3 Lessons From Confucius | The Analects
Summary
TLDRThis video explores key lessons from Confucius's Analects, emphasizing the importance of engaging with the text rather than simply reading it. The host discusses three main insights: the Golden Rule, the significance of honesty, and the balance between self-improvement and societal contribution. Each idea is analyzed through modern examples and thoughtful questions, encouraging viewers to reflect on how these ancient teachings can be applied to their own lives. The video invites audience participation to further discuss and play with these concepts.
Takeaways
- 📚 The video discusses the complexity of the 'Analects', emphasizing that it is not a text to be read passively but actively engaged with to ponder its ambiguous and sometimes contradictory ideas.
- 👤 The concept of the 'gentleman' is highlighted as a character type that Confucius holds in high regard, suggesting that modern interpretations can be gender-neutral.
- 🔄 The 'Golden Rule' is presented as a central theme in the 'Analects', encouraging viewers to consider its application in their lives and its potential exceptions.
- 🤔 The video invites viewers to reflect on the practicality of the 'Golden Rule', questioning how it might apply to individuals with unconventional preferences.
- 🗣️ Honesty and trustworthiness are underscored as essential virtues, with the video exploring their importance and the potential conflicts that may arise from strict adherence.
- 🤥 A discussion on the limits of honesty is initiated, using Confucius's teachings to consider whether deception can sometimes be justified, particularly in familial contexts.
- 💔 The impact of dishonesty on trust and forgiveness is examined, suggesting that even small lies can significantly damage relationships.
- 🤔 The video challenges viewers to consider the balance between working on oneself versus working on society, and how these two aspects might be interconnected.
- 🏆 The final insight encourages individuals to focus on their own qualifications and worthiness of appreciation rather than worrying about their position in society.
- 💭 The video concludes by encouraging viewers to engage with the text, discuss the ideas presented, and consider making a part two if there is enough interest.
Q & A
What is the main challenge in understanding the Analects according to the video?
-The main challenge is that the Analects are often mysterious, ambiguous, and sometimes contradictory, which can frustrate those looking for clear and neatly packed logic.
How does Robert Andre Lefleur suggest the Analects should be approached?
-Robert Andre Lefleur suggests that the Analects should be engaged with rather than just dryly read. The ambiguity in the passages is meant to be pondered, discussed, and even played with.
What is the significance of the golden rule in Confucian thought as mentioned in the video?
-The golden rule in Confucian thought, which says 'Do not impose on others what you yourself do not desire,' is significant because it serves as a guide to conduct throughout one's life. It is a principle that appears across different cultures and encourages empathy and moral consideration.
What potential issue with the golden rule does the video highlight?
-The video highlights that the golden rule may be problematic when people have different desires. For example, if someone enjoys a harmful activity, applying the golden rule could lead to inappropriate actions, like a masochist imposing their preferences on others.
Why does the video discuss the concept of honesty and trustworthiness in relation to Confucius?
-The video discusses honesty and trustworthiness because Confucius emphasizes these qualities as essential for personal integrity and effective social interaction. Trustworthiness in one's word is seen as crucial for gaining respect and authority, even in challenging situations.
How does the video address the complexity of honesty in Confucian thought?
-The video addresses the complexity by noting that while honesty is important, there are situations where it might conflict with other values, such as family loyalty. For example, Confucius suggests that an upright son would not report his father's wrongdoing, which raises questions about when deception might be justified.
What is the video’s perspective on balancing societal expectations with personal development?
-The video suggests that instead of worrying about societal recognition, individuals should focus on developing their own qualifications and becoming worthy of appreciation. It emphasizes that self-improvement can lead to positive contributions to society.
How does the video relate the concept of virtue to societal participation?
-The video relates virtue to societal participation by suggesting that gaining society's appreciation is often a result of virtuous actions. It implies that focusing on personal virtues can help improve society, and that individuals should work on themselves as a way to contribute positively to the broader community.
What example does the video provide to illustrate the potential conflict between honesty and other values?
-The video provides the example of an axe murderer asking where a family member is hiding. This situation raises the question of whether it is justified to lie to protect loved ones, illustrating the potential conflict between honesty and the value of preserving life.
What does the video suggest about the relationship between personal actions and societal change?
-The video suggests that personal actions, such as working on one's own virtues, can influence societal change. It raises the question of whether focusing on self-improvement is distinct from or intertwined with engaging in societal affairs, and whether personal development can lead to broader societal benefits.
Outlines
🤔 Understanding the Ambiguity of the Analects
The speaker discusses the complex nature of Confucius's *Analects*, describing it as ambiguous, contradictory, and frustrating for those seeking clear logic. However, this complexity is seen as an opportunity for engagement rather than a flaw. The speaker, inspired by lectures from Robert Andre LaFleur, encourages readers to engage with the text through discussion and experimentation. The video will explore three lessons from the *Analects* with this playful and reflective approach.
💡 Insight 1: The Golden Rule in the Analects
The speaker introduces the Golden Rule, a principle found across cultures, as it appears in the *Analects*. Confucius suggests that one should not impose on others what they themselves do not desire. The speaker shares a personal story to illustrate the rule's effectiveness and considers its limitations, such as how it might apply to someone with unconventional desires. The discussion invites viewers to think critically about the rule and how it might be adapted or harmonized with exceptions.
🛑 Insight 2: The Importance of Trustworthiness and Honesty
This section explores Confucius's emphasis on honesty and trustworthiness, illustrated by a passage about how being truthful can lead to success even in foreign lands. The speaker reflects on the value of honesty, comparing it to the story of 'The Boy Who Cried Wolf' and real-life situations where dishonesty can damage trust. The speaker also questions whether lying is ever justified, especially when it comes to protecting loved ones, and how dishonesty might hinder redemption and forgiveness.
🎯 Insight 3: Balancing Personal Virtue with Social Responsibility
The final insight discusses the balance between personal development and social responsibility, using a Confucius quote that encourages individuals to focus on their qualifications rather than seeking external validation. The speaker interprets this as a call to contribute positively to society by working on oneself. The distinction between personal growth and social engagement is examined, with the speaker questioning whether these two aspects are as separate as they might seem, inviting viewers to reflect on their own views.
🎬 Conclusion and Invitation to Engage
The video concludes by encouraging viewers to engage with the *Analects* and the ideas presented, emphasizing the value of discussion and exploration. The speaker hints at the possibility of a follow-up video and urges viewers to like, subscribe, and comment their thoughts, reinforcing the interactive nature of the content.
Mindmap
Keywords
💡Analects
💡Ambiguity
💡Gentleman
💡Golden Rule
💡Shu
💡Honesty
💡Conscientious
💡Trust
💡Appreciation
💡Virtue
Highlights
The Analects of Confucius is described as a complex and ambiguous text that requires active engagement rather than passive reading.
Robert Andre Lefleur's lectures suggest that the ambiguity in the Analects is intentional, encouraging readers to ponder and discuss its ideas.
The video aims to explore three key lessons from the Analects, inviting viewers to engage with the ideas and share their thoughts.
Confucius emphasizes the importance of the 'gentleman' or 'gentle person' as a character worthy of emulation in society.
The Golden Rule, found in various cultures, is presented in the Analects as a guiding principle for conduct: 'Do not impose on others what you yourself do not desire.'
The video discusses the practical application of the Golden Rule in personal life, including a personal anecdote about a party situation.
The video raises questions about the exceptions to the Golden Rule, such as the preferences of a masochist, and invites viewers to consider modifications to the rule.
Confucius's teachings on honesty and trustworthiness are highlighted, with the story of the boy who cried wolf used as an example.
The video explores the complexities of honesty, including the potential conflict between truthfulness and family loyalty.
Confucius's view on lying to protect family is contrasted with the importance of trust in relationships and the difficulty of forgiveness after dishonesty.
The final insight from the Analects discussed in the video is about personal development and societal appreciation, urging individuals to focus on their own qualifications.
The video suggests that working on oneself and contributing positively to society may be more interconnected than commonly thought.
The video encourages viewers to engage with the text of the Analects, ponder its ideas, and share their interpretations and discussions in the comments.
The video concludes by inviting viewers to like, subscribe, and hit the bell for more content, hinting at a possible part two if there is enough interest.
Transcripts
the analytics is complicated as anyone
who's read it will try to tell you it's
mysterious ambiguous sometimes
contradictory and it will surely
frustrate those who are looking for
neatly packed clear logic but perhaps
this isn't a negative in preparation for
this video i also watched a couple
lectures on the analects by robert andre
lefleur and it seemed like he was trying
to convey that the analects is a text
that isn't meant to be dryly red but
rather something to be engaged with the
ambiguity you get from these passages
are meant to be pondered discussed
experimented and played with for a lack
of a better word that's why we're only
going over three lessons from the
analects in this video because we're
going to play around with each of these
ideas and i hope you join me as well i'm
using the dc lao translation but you
could easily find a copy online
hopefully there'll be a lot of comments
below playing around with these ideas
with me and without further ado let's
get into it
hello and welcome to philosophy tunes
and guys are you ready to become
gentlemen you see throughout the text
confucius makes references to a type of
character that he holds in high regard
and that is the gentleman obviously in
today's world we could be gender neutral
about it wait is there even a word like
gentle woman i don't know sounds like
some country club sounding word but so
does gentlemen too i guess but yeah
we're going to be looking over for
insights from confucius's analects that
we can apply to our lives and attempt to
become gentlemen so let's start off with
insight number one
[Music]
wait wait you guys hear that oh man it
sounds like the infamous golden rule is
making an appearance here for those who
are out of the loop maybe still messing
around with the silver rule the golden
rule can be found across different
cultures and basically says that you
should treat others the way you want to
be treated here it is appearing in the
analytes itself zurichkung asked is
there a single word which can be a guide
to conduct throughout one's life the
master said it is perhaps the word shu
do not impose on others what you
yourself do not desire now like i
mentioned in the intro we're actually
gonna play around with this idea a bit
and think about it i've personally used
this method of thinking in my own life
and it's been pretty effective if i'm
ever in a situation to gain something i
ask what the negative consequences are
and if they affect someone i consider if
i'd really want that done to me so i was
at this party once right and this girl
who had a boyfriend was trying to flirt
with me and he was legit in the other
room it's just you know what not
important the point is that i'm thinking
yo i'd be pretty pissed if i was in the
dude's position so i ended up rejecting
her and me and her man started playing
mario kart instead now what would the
world look like if we all just took a
step back when we find ourselves in
those situations and ask ourselves would
i want this imposed on me as well well
there is a problem here people differ as
to what they want done to them like what
if we have a masochist who likes getting
beaten up we really just going to be ok
with him going into a retirement home
and throwing fists just because he'd
want it done to him how would the golden
rule work with someone like that i mean
overall i'm a big fan of the golden rule
it's clear and easy to implement but
there are these exceptions that stick
out like a sore thumb how significant
are these exceptions to your thoughts on
the golden rule is there a way to maybe
harmonize those exceptions into the
golden rule maybe you'd like to modify
the rule slightly to be more inclusive
again let me know your thoughts in the
comments below i'm sure we'll encounter
the golden rule in further videos so for
right now let's look at another insight
[Music]
now i know what you're thinking wow is
this really some profound wisdom here
tell the truth yo i remember when my
granny read me about the boy who cried
wolf i don't need confucius to tell me
what i already know well there might be
more to it as always let's start by
looking at the text if in word you are
conscientious and trustworthy and indeed
single-minded and reverent then even in
the lands of the barbarians you will go
forward without obstruction so there are
many passages in the text emphasizing
honesty and being trustworthy but
although it's clear that confucius wants
us to be trustworthy it's sometimes
difficult to find a clear and simple why
to all this well in our own lives we
know the value of honesty through the
boy who cried wolf's story being
trustworthy in your word is gonna give
your word more weight and power i knew
this guy that would tell outrageous
stories where he's involved in all these
crazy uncharted like life-threatening
adventures and at a certain point it's
like dude you're either the most
interesting person in the world or
you're just bullshitting and after that
realization his stories although pretty
extravagant just fell flat and
disappointing contrast that with a true
story which may not be as dramatic but
nonetheless holds power simply in the
fact that it's true there's a lot of
these story time animator youtubers and
one guy i'm not gonna name names here
revealed that his stories were works of
fiction and while they're interesting to
listen to the crazy things that happened
just come across as cringy rather than
wow i can't believe that actually
happened now coming back to focus here
is it always right to tell the truth
though confucius tells one story of a
meeting where basically he says that an
upright son would not report his father
if he stole a goat i mean it's not lying
per se but it's definitely in the realm
of deception to cover for your dad and
not turn him in does this mean that
family concerns are more important than
being trustworthy i think about that
famous immanuel kant example where the
axe murderer comes to your house and
asks where your family is i mean i would
feel inclined to lie and save their
lives i don't know about you guys so
what do you think is lying justified if
it's in the service of your family what
about friends what about strangers maybe
the scale of the lie matters another
note on honesty is that it gets in the
way of redemption and forgiveness now me
i try to be a forgiving person i think
people are dynamic and change and second
chances only conforms to that but trust
is a delicate thing a small little lie
can take root in your mind and totally
infect the way you may or may not trust
a person it's like cheating where some
people are willing to forgive their
partner who cheats on them but that
trust that was there pre-cheating is
gone and can probably never come back
what do you think does dishonesty get in
the way of forgiveness and second
chances or can it be brushed aside and
with that we move to the last insight
for this video
[Music]
okay wait wait wait now i know some
hardcore confucian scholars are gonna
get pissed at me for that little title
and while i agree that the analytics
talks a lot about society and social
relations there are passages i see that
talk about how we as individuals fit
into those relationships here just
listen to the quote first and tell me
what you think the master said do not
worry because you have no official
position worry about your qualifications
do not worry because no one appreciates
your abilities seek to be worthy of
appreciation so look yes confucius is
undoubtedly concerned with society
undeniably but you're reading this book
as an individual unless you've got some
weird hive mind thing going on and as an
individual you do participate in society
the question then is in what way can
society benefit by your inclusion well
you could take the position of just
criticizing society being pissed at
everyone else for not appreciating your
abilities as the quote says or you could
see society's appreciation as a goal and
work towards it and usually gaining
society's appreciation is a result of
doing a good deed i mean i haven't
really been congratulated for eating ice
cream today and why should i eating ice
cream isn't some nice generous act heck
it isn't even some challenge to be
overcome unless you're eating this junk
it's haagen-dazs all the way in this
household it sounds kind of stoic in a
way you concern yourself with society
due to virtue but you turn your
attention towards yourself and what you
can control in your life to help that
society it's hard to think of a
counterpoint for this maybe some people
can disagree with the distinction being
made between working on society and
working on yourself maybe the two are
more related than we think i mean maybe
getting involved in worldly affairs is
gonna change you as a person in a good
way is this distinction between working
on yourself and working on society
really so strong comment below your
thoughts and with that we reached the
end of the video again highly highly
recommend you play with the text as
mentioned earlier by commenting below
and starting some discussion and we only
went over three insights there's a lot
more goodies in this book so let me know
if you enjoyed this video and i might
make a part two if you did enjoy it then
like subscribe and hit the bell and with
that i wish you all a beautiful rest of
your day
[Music]
you
関連動画をさらに表示
Author's Purpose, Tone, and Mood | English Reading | Teacher Beth Class TV
Chanakya Neeti for 21st Century | Chanakya's 3 modern lessons for YOUTH | Abhi and Niyu
Plato's Crito: Socrates' 3 Rules for Ethical Thinking
Lost teachings of Jesus that was kept hidden by the church.
Virtue Ethics
The 4 Powerful 'P's
5.0 / 5 (0 votes)