being offered a position in the Ministry of Foreign Affairs?

The speaker refused the offer, stating that they would not accept a position that was based on an evaluation that they did not agree with.

What did the speaker do after refusing the position in the Ministry of Foreign Affairs?

The speaker submitted their resignation from the armed forces, stating their disagreement with the evaluation and the reasons for their refusal.

What is the speaker's view on the relationship between the government and the country?

The speaker believes that the government is changeable, while the country is constant, and the interests of the country should always come first.

What was the speaker's stance on the peace agreements?

The speaker was opposed to the peace agreements, believing that they did not truly bring peace and that Egypt's sovereignty was compromised.