Windows User Tries MacBook, Is Shocked…

Summary

In this video, the creator reflects on their journey from being a vocal critic of Apple products to becoming an unexpected MacBook user. After years of frustration with gaming laptops and Windows-based systems, they explore the benefits of Apple's hardware, particularly for video editing. The video highlights the smooth workflow, impressive performance, and long-lasting battery life of the MacBook, though not without some quirks. Despite the praise, the creator remains frustrated by Apple's pricing and product strategy. Ultimately, they embrace the MacBook for its superior editing experience but continue to wrestle with the cost and limitations of Apple's ecosystem.

Takeaways

• 😀 David admits he's now an Apple user after years of mocking Apple products, specifically after realizing how well a MacBook fits his YouTube workflow.
• 😀 Switching from Windows to Mac was a challenging journey, with multiple failed attempts before finally committing to the MacBook for editing.
• 😀 A major issue with Windows laptops for video editing is poor performance with relatively simple timelines, which contrasts sharply with the MacBook's smooth handling.
• 😀 The MacBook's ability to edit 4K 10-bit files with ease, without noticeable fan noise, impressed David, especially compared to the noise and performance issues of gaming laptops.
• 😀 The MacBook's battery life and ability to edit without compromising performance or sound quality was a big positive during trips.
• 😀 One unexpected surprise was the MacBook's superior speakers, which David described as clear, punchy, and capable of delivering a compelling stereo soundstage.
• 😀 Despite the benefits, David still finds Apple's pricing and product strategy frustrating, particularly with regard to RAM upgrades and overall pricing structures.
• 😀 While David appreciates Apple's hardware build quality, he still feels conflicted about the company's pricing tactics and lack of upgradeability in devices.
• 😀 A key frustration with Mac OS is the frequent need to type in passwords, even though there are biometric features available, which David finds inconvenient for his workflow.
• 😀 David acknowledges that Mac OS collects more telemetry data than Windows, which feels invasive, but also notes that Apple at least doesn't sell the data to third parties.
• 😀 The transition to Apple Silicon (M1/M2) in the MacBook has been a game-changer for David, offering a more stable and efficient editing experience than on his custom-built Windows desktop.

Q & A

Why did the speaker initially avoid using Apple products?

The speaker initially avoided Apple products due to a strong belief that they would make the same mistakes as their father and because of a general disdain for Apple's product ecosystem and advertising practices. He was also hesitant to become part of the 'Apple lifestyle' and had negative stereotypes about Apple users.

What was the turning point that led the speaker to switch to using a MacBook?

The speaker's turning point came after repeated frustrations with editing on a gaming laptop. He had difficulty with performance, noise, and buggy behavior on his Windows machine. The decision to fully commit to using a MacBook came after a trip to England, where the speaker was impressed by the MacBook's performance with high-resolution 4K video editing.

What was the speaker's experience with editing on the MacBook?

The speaker found the MacBook to be a much better experience for video editing, especially with 4K 10bit 4:2:2 files. The MacBook handled these files smoothly without issues related to timeline scrubbing or previews, and it remained quiet, unlike gaming laptops. It also offered a longer battery life and less noise, making it more comfortable to work around family.

How did the MacBook compare to the speaker’s Windows gaming laptop?

The MacBook outperformed the speaker's Windows gaming laptop in terms of editing experience. While the gaming laptop struggled with high-resolution video files and was noisy during use, the MacBook handled the workflow with ease, had quieter performance, and provided a smoother editing experience overall.

What aspect of the MacBook’s speakers stood out to the speaker?

The speaker was amazed by the MacBook's speakers, which were surprisingly loud, clear, and punchy for a laptop. He noted that they created a convincing soundstage, which made it an excellent content consumption device, a feature he hadn’t experienced with other laptop speakers.

What was the final moment that solidified the speaker’s identity as a Mac user?

The final moment occurred when the speaker returned to his Windows PC to edit a video but quickly became frustrated by Adobe software issues and instability. After switching back to the MacBook and having a smooth editing experience, the speaker realized that he had become a Mac user, despite his previous reluctance.

What is one of the key issues the speaker has with the MacBook’s display?

The speaker dislikes the motion rendering on the MacBook's display, specifically mentioning smearing effects during simple tasks like scrolling. This is particularly noticeable when compared to OLED displays, which offer smoother motion rendering.

What security feature does the speaker find annoying on Mac OS?

The speaker finds the frequent need to type in passwords annoying, despite Apple's security measures. He wishes Apple would allow users to disable certain security features, especially since he finds the fingerprint scanner inconvenient when the laptop is closed and on a desk.

How does the speaker feel about Apple’s data collection and privacy practices?

The speaker criticizes Apple for collecting telemetry data, claiming that while Apple doesn’t sell it, they still hoard it. He acknowledges that, compared to Windows, there are options to disable some data collection on both systems, but he’s still uncomfortable with Apple's approach to privacy.

What frustration does the speaker express about Apple’s pricing for RAM upgrades?

The speaker is frustrated by Apple's RAM pricing, particularly the fact that upgrading RAM in MacBooks costs significantly more than purchasing similar RAM for Windows-based systems. He feels that Apple's pricing is unreasonable, especially since they force users to pay for RAM upgrades when upgrading the silicon chip.