Orientalism and power: When will we stop stereotyping people? | A-Z of ISMs Episode 15 - BBC Ideas

Summary

Edward Said coined 'orientalism' to describe the stereotyping of Eastern cultures as inferior by Western powers. This concept not only demeans the East but also elevates the West, reinforcing cultural superiority. Orientalism distorts perceptions, reducing complex societies to exotic or fanatical caricatures. It's a form of knowledge that justifies Western dominance and influences policies with severe consequences. Despite its problematic nature, orientalism persists, shaping Western views of the East and self-perception.

Takeaways

• 📚 Edward Said coined the term 'Orientalism' to describe the stereotyping of Eastern cultures as inferior and exotic by Westerners.
• 🌏 The concept of 'the Orient' is rooted in the Latin word 'oriens', referring to the east where the sun rises, and is used to stereotype the East.
• 🔍 Orientalism serves as a distorted lens through which Western power asserts dominance over the East, viewing it as exotic, strange, or even dangerous.
• 👳‍♀️ Middle Eastern women are often depicted in a one-dimensional way as either exotic dancers or oppressed figures, ignoring their diverse realities.
• 👨‍🎨 Early 20th-century portrayals of Middle Eastern men as romantic or, more recently, as fanatical terrorists, reflect the orientalist bias.
• 🌐 The term 'Orientalism' is embraced by many to describe the unique racism they face due to cultural, religious, and ethnic stereotypes.
• 🏛️ Orientalism is not just stereotyping; it involves broader power dynamics, influencing policies like wars and travel bans.
• 🗣️ The term has been perpetuated by those in power, including government officials and the media, as a form of knowledge production.
• 🔎 Even statements by political figures like President Trump, who generalized about Muslims, exemplify the orientalist perspective.
• 🌐 The term 'Middle East' itself is considered orientalist as it reflects a Western-centric viewpoint on geographical regions.
• 🔄 Orientalism persists because it shapes not only Western perceptions of the East but also how Westerners view themselves.

Q & A

What does the term 'orientalism' refer to?

Orientalism refers to the stereotyping of the East, particularly how Europeans have historically portrayed the Orient as inferior, uncivilized, and exotic, while defining Europe as its opposite.

Who developed the term 'orientalism'?

The term 'orientalism' was developed by the late academic Edward Said.

What is the origin of the term 'the orient'?

The term 'the orient' comes from the Latin word 'oriens', which refers to the rising of the sun in the east.

How does orientalism act as a form of knowledge?

Orientalism is a form of knowledge that authorizes and justifies the assertion of Western power over the East, often by exaggerating cultural and religious differences.

What is the impact of orientalism on the perception of people from the Middle East?

Orientalism impacts the perception of people from the Middle East by portraying them as exotic, oppressed, or fanatical, often overlooking their humanity and reducing them to stereotypes.

How does orientalism influence policy decisions?

Orientalism can influence policy decisions by shaping how governments view the Middle East, leading to actions such as waging war or imposing travel bans on certain groups.

Why is orientalism considered more than just stereotyping?

Orientalism is considered more than just stereotyping because it involves broader power relations and has historically been produced by those in positions of power, such as government officials, religious figures, or the media.

Can you provide an example of orientalism in recent political discourse?

An example of orientalism in recent political discourse is when President Trump stated, 'I think Islam hates us,' which characterizes Muslims worldwide as anti-American.

Why is the term 'The Middle East' considered orientalist?

The term 'The Middle East' is considered orientalist because it standardizes a Western viewpoint by referring to West Asia and North Africa as the middle of the East, which is a perspective rooted in Western geography.

How does orientalism continue to be powerful today?

Orientalism continues to be powerful today because it is ingrained in how people view other cultures and themselves, often going unnoticed and shaping knowledge about the Middle East and parts of Asia.

What can be done to counteract the effects of orientalism?

To counteract the effects of orientalism, it is important to challenge and question the stereotypes and power dynamics it perpetuates, promote diverse and accurate representations of cultures, and encourage cross-cultural understanding and dialogue.

Outlines

00:00

🌏 Understanding Orientalism

Orientalism, a term coined by Edward Said, describes the historical portrayal of Eastern cultures as inferior and uncivilized by Europeans. This concept not only stereotypes the East but also serves to define Europe as superior. The term 'orient' itself, derived from 'oriens' meaning 'rising sun,' is used to categorize Eastern societies. Orientalism functions as a distorted lens that exaggerates cultural and religious differences, leading to the exoticization or negative portrayal of Eastern people, particularly in the Middle East. This perspective has real-world implications, influencing policies and actions such as wars and travel bans. Orientalism is not merely a stereotype but a broader power dynamic, often perpetuated by those in power, including government officials and the media. Even the term 'Middle East' is considered orientalist, as it reflects a Western-centric view. Despite its controversial nature, orientalism persists, shaping both Western perceptions of the East and their own self-image.

Keywords

💡Orientalism

Orientalism, as defined by Edward Said, is a term that describes the way Europeans have historically portrayed the East as inferior and uncivilized. It's not just a stereotype but also a form of knowledge that legitimizes Western dominance over the East. In the video, orientalism is depicted as a distorting lens that exaggerates cultural and religious differences, leading to the dehumanization and misunderstanding of Eastern people.

💡Edward Said

Edward Said was a late academic who developed the concept of orientalism. He argued that the portrayal of the East as exotic and inferior was a means to define Europe as superior and civilized. His work is central to the video's discussion, as it provides the framework for understanding the historical and ongoing impact of orientalism on Western perceptions of the East.

💡Stereotyping

Stereotyping refers to the oversimplified and generalized beliefs about a group of people. In the context of the video, orientalism is a form of stereotyping where Eastern cultures, religions, and ethnicities are reduced to a few exaggerated characteristics, such as the portrayal of Middle Eastern women as either exotic belly dancers or oppressed veiled figures, ignoring the complexity and humanity of individuals.

💡Exoticism

Exoticism in the video is used to describe the way Western perspectives often view Eastern cultures as strange, foreign, and fascinatingly different. This concept is critiqued as it contributes to the distortion of the East, reducing people to their cultural artifacts and ignoring their everyday realities, as seen in the example of Middle Eastern women being portrayed only in exotic or oppressed terms.

💡Cultural Differences

Cultural differences are the variations in customs, beliefs, and social behaviors among different societies. The video argues that orientalism distorts these differences, portraying them as extreme and often negative, which can lead to fear and hostility. This is evident in how the video discusses the portrayal of Middle Eastern men, ranging from 'exotically romantic' to 'crazy and fanatical terrorists'.

💡Power Relations

Power relations refer to the dynamics of dominance and subordination between different groups or societies. In the video, orientalism is described as a broader set of power relations that perpetuate Western dominance over the East. This is illustrated by how policies, such as wars or travel bans, are influenced by orientalist perspectives that view the East as inherently different and threatening.

💡Humanity

Humanity in the video is used to emphasize the shared human qualities and experiences that are often overlooked when cultures are reduced to stereotypes. The critique of orientalism highlights how it detracts from the recognition of Eastern individuals' humanity by focusing on their perceived exoticism or danger.

💡Racism

Racism is the discrimination and prejudice against people based on their race or ethnicity. The video connects orientalism to a unique form of racism experienced by Arabs, Muslims, and Asians, where their culture, religion, and ethnicity are stereotyped, leading to discrimination and misunderstanding.

💡Knowledge Production

Knowledge production refers to the creation and dissemination of information and ideas. The video discusses how orientalism has historically been produced by those in power, such as government officials and the media, to reinforce Western dominance. This is exemplified by the quote from President Trump, which characterizes Muslims as anti-American, perpetuating orientalist narratives.

💡The Middle East

The term 'The Middle East' is considered orientalist in the video because it standardizes a Western viewpoint by referring to West Asia and North Africa as the middle of the East. This term is critiqued for its Eurocentric perspective, which positions Western countries as the center and measures other regions in relation to them.

💡Self-Perception

Self-perception is how individuals or societies understand and view themselves. The video suggests that orientalism not only shapes Western views of the East but also influences how Western societies perceive themselves, often in opposition to the perceived inferiority of the East, reinforcing a sense of superiority and civilization.

Highlights

Orientalism is a term developed by Edward Said to describe the portrayal of the East as inferior and uncivilized by Europeans.

Said argued that orientalism also served to define Europe as superior and civilized.

The term 'the orient' originates from the Latin word 'oriens', meaning the rising of the sun in the east.

Orientalism is akin to Eastern-ism, which involves stereotyping of the East.

It is a form of knowledge that justifies Western power over the East.

Orientalism distorts vision and exaggerates cultural and religious differences.

Middle Eastern women are often depicted as exotic or oppressed, with no in-between portrayals.

Men from the Middle East have been portrayed as exotically romantic or as fanatical terrorists.

Orientalism is embraced by many to describe the unique racism they experience.

It encapsulates how culture, religion, and ethnicity are reduced to stereotypes, often overlooking humanity.

Orientalism is not just stereotyping but involves broader power relations.

The US government's orientalist views have led to policies with far-reaching consequences, such as war or travel bans.

Orientalism is produced by those in power, not just by ignorance or lack of knowledge.

President Trump's statement about Islam exemplifies orientalist rhetoric.

Orientalism continues because it is ingrained in how we perceive other cultures, often going unnoticed.

The term 'The Middle East' is considered orientalist as it standardizes a Western viewpoint.

Much knowledge about the Middle East and parts of Asia is still produced through orientalist lenses.

Orientalism shapes not only Western views of the East but also how Westerners view themselves.

Transcripts

The A - Z of isms... orientalism.

The late academic, Edward Said,

developed the term orientalism

to describe how Europeans portray the orient

as inferior, uncivilised and all around weird.

But importantly, Said argued this was also, simultaneously,

about defining Europe as the orient's opposite -

superior, civilised and all around wonderful.

The actual term 'the orient' refers to the rising of the sun in the east

and comes from the Latin word 'oriens'.

So we can think of orientalism as Eastern-ism

or stereotyping of the East.

Orientalism then, is the form of knowledge, in quotation marks,

that authorises and justifies the assertion of Western power

over the East.

But what does this actually mean?

Orientalism acts like a pair of glasses that distort your vision

and exaggerate cultural and religious differences.

With these glasses,

just about everything and everyone seems highly exotic and strange

or worse, fanatical and dangerous.

Women in the Middle East, for example,

appear only as exotic - a belly dancer -

or oppressed - a 'veiled woman' -

with no nuances in between.

And in the early 20th Century,

you might have seen men portrayed as exotically romantic

or more recently as crazy and fanatical, a terrorist,

and miss all the ordinary human beings along the way.

Many Arabs, Muslims and Asians embrace this controversial term

to describe the unique kind of racism they experience.

Orientalism encapsulates, for many,

how their culture, religion and ethnicity

are so often reduced to a stereotype,

causing their humanity to be overlooked and culture misunderstood.

Isn't this just a form of stereotyping then?

Well, yes and no.

Orientalism is about a much broader set of power relations.

When the US government views the Middle East

through orientalist glasses

it creates policies with far-reaching consequences.

From outright war waged on other countries

to imposing a travel ban on whole groups of people.

Perhaps the trickiest thing about orientalism

is that it's not fuelled by ignorance or a simple lack of knowledge,

just the opposite.

It has historically been produced as knowledge

by those in positions of power,

whether government officials, religious figures, or the media.

For example when President Trump stated,

"I think Islam hates us,

we can't allow people coming into this country

who have this hated for the United States."

He effectively characterised the 1.6 billion Muslims worldwide

as anti-American.

Even today,

orientalism continues because it is so ingrained

in how we see other peoples and cultures that it goes unnoticed.

Even the term, 'The Middle East' is considered to be orientalist,

because it standardises a Western viewpoint

by referring to West Asia and North Africa as the middle of the East.

Much of what counts as knowledge about the Middle East

and parts of Asia

is still produced through those distorting and reductive glasses.

And just like in the 18th and 19th Centuries,

orientalism remains powerful because it shapes,

not just how people in the West view the East,

but also how they view themselves.

Thanks for watching. Don’t forget to subscribe! :)