What is a Balanced Viewpoint on #Hezbollah? #sktothepoint
Summary
TLDRThis video explores Hezbollah's complex role in the Middle East, examining its evolution from a Lebanese resistance group to a regional power broker. It discusses Hezbollah's military support for the Assad regime in Syria, its political influence in Lebanon, and its controversial tactics, including sectarian cleansing and siege warfare. The video also addresses Hezbollah's impact on Lebanon's economy and political stability, presenting a balanced view on whether it is a force for good or a detriment to the region.
Takeaways
- 🌐 Hezbollah is a powerful Shiite Muslim group formed in Lebanon in the 1980s with strong support from Iran.
- 🔄 Historically seen as a resistance force against Israel, Hezbollah's role has evolved significantly over time.
- 🏰 During the Syrian Civil War, Hezbollah aligned with the Assad regime, transforming from a regional player into a key actor in an international conflict.
- 🔗 The alliance with Assad was crucial for Hezbollah's survival as the fall of Assad would threaten the entire 'Axis of Resistance' consisting of Iran, Syria, and Hezbollah.
- 🛑 Hezbollah's military involvement in Syria included brutal tactics, contributing to significant civilian deaths and sectarian cleansing.
- 🏠 In Lebanon, Hezbollah has grown from a resistance group to a dominant political and military force, refusing to disarm even after the end of the Civil War.
- 💼 Hezbollah's political influence in Lebanon is significant, holding seats in Parliament and having a veto over major government decisions.
- 💰 The group operates a vast parallel economy in Lebanon, engaging in illicit activities to fund its operations.
- 🌍 Hezbollah's actions have contributed to Lebanon's political paralysis, economic collapse, and regional isolation.
- 🔍 The perception of Hezbollah varies; some view it as a legitimate resistance force necessary to defend Lebanon, while others see it as a destructive force detrimental to Lebanon's future.
Q & A
What is Hezbollah's original mandate?
-Hezbollah was originally formed as a powerful Shiite Muslim group in Lebanon in the 1980s with the mandate to resist Israeli advances, particularly in southern Lebanon.
How did Hezbollah's role evolve during the Syrian Civil War?
-During the Syrian Civil War, Hezbollah's role evolved from a regional player to a key actor in an international conflict. They aligned with the Assad regime, which transformed them from a local resistance force into a military actor involved in a complex geopolitical situation.
Why did Hezbollah support the Assad regime?
-Hezbollah supported the Assad regime as a strategic survival tactic. The fall of Assad would have threatened the entire 'axis of resistance' consisting of Iran, Syria, and Hezbollah. Additionally, Assad's Alawite sect, an offshoot of Shia Islam, was aligned with Hezbollah's Shia nature, and they were fighting primarily against Sunni rebels.
What was the significance of the Battle of Al-Qusayr in the Syrian Civil War?
-The Battle of Al-Qusayr was a turning point in the Syrian Civil War, showcasing Hezbollah's military influence and brutality. It was a critical area for maintaining supply lines for the Assad regime, and its recapture by Hezbollah from the rebels was significant but came at a high cost to civilian life.
How did Hezbollah's involvement in Syria affect the Lebanese ecosystem?
-Hezbollah's involvement in Syria contributed to immense suffering and deaths of fellow Muslims, causing political paralysis, economic collapse, and regional isolation in Lebanon. Their refusal to disarm post-civil war and their control over key areas in Lebanon cemented their dominance in the country.
What is the 'axis of resistance' mentioned in the script?
-The 'axis of resistance' refers to the alliance between Iran, Syria, and Hezbollah. Hezbollah relies on Syria as a transit hub for weapons and financial support from Iran.
How did Hezbollah's tactics in Syria lead to sectarian cleansing?
-Hezbollah's tactics in Syria included siege warfare and sectarian cleansing, particularly against Sunni rebels. They implemented starvation tactics, cut off supply lines, and reshaped the demographics of Syrian cities in favor of the Assad regime, thereby increasing Shiite influence.
What is Hezbollah's role in the Lebanese political ecosystem?
-Hezbollah has a significant political presence in Lebanon, holding seats in Parliament and the cabinet. They have a veto over major government decisions, ensuring their continued influence in Lebanese politics.
How does Hezbollah maintain its economic power in Lebanon?
-Hezbollah operates a vast parallel economy in Lebanon, engaging in illicit activities such as smuggling and drug trafficking to fund its operations and military force. This has contributed to Lebanon's economic struggles and isolation from other countries.
What are the different views on Hezbollah within Lebanon?
-There are mixed views on Hezbollah within Lebanon. Some see them as a legitimate resistance force necessary to defend against external threats, especially Israel, and providing social services to the Shia community. Others view them as a destructive force causing political paralysis, economic collapse, and regional isolation.
What is the final summary of Hezbollah's evolution according to the script?
-Hezbollah has evolved from a resistance group to a regional power broker with immense responsibility and consequences. Their original mandate was to resist Israel, but they have become an oppressive force holding Lebanon and its people hostage to their broader geopolitical ambitions.
Outlines
🌍 Hezbollah's Role in the Middle East
This paragraph introduces the video's focus on Hezbollah's involvement in Middle Eastern geopolitics, particularly in Lebanon and Syria. It emphasizes the importance of understanding Hezbollah from a balanced perspective and outlines the key questions to be addressed. The video aims to explore Hezbollah's history, its evolution from a resistance force against Israel to a significant actor in the Syrian Civil War, and its strategic reasons for supporting the Assad regime, including the preservation of the 'Axis of Resistance' and sectarian motivations.
🏭 Hezbollah's Impact on Syria and Lebanon
The second paragraph delves into Hezbollah's military and political activities within Lebanon and its support for the Assad regime in Syria. It discusses Hezbollah's transformation from a regional player to a key actor in international conflicts, its brutal methods in recapturing strategic locations like Al-Qusayr, and its role in siege warfare and sectarian cleansing. The paragraph also touches on Hezbollah's influence on the demographic makeup of Syrian cities and its contribution to the suffering of Syrian civilians, including through the facilitation of chemical attacks by the Assad regime.
🔄 Hezbollah's Political and Economic Influence
This paragraph examines Hezbollah's political maneuvers within Lebanon, its refusal to disarm post-civil war, and its control over key areas of the country. It highlights Hezbollah's political power, including its ability to veto government decisions, and its economic influence through illicit activities that fund its operations. The paragraph also discusses the negative impact of Hezbollah's actions on Lebanon's political and economic stability, leading to isolation from Gulf States and a bleak economic future.
🔍 Evaluating Hezbollah's Dual Nature
The final paragraph invites viewers to consider Hezbollah's dual nature as both a resistance force and a destructive force. It acknowledges Hezbollah's support base and the social services it provides to the Shia community in Lebanon while also recognizing the suffering and regional instability caused by its actions. The video concludes by reflecting on Hezbollah's evolution from a resistance group to a regional power broker with significant geopolitical ambitions and consequences for Lebanon and the wider Middle East.
Mindmap
Keywords
💡Hezbollah
💡Axis of Resistance
💡Syrian Civil War
💡Bashar al-Assad
💡Sectarian Cleansing
💡Lebanese Civil War
💡Demographic Shift
💡Political Paralysis
💡Economic Reforms
💡Parallel Economy
💡Geopolitical Ambitions
Highlights
Hezbollah's involvement in the Middle East is complex and multifaceted.
Hezbollah is a powerful Shiite Muslim group formed in Lebanon in the 1980s with strong support from Iran.
Hezbollah has historically been seen as a resistance force fighting against Israel.
Hezbollah's role evolved significantly during the Syrian Civil War, aligning with Bashar al-Assad's regime.
Support for Assad was a strategic survival tactic for Hezbollah, as his fall would threaten the 'Axis of Resistance'.
Hezbollah's military role in Syria expanded beyond defending Shia communities to include siege warfare and sectarian cleansing.
The Battle of Al-Qusayr was a turning point in the Syrian conflict, showing Hezbollah's influence and brutality.
Hezbollah's tactics in Syria led to widespread destruction and displacement of civilians.
Hezbollah's involvement in Syria indirectly supported the Assad regime's use of chemical weapons against its own people.
In Lebanon, Hezbollah has grown from a resistance group to a dominant political and military force.
Hezbollah maintains its own armed forces, which are more powerful than Lebanon's official military.
Hezbollah's political influence in Lebanon has led to political paralysis and economic collapse.
Hezbollah operates a vast parallel economy in Lebanon, engaging in illicit activities to fund its operations.
Hezbollah's actions have isolated Lebanon from its Gulf neighbors, leading to a lack of financial support.
Hezbollah provides social services to the impoverished Shia community in Lebanon, maintaining a loyal support base.
Hezbollah's evolution from a resistance group to a regional power broker has come with immense responsibility and consequences.
Hezbollah's actions have been both beneficial and detrimental, depending on one's perspective.
Transcripts
hello and welcome to ESC the point where
I break down the most complex
geopolitical issues in a clear and
straightforward manner at least I try to
today we're going to explore hezbollah's
involvement in the Middle East with all
that's happening in Lebanon and beut and
with Israel's advances and the
assassination of Hassan asah I think
it's very important to look at Hezbollah
or rather at least try to look at
Hezbollah from a very balanced point of
view so we will be addressing the most
important questions so what's the how
does a balanced point of view on hesa
sound like and are they good or
detrimental for the pece of Middle East
let's have a look I think to understand
heah as a group it's critical to look at
their involvement in two specific
instances one would be their involvement
within the L ecosystem and the second
would be their support to the Asad
regime and how they played a very
important part during a Syrian Civil
War now let me tell you these are highly
charged topics that have shaped the
political and the conflict based
ecosystem of Middle East so we'll dive
into these issues with a detailed
nuanced perspective so if you had to
look at Hezbollah as a group let's take
a brief look at their history Hezbollah
is basically a powerful [ __ ] Muslim
group formed in lein in the 1980s with a
very strong support from Iran
and Hezbollah as a group has
historically been seen as a resistance
force fighting Israel and its advances
especially in the southern Lebanon part
but its role has definitely evolved and
by the time of the Syrian Civil War
which broke out in 2011 Hezbollah had
gone way past the Lebanese borders and
had actually aligned itself with the
regime of Bashar al- Assad this move
transformed Hezbollah from a regional
player into a key actor in a highly
complicated International conflict but
why did Hezbollah site with Bashar
al-assad
it's it's a pretty straightforward
answer uh it was just hezbollah's case
of a simple strategic survival tactic
the fall of Assad would threaten the
entire AIS of resistance which was made
up of Iran Syria and hesah so what is
this axis of resistance it's it's simple
Hezbollah basically relies on Syria as a
critical Transit hub for weapons and
financial support that it receives from
Iran the second most important factor
for Hezbollah to side with the ruling
Syrian dispens and Assad is of sectarian
dimension in nature Assad was an alawite
and what is what is an ala it's
basically an offshoot of the shiam Islam
Shia Muslim nature and Assad was
fighting primarily against the Sunni
rebels in Syria initially Hezbollah
framed its intervention in the Syrian
Civil War as a duty to protect uh the
Shia communities and their interests uh
including the religious shrines um in in
in in the Border areas between Syria and
Lebanon but slowly its military role uh
expanded and you will see why and how in
2013 U the Battle of alasar uh alasar is
is a place in Syria and I think this was
one of the most important points of the
conflict and also shows the vast
influence U and significance that uh the
support of esbah gave uh to the Assad
regime this was also considered as one
of the turning points uh in the Syrian
conflict alcasar is this place that is
situated near the Lebanese border and it
was a very critical point uh of area
which was used to maintain supply lines
for the Assad regime and it was the
hasbullah which led the charge uh to
retake and reclaim this place from the
Syrian rebels who had already captured
it from the Assad's military factions
and why is it a turning point I think uh
it was the nature in which Hezbollah
retook these Place U their methods were
really brutal the civilians were trapped
uh they could not move out um there was
indiscriminate shelling that took place
it killed women children men Rebels
everyone put together so it was not just
about fending off the rebels but there
was a large large collateral damage and
you can't even call it a collateral
damage when thousands of Civ civilians
perished uh in this fighting so this
victory for Assad which was a very very
important and a turning point kind of a
victory came at a huge cost thousands
were displaced and reports indicated
that hb's involvement had contributed to
significant civilian deaths I think the
main point of hezbollah's involvement uh
was not just about being a you know a
supply line to Assad's military uh or
you know helping them with supply chain
but it was also about uh this Siege
Warfare that they conducted and also a
large portion of their Warfare included
sectarian cleansing so like I mentioned
uh Hezbollah is basically a Shia outfit
and Assad's regime was fighting against
Sunni rebels in Syria so there was a lot
of sectarian cleansing that happened so
while The Siege Warfare was happening
and being conducted by the Hezbollah
outfits uh they also indulged in uh
especially in places like alipo and
madaya uh and and zabadani if I'm not
wrong they also indulged in sectarian
cleansing where by which you know they
implemented the starvation tactics
civilians were cut off from supply lines
beat food medicine or even places to
escape and and and a large population
died of starvation and not just because
of shelling or firing and experts view
this as not just a resistance movement
or a help that was offered to the Asad
regim but it was also a kind of a
Warfare designed to break the will of
the Rebel Fighters and even the citizens
and the civilians of Syria who were
against
aadim while this fighting was happening
Hezbollah Fighters also managed to drive
out the Sunni population from Key areas
in Syria and thereby reshaping the
demographics uh of individual Syrian
cities in favor of the Assad regime they
were basically trying to reduce the
influence and significance of the sunnis
in Syria and thereby increase the
influence of Shiites in favor of the
Assad regim so to summarize the role of
Hezbollah in being involved in the sieg
Warfare uh is that they contributed
directly or indirectly to thousands of
deaths of Syrian civilians uh including
women and children and they were all
driven out of their homes they were led
to starvation deaths as well and also
involved in sectoral cleansing if you
were to take a more closer look at
hezbollah's role uh um and its military
involvement in Syria we can we can say
that it was not just about fighting the
rebel forces but also about suppressing
the opposition uh to the Assad regim via
some of the most brutal methods seen
during the war in cities like alasa
which we've touched upon earlier alipo
the Damascus suburbs and and various
other places where uh there was a large
Sunni population heah was accused of
shelling residential areas
indiscriminately which is something that
they are currently accusing Israel of
doing in beut it is important to
understand that many of these places and
urban centers in Syria were densely
populated civilians and hezbollah's
tactics led to widespread destruction uh
of their homes schools and hospitals and
also when we talk about the sectarian
violence and sectarian cleansing it is
very important to understand um that um
it was not just about supporting the
Assad regime or you know supporting the
military conquest but also trying to
reshape uh the entire demographic
structure uh of uh the Syrian lands if
you were to look at what happened in
areas like zabadani and quamon um
Hezbollah backed forces systematically
targeted the Sunni communities causing
the forc displacement of families uh in
thousands who had lived there across
multiple Generations these Sy
populations were either killed displaced
or terrorized into leaving their homes
and when we talk about the Syrian
conflict we can never ignore the fact
that Assad's regime used extensive
chemical attacks to kill and threaten
the Sunni population and the overall
population in general which were opposed
to the regime while those who defend
hisbah would say that they were not
directly involved in the use of chemical
attacks I think it's very important to
understand that whether it is directly
or indirectly Hezbollah was definitely
instrumental in the military operations
that helped keep Assad in power and
therefore uses might to deploy the
chemical attacks against his own people
I think the most important uh event was
the Guta incident the gut chemical
attack in 2013 which was the place where
uh the infamous sarin gas was used to
kill hundreds and thousands of people
including children by propping up
Assad's regime Hezbollah indirectly
supported the apparatus that carried out
uh these atrocities in Syria I think
it's a fair question and an argument to
be had or pondered over even uh to to
you know to understand whether the Assad
regime would have had the ction uh to go
after its people by using these heess
chemical attacks if not for the support
the strong support of Hezbollah now
let's take a look at Hezbollah within
the Lebanon ecosystem and you know how
they moved from a resistance group into
also having their own political wings
and how they
you know strongly control the political
narratives that you know take shape in
Lebanon like we pointed out heaz was
basically during the Lebanese Civil War
and propped up by Iran uh they quickly
um became known for their military
progress especially during their fight
against Israel in 2000 where Israel was
uh you know withdrawing from Southern
Lebanon this was the time when many
Lebanese haed has as a legitimate
resistance force however uh over time
the group's ambition uh group it
basically grew much bigger than what
theed and it shifted from being militia
to becoming the most uh dominant
political and military force in entire
Lebanon asbah maintains its own armed
forces and this is uh this this is as as
of last week right so now we know that
most of the heah leadership is either in
hiding all they killed but uh
hezbollah's military force at its peak
uh was way more powerful than Le
lebanon's official military even after
the end of the Civil War heah refused to
disarm I think this was I think this was
one of the most important aspects um
in terms of how it shaped the future of
Hezbollah in Lebanon hezbollah's main
reason was that U there was always a
necessity to defend Lebanon from Israel
and this was the reason that they
refused to disarm even after the Civil
War and whether they have been
successful in defending themselves
against Israel uh what it actually did
was it helped Hezbollah to maintain
control over key areas in Lebanon
especially in southern Le Lebanon and
the Bea Valley in 2008 hea used its
military might to take over parts of
their after the Government tried to
clamp down on the Telecommunications
Network
this move showcased hezbollah's might
when it comes to using the force to
protect its own interests and and this
was also a point in history where people
started realizing that probably there is
no other stronger uh Power in Lebanon as
said from Hezbollah or or even any other
force that can take over take on
Hezbollah when we talk about Hezbollah
it's not just about their military force
The Brute Force or the resistance
Fighters but uh heah also has a lot to
talk about in terms of its political in
terms of its political Expeditions in
Lebanon heah naturally thought it was
better for it to also be involved
politically uh within the political
ecosystem of Lebanon and therefore it
entered lebanon's formal political
process holding seats in Parliament and
the cabinet over the years with
successful alliances uh with other
political outfits U Hezbollah has always
managed uh to gain significant influence
in the Lebanese political Spectrum in
fact it's not surprising that
hezbollah's political Block in fact has
a veto over major government and
political decisions ensuring that the
group remains uh a powerful player in
Lebanese politics let's look at how
Hezbollah has been controlling the uh
economy in Lebanon uh and in terms of
what it does to keep its organization
alive economically in Lebanon so beyond
uh military and political control what
as also does is uh it operates a vast
parallel economy how does it do that uh
it basically uh engages in illicit
activities such as smuggling drug
trafficking Etc to fund its own
operations in Lebanon and also fund its
military force when we talk about the
Lebanese political ecosystem I think uh
the increased influence of HB has
basically paralyzed lebanon's political
system it often blocks political reforms
uh critical uh economic reforms stalling
progress on anti-corruption activities
and also majorly contributing to the
dysfunction of the Lebanese government
historically speaking when we touched
upon hb's Clos ties to Iran and also
it's often criticized involvement in the
Syrian Civil War uh all all these
factors put together have often isolated
Lebanon from even its Gulf neighbors for
instance Saudi Arabia and other Gulf
States have often withdrawn financial
support from Lebanon leaving the country
isolated and without crucial economic
lifelines I think when we talk about the
economy of Lebanon um I think it's
important to again go back to the point
of the parallel economy that heah runs
lebanon's economy is in freeall
basically with skyrocketing inflation uh
unemployment poverty rates are high as
well while there are many factors at
play I think the most significant one is
hezbollah's uh unwillingness to support
any kind of economic reforms as it's
already in engaged in a parallel economy
and also involved in illicit Affairs
leading to drug trafficking smuggling
Etc and when you couple this uh with the
isolation that Leon faces from even
other Gulf States then you're staring at
a very Bleak future when it comes to
economic reforms and support financial
support so let's come back to the
question that we started this video with
what is the balanced point of view on
Hezbollah is Hezbollah good or bad for
Lebanon I think it's very important to
understand that the answer to such a
question depends on who you ask for some
Hezbollah is a legitimate resistant
force that is uh necessary to defend
Lebanon against external threats mostly
Israel aside from that when we also look
at Hezbollah from U Shia context um I
think heah provides a wide range of
Social Services uh to to to the
impoverished uh Shia community in
Lebanon and and continues to have a very
loyal support in Lebanon so I think
that's very important to understand uh
Hezbollah is not a terrorist outfit that
acts outside of Lebanon so it's
basically in the central parts of
Lebanon and it enjoys strong support
from the local of leanon um you know
there there's a definitely a large chunk
of population in Lebanon uh who continue
to support Hezbollah despite of All the
Troubles that you know Hezbollah has
brought to the country of Lebanon
however for many others I think
Hezbollah is a destructive force it's
detrimental in nature for the future of
Lebanon its involvement in Syria civil
war has has contributed to U immense
suffering um and deaths of fellow
Muslims and when we talk about uh how
hasbullah
acts in the political ecosystem of
Lebanon I think it's very important to
understand that it has caused a sense of
political paralysis economic collapse
and Regional
isolation I think if you were to take a
summarized view of Hezbollah uh and you
know if you were to summarize their
journey in two lines I think Hezbollah
has evolved a lot and it has evolved far
beyond its original Mandate of
resistance and has in turn become an
oppressive force uh one that holds
Lebanon and its people hostage uh to its
broader uh geopolitical Ambitions so H
has basically become this kind of a
monster that it originally was formed to
fight uh and here the monster I'm
referring to is Israel so esbah wanted
to basically fight a monster and in turn
it became a monster of its own to its
own people so I think the final summary
of esbah would be U its Evolution from a
resistance group to a regional power
broker but with that Evolution has come
immense responsibility and consequences
uh to the group not only for Lebanon but
also for the wider Middle East I think
it's important for people to understand
what heah stands for because world over
there are many people who are moaning
the demise of their top leadership and
also for what Israel is doing in terms
of going after the entire top leadership
of Hezbollah and more so in India you
have leaders like meua Muti who are
actually you know paying their respects
to the heah leadership and also as an
act of solidarity are you know
postponing their political campaigns
because of what's transpired over the
last few days uh but but I think it's
important to also understand uh what
heah has done to his fellow Muslims
because it was not just about going
after Israel which was their original
mandate but but but they became a power
broker and thereby uh lost sight of what
they were actually fighting for and and
became a monster themselves I hope you
found this video insightful and uh the
reason I do these videos is not just to
keep you informed of what's happening
but also to evoke a general interest in
you to go far deeper into these topics
so if you found this video insightful
please do uh drop in your comments as
I'd love to hear your thoughts on this
also let me know what you think of
hezbollah's role in Leb and syia and
coming back to the question is Esa a
good force or is it a detriment to the
region thank you for watching SK to the
point and until next time see you soon
関連動画をさらに表示
Operation Pager- Inside Story of Mossad in Lebanon
Iran Entry Confirmed | யூதர்களுக்கு அவசர செய்தி | Israel Urgent Message To Jews | TP
Lebanon Pager Blast : इज़राइल ने दुनिया को हिला डाला| Israel Top 5 Secret Operations| RJ Raunak
What is Hezbollah and how powerful is it?
War Starting in Middle East: Top Leader Eliminated. Iran Attacks US Base?
Tensions between Israel and Hezbollah 'could escalate further' | 7.30
5.0 / 5 (0 votes)