方脸说：算算中共到底每个月从你手上收走多少钱？看看每个月中国剥削你多少？中国的税收到底有多高？人民的负担到底有多重？

Summary

The speaker critiques the Chinese Communist Party (CCP), addressing accusations from CCP supporters that critics do not contribute to China. He details the various forms of taxes, both direct and indirect, that Chinese citizens pay, arguing that these significantly impact their incomes. By comparing Chinese and Canadian tax rates, he highlights the heavy financial burden on ordinary Chinese citizens. He also discusses the hidden costs embedded in housing, food, and consumer goods, ultimately showing that Chinese citizens are heavily taxed yet receive minimal welfare benefits. The video aims to raise awareness about the extensive financial contributions of Chinese citizens to the government.

Takeaways

• 😀 The video criticizes the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) and addresses common accusations against those who do so.
• 😒 The speaker calculates how much an average Chinese citizen contributes to the CCP through various taxes each month.
• 💸 There are two types of taxes in China: explicit taxes (like personal income tax) and hidden taxes (like value-added tax and corporate income tax).
• 📊 For a person earning 10,000 yuan per month in Shanghai, explicit taxes amount to 345 yuan (3.45% of the salary), while hidden taxes, including social insurance and housing fund, bring the total to 1,895 yuan (18.95% of the salary).
• 🧮 Including the employer's contributions to social insurance and housing fund, the total tax burden on a 10,000 yuan salary reaches 51.11%.
• 🏠 When buying property, nearly half of the cost in cities like Shanghai goes to land costs, which are essentially taxes paid to the government.
• 🍲 Eating out involves additional hidden taxes, with businesses paying significant amounts in value-added tax, corporate income tax, and rent, which is influenced by high property prices.
• 🛒 Consumer goods like phones, clothing, and cars also carry substantial hidden taxes, significantly increasing their final prices.
• 🚬 Sin taxes on items like tobacco and alcohol are extremely high, with cigarettes taxed at over 65%.
• 😡 The overall message highlights the high tax burden on Chinese citizens, both visible and hidden, which far exceeds that in many other countries, including Canada.

Q & A

What is the main argument presented in the video script?

The main argument is that Chinese citizens contribute significantly to the government through various forms of taxes and fees, and the extent of this contribution is often underestimated.

What are the two types of taxes mentioned in the script?

The script mentions two types of taxes: 'explicit taxes' (明税) like personal income tax, and 'implicit taxes' (暗税) such as social security contributions and other fees indirectly collected by the government.

How does the speaker calculate the total monthly contribution of a citizen earning 10,000 yuan in Shanghai?

The speaker calculates the total monthly contribution by adding personal income tax, social security contributions, and housing costs, which sum up to 5,111 yuan out of a 10,000 yuan salary.

What comparison does the speaker make between Chinese and Canadian tax rates?

The speaker compares the Chinese tax burden to that in British Columbia, Canada, stating that the overall tax contribution in China can be higher than in Canada despite the latter being perceived as having high taxes.

How does the concept of 'implicit taxes' affect the perception of taxation in China?

Implicit taxes, such as contributions from employers towards social security and hidden costs in goods and services, make the actual tax burden less visible to citizens, leading to a perception that taxes are lower than they actually are.

What does the speaker suggest about the government's strategy in tax collection?

The speaker suggests that the Chinese government uses a strategy of maintaining visible taxes at a seemingly low level while collecting significant amounts through less visible means, thus reducing public awareness and potential resistance.

How does the speaker describe the impact of high property costs in Shanghai?

The speaker describes that high property costs in Shanghai are significantly influenced by government land sales, which account for nearly half of the property price, leading to substantial indirect contributions to the government.

What analogy does the speaker use to illustrate the hidden costs in daily expenses like dining out?

The speaker uses the analogy of hidden taxes within restaurant bills, including value-added tax (VAT), business taxes, and corporate income taxes, which collectively increase the actual cost of dining out.

What is the speaker's view on the transparency of the Chinese tax system compared to North America?

The speaker views the Chinese tax system as opaque and complex, with many hidden taxes that make it difficult for citizens to understand their true tax burden, unlike the more transparent tax systems in North America.

What are the broader societal implications of the taxation system described in the script?

The broader societal implications include a lack of public awareness about the extent of their contributions, reduced demands for government accountability and welfare, and a skewed understanding of personal financial burdens.