Marsden Park: The Devil of Urban Sprawl

Summary

The video script discusses the detrimental effects of urban sprawl and infrastructure lag, particularly in Marsden Park, a suburb of Western Sydney. Rapid housing development has outpaced the provision of essential services like roads, schools, and transport, leading to overcrowding and a lack of accessibility. The script highlights the need for a more sustainable approach to city planning, where infrastructure development precedes and supports housing growth, to ensure residents have access to a high quality of life and a truly livable community.

Takeaways

• 🏗️ Rapid housing construction in Western Sydney has outpaced the development of necessary infrastructure, leading to urban sprawl.
• 🚗 The lack of adequate roads in Marsden Park, a suburb in Western Sydney, has caused significant traffic congestion and posed safety risks.
• 🏫 Schools like Northbourne Public School were delayed in opening, resulting in overcrowding once they finally opened their doors.
• 🛒 Residents of Marsden Park had to wait until 2021 for a shopping center, highlighting the issue of infrastructure lag.
• 🚌 Public transport, including bus services to Showground Station, was not immediately available, causing frustration among residents.
• 🏠 The term 'McMansions' is used to describe the mass-produced, generic houses built in these new estates, lacking the charm of older Sydney areas.
• 🌳 There is a need for more green spaces and larger backyards in these new suburbs, which currently lack the forestry charm of more established areas.
• 📈 High-rise development is presented as a more sustainable solution to accommodate the growing population while ensuring access to necessary amenities.
• 🏭 The Australian dream of owning a house is being compromised by the housing crisis and the lack of infrastructure in newly developed areas.
• 🚆 Plans for a heavy rail extension to Marsden Park are far off, indicating a long-term infrastructure lag that could affect the suburb's growth and accessibility.
• 🌐 The video calls for a change in the approach to urban development, prioritizing infrastructure before housing to create more livable and sustainable communities.

Q & A

What is the main issue discussed in the video script about urban development in Sydney?

The main issue discussed is urban sprawl and the problem of infrastructure lag, where the development of housing estates outpaces the provision of necessary infrastructure such as roads, schools, and public transport.

What is Marsden Park and why is it significant in the context of this video?

Marsden Park is a suburb in Western Sydney that serves as a case study for the issues of flawed city planning and the negative impacts of urban sprawl and infrastructure lag on residents.

What was the situation of Marsden Park before 2013?

Before 2013, Marsden Park was semi-rural with only a few small streets, a public school, and a mosque.

What changes started happening in Marsden Park from 2014?

From 2014, large areas of Marsden Park began to be developed, with new residents moving into the new estate from 2015 onwards.

Why is the term 'McMansions' used to describe the houses in these new estates?

The term 'McMansions' is used to describe the mass-produced, generic, and similar-looking houses in these estates, similar to how McDonald's burgers are mass-produced and uniform.

What is the problem with the development of Marsden Park in terms of infrastructure?

The problem is that the infrastructure, such as roads, schools, and public transport, is not keeping up with the pace of housing development, leading to overcrowding and inadequate facilities for residents.

What is the issue with having only one road leading out of Marsden Park for several years?

Having only one road leading out of Marsden Park for several years caused significant traffic congestion and posed risks in case of floods and bushfires, as it was the sole evacuation route.

What is the term 'infrastructure lag' and how does it relate to Marsden Park?

Infrastructure lag refers to the situation where the necessary infrastructure to support a growing town or city lags behind its development. In Marsden Park, this lag resulted in inadequate roads, overcrowded schools, and insufficient public transport for years.

What are the plans for improving transport in Marsden Park?

The plans include extending the Sydney Metro Northwest at Talawang to Showfields and then to Marsden Park, potentially linking up with the Sydney Metro Greater West to the new airport at Badgery's Creek. However, these plans may not be realized for another 10 to 20 years.

What is the author's view on high-rise development as a solution to the housing crisis in Sydney?

The author suggests that high-rise development is a more sustainable solution, as it allows for more people to live in a smaller area while ensuring access to green space, shopping centers, transport, education, and other facilities.

What is the author's final message regarding the situation in Marsden Park and Western Sydney?

The author's final message is a call for developers and governments to prioritize proper infrastructure and green spaces, recognizing that residents deserve more than just houses—they deserve a high quality of life and not to feel like second-class citizens.

Outlines

00:00

🏗️ Urban Sprawl and Infrastructure Lag in Marsden Park

This paragraph discusses the concept of urban sprawl, particularly in Marsden Park, a suburb in Western Sydney. It highlights the rapid housing development that has outpaced the provision of essential infrastructure such as roads, schools, supermarkets, and public transport. The video script points out that while developers are quick to build houses, the state government struggles to keep up with the necessary infrastructure, leading to issues like inadequate roads and overcrowded schools. Marsden Park, once semi-rural, has seen explosive growth since 2014, with housing estates growing without the corresponding public facilities, exemplifying the flawed city planning mindset.

05:02

🚦 Infrastructure Challenges and Development in Marsden Park

The second paragraph delves into the specific infrastructure challenges faced by Marsden Park, including the lack of adequate roads, which led to severe traffic congestion and posed risks related to flood and bushfire evacuation. The script mentions the opening of a second road in 2021 and the gradual improvement in public transport with buses to Showground Station. However, it also points out the suburb's struggle with infrastructure lag, where the development of essential facilities such as schools and shopping centers is significantly delayed. The paragraph emphasizes the state government's role in this lag and the impact on residents, who have had to endure years of inadequate infrastructure despite the rapid growth of housing estates.

10:05

🏘️ McMansions and the Future of Urban Development

The final paragraph critiques the prevalence of 'McMansions'—mass-produced, generic houses that lack the charm of older Sydney suburbs. It discusses the preference of Australians for standalone houses over apartments, which has led to the proliferation of these uniform dwellings in newly developed areas. The script argues for high-rise development as a more sustainable solution, allowing for better walkability and access to infrastructure in a compact space. It calls for a change in the current approach to urban planning, advocating for the prioritization of infrastructure before development to create more natural, accessible, and greener towns. The paragraph concludes with a call to action for developers and governments to provide better living conditions for residents, emphasizing that they deserve more than just houses.

Keywords

💡Urban Sprawl

Urban sprawl refers to the uncontrolled expansion of urban areas into rural and undeveloped lands. It is characterized by low-density, car-dependent development that leads to the consumption of open space and agricultural land. In the video, urban sprawl is portrayed as a destructive force in Sydney's outskirts, where houses are built at a rapid pace without adequate infrastructure to support the growing population, leading to issues like traffic congestion and lack of public services.

💡Infrastructure Lag

Infrastructure lag is a situation where the development of necessary infrastructure, such as roads, schools, and public transport, is delayed or insufficient relative to the growth of a population or urban area. The video highlights this concept by discussing how Marsden Park, a suburb in western Sydney, has suffered from infrastructure lag, with schools and shopping centers taking years to be built after the housing estates, leading to overcrowded conditions and poor accessibility.

💡McMansions

McMansions is a term used to describe large, mass-produced, and often architecturally generic houses that are built in suburban developments. The term is derived from 'McDonald's', implying a lack of uniqueness and quality akin to fast food. In the script, McMansions are mentioned to criticize the uniformity and lack of charm in new housing estates, which prioritize quantity over quality of living spaces.

💡State Government

The state government is the administrative authority responsible for governing a state within a country, with powers and responsibilities that vary from one country to another. In the context of the video, the state government of New South Wales is criticized for its role in the rapid development of suburbs without keeping pace with the necessary infrastructure, contributing to the issues faced by residents in areas like Marsden Park.

💡Housing Crisis

A housing crisis refers to a situation where there is a significant shortage of affordable housing, leading to difficulties for people to secure adequate shelter. The video script mentions the housing crisis in Sydney, where the demand for housing, particularly for young families, has led to the development of distant suburbs without proper planning and infrastructure.

💡Transport

Transport refers to the systems and infrastructure that allow the movement of people and goods from one place to another. In the video, the lack of efficient transport options in newly developed suburbs like Marsden Park is highlighted as a critical issue, with inadequate roads and public transport services causing significant inconvenience to residents.

💡Marsden Park

Marsden Park is a suburb located northwest of Sydney's central business district. The video uses Marsden Park as a case study to illustrate the problems of urban sprawl and infrastructure lag, showing how the suburb has grown rapidly with housing estates but has struggled with providing necessary services and infrastructure to its residents.

💡High-Rise Development

High-rise development refers to the construction of multi-story buildings, often used for residential, commercial, or mixed-use purposes. The video suggests that high-rise development could be a more sustainable solution to housing shortages, as it allows for more people to live in a smaller area, with better access to infrastructure and public services.

💡Green Space

Green space is an area of land covered with grass, trees, or other vegetation, providing recreational and ecological benefits in urban areas. The script criticizes the lack of green space in new housing estates, suggesting that they should include more trees and open areas to improve the quality of life for residents.

💡Walkability

Walkability refers to how friendly, safe, and convenient an area is for walking. The video implies that high-density, mixed-use developments with good walkability are preferable to sprawling suburbs, as they provide easier access to amenities and services, promoting a healthier and more sustainable lifestyle.

💡Australian Dream

The Australian Dream is a cultural concept similar to the American Dream, which often includes the aspiration to own a house, particularly in the suburbs. The video discusses how this dream is being compromised by the realities of urban sprawl and inadequate infrastructure, as people are forced to live far from city centers with limited access to services.

Highlights

Building a town requires houses, roads, schools, supermarkets, health facilities, parks, shopping centers, child care, and public transport.

Sydney is growing rapidly, with up to 200,000 people each year, leading to frantic development in western Sydney.

Urban sprawl is characterized by inadequate roads, overcrowded schools, and insufficient basic necessities and transport.

Marsden Park, a suburb in western Sydney, exemplifies the issues arising from flawed city planning.

Marsden Park's development began in 2014, with residents moving in from 2015, but infrastructure has lagged behind.

The Australian dream of home ownership is driving the demand for housing far from city centers.

Developers often promise amenities like schools and shopping centers, but these fail to materialize on time.

For years, Marsden Park had only one road leading out, causing significant traffic issues and posing risks.

Infrastructure lag is a widespread problem, with the state government struggling to keep up with developer speed.

Marsden Park's public school and shopping center only opened in 2021, years after residents started moving in.

High-rise development is presented as a more sustainable solution, offering better access to infrastructure.

The stigma associated with apartment living in Australia is driving the demand for houses, even in distant suburbs.

The government's approach to managing the housing crisis is criticized as short-sighted and leading to infrastructure lag.

McMansions, mass-produced and generic houses, are becoming common in new estates, lacking green space and charm.

Residents of western Sydney deserve proper infrastructure, greenery, and space, not just houses.

The video calls for prioritizing infrastructure development before housing to prevent further urban sprawl issues.

Marsden Park is slowly recovering, but it may take years to become a truly accessible and established town.

Transcripts

let's say you were building a town

what do you need

houses obviously

roads to get to the houses

you also need the basic necessities like

schools supermarkets health facilities

parks shopping centers child care and

more

you'd probably want a bus line as well

maybe even a train station to get people

to nearby towns

now picture this

imagine the houses were built and then

nothing

with sydney growing and growing by up to

200 000 people every year our state

government is frantically opening the

outskirts of western sydney up to

developers

houses are being built at lightning

speed developers have that first step

down pat

but the rest of it the roads the schools

the supermarkets the basic necessities

the transport

they're being left to the state

government

and that's a problem because they're not

keeping up

it's called urban sprawl and it's a

devil

today i'll be talking about marsden park

one of the many suburbs in western

sydney that is the victim of a deeply

flawed city planning mindset one that

has inadequate roads cookie-cutter homes

overcrowded schools and far more

problems

in this video we'll be exploring just

how destructive urban sprawl and

infrastructure lag have proven to be to

the residents of marston park

welcome to building beautiful

[Music]

before i continue please do consider

hitting the subscribe button if you

haven't already

and do be sure to check out the rest of

building beautifully you'll go to your

youtube destination for alding's city

planning after the video

marthan park is a small suburb located

49 kilometers north west of sydney cbd

before 2013 the suburb was pretty much

still semi-rural

little more than a few small streets a

public school and a mosque

this started to change in 2014

that was the year that massive pieces of

marsden park slowly begun development

the first new residents started moving

into the new estate in 2015.

over the years that have passed since

more and more of marsden park has been

opened up to developers

allowing the suburb to just grow and

grow

unimpeded

marston park benefits from being far

away enough from sydney cbd that

developers were able to keep prices low

but close enough to richmond road and

showfield's train station that people

could readily access transport to the

rest of sydney

or at least in theory

that's pretty much the thesis behind

urban sprawl especially in a city like

sydney

australians want to own their own houses

it's part of the australian dream and

that dream can come true

so long as you're happy to live 50

kilometers away from the city

there's not exactly much space left near

the inner city after all

developments like marsden park generally

are advertised in very flashy appealing

ways

talking about tree-lined streets

cycleways parks wide roads

they'll often talk about plans for a new

school any shopping center a child care

center maybe even a train station if

they're lucky

but that's the problem with urban sprawl

remember earlier when i talked about

what you need to build a town

when the development and growth of

estates occurs in such a quick

uncontrolled manner

the plans often just can't keep up

marsden park started opening up to

residents in 2015

it didn't get its new promise to public

school northbourne public school until

2021

it didn't get its new shopping center

until 2021 either

and its promised high school is still in

the planning stages

while the location has been secured from

the high school it could be years before

the school opens

buses from the suburb to show fields one

of the nearest train stations did not

run for years frustrating residents who

demanded better public transport

most worryingly of all for five out of

the past six years there was only one

road leading out of marsden park

illara willard

that's right the government managed to

stuff up perhaps the very first step of

developing a new town

adequate roads

for a suburb to only have one road

leading out of it is quite a monumental

stuff up

news articles quickly started appearing

in the media as traffic in marston park

backed up daily with residents

complaining that it could sometimes take

30 minutes just to get out of this

suburb in peak hour

this isn't just a convenience problem to

have no alternate route out of a suburb

also poses a flood and bushfire risk

especially given that areas of marston

park lie in high risk flood areas

[Music]

luckily another road able road opened

out of the suburb in 2021

and luckily the suburb is slowly playing

catch up it has had buses running every

15 minutes in peak hour to showfield

station since 2019.

it does now have a shopping center and

it does have its promised new school

the suburb is on its way to becoming a

proper established town

well fine northbourne public school

which has barely been open for two years

is already operating at 1 100 students

beyond its 1000 student capacity

infrastructure is catching up with

marsden park

it's just not doing so fast enough

master planned estates like marsden park

seem like excellent ideas when they are

planned and they often have the very

best of intentions

the trouble is that while the developer

can build houses the development of the

proper infrastructure to support these

houses

roads buses schools healthcare

they fall to the responsibility of the

state government

a state government that simply put often

lags behind that of the local developer

and local council

it's called infrastructure lag

where the proper infrastructure to

support a town lags years behind the

growth of the town itself and when the

infrastructure does arrive

often it's not even adequate enough

a perfect example of this is heavy rail

infrastructure

you see marston park may one day have

its own train station the plan is to

extend the sydney metro north west at

talawang to show fields then to martin

park before heading south to saint

mary's and linking up with the sydney

metro greater west to the new airport at

badgery's creek

the trouble is there are no plans in the

immediate future to carry through with

this

the metro to marsden park may not be

built for another 10 maybe even 20 years

this infrastructure lag is worrying

despite the areas west of blacktown

being the fastest growing in sydney

only 26 of sydney's

170 stations are west of blacktown

and there's only immediate plans for six

new stations to fix that in the next 10

years

infrastructure drives development

it's a message i've pushed time and

again on this channel

but the relationship should never be

reversed

development should not drive

infrastructure because the

infrastructure to support these

developments

roads schools transport

they should be coming first

infrastructure lag crippled marsden park

for years it's only just beginning to

recover and even so it could take years

before it's a properly established truly

accessible town

and the problems of marsden park are

simply being mirrored all over the

outskirts of sydney

austral oren park box hill harrington

park gledswood hills north kellyville

spring farm our state government is

releasing land for development faster

than it can build infrastructure to keep

up

and that's a problem

i mentioned earlier that living in a

house is part of the australian dream

and it's true

australians want to own a house

but that's difficult when our city is in

the grips of a housing crisis

often the only options for young

families wanting to raise their kids in

a house is to live on the far outskirts

of sydney regardless of how far away

they may be from the rest of sydney

regardless of whether or not the

infrastructure is even present here

the market wants houses

people want houses

and they're willing to accept anything

the result

rows and rows of houses that all pretty

much look the same squeezed in as tight

as possible together these houses have

been dubbed mcmansions in common media

throughout australia and even the united

states

because while they all may be nice and

big

they all look the same

mass-produced generic

like a mcdonald's burger hence the name

mcmansions

these areas need more trees more green

space bigger backyards

but they just don't have that

i don't want to insult those who live in

these estates because at least they get

to live in a nice house part of the

australian dream

it's just unfortunate that these areas

lack the foresty charm of older areas of

sydney

and that's sad

high-rise development is the better more

sustainable solution in a lot of these

situations

more people can be squeezed into a

smaller area while still ensuring

adequate access to green space shopping

centers transport education and more

it's just easier for planners to allow

for better walkability and access to

infrastructure if everything is tightly

packed together in apartments

[Music]

unfortunately many young families want

houses and that's understandable

living in an apartment carries an

unfortunate stigma in australian society

that even i myself am not immune to our

government is desperately trying to

build as many houses as possible trying

to keep up with demand trying to manage

the housing crisis as best as they can

but they're doing so in a horrifically

short-sighted way

imagine new estates where schools and

shopping centers opened up in sync with

the estate where roads were initially

built adequately enough to handle

congestion where bus services were

plentiful where train stations were

delivered as quickly as possible

imagine a town that grew in the natural

way i cited at the start of this video

our state government should prioritize

this

instead of allowing infrastructure lag

to continue to thousands of

residents of western sydney daily

urban sprawl is harming sydney simple as

that

residents and young families deserve to

live in houses but that's not all they

deserve and developers and governments

need to realize that they deserve proper

infrastructure

they deserve more greenery more space

they deserve to not feel like third

class citizens simply because they can't

afford to live closer to sydney's cbd

they deserve more

western sydney deserves more

marsden park deserves more

[Music]

if you like this video please do

consider liking and subscribing

thanks for watching

[Music]

[Music]

you