Russia is Running Out of People
Summary
TLDRThe script discusses Russia's demographic crisis, focusing on Chukotka's unlikely status as a beacon of hope with a rising number of large families amidst a national population decline. It highlights the country's shrinking cities, low birth rates, and high mortality rates, particularly due to alcohol consumption. The script also contrasts Russia's situation with other countries facing similar demographic challenges but for different reasons, emphasizing the unique economic and social implications for Russia's future.
Takeaways
- 🏙️ Chukotka, a remote region in Russia, is an unlikely candidate for a population resurgence, with its capital Anadyr being geographically distant and sparsely populated.
- 🛣️ The infrastructure in Chukotka is underdeveloped, with a road to connect it to Siberia expected to be completed in 21 years, and the airport being accessible only by helicopter for part of the year.
- 📈 Despite its small population increase, Chukotka stands out in Russia, where many cities have experienced a decline in population size, and the national birth rate is well below the world average.
- 📉 Russia's population has been in decline since the collapse of the Soviet Union, with more deaths than births for all but three years in the past 33 years.
- 🌍 The demographic challenges faced by Russia are not unique, as other countries like China, Korea, and Japan also experience falling birth rates and aging populations.
- 🔄 The difference between Russia and other countries lies in the causes of the demographic decline; in Russia, it's more a reaction to economic hardship and despair, rather than a choice due to increased opportunities for women.
- 💔 Russia's high death rate, particularly from heart-related issues, is suspected to be closely linked to alcohol consumption, which is deeply ingrained in the culture.
- 🍷 The type of alcohol consumed and the pattern of drinking in Russia, often involving vodka and binge drinking, contribute to the high mortality rate.
- 💔 Alcohol-related deaths have had a significant impact on Russia's population, with estimates suggesting over half of adult male deaths in Siberia between 1990 and 2001 were caused by alcohol.
- 💉 The Russian government's efforts to address the issue have been complicated by the reliance on alcohol tax revenue and the political challenges of implementing effective restrictions.
- 🌐 Russia's demographic crisis is multifaceted, involving not only alcohol consumption but also a poor healthcare system, the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic, and the effects of ongoing conflict.
Q & A
Why is Chukotka considered an unlikely center for Russian civilization's resurgence?
-Chukotka is remote, with its capital Anadyr being the easternmost city in Russia, situated just below the Arctic Circle. It is closer to Chicago than to Moscow, and its connection to the rest of Siberia is limited, with a road expected to be completed in 21 years. The region's population is also very small compared to its size.
What is the significance of the population increase in Anadyr mentioned in the script?
-The population increase in Anadyr, though small at 157 people between 2010 and 2021, is significant because it represents a rare instance of population growth in Russia, where most cities have shrunk in size during the same period.
How does Russia's fertility rate compare to the world average and within Russia?
-Russia's fertility rate of 1.6 is below the world average but is among the highest within Russia, indicating a general decline in birth rates across the country.
What was the Soviet Union's population peak and how has it changed since its collapse?
-The Soviet Union's population peaked at nearly 149 million in the 1980s, making it the 6th largest country in the world. However, after the collapse in 1991, the birth rate has never recovered, leading to a consistent pattern of more deaths than births for the last 33 years except three.
What demographic challenges does Russia face due to its declining birth rate?
-Russia faces a significant labor shortage, particularly in the blue-collar and tech sectors, which require a younger workforce. Additionally, the country has a very small percentage of workers under 30 and an extremely low unemployment rate, which could affect its economic growth and military readiness.
How does Russia's demographic situation compare to other countries like Italy, Japan, and Britain?
-While Russia, Italy, Japan, and Britain all face challenges due to declining birth rates and aging populations, the causes are different. In Italy, the decline is due to social and economic progress, whereas in Russia, it is a result of economic hardship and despair.
What is the 'Russian Cross' and how does it differ from the demographic trends in Italy?
-The 'Russian Cross' refers to the simultaneous occurrence of low birth rates and high death rates in Russia. Unlike Italy, where a decline in birth rates is associated with social progress and better health, Russia's situation is characterized by a lack of new births and an increase in deaths, leading to a more severe demographic crisis.
What role does alcohol play in Russia's high death rates?
-Alcohol is a significant factor in Russia's high death rates, with heart-related fatalities, which are the leading cause of death, spiking on weekends. The culture of binge drinking and the consumption of hard alcohol like vodka contribute to a higher rate of alcohol-related deaths.
How did Gorbachev's anti-alcohol campaign impact the Soviet Union's economy and why was it eventually rolled back?
-Gorbachev's anti-alcohol campaign led to a decrease in consumption and an increase in life expectancy. However, it also resulted in a significant loss of tax revenue, which was crucial for the government's budget. The campaign was rolled back in 1988 due to the economic strain it caused, contributing to the Soviet Union's eventual collapse.
What measures has the Russian government taken to address the demographic crisis, and why might they be insufficient?
-The Russian government has implemented policies like the 'Maternity Capital' program to encourage population growth. However, these measures may not be effective due to conflicts with other goals, such as funding for the military over healthcare, and the government's reluctance to address the root causes of the demographic crisis, like alcohol consumption and poor healthcare.
How has the COVID-19 pandemic exacerbated Russia's demographic and healthcare challenges?
-The COVID-19 pandemic has highlighted the inefficiencies in Russia's healthcare system, with low vaccination rates due to public distrust and outdated medical practices. This has led to a high number of deaths, further straining the demographic situation.
What are the long-term consequences of Russia's current demographic and healthcare situation for its economy and society?
-The long-term consequences include a shrinking workforce, increased burden on social services due to an aging population, a potential decrease in innovation, and a possible economic decline if the government fails to address these challenges effectively.
Outlines
🌐 Remote Chukotka's Unlikely Role in Russia's Demographic Revival
The script introduces Chukotka, a remote region in Russia, as an unexpected candidate for a demographic resurgence. Despite its isolation, with Anadyr as its capital city situated near the Arctic Circle and closer to Chicago than Moscow, it has gained the attention of President Putin. The region's population is minuscule compared to its size, and its growth rate, although small, is more significant than most Russian cities experiencing shrinkage. The script contrasts Russia's demographic challenges with historical data, showing a decline in birth rates and population since the Soviet Union's collapse, and highlights the country's need for a demographic turnaround.
📉 The Dual Demographic Crisis: Birth Rates and Life Expectancy in Russia
This paragraph delves into the causes behind Russia's demographic decline, distinguishing it from other countries like Italy where the drop in birth rates is associated with positive social changes. In Russia, the decrease is linked to economic hardship and despair. The script also discusses the 'Russian Cross' phenomenon, where a surge in deaths coincided with falling birth rates, and points to alcohol as a significant factor in the high mortality rate. It provides historical context, comparing the Soviet era's strict alcohol control measures under Gorbachev to the present situation, and the failed attempts to address alcohol-related issues.
💔 The Impact of Alcohol on Russia's Demographic and Economic Woes
The narrative focuses on alcohol's role in Russia's demographic crisis, illustrating how cultural practices and the type of alcohol consumed contribute to the high mortality rate, particularly among men. It discusses the government's past efforts to curb alcohol consumption and the unintended economic consequences that led to the rollback of such measures. The script also highlights the government's current stance on alcohol taxation and its implications for the country's healthcare and demographic challenges.
📉 Russia's Population Decline: A Complex Confluence of Factors
The final paragraph synthesizes the various factors contributing to Russia's population decline, including alcohol use, low birth rates, poor healthcare, the COVID-19 pandemic, and the ongoing war. It emphasizes the government's inaction and short-term decision-making that exacerbate the demographic crisis. The script concludes with the potential long-term effects of these issues on Russia's economy and society, suggesting that the country is facing a significant demographic and human capital challenge.
Mindmap
Keywords
💡Chukotka
💡Population Decline
💡Fertility Rate
💡Demographic Crisis
💡Alcohol Consumption
💡Labor Shortage
💡Economic Downturn
💡Life Expectancy
💡Mortality Rate
💡Birth Rate
💡Healthcare Efficiency
Highlights
Chukotka, a remote region in Russia, is being portrayed by President Putin as a model for the country's future despite its isolation and small population.
Anadyr, the capital of Chukotka, is closer to Chicago than Moscow and has limited accessibility, with a road connection to Siberia expected to be completed in 21 years.
Chukotka's population is minuscule compared to its size, with the entire region's population equivalent to less than half of Michigan Stadium's capacity.
The region has seen a net population increase of 157 between 2010 and 2021, which is significant given Russia's overall declining birth rates.
Over 70% of Russian cities shrunk between 2010 and 2017, reflecting a broader demographic issue in the country.
Russia's fertility rate of 1.6 is among the highest in the country, contrasting with the world average and highlighting a national trend of decreasing children.
The Soviet Union's population once peaked at nearly 149 million, but has been in decline since its collapse in 1991.
Russia's birth rate has never recovered post-Soviet collapse, leading to a consistent natural population decrease for all but three years in the last 33 years.
Russia is projected to drop to the 20th largest country by population by the end of the century, underscoring the urgency of its demographic challenges.
Russia faces a significant labor shortage, particularly among younger demographics, which is impacting its economy and workforce.
The country's demographic issues are exacerbated by a lack of 33-year-olds, a prime working-age group, due to the birth rate drop 33 years ago.
Globally, countries like China, Korea, and Japan are also experiencing birth rate declines, but Russia's situation is distinguished by its causes and consequences.
In Russia, the decline in birth rates appears to be more a reaction to economic hardship rather than a choice, unlike in countries like Italy.
Russia's high death rates, particularly from heart-related issues, coincide with a surge in alcohol consumption, pointing to alcohol as a significant factor.
Alcohol-related deaths in Russia are staggering, with estimates suggesting over half of adult male deaths in Siberia between 1990 and 2001 were due to alcohol.
Government efforts to combat alcohol consumption have been undermined by the need for tax revenue, revealing a conflict between public health and economic interests.
Russian President Putin acknowledges the demographic crisis as the country's most pressing issue, but policies have been limited in scope and effectiveness.
Russia's healthcare system is ranked last for efficiency, and the government's handling of the COVID-19 pandemic has further exacerbated demographic issues.
The ongoing war with Ukraine and the subsequent exodus of the population, particularly the young and educated, pose a significant risk to Russia's demographic and economic future.
The combination of alcohol use, declining birth rates, poor healthcare, the pandemic, and war has created a severe demographic challenge for Russia, with population declines accelerating.
Transcripts
Chukotka is an unlikely center for a resurgence of Russian civilization.
For one, it’s hardly the “center” of anything. Its capital, Anadyr, is also the country’s easternmost
city and sits just below the Arctic Circle. It’s closer to Chicago than it is to Moscow.
A road connecting it to the rest of Siberia is on track for completion… in 21 years. Until then,
the only way out is this airport, accessible only by helicopter for half the year.
Nor is there much “civilization” to be found. Despite being larger than France,
the region’s entire population would fill less than half of Michigan Stadium.
Life here moves pretty slowly.
When two brave Australian tourists visited in 2018, they made the local news.
And yet tiny, remote Anadyr, of all places, was one of the first stops Putin made this year.
There, in a staged meeting with local residents,
the president celebrated its rising number of large families, portraying the town as
a model for the rest of the country, a beacon of hope for Russia’s future.
So, what “rising number,” exactly, was Putin referring to? A net population
increase of 157 between 2010 and 2021, or 14 people per year.
…Not quite the shining success story the Kremlin would have you believe.
Still, he wasn’t wrong. An increase of 157 — any increase,
in fact — is far more than most places can claim.
Between 2010 and 17, over 70% of Russian cities shrunk in size.
And while Chukotka’s fertility rate of 1.6 is well below the world average,
it’s among the highest in Russia, where children are becoming increasingly rare.
In the 1980s, the Soviet Union had one of the highest birth rates in Europe. Its population
peaked at nearly 149 million, making it the 6th largest country in the world.
But after its collapse in ‘91, its birth rate has never recovered. Since then,
more Russians have died than been born for every one of the last 33 years except three.
Russia was first overtaken by Pakistan, then Nigeria, and finally Bangladesh. And
by the end of this century, it’s expected to fall all the way down to 20th place,
shrinking to three and a half times smaller than the United States.
Needless to say, these are troubling signs for a leader intent on reviving the Soviet legacy.
And it gets worse.
Because the Soviet Union collapsed 33 years ago, birth rates fell 33 years ago, which means today,
33 years later, Russia is missing a whole lot of 33-year-olds — the prime working-age demographic.
As a result, the country has a massive shortage of
labor — especially of the blue-collar and tech variety, which skew much younger.
A mere 15% of all workers are under 30 years old
and the unemployment rate has now reached a new low of just 2.6%.
…Not to mention, this dwindling 20-35-year-old
group is the exact one you’d need, to, say, fight a troop-intensive war.
Now, Russia is not alone. Far from it.
China’s birth rate, famously,
fell much faster. Korea’s is much worse. And Japan’s has stayed low for even longer.
Families across the developed world are getting
smaller and much of Europe and East Asia is shrinking.
Take Italy, for instance. As you can see,
both it and Russia saw the same roughly 50% drop in births — albeit, with a ten-year delay.
Likewise, both will experience the same economic challenges stemming from their smaller working-age
populations. More retirees withdrawing pensions than young people funding them. Fewer children
left supporting a larger number of older relatives. Fewer inventors to invent things,
landscapers to landscape, and caregivers to care for a growing cadre of seniors.
Russia may be in trouble, you might think, but no more so than Italy,
or Japan, or Britain. “Nothing to see here.”
But… there’s a critical difference. While the effects may look the same,
the causes couldn’t be more different.
In Italy, like most countries, these unfortunate problems have a silver lining. Birth rates fell
because fewer teenagers were getting pregnant. Women could go to school, had more career
opportunities, and were increasingly free to have as many or as few children as they wanted.
An economic defeat, but a human victory.
Whereas, in Russia, this drop was less a choice and more a reaction — to hard times,
mass unemployment, and a general sense of uncertainty and despair.
An economic and human failure.
Meanwhile, Italians were also living longer, healthier lives. Medicine was advancing,
the standard of living was rising, and pollution was being regulated.
Thus, even while the country got older, the number of deaths,
as you can see, remained more or less constant.
The same cannot be said of Russia. And this is where the two countries really begin to diverge.
There, deaths surged at the exact moment birth rates fell, producing what demographers call the
“Russian Cross.” And this was not just a temporary phenomenon — deaths have remained high ever since.
There’s no silver lining to be found here. This is the bleak story of a
nation being squeezed simultaneously from two directions — fewer births and more deaths.
Consider, for a moment, the scale of this tragedy. The annual number of deaths more than doubled
during the thirty years when HIV treatment, ICUs, and organ transplants became widely available.
As the economist Nicholas Eberstadt once observed, the last 16 years of Soviet rule saw 11 million
more births than deaths. Over the next sixteen years, it saw 12 million more deaths than births.
These are war-like casualties in peacetime.
So, what exactly caused all these deaths?
One clue is that heart-related fatalities — the leading kind — seem to spike on the weekend.
Another is that — whatever the cause — it appears less common in Muslim-majority regions.
All signs, in other words, point to alcohol.
The problem is not simply one of quantity. Though
it certainly doesn’t help that in some years Russians have consumed
almost double what the World Health Organization considers to be dangerous.
The problem, above all, is what kind of alcohol, where, and when.
The French sip wine, the British beer, and Russians, overwhelmingly,
vodka. Some stereotypes, apparently, are true.
Not only do Russians get more intoxicated, faster, as a result,
but a deeply embedded culture of social and binge drinking compounds these effects.
During Soviet times, vodka was sold with non-reusable caps. Bottles were consumed all at
once, usually in groups, and often in uncontrolled public spaces — unsupervised by bartenders.
This is an extremely lethal combination.
So much so that every Russian male has a roughly 25-30% chance of dying,
one way or another, thanks to alcohol.
The numbers on screen, bear in mind, are from 2012,
but note how Russia’s number is ten times higher than America’s.
Researchers estimate that between 1990 and 2001,
over half of all adult male deaths in Siberia were caused by alcohol.
On top of this, about 30% of all crimes and 72% of
all murders in 2017 were related to alcohol, according to the Kremlin.
These are staggering numbers, particularly for one of the
world’s most highly educated countries, with an upper-middle income, no less.
Unsurprisingly, then, the Russian male life expectancy
is just 68 years — closer to Haiti than Germany. The average man in Sweden,
Switzerland, or Macau will live a full decade and a half longer.
So, why does the government accept this tragic state of affairs? Surely,
even the most corrupt, authoritarian, and malevolent dictator would recognize
this for the epidemic it is, if only out of self-interest.
Well, as it turns out, serious efforts have been made in the past.
During Soviet times, authorities estimated that Russians spent 15-20% of their incomes
on vodka alone. And no fewer than 75% of work absences were attributed to alcohol.
In response, Gorbachev — a non-drinker himself — launched the strictest crackdown before
or since. Prices were increased, manufacturing restricted, rules tightened, and curfews enforced.
Entire vineyards were even destroyed by the state.
It worked. Almost immediately, consumption fell by about 25%, and, more importantly, it shifted from
vodka to beer. In less than 3 years, the male life expectancy increased by 3.2 years. For women, 1.4.
There was just one problem: or, rather, 28 billion — the number of rubles the government
lost in tax revenue, which, as Mark Schrad points out in his book “Vodka Politics,”
was roughly equivalent to Russia’s total loss from the collapse of world oil prices.
The Soviet Union, at the time,
truly ran on vodka — the tax revenue from which funded 25% of the government’s budget.
So, left with no other choice,
Gorbachev rolled back the campaign in 1988, just three years after it began.
But it was too late. To fund the deficit, the Soviet Union began printing money, which broke
the state-run economy, which led to shortages, which, in turn, caused its total collapse.
It would be too simplistic to say the anti-alcohol campaign brought down the
Soviet Union. But experts generally agree that it contributed, at the very least, to its demise.
Then, just when you thought things couldn’t possibly get worse, they did.
After 1991, alcohol suddenly became extremely cheap and even more accessible. In other words,
the floodgates were opened after 3 years of pent-up demand at the
exact moment Russians were at their most hopeless.
If they drank profusely before, now they were off the charts.
Consumption soared as they made up for lost time …and then some.
Over two decades later, Putin’s political placeholder, President Medvedev, tried again,
this time with more modest reforms — mandating health warnings, cracking down on DUIs, and,
if you can believe it, reclassifying beer as “alcohol,” rather than mere “food” product.
But, once again, during its economic downturn in 2014 when it was in dire need of extra revenue,
many of these measures were reversed. In the meantime,
Russians turned to all manner of far more dangerous alcohol substitutes.
The lesson? Don’t touch alcohol restrictions with a ten-foot pole. They’re costly,
they’re wildly unpopular, and they don’t work.
During the Great Recession, Russia’s finance
minister removed any doubt about the government’s true motives,
saying the best thing ordinary citizens could do to help the economy was drink more.
And one final cherry on top: a popular brand of Russian vodka is named after
Putin — who ironically, is a teetotaler like Gorbachev.
Now, Russia almost certainly stands more to lose
from encouraging alcohol consumption than it does to gain from taxing it.
As early as 2006, Putin declared the demographic crisis to be Russia’s “most important problem.”
Two decades later, he continues to say similar things, most recently on his trip to Anadyr.
And this isn’t just empty rhetoric. The country’s “Maternity Capital” program encourages population
growth by giving new families a one-time payment for giving birth to or adopting a child.
Still, these are relatively easy, low-risk policies — and,
frankly, likely not all that effective.
Whenever this demographic goal conflicts with any other goal, the latter inevitably wins.
Year after year, Putin has made short-term decisions
that aggravate the problem and mortgage Russia’s future.
Take healthcare, for example.
In a recent report, Russia ranked last out of 55 countries for healthcare efficiency.
Hospitals are so dirty, corruption so rampant, and medical practices so outdated that many people,
especially those outside of major cities, avoid seeking care altogether.
At no time was this more on display than during the COVID-19 pandemic.
Distrustful of the government, people avoided vaccines. Today,
a smaller share of its population is fully vaccinated than the lowest U.S. state — Wyoming.
As a result, as many as 1 million Russians may have died of the virus, according to outside
estimates. If true, this would make it one of the highest per-capita death rates in the world.
Rather than fund its outdated hospitals, the government diverts money toward the military.
Estimates of Russian casualties from its war with Ukraine range between 100,000 and
500,000 — in either case, a massive chunk of the demographic its economy needs the most.
Not to mention: countless families have fled the country since the war began — likely 1-2 million,
including 200,000 in the first 10 days of the invasion alone.
Keep in mind that only 29% of the population — the elite — hold a passport. Those who are leaving,
in other words, are disproportionately young,
wealthy, well-educated, and have skills in high demand.
The loss of 100,000 software engineers,
on its own, will cause chaos in Russia’s once-thriving technology industry.
Add all this up — alcohol use, declining birth rates, the poor state of healthcare,
the pandemic, war, and the subsequent exodus, and Russia has a serious problem.
It’s running out of people.
In 2020 and 2021, its population declined by over a million. And the worst may still be yet to come.
Again, none of this was unforeseeable,
which only makes the Russian government’s inaction that much more concerning.
Perhaps it should have taken the “Understanding Graphs” course on today’s sponsor, Brilliant,
which culminates in a capstone lesson on population growth.
Brilliant makes learning things like programming, data analysis,
AI, and math fun with interactive lessons, puzzles, and challenges.
Say you want to learn data analysis — a highly marketable and fast-growing field.
A typical online course might look like this — essentially,
a digital textbook with lessons on “density functions,” “binomial distributions,” and “the
addition rule.” If you’re lucky, you might watch an unedited 2-hour recorded lecture.
Brilliant, on the other hand, guides you through the material step-by-step,
with beautifully made and engaging interactive puzzles, interspersed with
real projects and challenges that teach you how to analyze, think through, and solve a problem,
like how to use what you’ve learned to build a music recommendation algorithm for Spotify.
Because each lesson is broken down into bite-sized chunks, learning becomes a
daily habit. Because you’re learning from first principles, you’ll learn universal
and transferable problem-solving skills and not just memorize facts. Finally, you’re more likely
to actually remember what you learn when what you’re learning is interesting. Imagine that!
Brilliant has courses on how Large Language Models like ChatGPT work,
how to program in Python, calculate probability, do calculus, and much, much more.
To check out Brilliant completely free for 30 days, click the link on screen
now or in the description below — that’s Brilliant.org/PolyMatter.
Doing so will also get you 20% off an annual premium subscription.
Go, pick what interests you most, and start learning today!
5.0 / 5 (0 votes)