Why is Argentina’s economy such a mess?

Summary

In Buenos Aires, a black market for currency thrives amid Argentina's economic turmoil, with hyperinflation and a history of mismanagement. The country's reliance on the IMF and its complex currency controls have led to a fiscal deficit and soaring inflation rates. The legacy of Peronism, protectionist policies, and overspending on subsidies and public wages exacerbate the situation. As the 2023 presidential election looms, the challenge lies in restoring trust and implementing sustainable economic policies to reverse decades of decline.

Takeaways

• 🚨 Argentina's capital, Buenos Aires, is rife with black market money deals due to economic instability.
• 💸 The country faces hyperinflation, with inflation rates higher than 100% for most of 2023, rivaling only Venezuela and Lebanon.
• 🤝 President Menem inherited a nation in economic and social disorder, with bank runs and political corruption.
• 🏦 The central bank's policy of printing money to finance spending has exacerbated inflation.
• 📈 Argentina's economy suffers from consistent mismanagement over decades, leading to a fiscal deficit for 13 years.
• 💼 The Peronist legacy, with its emphasis on strong state control and economic isolationism, has hindered economic growth.
• 🌱 Argentina's rich natural resources, like lithium and copper, are underutilized due to its isolation from global trade.
• 💰 The government's overspending includes high subsidies for utilities, which strains the economy.
• 🔄 Argentina's debt to the IMF is substantial, and the country has a history of defaulting on loans.
• 🚫 The government's trade restrictions and complex exchange rate systems create distortions in the economy.
• 🔄 Addressing Argentina's economic issues is challenging as solutions often have negative short-term effects before long-term benefits.

Q & A

What is the main issue being discussed in the transcript?

The main issue discussed is Argentina's chaotic economy, characterized by hyperinflation, economic mismanagement, and the prevalence of black market currency deals.

What is the significance of the black market for currency in Argentina?

The black market for currency is significant because it reflects the lack of confidence in the local currency and the official exchange rate, leading people to seek alternative ways to preserve their wealth.

How has Argentina's economic situation affected its citizens?

Argentina's economic situation has forced its citizens to be creative in saving money, such as hoarding cash at home, and has made it difficult for many to make ends meet due to the high inflation rates.

What is the historical context behind Argentina's economic decline?

Argentina's economic decline is linked to the legacy of Juan Domingo Perón, who introduced policies that emphasized a strong state, nationalism, and economic isolationism, leading to a decline in international trade and competitiveness.

What is the role of the Peronist political movement in Argentina's current economic state?

The Peronist movement, which has been in power for much of the past 20 years, has not evolved with globalization, contributing to Argentina's economic isolation and decline in global export shares.

How does the Argentine government's overspending contribute to the economic problems?

The government's overspending on subsidies, public wages, and pensions has led to a persistent fiscal deficit, which has been exacerbated by policies like printing money and borrowing, which have worsened inflation and debt.

What is Argentina's relationship with the International Monetary Fund (IMF)?

Argentina has a significant debt to the IMF, being the second-highest borrower. The IMF's lending conditions have been criticized for being too lenient, which some argue has not helped Argentina stabilize its economy.

What are some of the complex financial instruments and policies Argentina has implemented to manage its economy?

Argentina has implemented various financial instruments like the 'soya dollar' for soybean exports and different exchange rates for different activities, which have led to confusion and distortions in the economy.

What are the challenges in fixing Argentina's economy?

Fixing Argentina's economy is challenging because addressing one issue, such as reducing government spending or devaluing the currency, often leads to increased inflation and other negative consequences.

What is the key to resolving Argentina's economic issues?

The key to resolving Argentina's economic issues is regaining the trust of its citizens and the markets by implementing sound, long-term policies that address the root causes of the economic problems.

How does the upcoming presidential election in Argentina relate to the economic situation?

The upcoming presidential election in Argentina is significant because it presents an opportunity for change, but it is challenging to convince the disillusioned population that short-term economic pain will lead to long-term prosperity.

Outlines

00:00

💰 Black Market Economics in Buenos Aires

This paragraph discusses the prevalence of black market deals in Buenos Aires, where the sale of money is a risky yet common practice due to economic woes like hyperinflation. The script highlights the inheritance of economic and social disorder by President Menem and the dismissal of his trial as a witch hunt. It also touches on the frustration of Argentines with their country's economic dysfunction and the rise of a radical presidential candidate, Javier M, who proposes dollarizing the economy. The paragraph sets the stage for the economic challenges Argentina faces, including a history of high inflation rates and the impact on daily life, such as the need to save in dollars and the black market for currency.

05:01

📉 Historical Roots of Argentina's Economic Decline

The second paragraph delves into the historical reasons behind Argentina's economic decline, starting with the legacy of Juan Domingo Peron, who introduced strong state control and economic isolationism. It discusses the Peronist influence on Argentine politics, the shrinking of Argentina's global export share, and the government's over-spending on subsidies and public sector wages. The paragraph also addresses the fiscal deficit, the government's reliance on printing money and borrowing, and the country's frequent defaults, which have led to a lack of trust from lenders. The IMF's lending to Argentina is highlighted, along with the criticism of the IMF's lenient conditions for loans.

10:03

🚨 Complex Economic Policies and Their Consequences

The final paragraph explores the complexity of Argentina's economic policies, such as the soybean dollar and various dollar-related taxes, which create confusion and distortion in the market. It discusses the challenges of addressing the economic issues, as reducing subsidies or devaluing the currency could exacerbate inflation. The paragraph emphasizes the difficulty of convincing the population of the need for short-term sacrifices for long-term prosperity. It concludes with a focus on the importance of trust in the government and the markets, suggesting that sustainable economic recovery requires consistent good policies over decades.

Keywords

💡Black market

An illegal marketplace where goods or services are traded outside of government regulation. In the video, it refers to the unauthorized trade of currency in Argentina, highlighting the country's economic instability and the risks people take to secure their finances.

💡Hyperinflation

A rapid and uncontrolled increase in the prices of goods and services, leading to a decrease in the purchasing power of money. The video describes Argentina's struggle with hyperinflation, which has been higher than 100% for most of 2023, severely impacting the economy and citizens' lives.

💡Dollarization

The process of replacing a country's currency with a more stable foreign currency, typically the US dollar, to stabilize the economy. The video mentions a presidential candidate, Javier M, who wants to dollarize Argentina's economy to address its economic issues.

💡Economic mismanagement

The inefficient or corrupt handling of a country's economic policies, leading to negative outcomes. The video attributes Argentina's economic chaos to decades of consistent mismanagement, which has not been addressed effectively.

💡Peronism

A political and economic ideology in Argentina, named after Juan Domingo Perón, that emphasizes a strong state, labor rights, and nationalism. The video discusses how Peronism's legacy continues to influence Argentine politics and contributes to the country's economic challenges.

💡Fiscal deficit

A situation where a government's expenditures exceed its revenues, leading to a shortfall. The video highlights that Argentina has been running a fiscal deficit for 13 years, which has contributed to its economic instability.

💡IMF (International Monetary Fund)

An international organization that provides financial assistance and advice to countries facing economic difficulties. The video mentions Argentina's significant debt to the IMF, which is the second highest among all borrowers.

💡Export tax

A tax levied on goods that are exported from a country. The video discusses Argentina's high export tax on soybeans, which affects farmers' profits and incentivizes them to hold onto their products until the exchange rate is more favorable.

💡Soybean dollar

A special exchange rate offered by the Argentine government for profits from soybean exports, which is more favorable than the official exchange rate. This is an example of the complex and confusing economic policies in Argentina.

💡Trust

The confidence and reliance on a government or institution to act in a responsible and competent manner. The video emphasizes that rebuilding trust with citizens and markets is crucial for Argentina to address its economic problems and achieve long-term prosperity.

Highlights

Black market money deals are common in Buenos Aires, Argentina, despite the risk of imprisonment.

Argentina's capital is dealing with hyperinflation and economic woes, inherited from President Menem.

Former President Fernandes is found guilty of defrauding the state but dismisses the trial as a witch hunt.

Argentina's economy is chaotic due to consistent mismanagement over decades.

The country's inflation rate has been higher than 100% for most of 2023, with only Venezuela and Lebanon having higher rates.

Argentines save in dollars due to the high inflation and instability of the local currency.

The black market for currency is booming, with dealers operating openly in the city center.

Argentina's GDP is $630 billion US, but the booming black market is a symptom of the country's economic issues.

Argentina's decline is attributed to historical factors, including the legacy of Juan Domingo Peron's presidency.

Peronism, which has dominated Argentine politics, has not evolved with globalization, leading to economic isolationism.

Argentina's government overspends on subsidies, with the average Argentine spending significantly less on utilities like electricity.

The government runs a fiscal deficit, exacerbating the economic situation through policies like printing money.

Argentina has a history of defaulting on loans, making it difficult to borrow from international lenders.

The country holds almost a third of all IMF lending, with a debt to the IMF more than double that of Egypt.

Argentina employs trade restrictions, such as a 33% export tax on soybeans, affecting the economy's ability to generate foreign currency.

The government has created a complex system of different exchange rates for various activities, distorting the economy.

Solving Argentina's economic issues is challenging due to the interconnected nature of its problems.

Building trust with citizens and markets is crucial for Argentina's long-term economic recovery.

The 2023 presidential election in Argentina is approaching, with the challenge of convincing the population of the need for short-term sacrifices for long-term prosperity.

Transcripts

in a small office in Buenos Ires a black

market deal is

underway if they're caught those

involved could end up in jail but it's

not drugs or weapons being sold it's

money despite the risks deals like this

are common place in Argentina's capital

and they are one in a long list of

economic woses like

hyperinflation president menm inherited

a country in economic and social

disorder Bank runs even an ex-president

found guilty of defrauding the state

Fernandes has dismissed the trial as a

Witch Hunt the problem is that as we

normally say Argentina is the country

that never misses an opportunity to miss

an opportunity argentine's frustration

with the economic dysfunction saw the

rise of a radical presidential hope for

in the 2023

election

Javier M wants to dollarize the economy

a move he says would blow up the central

bank but the change that Argentina needs

will take more than one man the main

reason Argentina's economy is so chaotic

is because of consistent economic

mismanagement over decades without big

Solutions things could get much

[Music]

worse events of the past few years have

been difficult for the world economy

this is going to be a tough year tougher

than the year we leave behind this

financial storm hit when Argentina was

already in

Peril to understand how bad it is for

South America's second largest country

take a look at

inflation countries like Britain have

experienced annual price Rises on par

with the world average in high single

digits Argentina's inflation hasn't been

that low in decades the rate has been

higher than 100% for almost all of 2023

right now only Venezuela and Lebanon

have higher rates and it's really hard

to kind of just imagine what that's like

for some people they just can't make

ends meet

anymore inflation this High forces many

argentines to get creative argentine's

save in dollars because saving in local

currency in a local bank has been a

recipe for disasters even this isn't

easy right now argentines can only

legally buy $200 a month at the official

exchange rate that has created a vast

black market for currency dealers line

the streets of the city

center while people hoard stashes of

cash at

[Music]

home but buying dollars on the black

market Market is more expensive than the

official

rate El Flo is one of a handful of

bosses in Argentina's currency Black

Market he's agreed to talk to us on

condition of

anonymity he claims the black market has

tacet

[Music]

approval with a GDP of $630 billion US

Argentina is one of the largest

economies in South

America but this booming Black Market is

a symptom of just how bad things are and

the roots of the problem Run

Deep the main reason Argentina's economy

is where it is today is

historical once one of the richest

countries in the world there are many

reasons behind Argentina's decline

including the legacy of this man pan

Domingo

Peron elected president in

1946 he came to power after having been

inspired by melini's fascist Italy

basically what he took from fascism was

a strong State that's very intrusive and

a strong emphasis on

nationalism and he combined that with

also having a very strong labor movement

he introduced the 8-hour workday

increased wages for the poor and created

vast expensive welfare schemes he also

embraced economic

isolationism the emphasis on National

sovereignty led to kind of the coddling

of workers by protecting them from

foreign competition it has shut itself

off from international

trade today Argentine politics is still

dominated by his legacy peronists have

been in power for

of the past 20 years one of the issues

with with peronism is they they haven't

evolved with globalization and with the

world Argentina's exports have shrunk as

a percentage of global exports year

after year in the mining sector

Argentina has one of the largest

reserves of lithium and also it's very

rich in Copper just to think that Chile

is the biggest copper exporter in the

world and Argentina produces zero copper

and we share the same mountains as well

as remaining isolated from the world

economy the government also still hugely

overspends on things like price

subsidies the average European spends

around $40 a month on

electricity the average Argentine spends

$5 eight times

Less in 2022 alone this cost the

government $ 12.5 billion around 2% % of

Argentina's

GDP but government laress goes beyond

welfare of the 13 million people in

formal employment in Argentina over a

third of them are employed by the state

itself a lot of spending goes on paying

salaries and pensions you actually

wanted to go on things like investment

technology infrastructure helping the

poor rather than paying public wages all

of this point to the main issue in

Argentina's economy Argentina has been

running a fiscal deficit for the last 13

years if you're in a difficult time for

13 years in a row well you have a big

problem policies to counteract this

deficit like printing money only make

things worse governments have become

dependent on the Central Bank printing

money to basically Finance spending and

the more money you print the worse

inflation

gets local shopkeeper Martha Valdez

feels the direct impact of more money

being pumped into the

system putting more money into

circulation can mean it's worth

less

[Music]

printing money is only one way the

government tries to fund its spending

another is borrowing so Argentina has

borrowed a lot of money but it has also

defaulted so many times that people

don't want to lend it money anymore more

despite the risks there is one

institution that continues to

lend today Argentina's debt to the IMF

is more than double that of Egypt the

second highest borrower all told

Argentina holds almost a third of all of

the imf's total lending one of the

criticisms that most economists have

opposed to the IMF is that the

conditionality that they put to

Argentina was so so light they didn't

need to stabilize the economy they

didn't need to do any homework and they

receive money I think that was another

Miss opportunity for Argentina borrowing

and printing money are not unusual

tactics for governments but the extent

that Argentina's government does both is

Extreme and damaging in part because

loans from the IMF need to be repaid in

foreign currency and one tactic

Argentina employs to get that foreign

currency only complicates things more

trade

restrictions soybeans are one of the

country's biggest

exports the soybean producer in

Argentina they face an export tax of 33%

if a tone of soyan cost say $500 I

receive $500 minus 33% leaving the

farmer with

$335 they then have to exchange these

dollars for pesos at the the official

exchange rate when the dollar rate is

bad Farmers have to make harsh decisions

the incentive is to keep your soybeans

in your silos and and until the exchange

rate uh changes if everybody does that

the supply of dollars in the economy is

scars so the government invented

something that we call the soybean

dollar the soya dollar is a slightly

better exchange rate specifically for

profits on soya exports

but it's not the only Market with

confusing

rules if you want to um organize a

concert in Argentina and and bring a a

British singer you have to pay the

official dollar and then an extra tax we

call it the dollar call

[Music]

[Applause]

playay if you want to travel abroad you

use your Argentine credit card and you

pay the official Dollar Plus taxes and

we call that the dollar Qatar this idea

of having 10 15 20 different prices for

the same thing doesn't make any sense

that's a distortion with the set of

distortions is impossible that Argentina

grows over the years different

presidents have proposed different

solutions to the economic conundrum but

the outcome tends to be the same more

debt and more

inflation it's really really hard to fix

Argentina's economy and that's because

many of the things that we've talked

about are linked everybody agrees the

government needs to spend less one way

to do that is by reducing subsidies but

if you do that you're going to push up

inflation everyone knows the currency

needs to be devalued but if you devalue

the currency that will also push up

inflation so it's really hard because

tackling one part of the puzzle means

that things could get much worse before

they actually get get better as the 2023

presidential election

approaches it will be difficult to

convince a disillusioned population that

short-term pain will bring long-term

prosperity the real heart of the problem

is trust if Argentina cannot win back

the trust of its citizens or the trust

of the markets it's never going to be

able to fix its problem and in order to

build trust you need to have good

policies for decades not just for a few

years not just for one

government thanks for watching 2023 is

an election year here in Argentina and

I'm going to be covering it extensively

so if you want to read my coverage and

watch more videos like this please click

on the link and don't forget to

subscribe